Pollitical Corectness

Damn I'd take Jessy Ventura I wouldn't care if he did monday night raw as long as he told the truth the rest of the time lol....

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
meop79 said:


Pollitically Corect: A way of acting which is defined by a greater interest in the consideration of the pollitical and social consequences of an action that either the rightness or the intelligence of said action.

Meop79@yahoo.com

Pretty much the nut of it meop. A behavior based on 'feelings' as opposed to any rational thought or logic.

My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument, or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument. They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc. In effect, by discrediting the speaker they somehow discredit the thought. It's quite irritating. Keeping that in mind, it's interesting to tune into C-SPAN on occasion and watch the two minute speeches on the floor of the house. Have a pad of paper and a pencil handy and as each rep. gets up to speak, mark down whether they are attacking/supporting an idea, or a person. It's an interesting little excersize.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:

My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument, or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument. They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc.

Ishmael said:


One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while.

What an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap that is.

Education and logic just ain't what it used to be.

Ishmael
 
meop79 said:
Pollitical Corectness: (Adj) the act or action defined as being pollitically corrert.

Pollitically Corect: A way of acting which is defined by a greater interest in the consideration of the pollitical and social consequences of an action that either the rightness or the intelligence of said action.

Meop79@yahoo.com

Everybody's a comedian. I get it now.
 
meop79 said:
LoL the last defense of the idiot attack from the shadows of annonimity

Meop79@yahoo.com
I hope that wasn't aimed at me, attacking from the shadows ain't my style.

Ishmael said:
My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument, or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument. They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc. In effect, by discrediting the speaker they somehow discredit the thought. It's quite irritating. Keeping that in mind, it's interesting to tune into C-SPAN on occasion and watch the two minute speeches on the floor of the house. Have a pad of paper and a pencil handy and as each rep. gets up to speak, mark down whether they are attacking/supporting an idea, or a person. It's an interesting little excersize.

Ishmael
Interesting perspective considering the fact that I gave you an argument that was clear, simple, presented my factual evidence, and was logically valid - and your response was simply to hurl a few insults, saying that it was a load of horse manure, and that I was uneducated in an attempt to discredit me.

Then, when you finally did produce a (logically invalid) counter-argument, rather than just attacking me, you never even mentioned the logical form of my argument (let alone show that it contained a single logical error)!

All you did was attack the truth of my premises (the truth value of which are entirely irrelevant in determining whether an argument is logically valid or not - if in doubt, consult any logic textbook concerning 'validity' vs. 'soundness' of an argument).

I didn't actually find your name calling irritating though, I guess I just have a thick skin.
 
What the fuck is a "PC-er"? I don't know nuttin 'bout no PC, cain't define it, but ah knows one when ah sees one...
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a go

crysede said:

If members of a certain race (or sex, ect.) have to work harder simply because of their race, then it seems to me that their race fits the definition of oppressed quite well.

And how does the success of a few women, or a few blacks, prove that they are not oppressed as a group? The fact that successful one are seen as noteworth exceptions suggests the very opposite.

Interesting perspective considering the fact that I gave you an argument that was clear, simple, presented my factual evidence, and was logically valid - and your response was simply to hurl a few insults, saying that it was a load of horse manure, and that I was uneducated in an attempt to discredit me.

Then, when you finally did produce a (logically invalid) counter-argument, rather than just attacking me, you never even mentioned the logical form of my argument (let alone show that it contained a single logical error)!

All you did was attack the truth of my premises (the truth value of which are entirely irrelevant in determining whether an argument is logically valid or not - if in doubt, consult any logic textbook concerning 'validity' vs. 'soundness' of an argument).

I didn't actually find your name calling irritating though, I guess I just have a thick skin.

Let's start with the fact that you presented no evidence at all. You presented personal statements in the form of 'facts. Lavy presented facts.

There have been, and still are societies today in which the male has no property rights. Everything belongs to the woman. There are societies today in which the black man is the dominant political force. The first independent nation outside of the United States formed in the western hemishpere was, and still is, a nation of blacks (Haiti). The oppression of the black race started in Africa by black tribes that sold others into slavery. Whites have been, and still are sold into slavery. The American Indian practiced slavery long before the arrival of the white man.

Women of character and strength have always weilded power. Power in a different form, but power none the less. If you choose to look at history through a tinted lense, you will always get a distorted view.

