It's character that we lost

celiaKitten said:
Besides, what about the good vs. bad? You can't beat the shit out of your kids or spouse and get away with it *nowadays*. I'll take that change over a rude retail clerk anyday.

BTW - where was this *old days politeness* when a drunk 50-something man punched me in the nose because his credit card was denied at a store I worked for? As has been said before - the *old days* are always deemed better, people were more polite, honorable. Bull.

Nope, you can't beat the shit out of your kids or spouse and get away with it now. So why is it so much more common now? Character maybe?

Ishmael
 
celiaKitten said:
As has been said before - the *old days* are always deemed better, people were more polite, honorable. Bull.


And exactly how do you know that the old days weren't better? Did you live during them? Experienced how the people were back then compared to how they act now since society has degraded in many ways?


(Yes I didn't live through them so you don't need to blah blah blah about how I didn't experience them either so I don't know anyway)
 
Ishmael said:


Nope, you can't beat the shit out of your kids or spouse and get away with it now. So why is it so much more common now? Character maybe?

Ishmael


Pssssst... Its not anymore common than it was then. It just gets reported more often.
 
Ishmael said:


Oh bite me Laurel. Character can remain a constant even with women voting and blacks eating at Mickey D's. One has nothing to do with the other.

Ishmael

I'll bite you.

Seriously, I doubt that today is much different. Historically humans have always had corruption. Even during the Roman Empire, and before that.

It's one thing to yell 'corruption', it's another to claim there's more today than ever before.

It's all a cycle, and you of all people should know that.

Sorry, I disagree.

Moon
 
Nope, you can't beat the shit out of your kids or spouse and get away with it now. So why is it so much more common now? Character maybe?
More common now? Where did you get that? Reportings of beatings may be up, but that's because the police can now address the problem. It used to be legal to beat your wife. The books are littered with laws describing the exact belt widths that could be used to beat a woman, and how much of her body could be covered in bruises before the beating was considered excessive. This practice dates to pre-1963, your benchmark for the decline of character in our society.
 
Jeebus, here we go again.....

I get so fuckiing amused when a subject is raised, and someone interjects their fucking crusade agenda of reminding everyone of the miniscule issues 100 or 1000 years ago. Give it a rest!
So it was a certain way in the past, so what's the present excuse why people have no sense of honor, and in turn character? I live by my word, I say something and I stand by it (ask my ex). I often get ambushed by the shysters in life, and am disappointed, but still stick to whatever agreement I had with them, that is honor.
In the military where they instill the character and sense of "Duty, Honor, Country", they have a saying. It's, "Character is doing the right thing when no one is looking".
We have the government(s) we deserve. By not voting out the 2/3rds of felons in DC, we give them a green light to continue their treason, and corruption. By not voting in strength, they know they can manipulate the majority with a mandate from the fringe minority. (35%)
So, if you don't get involved, don't bitch being part of the herd, and if character doesn't begin with you, how can you expect it in others?

*"What we do in life, echoes in eternity." *Gladiator :D
 
Mischka said:
Perhaps because I was born in the midst of this downgrade of civilization, I cannot appreciate the differences you've noticed. I still get complete service from my auto repairmen (my oil change shop is amazing); ...

It's a shame that such an article rings true for you and Ishmael. It sounds so terribly pessimistic, and I cannot even begin to empathize with such a view.

I've noticed the "generation gap" in other discussions about manners, education, andpersonal responsibility. It is hard to imagine how manners and customs change over time without experiencing the changes firsthand.

Perhaps I'm spoiled about auto-repair service -- my father was the prototype for Mr. Goodwrench (A program I notice that GM has pretty much abandoned.) His attitude was "if the customer complained, then there is something that needs fixing." The place I take my car is better than most, but their attitude is "if I can't find it, it doesn't exist."

Mischka said:
That's my point. Every age is riddled with problems, and to point to today as the worst example of humanity is myopic.

Ignoring today's problems just because every other age had similar problems is just as myopic. Change is not always good, and new ways are not always bad.

