How well do you take criticism??

The Heretic

Literotica Guru
Joined
Oct 26, 2002
Posts
28,592
How do you handle it if someone points out some fundamental flaw in your story, your logic, your post, your assumptions.

How do you handle it if someone makes you aware of an mistake in your work, something you created for others, etc.?

I used to work as a software QA person, and as such it was my job to find flaws not only in the software but the documentation that went with it. I have found that many (most) people just don't respond well to critical feedback on something they put a lot of effort into - whether they are proud of it or not (albeit, pride does enter into it).

Many people tend to take critical feedback personally, as I was recently reminded when I pointed out, in a public forum, some flaws in an article I read. The author and a few other people took exception to put it mildly. I also had a few disinterested people read my posts for accuracy, and unsolicited they stated that I was fair in my criticism.

How do you respond to criticism?

No poll this time.
 
Is this thread a ploy to get people to admit their inabilty to take criticism well, then exploit them? Cause that would be funny.
 
Last edited:
Depends on who is giving me the criticism. Last summer a close friend gave me a strong dose of the truth. I could have gotten all offended and pissed off, but the fact was, he was correct in his criticism of my behavior.:)
 
The Heretic said:
How do you respond to criticism?
I forgot to say how I respond to criticism - just as well, this breaks up the post.

How I respond depends on the issue:

If it is something like an article, a post, a program module I wrote, something I create, etc. - then I welcome critical feedback with open arms. It is so hard to get people to be honest with you in their feedback, especially if they are face to face and have to work with you.

If it comes as criticism of my personal life, something I did or didn't do, etc. - well I don't take that quite so well. If someone questions my integrity - that is a hot button with me and I don't respond well at all. If someone is a friend and assumes the worst of me, or is sarcastic in an unfunny manner - I will probably seeth (sp?) for a while.
 
For myself it depends on who is critisizing and also how it's done. If it's respectful great, if someone comes at me in a snide or abusive manner that's another thing.
 
Kalyn said:
Is this thread a ploy to get people to admit their inabilty to take critiscm well, then exploit them? Cause that would be funny.
It would be very unfunny. While I have attacked people here from time to time, and have hurt people's feelings - it was never premeditated in the manner you suggest.

No, this is another in my series of threads where I try to understand human nature better. The last few days I have had some experiences where I had reason to reflect on this issue - so I created this thread. I often post threads about such things.
 
It depends on what's being criticized, who is criticizing, and how they’re doing it. If I turn an assignment into my teacher, I expect them to criticize it. It’s something I both need and desire. This assumes that the criticism is given in a professional manner on relevant details.

On a related note, the literary magazine at my college implemented a new submission procedure. If a piece was initially rejected by the selections committee but still has merit it’s now returned to the author with suggestions for revisions. I’ve heard quite a few students call this ‘censorship’ and they’re now refusing to submit any of their work.
 
The Heretic said:
It would be very unfunny. While I have attacked people here from time to time, and have hurt people's feelings - it was never premeditated in the manner you suggest.

No, this is another in my series of threads where I try to understand human nature better. The last few days I have had some experiences where I had reason to reflect on this issue - so I created this thread. I often post threads about such things.


Are you criticising my concept of humour?
 
I'm a creative writing major and most of my classes involve workshops, in which I hand in twenty copies of my work for my twenty classmates and the next session they publicly tell me exactly what they liked and didn't like about my piece.

It takes a tough skin. I've pretty much learned to take all the emotion out of it and objectively consider criticism.
 
Criticism sucks!
Sometimes I take it well, depending on my mood, but then again . . .
 
Pyper said:
It takes a tough skin. I've pretty much learned to take all the emotion out of it and objectively consider criticism.
That is what a professional has to do if they are going to publish - yet many (most?) never learn to deal with it. I fear it is only going to get worse because it is getting easier and easier to publish, both in print and online.

What I don't like is when I write something (usually a technical paper, or documentation for a product), and I get little or no feedback. Yeah, I know - users never read the manuals. :rolleyes:
 
Kalyn said:
Are you criticising my concept of humour?
Who me? :eek: Not likely! I've been told time and time again, by a few sarcastic people here, that I don't have a sense of humor. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top