meop79
Wandering.....
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2002
- Posts
- 26,945
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Enjoy the game! And I'm doing greatLovetoGiveRoses said:I'm doing great this morning, how about you? I'm on my way to see the US national soccer team play in a few minutes.
What is the middle ground? Are the oppressors only partially guilty of oppressing? If so, what are the other factors? How much a factor are the other factors? A little or a lot?
Also, if the oppressors are oppressing..what are they doing to oppress? I agree with you, there should be no oppressing. So, if we want the oppressors to stop oppressing, what must change to get them to stop oppressing?

That ain't cold unless you were sitting on a metal seat (and a real man would leave the door open too, so he could enjoy that bracing nor'easter coming off the bay)Lost Cause said:And it's 25 below! I was stationed in Goose Bay, Labrador when we occupied a chunk of that real estate for our nuke forces. It was primitive, and beautiful! I love isolated areas, and sitting on the docks and watching the seals and killer whales about 50 feet from the wharf! We used to fly to Gander to get a McDonalds hamburger, life's little pleasures!
*You need to keep your borders, Yanks might need somewhere to run to someday!![]()
Are you questioning Montey Python's credibility as political commentors?!meop79 said:And besides you weren't describing a comunal system you know... you were describing a representative democracy or a republican system lol
Meop79@yahoo.com
crysede said:
Are you questioning Montey Python's credibility as political commentors?!![]()
Are you messing with me? You don't want to mess with me...meop79 said:
crysede said:Afternoon meop
Interesting questions (which means a loooooong post I'm afraid, lol) - like I said, I can't point to any specific other factors that have been proven, but I'm naturalist when it comes to explaining human knowledge, including moral knowledge. I think that the fact that all human groups (at least once they reach a certain size and complexity), begin subjugating subgroups within them, suggests that it might be something inherent in human nature. It makes sense from an evolutionary point of view too - co-operation is a great survival strategy, but cooperating with some, so that your group can take advantage of others, is even better (for your group).
I think the real problem is that our social structure has changed much to fast in the last 4000 years or so, that our basic moral inclinations have simply been unable to evolve fast enough to meet the demands of our current lives (4000 years ain't that much time evolutionarily speaking). What we have works fine for small, homogeneous groups of people in which everyone knows everyone else - but when you crowd humans together in larger groups, especially once the group gets large enough so that there is some anonymity) you get problems.
That's NOT to say I think humans incapable living together in large groups - if we are willing to open our eyes to our faults, we're perfectly capable of recognizing when our instincts are working against us, and changing our behaviour.

