I know where I stand ...

torchthebitch

Soothing jacuzzi bath
Joined
Nov 16, 2006
Posts
15,972
but it did make me question my position.

I'll c&p for convenience

Drone attacks may be legal, but are they moral?
The silence from human rights groups on America's use of 'targeted attacks' in Afghanistan is deafening, says Alasdair Palmer

By Alasdair Palmer
Published: 4:33PM BST 09 Oct 2010

8 Comments

Abdul Jabbar, a British citizen from Birmingham, was killed last week in Pakistan by a missile launched from an American drone. If Jabbar was indeed planning a Mumbai-style massacre in a British city, as the intelligence services claim, his death will be a relief. Yet the degree to which it now seems to be acceptable for the US to use drones to kill those it believes to be involved in planning terrorist attacks is alarming.

Since the beginning of September alone, President Obama has authorised at least 25 targeted killings. The total since he came to office is more than 100. These have certainly killed some of the senior operatives of al-Qaeda and the Taliban. They have also killed dozens of people, including a large number of women and children, who were not involved in terrorism.

And yet there has been very little protest, certainly compared to the storm of international criticism that greeted the decision to hold suspected terrorists at Guantanamo – a policy that didn’t kill anyone, let alone any innocent women and children. The silence from human rights groups over the drone attacks is deafening. What has persuaded them that it is acceptable to kill people, including people who are not terrorists, but that it is inhumane to deprive them of a good night’s sleep?

There is no doubting the brutal effectiveness of drone attacks, or that they have a lot going for them in terms of risk and reward: they kill the enemy without exposing our forces to any danger. But the targeting is only as good as the information it is based on – and that information is, inevitably, often inaccurate.

Even when the targeted terrorist turns out to be in the building, there are often others with him who are also incinerated. In August 2009, for example, Baitullah Mehsud, the leader of the Taliban in Pakistan, was killed in a drone attack: his wife, his father-in-law, his mother-in-law, a lieutenant, and seven bodyguards also died.

No one knows exactly how many innocents have died as a result of drone attacks, but the total almost certainly runs to three figures. It is not easy to square that with President Obama’s insistence that his administration is “living by our values” – unless American values now include the endorsement of indiscriminate killing. The President has also stressed that America now complies with international law. Remarkably, he seems to be right: the consensus is that drone attacks are indeed legal. The UN produced a report on the topic at the end of May, which concluded that the best way forward is for an international conference of states to review the guidelines for setting targets “after a careful review of best practice”.

Best practice? Well, I suppose there is such a thing, even when you are involved in targeted killing. The UN’s Special Rapporteur thinks it involves specifying very clearly, in advance, whom you are going to target, as well as where, when, and why. That is something no country that uses drones will ever do: their success depends on the victims not knowing when or where they will be attacked.

The fact that targeted killing has been deemed “legal” seems to have had the effect of making many people, including the President, think that it is morally justified. But that conclusion doesn’t follow. There are plenty of things that are legal, but which you would not be morally justified in doing – just as there are times when you are morally justified in doing things that are illegal.

Perhaps using drones to kill terrorists is a legitimate way of prosecuting the war against al‑Qaeda and the Taliban. It may be that the women and children who get killed as a result don’t matter – although I would like to hear someone from the US government, or a human rights organisation, explain exactly why. But we – and the Americans – are deceiving ourselves if we think that something is OK just because international lawyers say it is.

for comments and related articles http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/...e-attacks-maybe-legal-but-are-they-moral.html

This paragraph

And yet there has been very little protest, certainly compared to the storm of international criticism that greeted the decision to hold suspected terrorists at Guantanamo – a policy that didn’t kill anyone, let alone any innocent women and children. The silence from human rights groups over the drone attacks is deafening. What has persuaded them that it is acceptable to kill people, including people who are not terrorists, but that it is inhumane to deprive them of a good night’s sleep?

posed the question which made me think. How, exactly, do human rights groups square that circle?
 
i don't know about human rights groups, but i've never liked the idea of drones. it just seems so cold and dehumanizing. yeah, i know it's war, but whatever. it's not a good thing to make killing people into little more than a video game.
 
I like drone attacks because evidence seems to support that they are effective. However, drone attacks on a sovereign state (I know, the Pakistan govt cannot control the lawless west part of the country) is certainly problematic.

The Pakistani people are just now taking revenge for the drone attacks on their soil.
 
Kashmir should have been handled by the international community... since it wasn't, we got a lot of lawlessness out of it... The vacuum in Pakistan is due in part to that.

This all reeks of Cambodia and Laos. There's no accountability and it's the kind of shadow war that's going to have long-term ramifications for the US and Britain.

Not to mention the problems with executing people from your own country without a trial...

