Is this forgivable?

Is it forgivable?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 7 11.7%
  • No.

    Votes: 49 81.7%
  • Ubiquitous Other.

    Votes: 4 6.7%

  • Total voters
    60
It is a shame when a guy lies about things like this when STD are around everywhere who knows he may have aids
 
Is it forgivable? Yes. It's forgivable if someone slaughters your whole family and has sex with your pet goat. Now whether she has it in her to forgive him depends on her.

Forgivable is possible, where she simply takes no further retribution against him, sure. Forgettable, no. She certainly shouldn't sleep with him again, since even if she knows about the herpes, he may have God knows what else. In a broader sense, she should be wary to trust anything he says since before he put his selfish pleasure over her health, and his word can't be trusted until he can prove that her well-being comes before getting his rocks off.
 
Not even close to forgivable. You don't play around with people's health, period, full stop. I could see not telling a woman about athlete's foot, but herpes?
 
I could never do that to someone, and while I could forgive a person who did that to me, I could never trust them again. In fact, that might be a better question to ask, becuase forgivness is tied up in so many thoughts and moral questions, while trust is a little less ambiguous- still not objective, but a little less loaded a term.
 
superlittlegirl said:
What would you do if you were in her position?
I'd be on my bike.

What would you do if you were in his?
Fessed it up in the first place, though my having STD is damb near impossibility.
 
Hypothetical speaking the person who did do this, was most likely told this information..


Genital herpes is an infection caused by the herpes simplex virus (HSV). There are two types of HSV.
HSV type 1 usually infects the lips, causing cold sore but this virus can also infect the genital area.
HSV type 2 is the virus which usually causes genital herpes, but it may infect the mouth during oral sex.

A person who has genital herpes infection can easily pass or transmit the virus to an uninfected person, during sex.

Both HSV 1 and 2 can produce sores (also called lesions) in and around the vaginal area, on the penis, around the anal opening, and on the buttocks or thighs. Occasionally, sores also appear on other parts of the body where the virus has entered through broken skin. HSV remains in certain nerve cells of the body for life, and can produce symptoms, on and off, in some infected people.

Many people who have herpes, usually do not recognize the symptoms of the infection. The symptoms usually appear within 2 to 10 days of being infected. When a person is infected for the first time, the symptoms may last 2 to 3 weeks.
Early symptoms of a genital herpes outbreak include:

· itching or burning feeling in the genital or anal area.
· pain in the legs, buttocks, or genital area.
· discharge of fluid from the vagina.
· feeling of pressure in the abdomen.

Within a few days, sores appear near the mouth, penis, or vagina depending upon where the virus entered the body. Sores may be found even inside the vagina and on the cervix in women, or in the urinary passage of men and women. The lesions appear as small red bumps, which develop into blisters and become painful open sores. The sores may then become crusty and heal without leaving a scar. When a person is infected for the first time the symptoms may include fever, headache, muscle aches, painful or difficult urination, vaginal discharge, and swollen glands in the groin.

A doctor may be able to come to a diagnosis of genital herpes by physical symptoms including the culture tests or antigen tests can be done from the blister fluid to detect HIV. Laboratory tests may also be requested for. A blood test cannot reveal whether a person can infect another person with this virus. But it can show if a person has been infected at any time with HSV.
 
my question would be could you ever trust him again ..........no. what he did was so wrong. I would trust that guy again. ohh and HSV type 1(cold sores) why it can infect the genital areait can only do so if you have a cold sore at that time. just like if you have one and kiss someone thats how they get it.
 
FLAME ALERT!

My understanding of herpes is that it can only be transmitted while the sores/blisters (whatever) are active and festering or whatever it is they do (think coldsore). I believe that happens fairly rarely in an established case, couple of times per year for a few weeks each time? (Feel free to jump in with more accurate data)

If that is correct, I wouldn't be so hasty to castrate him... unless he was in the midst of an attack and porked her anyway (in which case you bring the fuel, I'll bring the zippo.)

This guy should have about what, 11 months of fester free fuck time to sling seed without changing anyone's life? When she asked if he was clean, I'm guessing he heard "are you going to give me any diseases?" and he answered no, which was accurate, if not completely honest.

Disclaimer:
He should have said "I've got herpes but you're in no danger" and let her decide how to go from there, but he may have subconsciously been protecting what he thought was potentially a great relationship from an early and unnecessary death.
 
Re: FLAME ALERT!

Saytur said:
My understanding of herpes is that it can only be transmitted while the sores/blisters (whatever) are active and festering or whatever it is they do (think coldsore). I believe that happens fairly rarely in an established case, couple of times per year for a few weeks each time? (Feel free to jump in with more accurate data)

If that is correct, I wouldn't be so hasty to castrate him... unless he was in the midst of an attack and porked her anyway (in which case you bring the fuel, I'll bring the zippo.)

This guy should have about what, 11 months of fester free fuck time to sling seed without changing anyone's life? When she asked if he was clean, I'm guessing he heard "are you going to give me any diseases?" and he answered no, which was accurate, if not completely honest.

He should have said "I've got herpes but you're in no danger" and let her decide how to go from there, but he may have subconsciously been protecting what he thought was potentially a great relationship from an early and unnecessary death.