Despite the loss of manners and personal responsibility I see in today's society, I still wouldn't want to relive the fifties or sixties. There is a LOT that is better today than it was then -- manners, honor, and personal responsibility just aren't a part of what's good today.
 
Ishmael said:


Nope, you can't beat the shit out of your kids or spouse and get away with it now. So why is it so much more common now? Character maybe?

Ishmael

It's more *common* now because it's actually reported. There are stats on it, since it's not legal, nor socially acceptable. That violence was always there - it was just accepted as *right*. You could beat your wife and your kids, and no one thought anything of it in this *Golden Era* you mention. It's different now. These events are actually reported, so it isn't hidden anymore, it's talked about and you have statistics. That wasn't possible *then*.
 
Re: Jeebus, here we go again.....

Lost Cause said:
I get so fuckiing amused when a subject is raised, and someone interjects their fucking crusade agenda of reminding everyone of the miniscule issues 100 or 1000 years ago. Give it a rest!
So it was a certain way in the past, so what's the present excuse why people have no sense of honor, and in turn character? I live by my word, I say something and I stand by it (ask my ex). I often get ambushed by the shysters in life, and am disappointed, but still stick to whatever agreement I had with them, that is honor.
In the military where they instill the character and sense of "Duty, Honor, Country", they have a saying. It's, "Character is doing the right thing when no one is looking".
We have the government(s) we deserve. By not voting out the 2/3rds of felons in DC, we give them a green light to continue their treason, and corruption. By not voting in strength, they know they can manipulate the majority with a mandate from the fringe minority. (35%)
So, if you don't get involved, don't bitch being part of the herd, and if character doesn't begin with you, how can you expect it in others?

Holy duck shit, LC. I agree with you completely.
 
Weird Harold said:
Ignoring today's problems just because every other age had similar problems is just as myopic. Change is not always good, and new ways are not always bad.
I didn't mean to sound like I was ignoring today's problems. I fully recognize that the current crop of corporate scandals is not to be taken lightly. I just tire of hearing how today is the worst time in the history of mankind. I read a quote a while ago, lamenting the insolence and disintegrating moral fiber of the day's youth. It was written by a Greek philosopher, over two thousand years ago. Some things never change. ;)
 
Holy duck shit!!!!

You agree with meee.???.......aaaarrrrgggg (grasping heart, looking frantically for the nitro pills, or a defib machine)

*Seriously, thanx! :D :rose:
 
Re: Holy duck shit!!!!

Lost Cause said:
You agree with meee.???.......aaaarrrrgggg (grasping heart, looking frantically for the nitro pills, or a defib machine)

*Seriously, thanx! :D :rose:

lol - you're no more shocked than I was. I usually read your posts preparing to expect the worst. Our thoughts don't seem to match up, usually.

But, there's always the rare exceptions:rose:
 
Ishmael said:


My time frame is approximately the same as WH's.

I graduated HS in '63.

Ishmael

PS. Wh and myself have observed the same events as far as character I think.

While I'm a little younger than you and WH, I have a female perspective. I was young in the 60's, and was a teenager in the 70's. (I graduaded in 1975)

Women are taught differently now, we weren't taught to build 'character'. We were supposed to be a door mat. A joke a HS teacher said during a class still stands out in my mind.

"A male goes to college to get their Master's degree, a woman goes to get her Mrs. degree."

We were supposed to live in the shadow of a male. I don't call that character. Perhaps that is why so many females are attacking your stance here, including Laurel.

You have your points, I will admit, but it's still just a cycle in my opinion.

Moon
 
celiaKitten said:
BTW - where was this *old days politeness* when a drunk 50-something man punched me in the nose because his credit card was denied at a store I worked for?

Some people change with the times. Others, like me, still hold doors for women even though we've been cursed for being sexist when we do.

Re: child and spouse abuse

The definitions of what constitutes "abuse" have changed over the years as well as the reporting of abuse.

Mishka mentioned laws detailing specifics on what constuted abuse in the "bad old days." That may seem barbaric by today's standards, but it was the first step in banishing spouse abuse. I'm sure they were denounced as being liberal and excessively lenient when they were passed, just as there are people who object to being jailed for swatting their kids behinds in public.

