Freedom vs. Security

Which would you rather have? Explain

  • Freedom

    Votes: 31 83.8%
  • Security

    Votes: 3 8.1%
  • Other

    Votes: 3 8.1%

  • Total voters
    37
Coolville said:
a country that actually has to have this discussion has neither of the two things.

and that is a scary thought.

What a load of bollocks. Just discussing it doesn't mean to say that the country possess neither.
------------

It's all a matter of how much freedom and how much security there is. At which point does too much of one become detrimental to individuals or the community.
 
Coolville AT BEST has a fantasy idea of what the United States is like.
 
Jack, sarcasm is a weak man's tool. Thank you for helping me to make that point.

As far as your imaginative stories and creativity, more power to you.

Look at the facts, though.

There are many ways to kill somoene... many of which don't make near the mess.

drowning, we don't put a safety lock on water...

choking, we don't cut off hands...

suffocation... have we taken away pillows yet?

stabbing... we don't keep knives in a special case with a lock

fire... shall we regulate the sale of matches and gasoline?

poison... perhaps all people want to live in harmony with nasty rodents.

The fact is, criminals are the ones who hurt, what weapon or by which means is totally in their hands.

So before you rant about crazies and show everyone exactly how paranoid you are look into actualities and spend your time getting educated.

Because your fiction, amusing as it is, is still fiction.
 
"Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit" - Oscar Wilde

However it still manages to go over the heads of many people.

Sorry, I hadn't realised that your comment about arming all passengers on aircraft was flipant.
 
Jack, sarcasm is a weak man's tool. Thank you for helping me to make that point.

As far as your imaginative stories and creativity, more power to you.

Look at the facts, though.

There are many ways to kill somoene... many of which don't make near the mess.

drowning, we don't put a safety lock on water...

No, but we warn people of the dangers, we put life rings by open water, we teach our kids to swim, Is that acting responsibly or is setting a security level? Drowning as a form of murder is not that common. Not that easy too. You can't just walkout on the street with bucket of water and drown someone.

choking, we don't cut off hands...

I presume you mean 'strangulation' rather than 'on a pretzel' Again as method of murder in street crime or violent crime, not that common and there is a chance that the victim can fight back. Unless they're in a TV drama.

suffocation... have we taken away pillows yet?

No, but it's not a big threat.

stabbing... we don't keep knives in a special case with a lock

No but in the UK, in response to the number of knives used in street crime, there is now a 2 year sentence if you are arrested carrying a knife. Workmen have to be careful too - one carpet fitter was charged for carrying a knife. It was a stanley knife, used for his trade which was left out in his car. He was convicted and told he should have had the knife LOCKED away in his tool box.



fire... shall we regulate the sale of matches and gasoline?

They already are. Try sending a five year old into a shop to buy matches. Petrol is regulated for tax purposes. There are warning signs at petrol stations to turn off engines, no smoking. Do we really need those no smoking signs? Yes, because there are idiots who do not think, or don't care. So for the protection of themselves and everyone else we have those signs.


poison... perhaps all people want to live in harmony with nasty rodents.

Sales of poisons are regulated. Not only that, if you want to murder someone by poisoning there are plenty of ways to do it without resorting to purchased/stolen poisons. I know, I have a degree in Biochemistry.

The fact is, criminals are the ones who hurt, what weapon or by which means is totally in their hands.

So before you rant about crazies and show everyone exactly how paranoid you are look into actualities and spend your time getting educated.

Actually, I'm not paranoid. As you stated at the start of your reply, I was being sarcastic. I actually think that a better way to avoid hijackings is to make sure that NO passenger has a weapon, and giving passangers CONFIDENCE in the system so that when someone stands up and says 'I have a gun,' they know he is lying.

As for paranoia, consider this:

In three weeks the Washington snipers assassinated ten Americans; during the period, about 1,600 people were killed by guns across America.

Look at the effect the snipers had on Washington and the rest of the country. Look at how much coverage the other deaths in the news caused.

It is a question of how much security do you want to ensure your freedom, and who is to provide it - the state, the individual, or both.

Too much security results in oppression.

Too little and you are constantly lookinfg over your shoulder.
 
