IQ matters

I saw an ideal pass-or-fail IQ test: residential high-rise flats with balconies lacking railings. Dolts of all ages quickly remove themselves from the gene pool. Try it some time.
 
It's a .7 correlation. *nods*

I know right? I'm still trying to find that study. Andrew Sullivan (still smarting from his New Republic days when his boy Charles Murray wrote some racist bullshit) posted this last Friday. He points to an article (from 1994) that and says it states "heritability ranges from 0.4 to 0.8". If you go to page 14 you'll find that Sully misplaced a word: "estimates". Sully, of the Oxford undergrad and Harvard PhD, clearly knows what the word estimate means but left it out. Gee I wonder why?

Well, if you read the article you'll see that the estimate of 0.4 to 0.8 is mentioned nowhere else in the article nor is a citation given for what study/studies found said estimation. Why people continue to print Sully's clearly poorly researched articles is beyond me.

Anyway, I did a little searching and found one article that said the heritability is, maybe, between 0.34 and 0.48. Another article I found said heritability ranges between 0.2 in childhood and 0.8 in adulthood. Of course, when they ran their experiment they found that even though their method predicted a heritability of 30% (0.3) it actually turned out to be 1% (0.01). The last study I found said by ages 18-20 the heritibility reaches 0.8 for IQ. They also found that environment is only responsible for a 0.1 variance. Which is odd that in their conclusion they write "The proximate causes of variance in IQ are the ‘cognitively stimulating experiences’ that the individual is provided with and seeks for him/herself." In other words: a person's educational experiences (say a school environment) is a greater predictor of IQ than genes.

It's funny how hard the IQ-mongers really want genes, race, sex, or whatever to predict the score but study after study show it's simply not the case.
 
Probably the biggest misperception of IQ is that it somehow relates to ones training, experience, or level of success in life, and that the personal effort one makes in some particular way or at any particular moment relates to their IQ. There's really not much if any correlation... people with high IQ's exist in most every walk of life, and range from highly successful people in high caliber careers to the homeless and illiterate, and from the highly motivated to the totally derelict.
 
Probably the biggest misperception of IQ is that it somehow relates to ones training, experience, or level of success in life, and that the personal effort one makes in some particular way or at any particular moment relates to their IQ. There's really not much if any correlation... people with high IQ's exist in most every walk of life, and range from highly successful people in high caliber careers to the homeless and illiterate, and from the highly motivated to the totally derelict.

Dont worry, binky, nobody thinks you have a high IQ. I repeat, NOBODY. :)
 
I know right? I'm still trying to find that study. Andrew Sullivan (still smarting from his New Republic days when his boy Charles Murray wrote some racist bullshit) posted this last Friday. He points to an article (from 1994) that and says it states "heritability ranges from 0.4 to 0.8". If you go to page 14 you'll find that Sully misplaced a word: "estimates". Sully, of the Oxford undergrad and Harvard PhD, clearly knows what the word estimate means but left it out. Gee I wonder why?

Well, if you read the article you'll see that the estimate of 0.4 to 0.8 is mentioned nowhere else in the article nor is a citation given for what study/studies found said estimation. Why people continue to print Sully's clearly poorly researched articles is beyond me.

Anyway, I did a little searching and found one article that said the heritability is, maybe, between 0.34 and 0.48. Another article I found said heritability ranges between 0.2 in childhood and 0.8 in adulthood. Of course, when they ran their experiment they found that even though their method predicted a heritability of 30% (0.3) it actually turned out to be 1% (0.01). The last study I found said by ages 18-20 the heritibility reaches 0.8 for IQ. They also found that environment is only responsible for a 0.1 variance. Which is odd that in their conclusion they write "The proximate causes of variance in IQ are the ‘cognitively stimulating experiences’ that the individual is provided with and seeks for him/herself." In other words: a person's educational experiences (say a school environment) is a greater predictor of IQ than genes.

It's funny how hard the IQ-mongers really want genes, race, sex, or whatever to predict the score but study after study show it's simply not the case.

You are one ignorant son of a bitch.
 
Probably the biggest misperception of IQ is that it somehow relates to ones training, experience, or level of success in life, and that the personal effort one makes in some particular way or at any particular moment relates to their IQ. There's really not much if any correlation... people with high IQ's exist in most every walk of life, and range from highly successful people in high caliber careers to the homeless and illiterate, and from the highly motivated to the totally derelict.


Just look at sean.
 

You're full of shit.

In the first place I never posted that IQ was the sole determinant factor. And what she posted basically says exactly the same thing. Lower IQ individuals can succeed in life through dogged determination. Conscientiousness plays a role. High IQ individuals can, and do, fail in life due to bad choices and/or out and out laziness.

Group mean IQ's do go a ways in explaining why certain groups achieve more or less in life, but in the end the only determinant factor is the individuals IQ. Individuals on the high end of the standard deviation curve out perform their groups IQ. Which is to say that everyone has to be evaluated as an individual, not a group member.
 
There's no rush to respond to horseshit. Just as I didn't bother to respond to that junk science article you linked from PT.
 
Back when Bulliten Boards were popular I belonged to one like this that moved really fast.

This is more like a florida retirement village where a week or two between replies is a neck snapping pace.
 
There's no rush to respond to horseshit. Just as I didn't bother to respond to that junk science article you linked from PT.

I agree there was no rush. What you provided was horse shit. I knew you couldn't support it, which is why I called you on it. I even threw you a softball. You knew you were busted though. You did your best to hide from it too. Three weeks is pretty good for you.
 
Is the Pookie a Roary alternative or the Dick Raily alternative ID?

They all three do the stupid show me your google results game; losers.
 
Probably the most reliable indication of difference is the studies done of people conceived with donated semen. In the UK at least, most donors have been students, particularly medical students. Studies consistently show that these children achieve more academically than either their legal parents or their non AID peer group. They also earn more as adults. Obviously that is not an IQ test but it does appear to support the contention that smart parents have smart kids.
 
Then it should be soooo easy to provide 100 links for that .7 you are so adament about. But let's start with one. Ready? Go!

All you need is one, read "The Bell Curve." After that book came out the Social Psychologists went bat shit crazy trying to disprove the science, they couldn't. The work still stands today untarnished.
 
Back
Top