Fermi's Paradox - refuted? unfounded??

So following around someone like a little bitch equals interaction in Luks world...

It makes so much sense now.

I know you have him on ignore ISH but it seems the poor little guy just wants to interact with you....

Maybe one of you can now answer the question.
 
So following around someone like a little bitch equals interaction in Luks world...

It makes so much sense now.

I know you have him on ignore ISH but it seems the poor little guy just wants to interact with you....

You're right, I do. And it seems he does 'interact' with me.........in his own mind anyway.

Ishmael
 
You're right, I do. And it seems he does 'interact' with me.........in his own mind anyway.

Ishmael

But he questioned your position, while not understanding it or suggesting a position of his own. While it may not seem like much, certainly it deserves a response. Poor little guy is trying so hard.......
 
Good thread, Unfortunately Luk's typical trolling side tracked it. Lets see if we can get it back.

Being a eternal optimist <sarcasm>, what if:

All civilizations are doomed to die before advanced travel/communication is possible? What if no planet is capable of sustaining life long enough for contact to be made. Either through natural disasters or self annihilation, as technology surpasses the ability to use it safely, we are all doomed to die before ET is confirmed. What if we, as a planet, are simply too young and have hit that terminal "event horizon" yet.

or

Everyone else has figured out that their are indeed super predator civilizations and communicating your location is not a good idea..... :cool:
 
1.What about the UFO sightings by many people, including even military, at the same time?
- the Height 611 UFO incident
Belgian UFO wave 1990
The 1976 Tehran UFO Incident
To name just a few.


2.Or the paintings below? Or some of the ancient paintings on cave walls?
Still an unsolved mystery


http://www.crystalinks.com/ufosummer.jpg
Summer's Triumph - Bruges, 1538
(See the disc shaped objects at the top of the tapestry.


http://alien-ufo-research.com/images/ancient/baptismofchristufo.jpg
"The Baptism of Christ" - Aert De Gelder, 1710. … .


http://alien-ufo-research.com/images/ancient/christ-ufo.jpg
http://alien-ufo-research.com/images/ancient/christufoinlarge.jpg ........ http://alien-ufo-research.com/images/ancient/christufoinlarge2.jpg
The Crucifixion" - Unknown artist, 1350
 
Last edited:
I've always thought that it was human centric to think all life must be like the things we know.
If you could pop back a couple of hundred year with all of today's technology you could proclaim yourself a god and rule the world.

This too.

And yes, I believe that it Is probable that aliens might have visitted us.
Which doesn't make Me a conspiracy theorist. Given that russian officials, NASA astonauts and even the Clintons and other credible sources either claimed that they witnessed UFO's first hand, or acknowledged the existence of secret state documents in this regard.
It just means that those who refuse to even consider the the astounding amount of evidence, are over- the top skeptics.
 
Last edited:
You don't have to make "sense" of a transmission to know whether or not it is produced by an intelligent transmitter any more than you have to be able to read Arabic script to realize it is a written language. The mere presence of patterns says much about the author of the message.
An alien might detect an encoded digital signal and decide that it has an intelligent source. But layer a few million signals over a narrow EM bandwidth, and what chance would there be of sorting them out?
 
Good thread, Unfortunately Luk's typical trolling side tracked it. Lets see if we can get it back.

Being a eternal optimist <sarcasm>, what if:

All civilizations are doomed to die before advanced travel/communication is possible? What if no planet is capable of sustaining life long enough for contact to be made. Either through natural disasters or self annihilation, as technology surpasses the ability to use it safely, we are all doomed to die before ET is confirmed. What if we, as a planet, are simply too young and have hit that terminal "event horizon" yet.

or

Everyone else has figured out that their are indeed super predator civilizations and communicating your location is not a good idea..... :cool:

I think that there is something to the thought that intelligent life had a short time span and the chances of overlapping when the technology is such for both species that they can communicate (or at least see evidence of each other) would be really low. there must be someone that did the math one that one, too.

As to communicating your location not being a good idea, the second we get warp drive we are going to have to give that some serious thought. There was a great science fiction short story about this. Basically two species encountered each other "out there" and neither would leave because it woudl provide information about the home world. It was pretty interesting. If I can find it I'll post a link (or if anyone else knows of it or similar that would be cool).
 
Just wait till those eggheads over in Switzerland turn on that CERN machine. The aliens will be swarming through that black hole like fat kids heading to Krispy Kreame on free doughnut day.
 
