NC passes Admendment 1

No, Fuck you, Blacks DON'T HATE GAYS.

Go get your buddy JAMESBPIECEOFSHIT and tell me more about what how much you know about black people think, BUDDY.

I'll tell you some fucking stories that will really drive you nuts.

Youre fulla shit. If youre black, and yo momma is queer, you wont invite her to your wedding.
 
BTW, you didn't address my questions, which is par for the course.

I answered your significant question. The law changes to reflect--and address--society's conflicts. Constitutional law usually changes slowly, which is good. Stare decisis and precedent are important.

Your other quips are silly. No, the 14th amendment does not explicitly mention sexual preference. Show me where, though, it mentions race, color, religion or gender. Instead, the Court engages in--as Rob correctly pointed out--protected class analysis.

Your coprophilia question is sillier. Can your wife give you blow job in the booth at your nearby Big Boy's during the lunch hour? Can that restaurant legally serve you beef that has been kept at room temperature overnight?
 
Last edited:
Blacks hate gays....that drives me nuts. Black preachers, working real hard to kill the gay marriage bill here

According to NewSmax, admittedly not the best of sources:
April 2008: 67% of African Americans opposed gay marriage
April 2012: 49% of African Americans opposed gay marriage

I agree with you about black preachers though, they seem as bound and determined to kill gay marriage bills as their white brethren.
 
"out of context"?

You asked for where, I showed you where, you didn't like the answer I gave, so now I'm somehow "out of context"?

sort of like my pointing out that the 14th amendment's scope is not limited to protecting the rights of black men.

you provide an answer he does not like and somehow that makes it irrelevant.
 
Youre fulla shit. If youre black, and yo momma is queer, you wont invite her to your wedding.

You know fuck all about black people, you obsolete piece of shit.

Go sit your grandpa ass back down on the toilet for the fifth time today passing your prune breakfast and re-read your fucking Chester Himes novels while you try to squeeze a runny log of intelligence from your brain canal.
 
Bullshit! The original intent of the 14th was to protect the rights of black Americans, of that there is no doubt.

To what ridiculous extent the SCOTUS has expanded the meaning of the 14th up until now and into the future is the question. I know full well that you believe in the notion of judicial supremacy and approve of the Court amending the Constitution from the bench. After all it negates the pesky need for real amendments, destroys original intent, and places the law of the land in continuous flux, its meaning always "to be determined" by an imperial judiciary.

do you contend that the original intent was to limit the scope of 14th amendment's application to black Americans?
 
Yes, but would you support such a protected class under the 14th? That was the question. I mean, where does it end?

the Court is really stingy in recognizing protected classes.

i'm simplifying, but think of immutable traits: race, gender, etc. rob pointed out a test earlier that focuses on that distinction.
 
Why is it that "original intent" is a valid argument for the 14th, while "exact words" are all that matter for the 2nd?
 
I love how vette thinks we should assume the writers of the 14th Amendment were too stupid to write what they meant instead of what they actually wrote.
 
Are you going to contend the authors were contemplating protection for gay marriage? Just askin'.:D

i contend that the intent was to afford "any person" equal protection and due process under state law.

i think sexual preference is sufficiently immutable to merit protection.
 
Pretty much. Is there such a thing as someone who's consistent across the board in his political philosophy?

i think so. maybe not absolutely, but largely.

that's one reason i like the aclu so. they are pretty consistent, even if it pisses allies off.

they lost a lot of donors representing the nazis in skokie.

i think supreme court justices tend to be consistent over the short haul, though their temperament may shift over the long haul.
 
I love how vette thinks we should assume the writers of the 14th Amendment were too stupid to write what they meant instead of what they actually wrote.

Except for the 2nd amendment. Well, most of it, anyway. That stuff about militias was, like, a typo or something.
 
Are you going to contend the authors were contemplating protection for gay marriage? Just askin'.:D

so, the 14th amendment--originally intended to protect only black persons?
 
i think so. maybe not absolutely, but largely.

that's one reason i like the aclu so. they are pretty consistent, even if it pisses allies off.

they lost a lot of donors representing the nazis in skokie.

i think supreme court justices tend to be consistent over the short haul, though their temperament may shift over the long haul.

The aclu is a great example.

I remember having an argument with a bunch of SF guys about how the speech rights of NAMBLA were just as protected as anyone else's. "I don't give a fuck about the Constitution or anything else, those sick fucks should be shut up permanently." This, from a guy who swore an oath to serve the Constitution and trained his ass off to earn a green beret...
 
The aclu is a great example.

I remember having an argument with a bunch of SF guys about how the speech rights of NAMBLA were just as protected as anyone else's. "I don't give a fuck about the Constitution or anything else, those sick fucks should be shut up permanently." This, from a guy who swore an oath to serve the Constitution and trained his ass off to earn a green beret...

yeah, a lot of people have a tough time with the idea that standing up for a right to think and speak is not the same thing as vouching for the thoughts and speech.
 
Back
Top