martial arts

modest mouse said:
I am bookmarking this thread as "Do Not Fuck With The Following...."

lol, Yeah, but if they have "Karate Do" you should be ok modest mouse.
 
I can not come out and say which art I think is better than the other. I have studied the kicking arts and grappling arts and find the judo is best suited for my personality and body type. Then there is the new argument that all fights end up on the ground anyhow. I am not so sure all street altercations end up on the ground, but the last one I was in did and the judo prevailed.
The argument us ground guys have is this; If there is enought distance between us and the only way for you to hit me is by lunging or kicking then we don't have a fight. If you are within my reach it is difficult for you to kick me, but I can get ahold of you and throw or grapple as necessary. I prefer to avoid myself and only fight in sanctioned tournaments in the area. When a little guy like Royce Gracie can dominate like he did early. It shows technique is the key, not strength or who can kick higher. Technique and execution wins matches. I am glad to see so many people particiapte in this topic I thought I was alone!


Does anybody get into the spiritual (zen) side of the arts. I am curious to learn more. Perhaps you can recomend a reading to me.
 
Spiritual Study

I've done quite a bit of spiritual and awareness training. Honestly, I can never quiet my mind enough for the meditation to go anywhere.

Other than simple meditation and training to "sense intent", almost every single Aikido technique has some sort of spiritual signifigance. All of the techniques are supposed to evolve into a perfect sphere, because the founder Ueshiba(I'm not sure if that's right on the spelling) believed that all movement could be defined within a perfect sphere.
 
for the pasr several years i have practised the art of wu-shu, shotokan karate, and samuri jui-jitsu, as well as tai chi. wonderful stuff to keep the mind and body in balance;)
 
Hung-Gar Kung fu, we used to challenge other schools to friendly, full contact, east prey. However I am quite proficient in the art of Ching-Ching Bang, the way of the .45 Automatic, which is superior to all other forms of martial arts. Kiyyaaaiiiii....Boom!:D
 
Yeah, yeah I own a gun too and have a ccw.
This is my opinion. For those that thing carrying a gun will help
defend themselves and family are only half right.

Just because you carry and go to a range and practice hitting a target every 3-4 secornds does not mean you are proficient enough to pull it from under your coat and use it when confronted. Chances are many people do not practice drawing their gun from under their coats. The person that studies the arts does practice those moves daily in training.
It is my opinion that the person that can defend themselves with mind and body can react faster than the average ccw carrying cowboy. you tell me how fast you can draw a gun if somebody puts one to your back and asks for your wallet? My guess is by the time you do that you have a round in you! I bet the trained person can perhaps disarm that mugger faster than you can draw. UNLESS you practice drawing daily!

Just my opinion. train your body and mind to react. carrying does not defend you as much as some novice ccw people think.
 
Many threads of thought

Boxing is not to be poo-poo'ed, it is wonderful training whose liniage (sp?) is actually older than modern karate. I have used it's principles in the ring doing kick-boxing, as a point fighter, and as a bouncer. However, it's rules limit it in many situations.

I have played around with Judo and Akido, but most of my grappling comes from high school wrestling and that coupled with the locks and takedowns of Okinawan systems and some Chin-na is sufficient for my needs, I do not like going to the ground.

Now I know there is a school of thought that says all fights go to the ground, but I feel that that is if you choose it. After many years of being a doorman, working concert security, personal security, and crowd control, I will tell you this: You are aways out-numbered, and if you put your hands on someone and tie up, it only creates openings for allies who while may be cowed in a 0ne on one situation, will always be emboldened if they can get a free shot from tha backside.

Jim Harrison would put it this way, "You might be up in the biggest emptiest field in Montana, but as soon as you get the better of your opponent and put your hands on him, some gopher is going to come up out of the ground and bite you on the ass."

As far as handguns and swords go, I practice some two-man bokken sets as well as bo-bo, bo-sai, bo-tunfa, and bo-tinbe. I have a chinese mind when it comes to knowing weapons, and as Musashi would say, "Know thw ways of all proffessions." To wit, I have been shooting since the Marine Corps {qualified espert) and continue to practice shooting at least once a month if not more.

