Gun control, changed your mind now?

Bad_Doggie

Qu'est-ce que c'est?
Joined
Nov 24, 2006
Posts
6,809
I think at this point it’s obvious to all, apart from the most partisan, that the events of yesterday were the result of a deranged individual.

That said when you live in a society which allows widespread gun ownership (which can inevitably fall into the hands of deranged individuals) and has sections of your political spectrum which actively promote and enable gun ownership isn’t that irresponsible?

If in addition to this, at the same time, you also propagate a climate of political hatred, some of which obliquely refers to the use of arms; isn’t it inevitable that deranged, “fringe” elements will carry out acts such as yesterday. Isn’t that also irresponsible?

Should the political vitriol be toned down? Should there be tighter gun control?

Woof!
 
Blaming guns for a crime makes as much sense as blaming language for hate speech.....both are benign until a conscious effort to abuse them occurs.
 
I think at this point it’s obvious to all, apart from the most partisan, that the events of yesterday were the result of a deranged individual.

That said when you live in a society which allows widespread gun ownership (which can inevitably fall into the hands of deranged individuals) and has sections of your political spectrum which actively promote and enable gun ownership isn’t that irresponsible?

If in addition to this, at the same time, you also propagate a climate of political hatred, some of which obliquely refers to the use of arms; isn’t it inevitable that deranged, “fringe” elements will carry out acts such as yesterday. Isn’t that also irresponsible?

Should the political vitriol be toned down? Should there be tighter gun control?

Woof!

Right, because outlawing guns always totally eliminates violence in a country...

Oh wait, no it doesn't.
 
I think at this point it’s obvious to all, apart from the most partisan, that the events of yesterday were the result of a deranged individual.

That said when you live in a society which allows widespread gun ownership (which can inevitably fall into the hands of deranged individuals) and has sections of your political spectrum which actively promote and enable gun ownership isn’t that irresponsible?
No, it's just how we live and die. It's the wild west out here. Fun shit, lemme tell ya...

If in addition to this, at the same time, you also propagate a climate of political hatred, some of which obliquely refers to the use of arms; isn’t it inevitable that deranged, “fringe” elements will carry out acts such as yesterday. Isn’t that also irresponsible?
Maybe.

But automobile accidents kill 500 times more people.

They just aren't exciting enough to make the news.

Should the political vitriol be toned down? Should there be tighter gun control?

Woof!
Should you stop barking?
 
Blaming guns for a crime makes as much sense as blaming language for hate speech.....both are benign until a conscious effort to abuse them occurs.

Blaming guns that are used in a wholesale slaughter in which a gun was the weapon of choice make sense, no?

Or are you going with the guns don’t kill people, people kill people argument?

Woof!
 
Right, because outlawing guns always totally eliminates violence in a country...

Oh wait, no it doesn't.

Who said, “out lawing guns always totally eliminates violence in a country?”

If there were less/no guns would be less deadly don’t ya think?

Woof!
 
Who said, “out lawing guns always totally eliminates violence in a country?”

Pretty much every European I've ever talked to about gun control has at least implied it or something close to it...


If there were less/no guns would be less deadly don’t ya think?

Woof!

Including you apparently.

There would be fewer shootings obviously, but guns aren't the only way to kill people.
 
No, it's just how we live and die. It's the wild west out here. Fun shit, lemme tell ya...

Ya’ll are crazy people, Clint has a lot to answer for.

Maybe.

But automobile accidents kill 500 times more people.

They just aren't exciting enough to make the news.

I don’t think that automobiles are built with the express intent of killing.

It’s relatively rare that an automobile is the weapon of choice wouldn’t you say?

Woof!
 
Last edited:
No. I know how to shoot and we have weapons in our home. A gun is a tool, and one I deeply believe is my right to own and operate.

A car accident wouldn't decide I should take everyone's cars away.
 
Pretty much every European I've ever talked to about gun control has at least implied it or something close to it...

Then they are stupid, what effect they think gun control could have on knife crime, common assault or embezzlement is anybody’s guess.

Including you apparently.

There would be fewer shootings obviously, but guns aren't the only way to kill people.

Of course not, but then can you tell me of a more deadly weapon than a gun or a bomb?

Woof!
 
Who said, “out lawing guns always totally eliminates violence in a country?”

If there were less/no guns would be less deadly don’t ya think?

Woof!
Not really. If the suspect had walked up to the same range and detonated a suicide vest -- or remotely detonated an IED planted before hand since this was a publicized event -- how many more people would have been injured/died?

ETA: IIRC Japan recently had a case of a nutjob going berserk with a Samurai sword -- his score was higher than this incident.

In answer to your thread title: No, I haven't changed my mind about gun control. I still see no reason why I should be punished for the acts of a few nut-cases.
 
Last edited:
Then they are stupid, what effect they think gun control could have on knife crime, common assault or embezzlement is anybody’s guess.



Of course not, but then can you tell me of a more deadly weapon than a gun or a bomb?

Woof!

Guns give me the opportunity to defend myself at range. I live in a state where people are permitted to defend themselves by owning and carrying weapons. Despite screaming that there'd be anarchy and more deaths, the crime rate went down.

You can't focus on only the crimes. There are many crimes that are prevented and lives saved by self defense.
 
No. I know how to shoot and we have weapons in our home. A gun is a tool, and one I deeply believe is my right to own and operate.

A car accident wouldn't decide I should take everyone's cars away.

And by the same token you are comfortable with less desirable and in some cases insane elements in your society having access to said tools?

