Keystone -Make a decision

I don't think anyone is claiming that the pipeline, per se, is going to effect the environment, although some have raised the prospect of nasty spillage in case of a breach. The environmental argument is that building the pipeline would enable more exploitation of the tar sands, which is I arguably bad for the environment.

I think the nasty spillage over a major aquifer should be counted as environmental damage. The pipeline itself is of course mostly harmless but it's kinda one big issue.
 
I think the nasty spillage over a major aquifer should be counted as environmental damage. The pipeline itself is of course mostly harmless but it's kinda one big issue.

spillage and what other issues?
 
I think the nasty spillage over a major aquifer should be counted as environmental damage. The pipeline itself is of course mostly harmless but it's kinda one big issue.

On the other hand, folks in Lac Megantic are thinking that shipping crude oil by train isn't such a great idea, either.
 
I assume the other issues are dealing with the impact of building and maintaining the pipeline. It's constantly being compared to rail.

Energy security, isnt one issue the President is considering I guess...
 
True for volume per mile transported. But a railway is multi purpose. I'd like to see you ship lumber and tourists via pipeline. :cool:

truck and train, both more carbon-intensive means of transport.
 
You're joking right? We're about as energy secure as we're going to be until we go 100% renewable.

If increasing supplies of Canadian oil will reduce U.S. dependence on potentially unstable and unreliable sources such as Venezuela, Saudi Arabia, and Nigeria, I'm all for it....and create a few jobs here and there, stimuate growth along the way, create more "Mo", what is wrong with that?? If Obama passed this, it would be a huge win for his Presidency...
 
As far as the Refinery , good question.

you do know the carbon foot print is larger for railways than a pipeline.

The reason on the Refinery thing is there hasn't been a new one built in North America for over 20 years.

The refining of Oil products is the only place nobody makes any money, and they cost $20+billion to build.

As a Canadian, I say fuckit and we will build our Northern Gateway and sell our oil to asia. A little known aspect of Canadian Oil & Nat gas exports to the US, is it was the primary driver on the US side of the Canada/Us Free trade agreement in the 80's. We got access to the US market for our goods and services and the US got priority access to our Oil and gas.
 
The reason on the Refinery thing is there hasn't been a new one built in North America for over 20 years.

The refining of Oil products is the only place nobody makes any money, and they cost $20+billion to build.

As a Canadian, I say fuckit and we will build our Northern Gateway and sell our oil to asia. A little known aspect of Canadian Oil & Nat gas exports to the US, is it was the primary driver on the US side of the Canada/Us Free trade agreement in the 80's. We got access to the US market for our goods and services and the US got priority access to our Oil and gas.

Even if approved, you'll probably do that anyway....or we will
 
I don't think anyone is claiming that the pipeline, per se, is going to effect the environment, although some have raised the prospect of nasty spillage in case of a breach. The environmental argument is that building the pipeline would enable more exploitation of the tar sands, which is I arguably bad for the environment.

Yes because it's like the only pipeline in the Continental US...clearly unproven technology:eek::eek:

Oilsand products do produce more Carbon Dioxide that traditional light sweet crude, but not more than the heavy oil produced in Mexico and Venezuela.

Even with the most energy intensive Oilsand production, 88% of the Carbon is produced when it comes out the tailpipe of the car in Florida, vs 92% on the "cleanest" light sweet Saudi crude.
 
The pipeline won't effect the environment. It's scary there are people stupid enough to believe that.

I don't think anyone is claiming that the pipeline, per se, is going to effect the environment, although some have raised the prospect of nasty spillage in case of a breach. The environmental argument is that building the pipeline would enable more exploitation of the tar sands, which is I arguably bad for the environment.

Last first. The tar sands are going to be exploited no matter what so from the standpoint of any discussion in the US, it's a non-issue.

Modern pipeline design minimizes any spillage that might occur due to a breach. Not only are large spills bad for the environment and PR, it's just bad business to allow that much product to go to waste. A pipeline is not just one big tube connecting point A to point B. They are built in sections with shunt stations every so many 1000's of feet. In the event of a breach there is a pressure drop in the broken section and the shunt stations to either side of the breach automatically shut down restricting the spillage to only that product contained in the breached section.

If you're going to transport petroleum pipelines have the safest record by far.

Ishmael
 
Back
Top