And finally, zazen is very important in my life, but I prefer the moving meditation of forms practice verses the seated, but I still do it. It aids in the calm neccessary to be successful in small-scale interpersonal combat.

Whew!
 
arts

Your cross training is admirable! I agree with you, the ground is not the best place to be if can be avoided.

I get so worked up when I hear about people wanting to protect their families by carrying a gun. Many of them have no clue what that entails. they think oh, confrontation I'll pull. Bull!
 
I think the point is not the individual carrting the gun for protection, but the perp having doubt that the vic may be packing since they are usually morally weak cowards looking for victims.

Usually a confident walk, awareness of the surroundings, etc., are all that are needed.

But I keep a loaded weapon by my bed at night.
 
MARTIAL ARTS

I do subscribe to the theory a carrying society is a polite one. Unfortunately the ccw laws favor the crook! In Michigan as of July the ccw holder cannot carry in the following:
sporting events (if thats what u call the Lions)
ANY place liquor is served
financial institutions

Get the drift? so if we are prevented from carrying where a crook will because he can careless about laws. We need to learn how to defend our bodies or risk being taken advantage of.
 
Muggins usually do not occur in sporting venues, unless you count the way the replay officials mugged the Lions on Thanksgiving.

In crowd situations, there are people to handle security, similarly at financial institutions.

Hence, it is a reasonable restriction. Conceal and carry works for the business person making the night drop.
 
ARTS

Sodomy is what us season ticket holders are used to when it comes to the Lions!

I am not so sure I want to depend on security personnel at a venue or bank. There have been some high profile cases here in the Detroit area recenlty involvong guards. At two different shopping malls guards pursued and apprehended a theif. This led to an altercation in which the theif died because of the struggle. Both are in litigation and the plaintiffs are trying to prove the guards used techniques to disarm the theif that ulitmately killed them. Many of these guards are untrained and paid low wages to do this kind of work, hence you get unqualified people. Perhaps had they been trained in CDT or one an art of choice they could have disarmed the guy without this outcome. On the otherside you can argue what they did do may have prevented their own death. either way training your mind and body to react is what we should focus on.

jean, you make valid points my friend. wish I could train with you.
 
In Mexico

[there for competition]

You go into the bank one person at a time and they have two guards with machine guns pointed at you and the tellers are behind thick bullet-proof (I assume, who knows, maybe it wasn't made in America) glass.

Glad I live in a small, rural community when you start talking about things like that.
 
Jean Val Jean-- I'm sure if you noticied it, but Greco-Roman wrestling is a very effective art for getting the better of your opponent in a grapple. The people that invented the style were brilliant, and if the society of the time would have been a bit different, it might have evolved into a style that incorporated a spiritual side as well.

One thing about fighting a group. All of the training that I do starts out as one person, but we are pretty much required to take in our surroundings as well. It's not always a good idea to tie someone up with a move, but it can be useful. Usually though, you'll be better of throwing your hapless victim into his other attacking friends. We also learn ways to do moves that won't get you in trouble with the police. Several martial arts are illegal to use in most instances if your rank is high enough. My teacher isn't allowed, by law, to raise his hands above his waist unless he is being attacked by at least 5(?) unarmed people, 3 people using knives, or one person with a gun. Yeah...bullets move faster than people.

But several techniques in many different arts are illegal to even teach in the US. A good example is how to get out of the default police hold--with your arm behind your back and pressed up against a wall (or car).

Most higher ranking tests involve being able to deal with multiple attackers. It's not uncommon for a Tai Chi or Aikido practitioner to be able to stop any amount of people coming at them. You can only have so many people in an area surrouding a person. Of course, we're leaving out the idea of guns in this equation. But I wanted to point out that someone that has trained quite a bit would have no problem with several people coming at them.

Personally...I've been able to handle 3 people at once, but I think I got really lucky. :)
 
All styles are good styles. There are good teachers and bad in each. There are good students and bad in each. A good student can learn a lot from a bad teacher.