Just wait till those eggheads over in Switzerland turn on that CERN machine. The aliens will be swarming through that black hole like fat kids heading to Krispy Kreame on free doughnut day.

Good thing we're fully covered by Stranger & Stranger, Inter-dimensional Insurance Inc. LLP.
 
Could it be that the 'alien/UFO' craft are infact future earth dwelling humans that have the technological ability to travel time? And whether it be to generate continued public interest and propagate their own future research funding or pass down technology or information or observe/change the past by traveling back in theyre disc/ball/triangular/cigar shaped time traveling vehicles?...

Or yeah, distant civilizations that fly here on annual family holidays etc to view and be entertained by the happenings here on earth(18-30 contiki saucer tours).
 
Douglas Adams calls those, or something like them, Teasers - Ford Prefect hitched a lift to Earth with one:

'Teasers are usually rich kids with nothing to do. They cruise around looking for planets that haven't made interstellar contact yet and buzz them (ie: they find some isolated spot with very few people around, then land right by some poor unsuspecting soul whom no one's ever going to believe and then strut up and down in front of him wearing silly antennas on their head and making "beep beep" noises) Rather childish, really. '

Hmm, i didnt know that, i should read Hitchhikers rather than watching it. Cheers..
 
*big sigh*

This is is probably not a good use of my time, but I do what I must. For science!

XKCD I already know and love, and the stages of civilisation, Dyson sphere stuff too. But the filter, and the theories surrounding that, are gloriously new to me. Absolutely fascinating, and the sort of thing that sends me into a personality-driven thought-loop for days.

That's a good thing, by the way. Thank you.

I love everything Randall Munroe does! I've been inspired by his Thing Explainer to translate some of my work stuff into the most commonly user ten-hundred words. My industry loves its jargon; I enjoy stripping it back. Words should convey meaning, not obscure it.

I think you would like Douglas Hoftstadter's strange loops :)

This is the part that is at issue at the moment: "Let’s imagine that after billions of years in existence, 1% of Earth-like planets develop life"

The math is suggesting that this seemingly innocuous assertion is not supported. Billions of years does not seem to be enough time to imagine 1% of Earth-like planets developing life. The suggestion is we are an anomaly of early development of life.

Thank you for the lecture but your efforts would probably be better spent figuring out what the hell you're talking about. It's not like someone corrected a math error. It's paradoxical because it derives from a series of variables and philosophical principles used to calculate a probability, at a massive scale, that's at odds with the evidence we have so far.

These guys tweaked one of the variables and its underlying assumption (that life can only around sun-similar stars, expanding to include smaller, weaker stars with longer lifespans) and spat out a different probability. Even the authors of the paper acknowledged that there's another possible explanation beyond being too early - that red dwarves simply can't support the formation of life (would be interesting to test!). It also seems like it kinda conflicts with the mediocrity principle in suggesting that we're an anomaly by arriving first, but I'll reserve judgment til it's published in full.

Anyway, it's not the first time it's been done, and I know you're excited about your article, but it's nothing to start a breathless "oh shit this changes everything" thread over. Last year someone at Cornell had concluded we're likely to hear something in about 1500 years, so stay tuned.

It is cool, though. I am not trying to diminish the cool.

I think that there is something to the thought that intelligent life had a short time span and the chances of overlapping when the technology is such for both species that they can communicate (or at least see evidence of each other) would be really low. there must be someone that did the math one that one, too.

As to communicating your location not being a good idea, the second we get warp drive we are going to have to give that some serious thought. There was a great science fiction short story about this. Basically two species encountered each other "out there" and neither would leave because it woudl provide information about the home world. It was pretty interesting. If I can find it I'll post a link (or if anyone else knows of it or similar that would be cool).

Yup. There are some mind-blowing explanations and a lot of really fascinating thoughts out there - go forth and consume.

I imagine you're thinking of First Contact.
 
Communication and/or observation.

A stage II civilization (Dyson Sphere) would be virtually invisible to us. We wouldn't even be able to detect the gravitational anomaly in the parent star. They would undoubtedly have to dump the excess energy via some heat transfer method, but we would most likely throw it into the 'Brown Dwarf' category. Obviously they would be emitting no wavelength of any consequence. Further, it is probably that they would have found a way to utilize quantum inseparability. Which means that we would have no way of tapping into the communication stream even if we had the technology to so.

Why hasn't SETI found anything yet? The problem comes down to time and direction. The higher the sensitivity of the measuring instrument, the narrower the field of view. We just can't cover four pi steridians. The time component should be obvious as well. The signals from advanced civilizations have already passed us by and from less advanced haven't gotten here yet (assuming they're still in the common spectrum emission phase).