If Pakistan can't control their own problems, they should be treated as a failed state, but what's going on now violates their sovereignty and is going to end up making a lot more enemies.
 
i don't know about human rights groups, but i've never liked the idea of drones. it just seems so cold and dehumanizing. yeah, i know it's war, but whatever. it's not a good thing to make killing people into little more than a video game.

It is simply another step in the military's efforts to take the hesitation out of the trigger finger.

I like drone attacks because evidence seems to support that they are effective. However, drone attacks on a sovereign state (I know, the Pakistan govt cannot control the lawless west part of the country) is certainly problematic.

The Pakistani people are just now taking revenge for the drone attacks on their soil.

The principle of hot pursuit still applies, and there is no reason that Nato troops should not deploy drone attacks in response to a Taleban attack. At least they are more targetted than an artillery salvo.

It is the attacks in response to intelligence that become more problematic.

And if a terrorists famnily dies with him? So much the better.
 
This all reeks of Cambodia and Laos. There's no accountability and it's the kind of shadow war that's going to have long-term ramifications for the US and Britain.

Not to mention the problems with executing people from your own country without a trial...

.

Two pertinent points, although I would add Germany, Italy and some other ountries to the list. Some of the best and most feared troops out there come from places like Lithuania and other former Warsaw Pact nations.
 
In the first place, we would all do well to question the assumption that “human rights” groups, many if not most of whom are essentially anti-war, somehow have a monopoly on what constitutes acceptable conduct between nations engaged in the very act they oppose. In the case of the United States, we and other nations addressed the morality of war many years ago in formulating the Geneva accords. There is precious little that those treaties do not cover, and it is not at all clear to me why anyone else not a party to those agreements would have a credible contravening argument to the major provisions which the signatories to Geneva have adopted.

Secondly, imho, the harsh light of criticism forfeits whatever credibility it might have if it is purposely focused on the excesses of one participant to the exclusion of the other. This is NOT an attempt to justify the moral transgressions of either party under the “they-did- it-so-we-can-too” doctrine, but society owes itself an objective comparative moral analysis of, say, the acts of the Allied Powers during World War II contrasted to those of Nazism, fascism, and Japanese Imperialism in order to rationally determine where the worst of the offenders and their offenses lie. The same holds true for Islamic jihadists today.

It is at this point that one usually hears the misapplied truism, “we hold ourselves to a higher standard.” True for certain, but misapplied if such application fails to hold the other side to a standard at all.

Turning to the specific issue of Predator drone attacks, three issues seem to be the most troublesome to many: targeted killings, collateral death of non-combatants and the robotic, “no-hands-no-risk” status of those piloting the drones.

Targeted killing through intelligence rather than via the random nature of the “fog of combat” seems more like assassination to some while combat death through happenstance seems comfortably less accountable.

The fact is, legitimate combat tactics recognize both. Very few combat actions are initiated without the benefit of some intelligence. The largest campaigns directed at large numbers of enemy forces (D-Day comes to mind) require intelligence that is literally massive and detailed. The fact that detailed intelligence might be collected to mount an action against a specific military leader rather than against a company or brigade of his subordinates is a distinction without moral relevance.

One of the most notable of these actions was taken against Admiral Yamamoto in 1943. US intelligence learned that the man who commanded the attack on Pearl Harbor would be flying to a specific south pacific island at a specific time. The mission to “Get Yamamoto” was personally approved by President Roosevelt and proceeded down the chain of command to the fighter squadron that successfully completed the mission.

In short, the killing of combatants and their leadership with whom one is at war can never justly be compared to political assassination.

Secondly, all combatants in any war have a moral obligation to avoid collateral damage of non-military property or equipment as well as the collateral killing of civilian non-combatants. Avoid means exactly what it says. It is not a blanket prohibition wherein the unintended death of a single civilian equates to a war crime against the aggressor. I don’t even believe Geneva specifically prohibits all combat actions where collateral civilian deaths might be possible or even likely. I don’t know how the CIA or the Defense Department make such decisions. I do know that history records more than one instance where an attack on Osama Bin Laden himself was canceled due to the prospect of collateral civilian casualties.

But let’s take a closer look at one example in the article cited – the death of Baitullah Mehsud, his wife, his mother- and father-in-law, a lieutenant and seven bodyguards. How many possible non-combatant casualties do you find in that picture? I can only name three. A lieutenant and seven bodyguards are not exactly innocent bystanders.

Moreover, taken alone, the article’s conclusion that collateral casualties might total “three figures” hardly justifies the characterization of “indiscriminate killings.” Such a conclusion is meaningless without knowing the accompanying number of combatants and enemy leadership killed as well as the details of whatever discriminating efforts were attempted, if any. Time and again we’ve heard of combat troops and pilots getting or attempting to get permission from superiors to fire upon known or suspected enemy insurgents. Nothing leads me to believe our rules of engagement are too liberal or indiscriminate. If anything, the opposite is true.