I am SO proud to be an American!

Whatever your opinion is... if it works for you, more power to you.

I am thankful that you aren't an American citizen with voting power, because, our world views are totally different buddy.
 
Hey, variety makes life more interesting!

So I have different opinions to you. Lot's of people do. It makes life more interesting.

I only object when people choose to back up their view point with violence.
 
Interesting question, of only because I think both terms are very open ended and, if considered carefully, might lead to a different answer.

Security: What type of security are we talking about here, personal security or national security. Of those, do we mean physical security or financial security?

Freedom: Again, personal or national? Freedom to do as we wish in a blissful state of anarchy or in a self-regulated Libertarian dream?

It's hard to say for either one. I happen to think that the Founders of the country got it right when they weighed the balances and came down on the side of a very limited national government whose primary duties were ensuring national security and doing basic organizational stuff and a strong state and local government system where the people in each place could decide how strongly they wanted their governmental controls. I believe they were right on the money when they granted rights without condition in the Bill of Rights (a document created because at least half of the colonies wanted *more* personal freedoms guaranteed in the Constitution) and assumed that with those rights came the responsibility for using them safely and wisely.

As was said earlier, I'd rather have a direct and reliable means of deciding whether I have more security or more freedom and at present, I have no real control over that at all. No one is better suited to decide what level of personal security I require than I, and I find that buying security with freedom is a very expensive proposition.
 
JazzManJim said:
... No one is better suited to decide what level of personal security I require than I, and I find that buying security with freedom is a very expensive proposition.

It doesn't have to expensive. It all depends on the level of security you want.

Car alarms, locks, window locks, all cost a small amount of freedom, are a minor inconveniece.

Searches at airports? A little more Identification needed to board a plane? That's a price I don't mind paying.

It's when the state decides that I everyone is a potential criminal all the time and should be treated as such. Phone calls taped, mail checked, emails logged, financial transactions monitored... That's too high a price for me to pay.
 
Mad_Jack_Rabbit said:
It doesn't have to expensive. It all depends on the level of security you want.

Car alarms, locks, window locks, all cost a small amount of freedom, are a minor inconveniece.

Searches at airports? A little more Identification needed to board a plane? That's a price I don't mind paying.

It's when the state decides that I everyone is a potential criminal all the time and should be treated as such. Phone calls taped, mail checked, emails logged, financial transactions monitored... That's too high a price for me to pay.

Locks and alarms aren't really impingements on your personal freedom when you put them up yourself. That you have the freedom to put them there, or take other prudent measures to protect yourself is far more important an issue.

What if, for instance, you live in an area where locks and alarms are not effective deterrents to criminals? What if you live in an area where the police routinely tell people that if they don't like the drug dealers, they should move because the police can't do anything about them? What if you live in an area where your neighbor and her children were burned to death by firebombing for standing up to a local drug dealer? People in those places have already surrendered large portions of the freedom to defend themselves and their property in return for...well...nothing. The government reneged on their part of the deal.

This happens in a lot of places. I believe that it's a wiser course of action for the people to merely inform the government that we no longer require their services in many areas, or that we're going to take mroe direct local control of these services, and excersize the freedoms we surrendered but for which we've not gotten full value.

The problem with a couple of your paragraphs is that in both cases, the government assumes you to be up to no good. You're just more comfortable with a lesser degree of direct action. Unfortunately, once a government decides that everyone is suspect (to the point of having to routinely prove their identities to various and sundry or prove themselves innocent and guileless to use public transportation, etc) it's a relatively simple thing for it to take more and more action until near-constant surveillance is a matter of course.

And if they do is by degrees, the population gets pretty used to it and they barely even notice the next intrusion or the next one.
 
Rex1960 said:
I actually don't know how to seperate both items. Is there freedom without any security ?
Of course there is. Neither is dependent on the other. One might have a great deal of both, or little of either. But one can usually give up some of one to get more of the other.

In 1776, Americans gave up their security completely and involved themselves in a war of uncertain outcome in a bid to gain their freedom. In those days, many gave their lives to attain and secure the freedoms Americans enjoy today. Sadly, there are always those who would give up all of those freedoms in a second if it would save their lives.