Woof!
 
And by the same token you are comfortable with less desirable and in some cases insane elements in your society having access to said tools?

Woof!

Of course not. But I don't want drunks driving cars either. They are punished after the fact. I can't prevent it, but I can fight to defend the rights of non-insane, non-criminal people to operate one.

Nobody can legislate that crazy people aren't born and don't abuse the privilege of being alive by denying it to others.

Horrible people can drive cars, have children...I can't stop them. Can you?
 
Of course not. But I don't want drunks driving cars either. They are punished after the fact.

But, if you, (hypothetically in this case) could remove the possibility would you?
And an argument where you can’t bad stop behaviour in one instant isn’t an argument of why you shouldn’t stop enabling bad behaviour in another instant.

Nobody can legislate that crazy people aren't born and don't abuse the privilege of being alive by denying it to others.

Horrible people can drive cars, have children...I can't stop them. Can you?

Nope, no doubt a crazy person could kill someone with a plastic fork, I can’t stop him. You could make it more difficult for him though. It’s more difficult to kill someone with a plastic fork than having access to a semi?

Woof!
 
And by the same token you are comfortable with less desirable and in some cases insane elements in your society having access to said tools?

Woof!
The "less desireable and insane elements" are already legally barred from possessing a gun. (ETA: In Arizona specifically and most other jurisdictions in the US and its possessions.) That of course presumes a prior encounter with the law so as to be identified as undesireable and/or insane -- are you suggesting that the desire to lawfully own, possess, and use a firearm is defact proof of indesireability and/or insanity?

If so, I'm offended by your presumption of my guilt.
 
Last edited:
But, if you, (hypothetically in this case) could remove the possibility would you?
And an argument where you can’t bad stop behaviour in one instant isn’t an argument of why you shouldn’t stop enabling bad behaviour in another instant.



Nope, no doubt a crazy person could kill someone with a plastic fork, I can’t stop him. You could make it more difficult for him though. It’s more difficult to kill someone with a plastic fork than having access to a semi?

Woof!

That's like saying if I'd hypothetically take heroin if I could not have an addiction factor. Sure, in a perfect world.

Unfortunately this is not a perfect world. This is the real world. Eliminate the possibility of the general public from defending themselves and you victimize the general public. You don't punish the criminals, who will get guns from illegal means anyway. You penalize the law abiding.

The reality is that open carry and concealed gun ownership, being legal, actually makes it harder for the criminals. I like it that way.

You have to look at the whole picture. Not just the body count of those who use guns. You have to factor in all the lives saved by those who use them to defend themselves without bloodshed. A gun can make a criminal turn tail and run, no bloodshed.

As to the plastic fork, England has made guns illegal, now they're considering pointy weapons illegal. What's next, sticks?

I don't feel safe because I'm confined to the stone age and theoretically the bad guys can get their hands on anything they want illegally. The safety is an illusion.

By the way, please shoot me rather than stab me.
 
RECIDIVA is right.

I dont own a gun, and generally think guns invite problems. But when I lived on a river a gun came in handy for shooting snakes and rabid animals that came along. Its a lot easier to point a shotgun at a rattlesnake and pull a trigger than fuck around with a stick or hoe. Ditto for rabid coons.

In America we make fools and nutjobs the common denominator for rules.
 
The political tone cannot be muted for central government has become so powerful that winning and losing in the political games means deleterious effects to your group.





:(

__________________
When the government gets powerful enough to fight over, the people will fight over it, and to the victors go the spoils, thus setting up the next fight.
A_J, the Stupid
 
That's like saying if I'd hypothetically take heroin if I could not have an addiction factor. Sure, in a perfect world.

Unfortunately this is not a perfect world. This is the real world. Eliminate the possibility of the general public from defending themselves and you victimize the general public. .

The object is to remove the necessity of the general public to defend themselves against such threats.

You don't punish the criminals, who will get guns from illegal means anyway. You penalize the law abiding.

Of course you punish criminals who get guns illegally. You also make it more difficult for the guns to fall into the hands of all undesirable elements that’s the point.

The reality is that open carry and concealed gun ownership, being legal, actually makes it harder for the criminals. I like it that way.

I don’t think the stats back that up.

You have to look at the whole picture. Not just the body count of those who use guns. You have to factor in all the lives saved by those who use them to defend themselves without bloodshed. A gun can make a criminal turn tail and run, no bloodshed.

I’ve never seen any stats that suggest that either.

As to the plastic fork, England has made guns illegal, now they're considering pointy weapons illegal. What's next, sticks?

Certain types of knives and swords are now also illegal in the UK as is carrying them in a public place. I don’t see how that can have any other effect than reduce the possibility of being assaulted by such a weapon. Being killed by a plastic fork is relatively rare.

I don't feel safe because I'm confined to the stone age and theoretically the bad guys can get their hands on anything they want illegally. The safety is an illusion.

Factually, you, your family and your children are far more likely to be victims of gun crime than I am. I like it that way and that’s not an illusion.

Woof!
 
Last edited:
The political tone cannot be muted for central government has become so powerful that winning and losing in the political games means deleterious effects to your group

I was just wondering if, as citizens, of your country; are you comfortable with the level of political hatred and oblique references to the use of arms to achieve political aims that has been becoming more prevalent.

Regardless of how deleteriously government may effect your group.

Would you also agree with my “far away” observation that US politics has become increasingly hate filled and personalized?

Woof!
 
Back
Top