My point being that the hypothesis that we are "the first" is based a a whole host of questionable assumptions, including the assumption of 'straight line' evolution. Even our own experience calls that into question.

There are only two assumptions that are probably true. The first being that there had to be one hell of a lot of super nova to create the heavier elements. (Although as far as I know, no element heavier than Iron is actually required for life as we know it. The heavier elements are required for use by advanced civilizations.) The second is that whatever life is out there is most likely Carbon based. Solely because Carbon combines with damn near everything for the formation of complex molecules. That and the fact that Carbon is part of the main sequence of star formation and death. Silicon and Germanium not so much so.

So like so many other hypothesis, it can't be discounted until proven otherwise. But I don't give it a high probability of being proven true.

Ishmael
 
Communication and/or observation.

A stage II civilization (Dyson Sphere) would be virtually invisible to us. We wouldn't even be able to detect the gravitational anomaly in the parent star. They would undoubtedly have to dump the excess energy via some heat transfer method, but we would most likely throw it into the 'Brown Dwarf' category. Obviously they would be emitting no wavelength of any consequence. Further, it is probably that they would have found a way to utilize quantum inseparability. Which means that we would have no way of tapping into the communication stream even if we had the technology to so.

Why hasn't SETI found anything yet? The problem comes down to time and direction. The higher the sensitivity of the measuring instrument, the narrower the field of view. We just can't cover four pi steridians. The time component should be obvious as well. The signals from advanced civilizations have already passed us by and from less advanced haven't gotten here yet (assuming they're still in the common spectrum emission phase).

My point being that the hypothesis that we are "the first" is based a a whole host of questionable assumptions, including the assumption of 'straight line' evolution. Even our own experience calls that into question.

There are only two assumptions that are probably true. The first being that there had to be one hell of a lot of super nova to create the heavier elements. (Although as far as I know, no element heavier than Iron is actually required for life as we know it. The heavier elements are required for use by advanced civilizations.) The second is that whatever life is out there is most likely Carbon based. Solely because Carbon combines with damn near everything for the formation of complex molecules. That and the fact that Carbon is part of the main sequence of star formation and death. Silicon and Germanium not so much so.

So like so many other hypothesis, it can't be discounted until proven otherwise. But I don't give it a high probability of being proven true.

Ishmael

Kipping would disagree. Well, if he was alive. And if he didn't see the years of shitty results attached to his award...
 
*big sigh*

This is is probably not a good use of my time, but I do what I must. For science!



I love everything Randall Munroe does! I've been inspired by his Thing Explainer to translate some of my work stuff into the most commonly user ten-hundred words. My industry loves its jargon; I enjoy stripping it back. Words should convey meaning, not obscure it.

I think you would like Douglas Hoftstadter's strange loops :)



Thank you for the lecture but your efforts would probably be better spent figuring out what the hell you're talking about. It's not like someone corrected a math error. It's paradoxical because it derives from a series of variables and philosophical principles used to calculate a probability, at a massive scale, that's at odds with the evidence we have so far.

These guys tweaked one of the variables and its underlying assumption (that life can only around sun-similar stars, expanding to include smaller, weaker stars with longer lifespans) and spat out a different probability. Even the authors of the paper acknowledged that there's another possible explanation beyond being too early - that red dwarves simply can't support the formation of life (would be interesting to test!). It also seems like it kinda conflicts with the mediocrity principle in suggesting that we're an anomaly by arriving first, but I'll reserve judgment til it's published in full.

Anyway, it's not the first time it's been done, and I know you're excited about your article, but it's nothing to start a breathless "oh shit this changes everything" thread over. Last year someone at Cornell had concluded we're likely to hear something in about 1500 years, so stay tuned.

It is cool, though. I am not trying to diminish the cool.



Yup. There are some mind-blowing explanations and a lot of really fascinating thoughts out there - go forth and consume.

I imagine you're thinking of First Contact.

Just trying to have a conversation but thanks for being condescending.
 
thanks.

the folks are gonna have a
*chuckle*
about this thread
back on flexnor....

btw...
for some time to come,
you're all alone.

don't let it go to your heads
 
thanks.

the folks are gonna have a
*chuckle*
about this thread
back on flexnor....

btw...
for some time to come,
you're all alone.

don't let it go to your heads

Kinda like being in the ghetto of the galaxy I suppose.

Ishmael
 
Back
Top