Finally, we come to the most baseless complaint concerning drone attacks. The notion that it is akin to a video game wherein the shooter (i.e. “player 1”) is detached from the victim (“player 2”). I don’t pretend to know what drone “pilots” feel when killing the enemy. I don’t much care.

Nor, I suspect, does the entire field of weapons development which has labored since time began to give users of weaponry an UNfair advantage over an opponent. One of the most common advantages sought has been to physically separate an attacker from an effective counter attack. It’s part of the advantage we see in bullets over spears, artillery over bullets, bombs over artillery, and now unmanned, drone aircraft over human piloted aircraft.

There is no evidence I am aware of that would suggest that unpiloted drone aircraft are more likely to indiscriminately strafe and bomb enemy territory simply because the pilot is sitting at a computer terminal.

Neither is there a moral disconnect between how people are killed in war vs. how they are treated if taken into captivity. The acceptable conduct governing each is obviously different and often not comparable.
 
Well how come they made their voice heard over Guantanamo, but it isn't getting over about drones?

it is getting heard, if you care to listen. I think one of the main issues is that guantanamo was problematic because it was indiscriminate, involved torture etc.

the drones have so far tended to be pretty specific and hit the 'bad guys' which means that it is harder to argue against them other than on macho-moral grounds.
 
i don't know about human rights groups, but i've never liked the idea of drones. it just seems so cold and dehumanizing. yeah, i know it's war, but whatever. it's not a good thing to make killing people into little more than a video game.

That's an utterly ridiculous and ignorant way to characterize it.
 
it is getting heard, if you care to listen. I think one of the main issues is that guantanamo was problematic because it was indiscriminate, involved torture etc.

the drones have so far tended to be pretty specific and hit the 'bad guys' which means that it is harder to argue against them other than on macho-moral grounds.

Those are merely allegations at this point. They have never been proven.
 
it is getting heard, if you care to listen. I think one of the main issues is that guantanamo was problematic because it was indiscriminate, involved torture etc.

the drones have so far tended to be pretty specific and hit the 'bad guys' which means that it is harder to argue against them other than on macho-moral grounds.

The number of innocent people killed by drones is much, much higher than the number killed at Guantanamo. It's the nature of the technique...a missile destroys everything in the area.
 
The number of innocent people killed by drones is much, much higher than the number killed at Guantanamo. It's the nature of the technique...a missile destroys everything in the area.
That's not the right measure. Hardly anyone is killed in Guantanamo.

If you want to compare the two--and I don't understand why you would--the correct question would be how many of the wrong people are affected (killed, tortured, detained, whatever) by each.

But the actual correct question when dealing with drones--without the false equivalence--is whether the civilian ("wrong") losses are worth the terrorist ("correct") losses--and whether, even so, if the terrorist losses are worth the troop losses.

I don't know the answer. but I suspect a strong yes.
 
I've never been a fan of state murder whether it's done with a gun or an Xbox controller. And when the murders are being done because some faceless bureaucrat says so, it becomes even more problematic.
 
If you want to compare the two--and I don't understand why you would--the correct question would be how many of the wrong people are affected (killed, tortured, detained, whatever) by each.

So arresting people is the same as killing them, because both affect people?

If a good technique for dealing with tips on bad guys would be to blow up everybody in the area where they are reported to be, then our police forces seem to be way behind the times.
 
So arresting people is the same as killing them, because both affect people?

If a good technique for dealing with tips on bad guys would be to blow up everybody in the area where they are reported to be, then our police forces seem to be way behind the times.
Drones aren't the opposite of Guantanamo, they're the opposite of manned surveillance flights, or troops on the ground.

Guantanamo is either a POW camp or a U.S. court-system holding cell (but not both).

Drones are killing machines. Guantanamo is a detention machine. They serve entirely different purposes. Comparing their kill rates is a false equivalency.
 
Drones aren't the opposite of Guantanamo, they're the opposite of manned surveillance flights, or troops on the ground.

Guantanamo is either a POW camp or a U.S. court-system holding cell (but not both).

Drones are killing machines. Guantanamo is a detention machine. They serve entirely different purposes. Comparing their kill rates is a false equivalency.

So you say.

Previously, the US was more likely to pursue tips on Al Qaeda leaders by arresting them and subjecting them to harsh interrogation.

This may have resulted in some useful intelligence, or may have been a complete waste of time and resources. In the end, it led to massive outcry that the US was being barbaric and inhumane.