Further, past history is no excuse for current behavior or thoughts. It is up to the individual to thrive or fall on their own merits. Legitimate beefs are when a government sanctions a religion, race, or culture to the exclusion of others. That can no longer be said to be true in the United States.

The fact that I consider your ideas to be horse shit, does not mean that I have have called you a name. In fact, there are probably areas where we are in total agreement. The fact that I do not agree with you in certain areas does not diminish you as a human being in my eyes. It would take far more than, in my humble opinion, your misguided views on PC to do that.

And last but not least, you assumed that I was refering to you in the last post. Not neccessarily. There are others far more indoctrinated than you here.

Ishmael
 
I'm going to reply to your last post in two instalments, which I think is acceptable, since there are really two independent parts to your post. Firstly, I'll address your comments regarding my last post.
The fact that I consider your ideas to be horse shit, does not mean that I have have called you a name. In fact, there are probably areas where we are in total agreement. The fact that I do not agree with you in certain areas does not diminish you as a human being in my eyes. It would take far more than, in my humble opinion, your misguided views on PC to do that.

Your reply to my logical argument to the contrary of your position was:
One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while.

White males are oppressors and even one else is a 'victim'. What an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap that is.

Education and logic just ain't what it used to be.

This is not a counter-argument, it is not an argument at all (by argument, I mean logical argument, and since it lacks premises, a conclusion, and any form of logic, it clearly does not qualify as such).

Your next-to-last post said: My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument.
I found this ironic, since this is exactly what you did (see above).

Your post then when on to say: They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc. In effect, by discrediting the speaker they somehow discredit the thought. <snip> mark down whether they are attacking/supporting an idea, or a person. <snip>

Your statement Education and logic just ain't what it used to be. was an attack on me, in which you attempted to discredit me by suggesting I was lacking in education and logic. This is the first tactic you disparage in your last post.

Your referring to my idea as One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while. and an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap is an attack on my idea, not a support of your own ideas. This is the final tactic you mention in your post.

In short, all three tactics that you claim are 'irritating' hallmarks of the PC'er, you used yourself in your first response to me. Thus I found your last post to be an extremely bizarre point of view for you to express.

And last but not least, you assumed that I was refering to you in the last post. Not neccessarily. There are others far more indoctrinated than you here.
Actually, I thought you were referring to the politicians and activists you talked about watching on C-SPAN. I found your comments about them to be ironic, not because I thought you were referring to me, but because you had used the very same tactics you were decrying so vehemently.
 
The Never Ending Reply, Part II

Originally posted by Ishmael Let's start with the fact that you presented no evidence at all. You presented personal statements in the form of 'facts. Lavy presented facts.
Last time I checked demographics counted as facts, and that's what I presented as the factual support for my argument. I didn't post them of course - entering in all that data would take hours; it would be for Canada (since I didn't keep a copy of the data for the US last time I had to use this information), and thus probably not satisfactory to you; plus the data in question is very easy to get a hold of if you want to see for yourself (local libraries should have copies, or you can contact the statistics dept. or agency of your government).

There have been, and still are societies today in which the male has no property rights. Everything belongs to the woman. There are societies today in which the black man is the dominant political force. The first independent nation outside of the United States formed in the western hemishpere was, and still is, a nation of blacks (Haiti). The oppression of the black race started in Africa by black tribes that sold others into slavery. Whites have been, and still are sold into slavery. The American Indian practiced slavery long before the arrival of the white man.
I'm not sure what the point of this premise is: the fact that blacks aren't disadvantaged in non-Western cultures has no bearing on whether or not they are disadvantaged in Western cultures.

Women of character and strength have always weilded power. Power in a different form, but power none the less. If you choose to look at history through a tinted lense, you will always get a distorted view.
If you are defining those possessing character and strength as those who do, in fact, wield power, then your argument is circular (thus invalid).

If that is not how you are defining 'women of character and strength', then I would like to know how you know that no woman of character and strength has ever been prevented from wielding power. Since most of the women (and indeed most of the people) of history died without leaving any record of their ever having existed, I cannot see how you can possibly claim to have this knowledge (thus your argument is unsound).

