Is it unethical?

Sillyman

Clearence INFRARED
Joined
Sep 11, 2001
Posts
11,143
I needed new shoes. I have no money. I asked my grandmother to get me some new ones. She gave me $30 to buy shoes before she left town. I went and bought a pair for $6.95. Is it unethical of me to keep the rest of the money?
 
I say no.

She's your grandma, grandma's know you can buy things cheaper than $30. They are expert bargain shopers. So it was almost a given that you'd find cheaper shoes and be able to keep the rest. She expects it.


At least that's how I see it. :D
 
Kitte said:
short answer no
long answer yes

What she said!

I would damn sure be saving my money to buy a 30 dollar pair of showes before gramma comes back though or ask her what to do with the left over money.

:)
 
Sillyman said:
I needed new shoes. I have no money. I asked my grandmother to get me some new ones. She gave me $30 to buy shoes before she left town. I went and bought a pair for $6.95. Is it unethical of me to keep the rest of the money?

I don't think it would be unethical, per say, to keep the money since she probably didn't expect to receive the money back. However, the decent thing to do would be to return the unused portion. If she says, "No, keep it," then you may keep it with a clear conscience.
 
Yes. Now send me the change so I can buy some new shoes.

Hi, my name is PacificBlue and I love shoes. :D
 
Give the change back to Grandma. The damage that could be done if the true price of the shoes comes out is not worth 23 bucks.
 
You know your Grandma better than we do. What does she expect you to do?


My grandmother wouldn't expect the change back. I know that from experience. What's your experience been with your grandmother?
 
My first thought was....why wouldn't you work your butt off to give your poor granny back the $30.00?? My second thought was...where did you find shoes for 6.95??? Lastly....buy granny something nice with the change.
 
Most grandmothers would be happy to give you the $25 bucks anyway...but if mine were alive, I could never be dishonest with them. I mean, even if she never found out, come on...they're grandmothers. Their job is to be mothering, spoiling, almost mythical creatures that you revere.

Well, one of mine was rather nasty, but hopefully she's the exception & not the rule.
 
Sillyman said:
I needed new shoes. I have no money. I asked my grandmother to get me some new ones. She gave me $30 to buy shoes before she left town. I went and bought a pair for $6.95. Is it unethical of me to keep the rest of the money?

Ask her if you can keep the change.
 
Go out and buy another $23 worth of shoes. After all, you didn't specify how many pairs, did you? :)
 
If you were my grandkid and you tried to give me $23.05 after I gave you a 30, I'd drag your ass back to where ever you were and make you buy 3 more pairs so you'd be covered for new when those wore out, and then I'd make you buy some candy with the change.

I think my grandkids would learn quick that what grandma don't know, won't hurt her cause grandma only cares that you got shoes.
 
Re: Re: Is it unethical?

cg_allstar said:


I don't think it would be unethical, per say, to keep the money since she probably didn't expect to receive the money back. However, the decent thing to do would be to return the unused portion. If she says, "No, keep it," then you may keep it with a clear conscience.

Ethics are what we interpret them to be......

As for me, I'd find a way to repay Grandma the entire $30.00 back. That for me would be the ONLY thing to do.


And anyway, What kind of shoes DID YOU BUY for $6.95? FlipFlops??????

:confused:
 
It was a gift, not a business transaction..

She knew you'd find some for cheaper, and assumed you'd use the rest for what you needed. If you called her, I'd bet she say that. My Grandma used to do that before she'd leave, hand me a twenty, tell me to buy a new shirt. The average price of a shirt I'd wear would be about ten bucks, she knew that.

*Go with it. :D
 
damn.. $6.95 shoes?? Where?

I went and spent $352.00 on 4 pair of shoes today.. have to buy another 4 pairs on Wednesday..
 
jeez some of you people are harsh. when did it become unethical for a starving student to accept a little money for his or her grandmother?
 
Back
Top