So now we just kill these guys--no reading them their rights, no geneva convention--and anybody in the immediate area. (Shoudn't have been hanging out with people we think are terrorists. Didn't Gitmo teach them that?)

I'd suggest that comparing kill rates is a reasonable way to look at the degree to which we are being inhumane.
 
So you say.

Previously, the US was more likely to pursue tips on Al Qaeda leaders by arresting them and subjecting them to harsh interrogation.

This may have resulted in some useful intelligence, or may have been a complete waste of time and resources. In the end, it led to massive outcry that the US was being barbaric and inhumane.

So now we just kill these guys--no reading them their rights, no geneva convention--and anybody in the immediate area. (Shoudn't have been hanging out with people we think are terrorists. Didn't Gitmo teach them that?)

I'd suggest that comparing kill rates is a reasonable way to look at the degree to which we are being inhumane.
[Double posts earn blow jobs for the poster.]
 
So you say.

Previously, the US was more likely to pursue tips on Al Qaeda leaders by arresting them and subjecting them to harsh interrogation.

This may have resulted in some useful intelligence, or may have been a complete waste of time and resources. In the end, it led to massive outcry that the US was being barbaric and inhumane.

So now we just kill these guys--no reading them their rights, no geneva convention--and anybody in the immediate area. (Shoudn't have been hanging out with people we think are terrorists. Didn't Gitmo teach them that?)

I'd suggest that comparing kill rates is a reasonable way to look at the degree to which we are being inhumane.
No. Comparing collateral damage is a reasonable way. Comparing kill rates is a flawed measure, since one method is meant specifically to kill and not detain, and one is meant to detain and not kill.
 
No. Comparing collateral damage is a reasonable way. Comparing kill rates is a flawed measure, since one method is meant specifically to kill and not detain, and one is meant to detain and not kill.

Well, ok. I can live with "flawed measure" since everything about these situations is flawed.

You seem unwilling to acknowledge the point that a method that is designed to kill is, by most societal norms, the worst method that one could imagine.

The military moral conundrum is that, given somebody we don't like who is not actively engaged in combat but thought to be a threat, many people think it is "worse" to capture someone and then roughly interrogate them, than it is to just kill them with explosives.
 
Well, ok. I can live with "flawed measure" since everything about these situations is flawed.

You seem unwilling to acknowledge the point that a method that is designed to kill is, by most societal norms, the worst method that one could imagine.

The military moral conundrum is that, given somebody we don't like who is not actively engaged in combat but thought to be a threat, many people think it is "worse" to capture someone and then roughly interrogate them, than it is to just kill them with explosives.
It's all a mess. I'm not defending either. I'm just pointing out the raw rhetorical flaw in basing the comparison on kill rates.

Having said that, *if*--and that's a big if--our intelligence is reliable, then the drone/kill strategy sure feels superior to the send-troops-in-and-detain-suspects strategy. But who the fuck knows.

Having said that that, if and when we ever kill bin Laden, it seems assured that it will be by drone.
 
Having said that, *if*--and that's a big if--our intelligence is reliable, then the drone/kill strategy sure feels superior to the send-troops-in-and-detain-suspects strategy.

I think this is the core of the question. That's not usually how we handle these types of situations even with serious threats in the US...it would be unconstitutional, among other things.

Clearly there are different situations for combat scenarios, but these attacks are taking place miles from any combat, even in another country that we think is our ally at times, for reasons that are not always clear.

Why does this approach feel superior? It certainly kills more innocents, drastically reduces the possibility of gathering useful intelligence (say, from computers in the area), and of course there are no do-overs for mistakes.
 
I think this is the core of the question. That's not usually how we handle these types of situations even with serious threats in the US...it would be unconstitutional, among other things.

Clearly there are different situations for combat scenarios, but these attacks are taking place miles from any combat, even in another country that we think is our ally at times, for reasons that are not always clear.

Why does this approach feel superior? It certainly kills more innocents, drastically reduces the possibility of gathering useful intelligence (say, from computers in the area), and of course there are no do-overs for mistakes.
It feels superior solely on the measure of US casualties incurred per foreign body neutralized. The rest is up for (important) discussion.

Again, though, if we ever take out bin Laden, I can bet you the contents of your savings account (since you don't want mine) that it's going to be by drone. It's a thorny issue...
 
Personally I favor taking out high ranking enemies by targeted strikes rather than sending lots of young men to kill lots of other young men. Further i have little concern for the collateral damage caused by a Hellfire. It is substantially less than that caused by FGA or artillery.

As Col Hogan points out, the Geneva convention requires combattants to try to minimise collateral damage and casualties. As I see it, killing the command structure achieves this, simply because there are fewer targets.

And by extension, I think it validates assassination of senior political leaders. In fact, I advocate it.
 
Back
Top