Assuming that you could prove the above, what sort of 'power in a different form' do you mean? Women did generally have power over such household matters as what was for dinner, or which servants were hired - but that can hardly be claimed to be equivalent to wielding political power. What is your justification for claiming that this 'power of a different form' was equivalent to the social and political power wielded by men? (I'm assuming that you are claiming that the power was equivalent, since if the women has access only to an inferior form of power, that would mean they were oppressed.)

Further, past history is no excuse for current behavior or thoughts. It is up to the individual to thrive or fall on their own merits. Legitimate beefs are when a government sanctions a religion, race, or culture to the exclusion of others. That can no longer be said to be true in the United States.
I didn't delve into history, and the only time I've mentioned it is in response to you when you brought the subject of history up. I have not used history to defend my arguments. (Unless you consider the events of the last decade or two to be history - in which case no problem, that reference can be removed: my argument did not actually need reference to anything past the most recent demographic data to be valid).
 
Re: The Never Ending Reply, Part II

crysede said:


I didn't delve into history, and the only time I've mentioned it is in response to you when you brought the subject of history up. I have not used history to defend my arguments. (Unless you consider the events of the last decade or two to be history - in which case no problem, that reference can be removed: my argument did not actually need reference to anything past the most recent demographic data to be valid).

And there is the crux of it. You have no sense of history, so your comments concerning "always" are just your own 'spin' on what you believe.

Women have always weilded immense political power. An entire, and major, sub-sect of Islam is based on the beliefs of a woman and is even named for her. There are as many great turning points in history that revolve around a woman as there are those that revolve around men. The first self-made black millionare was a woman.

There are more instances than one can count of women rising to positions of power. But they worked for those positions. Earned them. No one is entitled to anything. If a woman were to run for president today whose ideals and philosophy appealed to the majority of voters, she would be elected. But she better be tough, because the opposition is going to use everything they have against her. And if she were to lose, it would NOT be because she was a woman. It would be because the majority of the electorate rejected her ideas.

The fact of the matter is that the majority of women are not interested in running for politics. Or having a career. That is their choice to make, not yours or anyone elses. That also means that there will be fewer of them to represent the people. And that is the job, not representing your sex, or your ethnic background, representing ALL of the people in your district.

And if there are women out there that would like to run for office, or have a career, and don't because they decided that they are "oppressed". Well, they quit before they even started. And if they complain, they're just whiners. They are entirely lacking in character.

Non-discrimination policy with teeth makes sense. Reverse discrimination is nothing more than retribution perpetrated on parties that for the most part were never guilty. It breeds resentment and diminishes any real accomplishment that the 'favored' individual may have really done. Because there will always be the thought in the back of many's mind that "She's only got that job because of the quota's." And there will always be the doubt in the persons mind that maybe what they're saying is right.

After having tried that for years and years. State after state is dumping that policy. They too are seeing the damage done. Only the Politically Correct Universities are holding on to that theory. Tooth and nail.

For years MIT recruited lower income minority students to the university on full scholarships. They 'normed' the SAT scores inorder to enroll these individuals. After 15 years of a 80% drop out rate at the sophmore level, they are changing their policy too. These individuals would have been able to cut the mustard at a lesser university, but now they're branded as failures. MIT was faced with lowering it's academic standards, or quit recruiting people not qualified to attend. Harvard has gone the opposite direction.

Ishmael

PS Demographic data does not reflect desires or skills. It's just numbers. In my field of expertise there are fewer and fewer qualified women every year. That means that there are fewer and fewer women in the pool that would make qualified managers. Lavy and I have already been down this road.
 
Great thread.

Especially Laurel arguing for censorship and against free speech.

As far as I am concerned, anyone should be allowed to call anyone whatever they want. Otherwise it goes under the sheets, new euphamisms are created, code words, etc. Much, much better to have it out in the open so everyone can see what kind of person things like that and gives them a chance to avoid or isolate them, maybe even educate them. But to go upside their head with the nightstick of government is just not the right answer.




I've always said, "HATE SPEECH IS FREE SPEECH!"
 
Volume I: The Decline and Fall of History

Before replying I just wanted to mention that, although you got of to a rather shaky start, this debate has become quite enjoyable now :)

I'm going to address your post in two parts again (to break my reply up into more manageable chunks), since your two arguments, though related, are logically independent. I will look at the historical argument first. (It will be a few hours before I have time to post the second part of my reply, I've got a bunch of boring rl stuff to do first.)
Ishmael said:
And there is the crux of it. You have no sense of history, so your comments concerning "always" are just your own 'spin' on what you believe.
What is the 'it' that this is the crux of? I can only find three possible meanings you might have intended (the first is the one that your above statement most clearly seems to be intended to express - but since that makes no sense, I have considered two possible alternatives as well):
  1. That my reason for challenging you on your use of the universal quantifier is because I do not understand history.