Changes in what is considered "acceptable" methods for disciplining children have paralleled the decline in manners. Corporal punishment might be abhorant to many people today, but it was effective when allowed.

I'm definitely NOT advocating a return to the "good old days" when fathers took their children "behind the woodshed" where the screams of pain wouldn't bother other family members, but I do feel that today's standards are far too restrictive with regards to the distinction between discipline and abuse.
 
Re: Re: Jeebus, here we go again.....

celiaKitten said:


Holy duck shit, LC. I agree with you completely.

My gawd. So do I.....what a wierd feeling.
 
There are still some young people who were taught and are being taught manners and politeness. Hell I was spanked and occassionaly smacked as a child and it didn't hurt me in any real long-lasting way. I tell ya, a few swats on the ass does alot to build character.
 
I agree with some of your points, WH. I was one that my father 'took to the woodshed' except he didn't bother to take me anywhere. He just wailed that leather belt where ever I happened to be at the time, in front of family or friends. Very humiliating.

The problem today is, parents are not disiplining their children, cause they are too busy being selfish. I disiplined my son, but I didn't wale into him at the slightest infraction. I probably 'spanked' him 5 times in his young life. I mostly sent him to his room and calmed down, then called a meeting. I didn't have to lay down corporal punishment.

The point was, I was consistent. Most parents aren't They need parenting lessons, cause for some reason the instincts have been damaged.

This comes from to much domesticating by societies 'rules'. I don't know if you believe in your own 'instincts' but I believe in mine.

Moon
 
Weird Harold said:


Some people change with the times. Others, like me, still hold doors for women even though we've been cursed for being sexist when we do.

I hold open doors for men and women, older or younger. It's just polite to do. Admonishing someone for being sexist in doing that is ridiculous! I'm sorry you've had that experience. More of my point was that some reared in the *Golden Era* lack as much character as anything that's been cited in this thread. It's a never ending cycle. Things change and the generations before don't always like the changes, and it becomes a general complaint. A man punching a woman in the nose in public doesn't strike me as having good character.

I'm definitely NOT advocating a return to the "good old days" when fathers took their children "behind the woodshed" where the screams of pain wouldn't bother other family members, but I do feel that today's standards are far too restrictive with regards to the distinction between discipline and abuse.

*What follows is my own opinion - not meaning to turn this into a different debate*

My .02: If you have to use anything more than your hand to discipline your child, then you have issues. You shouldn't have to leave marks on a child to discipline them. Spanking is all well and effective. Welts and scars are nothing more than a sign of a weak parent. Some people manage to turn out just fine when given this kind of treatment by their parents. The plain fact is: not all parents adequately communicate with their children to make a severe physical punishment effective. It just scares the shit out of the child, makes them hide away from their parent emotionally. That is not a positive result. To say that juvinile delinquancy is caused by the lack of corpral punishment assumes a lot. There are far more factors affecting it.
 
MoonWolf said:


While I'm a little younger than you and WH, I have a female perspective. I was young in the 60's, and was a teenager in the 70's. (I graduaded in 1975)
...
We were supposed to live in the shadow of a male. I don't call that character. Perhaps that is why so many females are attacking your stance here, including Laurel.

You have your points, I will admit, but it's still just a cycle in my opinion.

You make a very good point about gender differences in the past, however the joke your HS teacher told was "old news" even in the sixties when that attititude started being broken. (Maybe even earlier when women went to work during WWII.)

There is one aspect of the "cycle" argument that seems to be ignored here -- when manners, honor, and personal responsibility have shown a marked decline in the past, as in the latter days of Rome and the Greeks, or the last days of the French Aristocracy, they have always preceded a "collapse of civilization" of some degree.

Manners and Morals declined in the "Roaring 20's" and sere followed by a stricter morality during the Great Depression -- just as one example that seems relevant to today's corporate scandals.

Those of us who complain about today's society do so as much to warn of the consquences that history has shown, time and again, follow such a turn in society as we do to bemoan the "golden age" of our youth.
 
