Executive Action on Immigratiion.

There is no provision in our constitutional scheme which provides that a frustrated president may act on his own.

Obama's executive order was based on no legislation, and it runs counter to legislation and to the will of the voters as just articulated in an election.

Obama said over 20 times that he lacked authority to do what he just did.


Executive orders don't have to be based on legislation, considering the president is, er, not part of the legislative branch.
 
There is no provision in our constitutional scheme which provides that a frustrated president may act on his own.

The president acts alone in most of what he does. Every chief executive in the world, governmental or corporate, has that kind of discretion, it's the point of having an executive.

And see unitary executive theory. Pubs were all for that concept during the W years. What happened to you guys?!
 
Last edited:
Yes Mr. lawyer but it only counts if you took no action to evade detection and prosecution.

[shrug] FGB's hypothetical is silent on that point.

And, there are a lot of undocumented immigrants in America who appear to take no particular action to "evade detection." (Not that any statute of limitations I know of bars their deportation after however long a period of residence, whether they've tried to evade detection or not.)

Are you seriously a lawyer?

Yes (personal-injury, not criminal-defense).
 
Last edited:
Will Boner retaliate with another government shutdown?


I could use another two week vacation.
 
No, they will send a budget bill defunding Obama's actions . . .

Well, there's a problem with that.

Still, King and others are insisting they can defund government, or at least the agencies tasked with implementing Obama’s move, and get away with it politically. That’s even after the House GOP Appropriations chair, Rep. Hal Rodgers, reminded them that the agency in question, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, is entirely self-funded, via the fees it charges, and thus could continue to process requests. “The appropriations process cannot be used to ‘defund’ the agency,” a committee statement said, according to Greg Sargent.

Also, if the agency responsible for deportations could be defunded, that would mean . . . no deportations. No deportations at all, even of those immigrants the agency would deport if it were up and running. Is that the result you want?

. . . and he will veto it, thereby shutting down the government. He will shut it down and lie about it all of you dupes.

Yeah, yeah . . .

But conservatives continue to push the idea of passing riders to appropriations to defund certain agencies, or to fund only agencies they like, even though it’s clear the Congressional GOP leadership wants no part of a government shutdown showdown this time around. Sen. Ted Cruz, for instance, sneering that “Obama is not a monarch” in Politico, says that if he vetoes a bill funding only certain parts of government, he will be blamed for the ensuing shutdown:

President Obama will no doubt threaten a shutdown—that seems to be the one card he repeatedly plays—but Congress can authorize funding for agencies of government one at a time. If the President is unwilling to accept funding for, say, the Department of Homeland Security without his being able to unilaterally defy the law, he alone will be responsible for the consequences.

Of course, that’s the exact argument Cruz and others, even Mitch McConnell, made about the politics of the October 2013 shutdown – and they were wrong that time. Polls showed the public blamed the GOP. They’ll be wrong again.
 
Last edited:

I laughed when I read that yesterday. I knew the cowardly Vettebigot would blithely recommend "defundin' the department", completely unaware that the department is self-funded via user fees, which is a change that libertarians foisted upon #ThosePeople years ago.

Now it could be, of course, that Vetteman is recommending that Congress steal the money lawfully collected by ICE. As a Vietnam-era Marine, he learned the Corps' core tenets ("theft", "rape" and "dishonor") back then.

Simper Fi!
 
No, they will send a budget bill defunding Obama's actions, and he will veto it, thereby shutting down the government. He will shut it down and lie about it all of you dupes.

So the Republicans will shut down the government.
 
You are a perfect example of what's wrong with our country

Obama makes another decision that benefits the Third World and hurts America. He is a Third World Manchurian Candidate who lies for a living in order to harm the United States of America.

It is not the quality of our leadership, but the percentage of dinbats like yourself who refuse to honor my vote and all the other americans who elected our President. He is your leader too or america is broken. Why don't you shape up and try to help your leader instead of calling him names and working against him and your country that he leads. Obama isn't a bad leader as much as you are a lousy follower.

You learn that in the marines?
 
It is not the quality of our leadership, but the percentage of dinbats like yourself who refuse to honor my vote and all the other americans who elected our President. He is your leader too or america is broken. Why don't you shape up and try to help your leader instead of calling him names and working against him and your country that he leads. Obama isn't a bad leader as much as you are a lousy follower.

You learn that in the marines?

This cannot be stated long or loud enough.
 
Back
Top