    Although this seems to be what your statement says, it is logically incoherent:

    My comments concerning 'always' have been pointing out the logical invalidity of your use of the universal quantifier. You do not know all the facts about every women or every black of any 'type' in history, therefore you cannot make claims espousing something to have 'always' been true for 'all' women/blacks of a certain type.

    There is nothing to spin here - you are committing a simple logical fallacy that invalidates your argument. There is no need for me to even consider the soundness of your premises in this case - the fact it is invalid logically demonstrates it is wrong. I can show this using symbolic logic, pointing out the rule of logic this argument breaks, if you would like me to make this point more clearly.
  2. That my reason for saying that there are minorities that are oppressed in Western society is that I do not have a sense of history.

    This is argument is also invalid: even if not one single minority had ever been oppressed in the entire history of the earth, that would in no way prevent a minority from being oppressed now.

    To claim otherwise is equivalent to arguing, that since human beings could not build nuclear bombs prior to the 1900's, they cannot build nuclear bombs now.

    Keep in mind - I am not refuting the soundness of your argument here - the subject matter, whether bombs or oppression or bioethics, is irrelevant; since I am here refuting your argument's logical form (its validity). If the argument in (2) is what you meant to say, then your argument is clearly invalid (once again, I'll demonstrate this in symbolic logic if you wish).
  3. The third option is what the remainder of your post suggests you meant: that my reason for saying that there have been minorities that have been oppressed in history, is that I do not understand history.

    Unlike (2), this argument is valid, thus I will now have to consider the soundness of your premises in order to refute it (this was unnecessary in (1) and (2), since the arguments were invalid - thus even if true, the premises failed to entail the conclusions).

    Since our argument, up to now, has been whether or not oppression exists in Western society today, I'm not sure why we are changing topics, nevertheless, this topic is fun too so fine by me since I do believe that oppression has existed in previous societies - but I want to make it very clear that I am not claiming that this fact proves that oppression exists today (as I pointed out above, that would be an invalid argument). Whether oppression has existed historically, is a different assertion, requiring a different proof.

My rebuttal to your argument (3), follows:
Women have always weilded immense political power. An entire, and major, sub-sect of Islam is based on the beliefs of a woman and is even named for her.
There are only two major sects of Islam, Sunni (about 90% of Muslims) and Sh'ite (about 9%). In neither of these is there any sub-sect that worships Aisha - to do so would be blasphemy. The core of Islam is very clear: there is no God but God, and Muhammad is His Prophet - if you do not assent to this, you are not a Muslim.

The Quran is the primary document - it is the only one that God gave to His Prophet - the Hadiths are not seen in the same light, they are merely the teachings of the Prophet (and other rightly-guided persons). Aisha's teachings are in the Hadiths, not the Quran.
There are as many great turning points in history that revolve around a woman as there are those that revolve around men.
Is this something you are asserting? If so, would you care to explain why the vast majority of important figures in recorded history (ie, what is written in history texts) show history revolving around men? I have written many papers on historically important female figures - and have done countless hours of research in order to track them down. It is not as easy task. Where as male political/religious/social leaders, reformers, revolutionaries, scientists, authors, poets, philosophers, artists, etc. are a dime a dozen, finding examples of more than a handful of well-known women in these capacities is a herculean task.

As an interesting exercise, since you like to use Muslim women as an example, I suggest you compare the number of women who have wielded power in Islamic history (by this I mean pre-modern history), to the number of men. The number of women scholars have identified (through no lack of effort) so far remains under 20; the number of men, in the thousands. If you would like bibliographic references, I would be happy to supply them.
 
Last edited:
sd412 said:
Um... So you're saying that because I call people "African-Americans" instead of "Niggers" that other people are less likely to come to America?

Fuckin'A Funny!
 
Slapper?

A girl can tell people she's a slapper, but If I mention it, I get called a sexist bigot!


Whats a Slapper? Must be an British term.....
 