I believe that you can transmit the virus while symptom free just priorto an outbreak. No slack for the idiot dude from me.
 
Re: FLAME ALERT!

Saytur said:
My understanding of herpes is that it can only be transmitted while the sores/blisters (whatever) are active and festering or whatever it is they do (think coldsore). I believe that happens fairly rarely in an established case, couple of times per year for a few weeks each time? (Feel free to jump in with more accurate data)

If that is correct, I wouldn't be so hasty to castrate him... unless he was in the midst of an attack and porked her anyway (in which case you bring the fuel, I'll bring the zippo.)

This guy should have about what, 11 months of fester free fuck time to sling seed without changing anyone's life? When she asked if he was clean, I'm guessing he heard "are you going to give me any diseases?" and he answered no, which was accurate, if not completely honest.

Disclaimer:
He should have said "I've got herpes but you're in no danger" and let her decide how to go from there, but he may have subconsciously been protecting what he thought was potentially a great relationship from an early and unnecessary death.

Herpes virus spreads by close direct contact.
When HSV is active, the affected person usually has sores in the genital area, from which the virus is shed. Since the virus remains in the nerve cells near the skin, after the initial infection, it may still be shed in the abscence of any visible spores. In other words, if a person has suffered from one attack of HSV infection, he may remain infectious to others even in the abscence of obvious sores.

After a person has the first infection of herpes, the virus travels to the nerves at the end of the spine where it stays inactive for a while, hidden in the nerve cells.
From time to time, the virus may become active and travel along the nerves to the skin. It usually multiplies at the same site as during the first infection, causing a recurrence of symptoms.
Small amounts of the virus may be shed at or near places of the first infection, in fluids from the mouth, penis, or vagina. Because these lesions may not always cause pain, a person may not give them much thought. But such a person can still infect a sex partner during this time.

Repeated infections of genital herpes are usually mild and last for about a week. Such infections can cause a tingling sensation or itching in the genital area, or pain in the buttocks or down the leg. These early symptoms could be painful. While no sores may be present, small blisters could appear and break into open sores that crust over and disappear.

Some people may have one or two outbreaks in a lifetime. Others may have several outbreaks a year. It is not known why the virus becomes active again from the nerve cells. Patients sometimes associate a fresh recurrence with some other incidental illness, stress, or a menstrual period. Sometimes excessive exposure to sunlight is said to cause a recurrence. As the disease becomes chronic (long standing), the duration between the relapses also gets prolonged.

If a person has early signs of a herpes outbreak or visible sores, sexual intercourse (even oral sex) should be avoided totally, until the sores have healed completely and the signs of infection have disappeared completely. Using condoms during sexual intercourse may offer protection from the virus.
 
I dont know about just before I have had cold sores before I always know I am getting them a few hours before they show up so I know not to kiss my husband and we have never had any problems.

for me the problem with the guy is the fact he lied about something so big as std something that could affect her the rest of her life.
 
Forgive him? Absolutely.

Forget about it? Hell no. Tell him to hit the bricks.

That's a pretty hefty lie. Count on it happening again
 
Re: Re: FLAME ALERT!

Carp said:
I believe that you can transmit the virus while symptom free just priorto an outbreak. No slack for the idiot dude from me.
Are you sure?

And if so, what is "just prior"?

And if it's a couple of extra days and you factor it in to my original post, and he knew with complete certainty that he could not infect her... I'm still not convinced he's really all that despicable.

Is there a doctor in the house?
 
Re: Re: Re: FLAME ALERT!

Saytur said:
Are you sure?

And if so, what is "just prior"?

And if it's a couple of extra days and you factor it in to my original post, and he knew with complete certainty that he could not infect her... I'm still not convinced he's really all that despicable.

Is there a doctor in the house?

Read above you!
 
Re: Re: Re: FLAME ALERT!

Saytur said:
Are you sure?

And if so, what is "just prior"?

And if it's a couple of extra days and you factor it in to my original post, and he knew with complete certainty that he could not infect her... I'm still not convinced he's really all that despicable.

Is there a doctor in the house?

I'm pretty sure that you can shed virus while symptom free. Hat being the case, he can never be sure that it is safe to have unprotected sex.
 
Not forgiveable - for many of the reasons already stated.

Permantly risking her health - how she will have to live the rest of her life - is not forgiveable. What's the difference between this and assault? Other than the fact that one can physically recover from being beat up. There's no recovery from herpes. She would have to live with both the emotional and physical damage for the rest of her life.
 
"If" the information Dark posted is correct, I offically join the ranks of the rest of you. Where did it come from?
 
superlittlegirl said:
What would you do if you were in her position?
Evaluate if the nice rapport and friendship survived the betrayal. He put a single episode of pleasure ahead of their relationship and her trust, and that's hard to overcome.

I have friends that have dated people with herpes, but they found out prior to sleeping together. One couple got married, one ended it. It's an individual decision, complicated by the deceit. Frankly, that would kill it for me.

What would you do if you were in his?
Take a step back and grow up. Life with herpes is not the same as life without, and he needs to fully realize this. He simply cannot lie about it any longer. Sorry, but casual sex is not in the cards after you've been infected, because the risk of transmittal is always there. Hopefully he'll learn this before he accidentally infects someone after another such lie.
 
Back
Top