Prenuptual Agreements

MissTaken

Biker Chick
Joined
Jun 30, 2001
Posts
20,570
Who has 'em?

Who loves 'em?

Who would never consider one?

Who requires them?
 
I dont have one....dont need one....but the other day my wife and I made a will....it felt like I was making a pre nup. Because the kids are hers and not mine it was and is a little different if she was to pre decease me. It brought up a lot of "I dont think this girl trusts me" issues for me.
 
Prenups seem to have had their day -- not because they're a bad idea (I haven't made up my mind on that yet), but because divorce court judges are, by and large, ignoring them whenever a spouse decides to contest their provisions.

Once upon a time, I would not have believed that judges would ever be allowed to exercise such a power. A prenup is entirely contractual and, when executed by persons of sound mind not under duress, should have the same presumptions of effectiveness as any other contract. But then, the notion of a binding contract has taken a pounding in the courts, too, hasn't it?
 
MissTaken said:
Who has 'em? I don't but wished I did.

Who loves 'em? I think they would be great.

Who would never consider on? If I ever got married again there would be on in palce.
Who requires them? I would if I had to do it over.
 
My ex husband asked me to sign one.

I told him I wouldn't. That he needed to trust me to remain committed or in the event of divorce, needed to trust me to be fair and not "fleece" him.

I really felt that his offer showed a significant lack of trust in me. ew talked, he listened and then, there was no prenup. We are divorced and I was true to my word.

I did consult an attorney about the matter, at the time. He said, that in NY, at least, the divorce laws are their own sort of prenup. There is a limit to how much I could get from him and that anything he brought into the marriage was his to take out of it, when it was over.
 
What good is any contract anymore? People appeal and contest such agreements left and right. And the courts are listening. So, why bother in the first place?

I would be offended if my spouse-to-be requested that of me. I would consider it a sign that he had no faith in our love; no belief in our future; no respect for commitment.

But, being the hypocrite that I am, I would probably ask for one in order to protect my interests. There is no rhyme nor reason for that. Just a self-serving mechanism to avoid being 'taken'.
 
ldrequiv said:
Once upon a time, I would not have believed that judges would ever be allowed to exercise such a power. A prenup is entirely contractual and, when executed by persons of sound mind not under duress, should have the same presumptions of effectiveness as any other contract.

I think anyone who's ever planned a wedding would tell you that the two parties involved are never of sound mind, and the entire process is nothing but duress.
 
I don't have a problem with them.

I think that divorce can make even the most even-tempered, fair-minded person want to lash out in anger, in some circumstances.

As long as it was constructed to be fair, not to fuck the other person over in case of divorce, then I wouldn't have a problem with requiring one or being required to sign one.
 
Agent99 said:


I would be offended if my spouse-to-be requested that of me. I would consider it a sign that he had no faith in our love; no belief in our future; no respect for commitment.


I would require one (but what is the point in getting married?)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Prenups are reasonable in many circumstances. Alot of people with second marriages who want to leave money to their kids rather than their second spouse get them, and it works well.

I think that for first marriages with young people it is sometimes a little creepy.
 
If it were important to him I would sign one... but I also see them as planning to fail which disheartens me. But if for his peace of mind or due to family pressures (the one instance of a friend of mine having one, his parents were afraid she was a gold digger) sure why not.
 
Killswitch said:
I dont have one....dont need one....but the other day my wife and I made a will....it felt like I was making a pre nup. Because the kids are hers and not mine it was and is a little different if she was to pre decease me. It brought up a lot of "I dont think this girl trusts me" issues for me.

In most states, even if the will cuts you out, you can elect against it and still get a fair amount.
 
I think that given the majority of marriages end in divorce it's smart to agree in advance that:

1. assets brought into the marriage remain the property of the original owners

2. each maintain separate financial identities

3. a third financial entity be created to operate the marriage

4. assets purchased by the third entity are held jointly and divided if required

This stuff should all be discussed before any engagement.

Of course, nobody does it, and I certainly didn't...but it should be.

Lance
 
Yup, I would require one. I would consider myself to be a lousy business person if love made me completely lose my business sense. At this stage of my life, I have built accumulated assets intended for my retirement. Those would have to be safe before I'd consider marriage.

As far as a prenup meaning the spouse doesn't trust you, that's not true. You trust each other when you are getting married or you wouldn't BE getting married in the first place. But have you ever heard of someone who said "I want to be married for a little while, and then I plan to divorce?" I doubt it. The vast majority of people go into marriage thinking it will last forever. Some of them are wrong. The prenup is just there in case the marriage is one of the many which don't make it to eternity.
 
I'm afraid you're mistaken, Lance. The majority of marriages don't end in divorce. The statistic is that divorces occur at about half the rate at which new marriages are made. With 94% of the adults in the country married, it would be odd if marriages were failing more often than not.

Regards,
Ldrequiv.
 
ldrequiv said:
I'm afraid you're mistaken, Lance.

Get used to it, you'll be saying this quite regularly. :D

And welcome to Lit! Do you like pickles?
 
Back
Top