Laurel said:


You'd probably lose your job if you went around calling the Black people there "niggers". However, you'd probably lose your job if you went around calling people "assholes". However, if you lost your job on that basis that you held racist beliefs, even if you did not act improperly, you could probably sue. I'm no lawyer, but I would think you'd have a case for discrimination.

I don't think so. Most employees - those without employment contracts - are "at will" employees. That means they can be fired at any time for any reason.

Unless

They're part of a "protected class", or are otherwise protected under specific federal legislation. (I'm talking about the US here.)

An employer could be liable, I think, for allowing or creating a "hostile workplace." One that constituted, for example, sexual harassment. Discriminating against people on the basis of sexual orientation, on the other hand, is perfectly legal. (Except, I think, in San Francisco.)

:D
 
Volume II: Inherent Inferiority

The first self-made black millionare was a woman.
I never said no women have ever succeeded, nor did I say no blacks have ever succeeded. I do not use universals in this manner, I know better - they are far too easy to counter.
There are more instances than one can count of women rising to positions of power. But they worked for those positions. Earned them. No one is entitled to anything. If a woman were to run for president today whose ideals and philosophy appealed to the majority of voters, she would be elected. But she better be tough, because the opposition is going to use everything they have against her. And if she were to lose, it would NOT be because she was a woman. It would be because the majority of the electorate rejected her ideas.

The fact of the matter is that the majority of women are not interested in running for politics. Or having a career. That is their choice to make, not yours or anyone elses. That also means that there will be fewer of them to represent the people. And that is the job, not representing your sex, or your ethnic background, representing ALL of the people in your district.

And if there are women out there that would like to run for office, or have a career, and don't because they decided that they are "oppressed". Well, they quit before they even started. And if they complain, they're just whiners. They are entirely lacking in character.
If you refer back to my initial posts (on pages 5 and 6 I believe), you will see that I have never claimed that people who did not try to achieve something, did not succeed because they were oppressed.

My argument is that there are groups in our society in which members are likely to be prevented from succeeding, or are likely to be confronted by obstacles to success not faced by other (advantaged) groups, due to their sex/race/etc (not related to job performance - clearly, it is not oppressive to deny a female actor the male leading role).

Your argument is that there is no such oppression in existence (in fact, you claim, there has never been any), and that those who claim that they are being unfairly discriminated against due to belonging to some minority, are just whiners. They are entirely lacking in character.
Non-discrimination policy with teeth makes sense.
You have consistently been claiming that oppression does not exist. This means you must hold one of the two following positions.
  1. You feel that discrimination is not oppressive.

    Discriminate: to make a difference in treatment or favor on a basis other than merit, eg, discriminate in favor of your friends, discriminate against a certain nationality
    Oppress: to subject to continual cruelty or injustice
    (def. from the Oxford)

    What is your justification for claiming that a society that favours certain groups is not subjecting these groups to injustice?
  2. If you are not claiming that discrimination is non-oppressive, then you must hold that discrimination is not unjust. Why do you think we need a non-discrimination policy with teeth if discrimination is just?
Reverse discrimination is nothing more than retribution perpetrated on parties that for the most part were never guilty. It breeds resentment and diminishes any real accomplishment that the 'favored' individual may have really done. Because there will always be the thought in the back of many's mind that "She's only got that job because of the quota's." And there will always be the doubt in the persons mind that maybe what they're saying is right.

After having tried that for years and years. State after state is dumping that policy. They too are seeing the damage done. Only the Politically Correct Universities are holding on to that theory. Tooth and nail.

For years MIT recruited lower income minority students to the university on full scholarships. They 'normed' the SAT scores inorder to enroll these individuals. After 15 years of a 80% drop out rate at the sophmore level, they are changing their policy too. These individuals would have been able to cut the mustard at a lesser university, but now they're branded as failures. MIT was faced with lowering it's academic standards, or quit recruiting people not qualified to attend. Harvard has gone the opposite direction.
What you are now debating is 'affirmative action', another new topic. 'Affirmative action' is one of our societies attempts to deal with the fact that there are oppressed minorities within it. Whether or not AA works has nothing to do with whether or not there are, in fact, oppressed minorities. I think AA, implemented on the procedural level, is generally misdirected and doomed to failure - but the fact that I do not think AA is a particularly good response to oppression, does not mean I do not think oppression exists; nor have you proved oppression doesn't exist by giving evidence to show that AA does not generally work.
PS Demographic data does not reflect desires or skills. It's just numbers. In my field of expertise there are fewer and fewer qualified women every year. That means that there are fewer and fewer women in the pool that would make qualified managers. Lavy and I have already been down this road.
I agree, demographic data does not reflect desires or skills, and cannot be used to assert anything about such. Since my first argument seems to have been somewhat unclear, I'll restate it in more detail. My argument from demographic data is as follows:
  • The data clearly shows that there are a number of groups (blacks, women, etc.) that are disproportionately represented (per capita) in the lower end of the social spectrum. Since you appear to be familiar with these statistics, I think we can agree on this much since so far it is just math.
  • A couple of examples of these statically disproportionate representations are:
    1) women are more likely to live in than single men
    2) blacks are more likely to be in jail than whites