Very good points, Moon. Consistency is the key. Even parents who spank can be inconsistent. The important thing in using physical punishment is that you need to make sure that it is a consequence rather than an outlet for your own anger. That is where abuse begins. My mother spanked us with sticks we had to choose from the yard. This gave her time to cool down, and by the time we returned with the sticks, she only had to tap us and we thought it hurt! But the most useful tool in my mother's arsenal was her disapproving look. I would rather get spanked than have that look.

I think that parents today are too busy being their kids' friends. I am a teacher, and I see so many kids who have no respect for their parents. It is sad.
 
First of all, dishonest business and government has been with us a long time. We've already had this argument, and there is no need to go back to it.

The article attempts to show the innocence of the corporate state by redirecting attention to the media and the government. This is intresting. Who owns the majority of the world's media? Corporations. Who donates most of the money for political campaigns? Corporations. Who do we have primarily seated in office? Corporate officers and investors. Politics is a rich man's game, and one of the few ways to be rich enough to even consider running is to be a serious investor of some sort. So really, we are talking about the same people here.

The article also mentions that it was the current accounting principles that allowed for the slip in the first place, and that new rules would only cause futher problems. I fail to see the logic behind this. If providing a the legal loophole allowed them to get away with it, surely making a new law to close the loophole would prevent it right?

Another thing is that honor and character are ultimately very personal things. Their are men who would lynch someone without a tear of remorse who consider themselves honorable men.
 
celiaKitten said:
A man punching a woman in the nose in public doesn't strike me as having good character.
...
My .02: If you have to use anything more than your hand to discipline your child, then you have issues. You shouldn't have to leave marks on a child to discipline them. ...To say that juvinile delinquancy is caused by the lack of corpral punishment assumes a lot. There are far more factors affecting it.

A man punching ANYONE for something that is HIS fault is a sign of poor character. There have been people like that in every age, and their existance doesn't say anything about the general state of moral character in a society. The fact that other customers didn't leap to you defence just might provide some clue, although a single incident can't define a society as good or bad.

I agree completely with your views on spanking, however, I have (personally) seen 911 called on a mother for a single swat to a child's bottom in a store because the child ignored her when told not to touch stuff -- That's what I mean about today's standards being too restrictive. My Ex-wife is scared to even reprimand her daughter in public because of "do-gooders" who think telling a child "no" will warp the child for life.

There are, without doubt, well mannered, responsible people abroad in the world today. I just find them harder to pick out of the crowd than in the past.

soliloquy:
Very good points, Moon. Consistency is the key. Even parents who spank can be inconsistent.

Some parents don't understand the concept of, "never make an idle threat to a child." Consistency is very important, but so is fairness.

There are many factors in the decline of personal morality -- poor parenting is high on the list, but it isn't the whole reason or even a really significant percentage of the whole.

The decline in personal honor, personal responsibility, and good manners are simply symptoms of problems that are afflicting society.
 
There are many factors in the decline of personal morality -- poor parenting is high on the list, but it isn't the whole reason or even a really significant percentage of the whole.

Quite right...I could list a thousand off of the top of my head. Poor parenting, poor teachers, media influence, and on they go...

So, the question is...if we see some of the problems, where are the solutions?
 
Yes, you are right about the joke from my teacher being 'old news'. A very good point that strengthens my point.

I don't have a problem with complaining about the wrongs of society, but to claim this is the first time, or worse than any other is narcissistic. It's right to stand up for injustices, otherwise they would never bring about change. Change is good, for the most part, though painful in the process.

I complain about wrongs too, though maybe not as loudly as others on this board. I read most political threads, even if I don't have an opinion formed yet. I have actually learned alot from here, and I appreciate that.

Thank you for your comments.

Moon
 
soliloquy said:
So, the question is...if we see some of the problems, where are the solutions?


My pet solution is education reform.

There's a rather long thread back in the depths of the board where MorningGirl5 and I discussed what's wrong with education and how to fix it.

My logic is that School is a point that everyone has in common, and changes there affect everyone approximately equally. It's also everyone's first "job" and shapes people's expectations of what a "boss" and "co-workers" should expect of them. That's an over-simplification, but reasonable for the short-form explanation.
 
Back
Top