In our school, a black belt candidate has to be able to survive the full assault of multiple black belt attackers (many times from other schools and styles). There are tricks.

But in RL, when working against numbers, when you have 30-45 on the main floor and there are 20,000 in the venue...

Well then if they want the stage, then they take the stage.

Even as a bouncer in a small club, you cannot piss off a significant fraction and survive...

But here at Lit ;)
 
Working against numbers is right!

I mean, even if I KNEW exactly how many people I could handle at once in a riot situation...I'm not going to be able to do the math as the rush over me in a fleshy tide :)
 
Manning the barricades for example,
20,000 people in the venue, 8,000 on the floor (more by the end of the show). 15 us us spread across the front in the pit, 2 more on each flank checking passes, maybe 8 more on the floor controlling access, and about 20 more scattered about the venue in great positions to run like hell!

Just ask Axel Rose, If they decide they want the venue, it is thiers!


So that's 1333 more or less that you have to control to hold your own. I don't think Bruce had to fight that many in Enter the Dragon.

That's why the number one rule of self-defense in a crowd-control situation is BE NICE!
 
1st dan in TKD, starting Jukido-JuJitsu a few months ago.

I also shoot handgun on a semi-regular basis, usualy a S&W revolver in .38 or a glock subcompact 9mm.

Also into edged, impact and flexible weapons.

I have to say I only consider my Black Belt a highschool diploma. It means I have got the basics to really start learning and to ask the right questions of future teachers.
 
Western

I fence foil. I'm competeing in an E event on Sunday. Twice a week I get to be Porthos.
 
FORMER WRESTLER

Compeated in High School. I enjoy MMA videos and have over 80 different tapes. PRIDE, UFC, and Brazillian Vale Tudo rock!
 
Yes. like a high school diploma, that is how I regard. The point at which someone has a grasp of the basics and you can begin to teach.

Would like to see a mixed match tournament. Broadsword vs. Katana. Katana vs. foil. Foil vs. Esplana y daga. Maybe even some bo and staff, sai vs. katana...

uhhh.., pd, maybe time to diversify a little?

The maddest I've ever seen Jim Harrison is when he gets on his kick about how he could whip all those UFC pussies but they wouldn't let him because he was too old. Man he starts spitting and looking around, and you have to back up because you know he's looking for someone to hit...

But really, I wrestled too. It is a good starting point.
 
I agree the blackbelt is the beginning to the learning period. Master of the basics. I study judo and a first dan blackbelt is a Shodan, not ichidan. Althought ich does translate to number one. Sho translates to learning I believe.

The non martial arts community though has this imprssion of blackbelts that is misleading. They feel that if you attain that you are some sort of invincible bad ass that can bust up anybody in your way. Far from the truth in my book. I can still b whooped on any given day and I know it!!

Can't wait to begin Aikido. What a beautiful art!!
 
You've been away so long that I've changed my name since we last talked. [hint, 24601]. I've done a little akido, but the gentle way did not suit my nature.

Now if you have a black belt under Jim Harrison, you will be in the mold of the public perception. A BAD ASS!

One Korean once told one of his instructors (who told it to me), A black belt is like a high school diploma. 10% will be very good, 10% will be very bad, everyone else will be average, but everyone should be able to get one. On the other hand, I know one teacher of Okinawan Kempo who believes in keeping people brown belt for at least seven years so he can get the teaching time out of them since so many people quit once they attain thier black belt.

The latter is a pet peeve of mine because of all the people who get a black belt and then stop training seriously, but still like to throw it in that they are a black belt. And the worst ones [ClosetDesire comes to mind] who have somehow attained "master's ranking" but have done no training over the years other than exchanging Xmas cards with and paying annual fees to thier "Grandmaster," yet still like to be "the expert" in all things martial. Makes me want to retch.
 
arts

I agree with folks that attain not just shodan, but say even Godan 5th dan that don't train. there is a guy around my town that claims to be a 6thdan. I have never seen this person in a gi or on the mat. Been to tournaments though and all he does is bark!! Could not tell you what he is capable of.
That is a shame because he sould be sharing his knowledge in a positive way.
 
Back
Top