    Since these statistics are some of the most commonly reported ones in demographic studies, I will assume you are familiar with them as well (as mentioned, this data is easy to find if you are not).
  • Given my above two premises, there are two basic logically reasonable conclusions one could draw:
    a) data like (1) and (2) are due to the existence of discrimination against certain groups within society
    b) data like (1) and (2) are due to an inherent inferiority of certain groups within society
Your explanation for the data is that certain groups tend to lack the proper desires, skills, determination, and/or character - and you have taken pains to state that no oppression exists. This is (b). In light of this, explain to me how (1) and (2) have come to pass (keep in mind, that since you deny the existence of oppression, you cannot claim there is any unfairness within society playing a role here)
  1. What is it about women's character that makes them more likely to live in poverty?
  2. What is it about the character of blacks, that makes them more likely to engage in criminal behaviour than whites?
In case you wish to object at this point, that my examples are purposefully difficult: this is true, they are - but if you wish to maintain your position, it cannot just be for the easy cases: you must be able to defend it in the hard cases as well. If it does not hold up in these two examples, it does not hold up period.

[edited to sort out my lists, to please my proofreading stalker ;)]
 
Last edited:
I shouldn't make any comments on this thread until I read the whole thing and I usually don't. I glanced at it quickly and it looks very interesting. Yes Meop, you kicked over a hornets nest. Cry, I need time to read your comments in more detail, and I will when I have time, though I can see you're discussing race, gender and minority rights in general. I'm not going to comment on that without more reading.

I did read the origin and the first few posts and they talk about Political Correctness and whether it's harmful or not.

There are lots of places (staying outside of minority rights) where the very vocal representatives of positions in a number of areas use PC to stifle meaningful and objective discussion of the facts. As my first example, I give you forest management. The west is burning as we speak. The "Environmentalists" claim that no one should touch a forest and anyone who would make a proposal to touch a forest is anti-environmentalist. Yet the professional forest managers, people who make their living caring for forests, say that some amount of management is needed to "protect" the environment. The strength of the "Environmentalists" "color" the professional forest managers as "anti-environmentalist" so effectively that their voice is not heard and has resulted in the situation where it's not "politically correct" to make arguements against the "don't touch the forest" position. This is bad when "facts" cannot be discussed.

There are many cases where one group appeals to the emotions of a constituancy to "blow smoke" over facts so that they can win their case regardless if the good of the nation is being addressed effectively or not.

Another case is education. Most inner city families (based on poll data) are in favor of voucher program so that parents can make decisions about education. There is clear evidence that school choice programs result in an improvement in acheivement in areas using school choice programs (Cleveland for example).
Yet, professional educators represented by teachers unions and other civil employee unions are adamantly against school choice. The unions claim that it's not good for the parents or the teachers to have choice, that all the money should be dedicated to the monopolistic approach currently being used. Don't get me wrong. I think our teachers are dedicated hard-working professionals who are doing their best for the kids of our country. However, I think they can do equally well if not better within a different framework where parents and teachers have more choice. Yet, the unions have succeeded in creating a situation where it is not "politically correct" to even consider school choice in most jurisdictions.

Do we want to talk about the number of single parent families, the incentives against marriage, and the impact on the educational development of children. I didn't think so. There seems to be a strong wave of PC in that discussion also, but I don't know enough about it to discuss it.
 
SINthysist said:
Great thread.

Especially Laurel arguing for censorship and against free speech.

What are you babbling about?

Go back and read my posts a little closer.
 
Exactly.

I'm going out for a few hours. When I come back, I'll check back so I can read about how I'm a Big Bad Censor.
 
Back
Top