NC passes Admendment 1

31% is huge to you? Especially when only 14% feel strongly about it?


http://www.people-press.org/files/2012/04/4-25-12-7.png

Get a clue sparky. Every, and I mean EVERY, article I've read today quotes poll that state that Americans are evenly divided on the issue. Yet every time it's been put to the voters the results are a 20+ pt. spread. The closest vote was in Oregon and that was a 16 pt. spread.

There is no other conclusion one can reach other than the polls are shit on this issue. So take your poll and shove it, it's meaningless.

Ishmael
 
You keep putting the subject of women in my mouth. You brought it up in one of your famous deflections. Remember?

you're the one who tried to argue that the 14th amendment's purpose is to protect black citizens and who keeps suggesting that applying it to "any person" other than a black citizen is judicial activism.

my point is that that the due process and equal protection clauses are not so limited.
 
Big percentages of Blacks and Hispanics voted for Prop 8 in California.

Blacks hate gays....that drives me nuts. Black preachers, working real hard to kill the gay marriage bill here
 
Until Heller, gun rights were the subjects of votes all over the country. This is a free country, of the people, for the people, and by the people. Nothing happens in a democracy without a vote.

Under Hitler, trade unions were banned, and gays were rounded up...

Sounds like your utopia.
 
If it's a fundamental right, why is it an issue? Why did the President say it's a state issue, if it's a right? Why is the law of the land DOMA, and when did DOMA get overturned by the SCOTUS? Where does the 14th Amendment say anything about sexual preference? When coprophiliacs claim a 14th Amendment right to have their favorite entree included on the menu of your favorite restaurant, will you say it's covered too?

The 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments are known as the Civil War Amendments.

you know what, vette, as hard as it is for you to grapple with, society changes and so does the law. even constitutional law.

at one point, some crusty bastard made just the argument that you're making now about married women owning property, another one made it about jews moving into exclusive neighborhoods, and yet another made it about a black man marrying a white woman.

in each of those cases, prejudice and hate and tradition made it easy to pretend the law afforded the married woman, the jew, and the interracial couple no rights under the 14th amendment.

and in each of those cases, people first and then the courts recognized rights were being denied.

my guess is that if the states drag their feet, courts will recognize that gays have a constitutional right to marry. may be a while. but i bet it will happen.
 
you know what, vette, as hard as it is for you to grapple with, society changes and so does the law. even constitutional law.

at one point, some crusty bastard made just the argument that you're making now about married women owning property, another one made it about jews moving into exclusive neighborhoods, and yet another made it about a black man marrying a white woman.

in each of those cases, prejudice and hate and tradition made it easy to pretend the law afforded the married woman, the jew, and the interracial couple no rights under the 14th amendment.

and in each of those cases, people first and then the courts recognized rights were being denied.

my guess is that if the states drag their feet, courts will recognize that gays have a constitutional right to marry. may be a while. but i bet it will happen.

So now your saying it's alright for the courts to go against the well of the people?
in that case where does the courts stop?
 
So now your saying it's alright for the courts to go against the well of the people?
in that case where does the courts stop?

no.

the court's proper role is to be a rubber stamp.

in the united states, there are never tyrants and there are never lynch mobs.

there are never unpopular rights to uphold.

no siree.

in the united states, courts should be cheerleaders encouraging the people to do whatever they want to do, so long as it's the popular thing to do.
 
Get a clue sparky. Every, and I mean EVERY, article I've read today quotes poll that state that Americans are evenly divided on the issue. Yet every time it's been put to the voters the results are a 20+ pt. spread. The closest vote was in Oregon and that was a 16 pt. spread.

There is no other conclusion one can reach other than the polls are shit on this issue. So take your poll and shove it, it's meaningless.

Ishmael


Tell me how the Pew poll is invalid.

Voting is not a scientifically valid way to tell what people are thinking about an issue. You know that right? What if Pew said they're going to do a poll and whoever drives to their office during the work day gets to participate?
 
Last edited:
no.

the court's proper role is to be a rubber stamp.

in the united states, there are never tyrants and there are never lynch mobs.

there are never unpopular rights to uphold.

no siree.

in the united states, courts should be cheerleaders encouraging the people to do whatever they want to do, so long as it's the popular thing to do.

I got now the courts should tell us what to do and how think.
I remember a war over this.
 
Back
Top