Fermi's Paradox - refuted? unfounded??

I've got an uncle who knows a gal who knows a guy.

Who teleported here from another universe. I knew a woman who did the same thing, but it was just one of those one night stands for her.

Ishmael
 
Who teleported here from another universe. I knew a woman who did the same thing, but it was just one of those one night stands for her.

Ishmael

Oh dear ): I think you may have misunderstood the big bang theory.

Don't worry - we're probably just a computer simulation anyway.
 
I've always thought that it was human centric to think all life must be like the things we know. If you could pop back a couple of hundred year with all of today's technology you could proclaim yourself a god and rule the world.

Who knows what a life form might be like if we gave up on the idea it will be similar to us.

What do you mean by "similar"? To me, all higher animal species are similar -- even fish -- in that they typically have various senses, mobility, respiratory, circulatory and skeletal systems. Could there be a literal "Planet of the Apes" somewhere? Sure. Why not?

But I don't think we're going to run across a planet intelligently governed by and boasting a functioning social order of chickweed or lichen. I think that which we describe as or very much functions like a brain is required to lay claim to the title of intelligent life.
 
What do you mean by "similar"? To me, all higher animal species are similar -- even fish -- in that they typically have various senses, mobility, respiratory, circulatory and skeletal systems. Could there be a literal "Planet of the Apes" somewhere? Sure. Why not?

But I don't think we're going to run across a planet intelligently governed by and boasting a functioning social order of chickweed or lichen. I think that which we describe as or very much functions like a brain is required to lay claim to the title of intelligent life.


What I meant was we assume is life as described as what we know as life. Fish, apes or lichens or all systems we know. There are all things under the right conditions could be evolved to higher life forms. Crystalline structures are assumed to be dead.

What we assume that the definition of intelligent life is limited by our current knowledge.

My point is that most of the science 200 years ago has been proved wrong or misguided.

The guy that first suggest sterilization of medical instruments was laughed out of his field.

What we know now may be increible wrong.

Other life forms may be beyond our current comprehension.
 
What I meant was we assume is life as described as what we know as life. Fish, apes or lichens or all systems we know. There are all things under the right conditions could be evolved to higher life forms. Crystalline structures are assumed to be dead.

What we assume that the definition of intelligent life is limited by our current knowledge.

My point is that most of the science 200 years ago has been proved wrong or misguided.

The guy that first suggest sterilization of medical instruments was laughed out of his field.

What we know now may be increible wrong.

Other life forms may be beyond our current comprehension.

You mean like AGW? Perish the thought.

Look at the stages of development of civilizations. We're no where near getting out of stage one. Probably a few thousand years away from stage two, if we can survive that long.

Ishmael
 
Given the untold billions of stars whose collective galactic light has reached us, Fermi's paradox tells us we should have at least heard from someone else by now. The physical constraints of the actual space travel of carbon-based life forms virtually guarantees we will never shake hands with intelligent aliens from another planet, even if such "people" exist. But the likelihood of a species of superior intelligence to ours sending out radio or optical signals over the past few hundred million years is a reasonable probability, even if that civilization has long ago died off. A simple repeating pattern of five or six different permutations would tell us all we need to know.

So where are they? Not a good sign.

I do agree with that. But I also wonder, since our civilization has only be able to detect radio signals for about 100 years or so, we may not be listening for the right thing.
Let's not forget about signal degradation over interstellar distances. Gravity fields, clouds of dust, the EM output from stellar and near stellar masses, not to mention signal spread, then factor in that one must be listening when the broadcast signal passes by AND have the wherewithal to intercept and interpret said signal. All this assumes another intelligent, advanced civilization is actually broadcasting within the EM spectrum and/or actively searching for another intelligent species with whom to make contact.

That's a shitload of "ifs" that need to come together, so it's really not that big a surprise.
 
Let's not forget about signal degradation over interstellar distances. Gravity fields, clouds of dust, the EM output from stellar and near stellar masses, not to mention signal spread, then factor in that one must be listening when the broadcast signal passes by AND have the wherewithal to intercept and interpret said signal. All this assumes another intelligent, advanced civilization is actually broadcasting within the EM spectrum and/or actively searching for another intelligent species with whom to make contact.

That's a shitload of "ifs" that need to come together, so it's really not that big a surprise.

Don't be an idiot. The radio in my car always gets perfect reception. What difference could a few hundred light years make. :D
 
Earth used to emit strong analog, uncoded signals for anyone who could listen. Now, most signals are digital and encoded. Aliens would have to sign up for subscriptions in order to make any sense of our transmissions.
 