Ishmael said:Thanks for the 'pump' LTGR, but I won't quite acknowedge the "pillar of the community" thing.
I will admit to discrimination. My recent business venture requires that I use a good deal of casual labor from time to time. I prefer to recruit women for this and middle aged women at that. Why? They have more stamina than men. They take direction easily and perform the task as shown, not attempting to take short cuts or re-invent the wheel. All in all, they are superior to men for the specific task in all ways. Of course I don't always get my preferences and have to use men. In that instance I do pay them the same as I do the ladies.
It has only been within the last year or so that I've been engaged in this endeavor and it is the first time that I've required a work force with these specific attributes. I had always wondered why industries that required repetitive detail work tended to have their assembly lines staffed primarily with those of the female gender. Now I know.
Of course this does NOT bypass chrysede's "oppression" argument or her dubious 'facts'. But until such time as an all female society can successfully bypass all this supposed cultural indoctrination and demonstrate a change in brain chemistry and brain area utilization brought about by cultural and educational differences only, I'm inclined to believe that the differences are there for a reason and that reason is a deeply rooted atavistic survival strategy. Untouched small aboriginal communities tend to sort themselves out along the same lines. The division of labor tends to be along the lines of natural ability and economy of effort, not institutionalized oppression.
Ishmael
) and it was sooooo good!!
I was not saying this, I would never say this! The fact that oppression might come about due to a natural inclination does not justify it. To claim such a thing would mean that men's higher sex drive justified rape (which would be evolutionarily advantageous to them), and therefore rape is natural. This is clearly nonsense: men are not mindless insects living by instinct alone - contrary to the opinion of some militant-feminists, I think it is clear that men are perfectly capable of seeing that rape is wrong, and thus the vast majority find the idea of actually raping a woman repulsive.LovetoGiveRoses said:You seem to be saying that there's some justification for the statistics you cited It makes sense from an evolutionary point of view too - co-operation is a great survival strategy, based on an evolutionary cooperation strategy between men and woman.
Wouldn't that then be deemed "natural" rather than "subjegation" or "oppression".
Oppression implies that the oppressor is doing something to cause the oppression. But if this is a natural or an evolutionary coping strategy, then, by definition it isn't oppression. It's simply and evolutionary coping strategy.
No, I think this is likely to be the case, but since there is no evidence, to date, to support this claim I am not asserting it as a fact - I would readily admit that there might not be any evolutionary factor at play here. As mentioned in my reply to Sandia, I do wish to avoid the pitfall of making assertions about science without scientific evidence to support them.But we're talking about work and economics and pay in this thread. We both agree, I think, that there's some evolutionary factor in the relationships that we have.
If the career was indeed freely chosen, then I agree. I know that in the case of my maternal grandmother (and my mother, for that matter) it was not a free choice. My grandmother was a brilliant mathematician, but was pressured by well-meaning family and fellow academics (who 'knew' that she could not be truly 'fulfilled' as a woman in academia) into giving up her academic career for family life (a life that not all women prefer, contrary to popular belief: reading her journals, it is clear she was miserable).I think the same is true of the careers that we choose. Women are often in lower paying career fields. The reason why some career fields are lowing paying than others is a ecoomics question and I don't think part of this thread.
Could you post a link to this please? I feel uncomfortable debating statistics without examining that data myself, particularly in cases like this, where it disagrees with other analysis I have seen.When women and men are in the same line of work (same jobs) and you correct for length of time worked, work hours, and education...there is no differential for men and women's rate of compensation (US census data).
I disagree - there are many women who would prefer a career to raising a family, and there are many men who would prefer raising a family to a career. Why is that society holds that women naturally need to dedicate themselves to their children, and men don't? I have often heard fathers saying that they deeply regret not being able to spend more time with their children - why do we (as a society) take this regret seriously only when it is expressed by women? There is no evidence to support the notion that women are naturally better caregivers - men generally love their children just as much as women do, and feel the need to protect and nurture them, children do not suffer if they are raised by a single father rather than a single mother (being raised by both parents is, of course, preferable).Further, I'll argue that some of the lack of advancement of women is due to a woman's choice as part of this evolutionary or "natural" relationship. My neighbors wife works at a company as an accountant. She's very good. She's very precise. She has young children. She likes her job. She never has to travel. She gets home from work every day in time to greet her children. She's been offered a supervisory spot many times. She turns it down every time. She thinks that the supervisors job is less predictable (having to deal with management issues often is) and she doesn't want to jeopardise her ability to be home every day to meet that bus.
Biological evolution, if that's what you are referring to here, cannot take place at this sort of rate. If you meant we are evolving (ie, developing) socially, then I agree: we are becoming far more willing to acknowledge the systemic oppression that exists in society - rather than claim that social inequalities are due the inherent inferiority of certain groups.There are many more women leaders these days than there have been in the past. Look in the media and in boardrooms. Carly Fiona is the President of HP/Compaq for example. Maybe we're continuing to "evolve".
Assuming that by 'systematic effort' you mean 'actively seeking out all members of applicable minorities and oppressing them' - I quite agree, no such thing is happening.Nevertheless, there are still a small percentage of women leaders. Is there room for improvement in the statistics that you cite? Yes, definately. Is there more room for having more women leaders? Yes. Is there a systematic effort of oppression going on that caused the statistics...I think not. Is there room for continued change resulting in a higher level of average earnings for women? Yes, definately. Maybe it's continued evolutionary change.
Unless his earnings are in the billions of dollars range, I think we can safely assume that he is not skewing the average.His income is much higher than the average for white males. He skews the average up quite a bit. He is one of those people who are contributing many basis points to the difference in the average wage difference between men and women. Is he causing oppression? How? By your earlier definition, you were accusing all white males of being oppressors because they made more than women on the average. But how is he oppressing?
Is it his problem that any particular person is not as well off as he is? No. However I would argue that, as a member of this society, the fact that we (as a society) discriminate against certain groups is a problem we all must face, including him.Is it his problem that people, particularly women, haven't started a business also?
Um, what dubious facts?Ishmael said:Of course this does NOT bypass chrysede's "oppression" argument or her dubious 'facts'.
Untouched, small aboriginal communities - as you yourself pointed out earlier - do not inherently organize themselves paternalistically. Also, the 'male vs. female brain' argument is not exactly supported by modern science:But until such time as an all female society can successfully bypass all this supposed cultural indoctrination and demonstrate a change in brain chemistry and brain area utilization brought about by cultural and educational differences only, I'm inclined to believe that the differences are there for a reason and that reason is a deeply rooted atavistic survival strategy. Untouched small aboriginal communities tend to sort themselves out along the same lines. The division of labor tends to be along the lines of natural ability and economy of effort, not institutionalized oppression.
crysede said:[for the whole post see page 15]The issue the male vs female brain is incredibly problematic, so far the basic pattern has been: one study is released purporting to show a relationship between some difference in men and women's behaviour based on empirical differences in the brain, it is soon followed by a host of other studies either showing that the purported empirical difference does not really exist, or giving evidence that suggests that the proposed link between behaviour and the biological difference does not exist.
An example that you are probably familiar with is the 'women are left brained' claim. It was highly reported in the media - though, as usually, the media paid little attention to its subsequent fall. Neurology has thoroughly disproved the notion that one side of the brain dominates - the only time this will happen is if you are missing the other side of your brain. Otherwise, the two halves are equal but different - and all processes are routed through both, not just one as we used to think.
Even when differences in brain chemistry and/or function can be found, it is next to impossible (at this date) to determine whether these differences are due to biology or social conditioning - social interactions have been found to play a tremendously important role in the development and organization of neurons, and the levels of many neurotransmitters and hormones within the body. Genetics is not the rigid program we once thought: it is a very fluid information medium, allowing the environment and the organism to have tremendous input.
What's that?Ishmael said:Lauren's claim about how executives and managers address each other makes it plain that she has never been in such an environment. They refer to each other by their first names. Male, female, black, white, asian, or otherwise. It seems that they are mature enough to know that they are on the same team and while they may have differences of opinion, they share common goals. You will find her verbal examples much more readily in the 'blue collar' worker class.
Ishmael