What kind of freedom is it, when you're suffering from all those fears, a terrorist act could harm your loved-ones ?
It's the same kind of freedom as when you're not suffering from all those fears. How you react to a situation emotionally changes nothing -- you are no less free than another who faces the same threat without fear.
 
lilpriss said:
I certainly would never break into someones home if I knew for a fact there was someone in the house who had a gun and knew how to use it. And use it well.
Even if you don't own a gun, it's no secret that on seeing an NRA sticker in the window of a house, most burglars will move on to another one. It isn't really worthwhile to find out if there's an armed occupant inside or not. This wouldn't be of any help outside the states, of course.
 
Maybe we have different definitions for either freedom and security.

I for one don't feel free when I feel unsecure.
 
Oh no Rex, freedom comes with insecurity.

Not to sound like James T. Kirk, but we're really not human or noble if we're nut struggle, striving, reaching for something better, new, bold, pushing horizons...

To feel secure is to be stagnating and while you may FEEL free, I think while still human, you may not be noble.
 
JazzManJim said:
People in those places have already surrendered large portions of the freedom to defend themselves and their property in return for...well...nothing. The government reneged on their part of the deal.
The police will arrest suspects who have broken the law. They don't arrest anyone because they may be about to break the law. They aren't there for your personal protection -- that's your responsibility.

Unfortunately, once a government decides that everyone is suspect (to the point of having to routinely prove their identities to various and sundry or prove themselves innocent and guileless to use public transportation, etc) it's a relatively simple thing for it to take more and more action until near-constant surveillance is a matter of course.

And if they do it by degrees, the population gets pretty used to it and they barely even notice the next intrusion or the next one.
Very true, and in fact I believe it's now the case in the UK that in urban areas surveillance cameras are everywhere, and people seem to pretty much have accepted it.
 
It is beginning here to with the traffic cams.

But even the news channels have cameras all over town which they tout as weather cams, but I think are there to get lucky for that once in a lifetime shot, like the survailance tape of one of the recent questionable plane accidents that has never been released to the public.

It will end when the TV watches you, eh?
 
Rex1960 said:
Maybe we have different definitions for either freedom and security.

I for one don't feel free when I feel unsecure.
I was just thinking that perhaps "freedom" is the wrong word from a European standpoint. The word used should probably have been Liberty, but in US English, the two are used interchangeably.

You are using the word in a relative way. When you say, for instance, that you don't feel free without security, you are saying that what you want is freedom from fear. But such things as freedom from fear, freedom from uncertainty, freedom from want, are entirely different from Liberty.
 
Byron In Exile said:
Even if you don't own a gun, it's no secret that on seeing an NRA sticker in the window of a house, most burglars will move on to another one. It isn't really worthwhile to find out if there's an armed occupant inside or not. This wouldn't be of any help outside the states, of course.

Is this really true? Surely the MAJORITY of breakins occur in properties which are BELIEVED to be empty rather than believing that the occupier has a gun.
 
Byron In Exile said:
The police will arrest suspects who have broken the law. They don't arrest anyone because they may be about to break the law. They aren't there for your personal protection -- that's your responsibility.

Actually they will arrest to prevent a crime being committed and they will arrest before a crime is committed to prevent 'breechs of the peace'



(About CCTV CAMERAS IN THE STREETS)
Very true, and in fact I believe it's now the case in the UK that in urban areas surveillance cameras are everywhere, and people seem to pretty much have accepted it.

We have them in the UK. They were intended to detere crime but they don't - good street lighting is more effective and cheaper, makes people feel safer too. Where CCTV comes in useful is catching criminals and securing convictions AFTER the event.

I don't mind the CCTV cameras, they don't really infringe my privacy or liberty.
 
MechaBlade said:
Freedom. If I had a choice between total police state where you had to show ID before leaving your building and total anarchy where you had to bring your gun before leaving your building, I would choose anarchy.

I'd not only choose it, but embrace it.

Security is a matter of personal responsibility, like washing your dirty dishes. It's unrealistic to expect others to do it for you.
 
Freedom is desirable yet sadly unattainable. Until we are ready to ebrace freedom, my vote goes out to security.
 
Back
Top