Let's not forget about signal degradation over interstellar distances. Gravity fields, clouds of dust, the EM output from stellar and near stellar masses, not to mention signal spread, then factor in that one must be listening when the broadcast signal passes by AND have the wherewithal to intercept and interpret said signal. All this assumes another intelligent, advanced civilization is actually broadcasting within the EM spectrum and/or actively searching for another intelligent species with whom to make contact.

That's a shitload of "ifs" that need to come together, so it's really not that big a surprise.

..or they were broadcadting in a window of time, since passed, and found that advertising attracted the wrong sort of tourists.
 
Earth used to emit strong analog, uncoded signals for anyone who could listen. Now, most signals are digital and encoded. Aliens would have to sign up for subscriptions in order to make any sense of our transmissions.

You don't have to make "sense" of a transmission to know whether or not it is produced by an intelligent transmitter any more than you have to be able to read Arabic script to realize it is a written language. The mere presence of patterns says much about the author of the message.
 
Earth used to emit strong analog, uncoded signals for anyone who could listen. Now, most signals are digital and encoded. Aliens would have to sign up for subscriptions in order to make any sense of our transmissions.
and you think Richard Branson is human? uhuh. Aliens have been here for years and run all the major corps and intell. Before you say it, Trump is actually human - he slipped through the net - but that's kinda obvious isn't it?
 
You don't have to make "sense" of a transmission to know whether or not it is produced by an intelligent transmitter any more than you have to be able to read Arabic script to realize it is a written language. The mere presence of patterns says much about the author of the message.

You're tying to communicate with a moron.

Ishmael
 
Potential solutions to/explanations for Fermi's paradox are hardly new (I'm partial to ruminating on the ever popular great filter). It doesn't change the fact that we're just ants walking in circles on a flat disc :) Speaking of:

https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/the_search.png

Don't waste time on wikipedia. This is my favorite intro for the uninitiated.



Some of us already are, thank you very fucking much. I don't have any evidence that I'm mortal yet. I haven't died once. Twenty-nine years down infinity more to go.

This is the part that is at issue at the moment: "Let’s imagine that after billions of years in existence, 1% of Earth-like planets develop life"

The math is suggesting that this seemingly innocuous assertion is not supported. Billions of years does not seem to be enough time to imagine 1% of Earth-like planets developing life. The suggestion is we are an anomaly of early development of life.
 
Excellent thread, lots of interesting thoughts, opinions and hypothesis.;)
 
You mean like AGW? Perish the thought.

Look at the stages of development of civilizations. We're no where near getting out of stage one. Probably a few thousand years away from stage two, if we can survive that long.

Ishmael

Does anyone else see how this is completely false on a few different levels?

Earth used to emit strong analog, uncoded signals for anyone who could listen. Now, most signals are digital and encoded. Aliens would have to sign up for subscriptions in order to make any sense of our transmissions.

You don't have to make "sense" of a transmission to know whether or not it is produced by an intelligent transmitter any more than you have to be able to read Arabic script to realize it is a written language. The mere presence of patterns says much about the author of the message.

You're tying to communicate with a moron.

Ishmael

That wasn't the point 'Phro was making but I'm sure that doesn't matter to either of you.

Also, quit fucking up whilst trying to insult someone, it's pathetic.
 
The speed of light and its potential harnessing must surely be humanities next best conquest in order to aid our further exploration of 'Time & Space', long gone are the days of a fluxcapacitor and 88mph.

I often ponder what the view from the surface of an atom may resemble..
Sub atomics and the speed of light may hold interesting potential for travel.

Somedays though i do feel akin to an amoeba in a culturing petri dish in some lab somewhere thats primary task is to find a cure for the Amoeba.

Ahh the duplicity of the human affliction.. :)
 
Look. Poor little Luk following Ish around like a little bitch again. I'm shocked!! Shocked I tell you!!! :cool:

The only thing more shocking is the poor little guy spouting off while having no idea what he is talking about......

I know what Freud would say.
 
The only thing more shocking is the poor little guy spouting off while having no idea what he is talking about......
.

You came into the thread to bitch about me not knowing what I'm talking about and then say nothing. Just another Tuesday.

You wanna attempt to answer the question I axed regarding your father's statement and why it is a complete falsehood?

BTW, you've made two posts today- both about me. Think about that minute and then ask your idiot father where he went wrong with you, jr.
 
You came into the thread to bitch about me not knowing what I'm talking about and then say nothing. Just another Tuesday.

You wanna attempt to answer the question I axed regarding your father's statement and why it is a complete falsehood?

BTW, you've made two posts today- both about me. Think about that minute and then ask your idiot father where he went wrong with you, jr.

And your 4th post about him today.

Congratulations!!!!!!
 
So following around someone like a little bitch equals interaction in Luks world...

It makes so much sense now.

I know you have him on ignore ISH but it seems the poor little guy just wants to interact with you....
 
Back
Top