Lauren.Hynde said:What's that?
What are you talking about now? Did I talk in my sleep again? I don't remember making any claim, honestly... Can you quote me, please?
Hello, LovetoLovetoGiveRoses said:[...]
Webster's Dictionary..Oppress..1) to weigh heavily on the mind, spirit or senses, 2) to keep down by the cruel or unjust use of power; tyranize over.
[...]
To me, and apparently to Mr. Webster, the word oppression always contains the assumption of cognitive action (as in tyranize). It also implies cruelty, as noted in Mr. Webster's dictionary.
[...]

I think I was remiss in not quoting my entire argument, by just quoting part of it I have given you the wrong impression of what I was claiming. I was not suggesting science proved that the behavioural and/or functional differences between men and women, whites and blacks, etc. were all social in origin - I freely recognize that it has done no such thing. My comments were an explanation of why modern science does not proven the counter claim.Ishmael said:Your last paragraph of your last quote snippet is a thinly veiled denial of what science is learning more and more about each day. Namely thar men and women utilize different areas of their brains in differing intensities to accomplish the same tasks. Some of these tasks are more efficiently accomplished by one sex, or the other depending on the task. The eveidence keeps mounting and the 'nay sayers' keep dredging up this 'social conditioning' argument as the reason that there are differences and further that the differences are 'minor'. In science, the devil is in the details. The 'minor' is what makes all the difference and in some of these tests the differences are dramatic and in virtually all cases, repeatable.
Now why didn't you just explain this to me this back on page 11 when I explained why your argument was incoherent to me: if you'd told me that I was misinterpreting what you meant by the term 'discrimination' that would have cleared up an awful lot of confusion for me. I thought that you were claiming that there was systemic discrimination, but denying that there was systemic oppression, lol, you can see why I was so perplexed.I have never contended that oppresion has not, or does not occur. But I reject the counter claim that it is like Santa Claus. It's everywhere. In others words there are individual cases, but not systemic oppresion. Not theses days at least.
Actually it was Lavender's, I stole it from her because it made my point perfectly - and it was not meant to refer to today, it was a reference to when this actually took place. I think the post in which she made the point was on page 7 or 8.Ishmael said:You are right and have my apologies. It was crys. that made the comment about first names and 'dear' comments.
Aw come on, don't be upset - some of us are having a great time on this thread and haven't gotten the least bit angrymeop79 said:That's ok lauren lets go play on a different thread this one is getting boring.... honestly the idea wasn't to get so frigging angry or to dredge up such... well petty argumants as some of the folks on here have sighmodern society at work I supose...
I actually agree with the guy that said we have probably gone too far too fast for social structures to evelove with us... but shrug so what?

Lauren.Hynde said:Hello, Loveto
Just making a point of order. I don't think it's productive to discuss the dictionary, but in the latest revision of Mr. Webster's, you can read:
Oppress...1) to crush or burden by abuse of power or authority 2) to burden spiritually or mentally : weigh heavily upon.
The reference to tyranize was removed. Also, it doen't imply cruelty. Even in your definition, it said "cruel or unjust use of power".
Lauren.Hynde said:Hello, Loveto
Just making a point of order. I don't think it's productive to discuss the dictionary, but in the latest revision of Mr. Webster's, you can read:
Oppress...1) to crush or burden by abuse of power or authority 2) to burden spiritually or mentally : weigh heavily upon.
The reference to tyranize was removed. Also, it doen't imply cruelty. Even in your definition, it said "cruel or unjust use of power".