Selective Reproduction

Would you...should you...reproduce if you knew you had a genetic predisposition to (for example) Autism, Retardation, Down Syndrome, Cystic Fibrosis or some other major defect?
Yes, if it is defective, then terminate it.

Should you have the power to design your own child?
Yes.

Perfect children are the future.

Or would you rather leave it to chance?
Hell know, super immune systems, intellect, numerous physical augmentations, why wouldn't I give my kid every advantage?

Hell, I'd give him viper spit and IR vision if it's optional.
 
Yes, if it is defective, then terminate it.

Yes.

Perfect children are the future.

Hell know, super immune systems, intellect, numerous physical augmentations, why wouldn't I give my kid every advantage?

Hell, I'd give him viper spit and IR vision if it's optional.

And there it is, the definitive answer.

But buying super good looking, super intelligent, super long lived (we do know the genes associated with long life), and no genetic defects is going to cost..........a lot. And these aforementioned 'elites' will be able to inter-breed, and they will, without any concern for inbreeding. They'll be all over the globe and will be part of a very select club. What with robotics doing all the menial work, even raging war for them, it won't be long before they figure out that there are about 4 billion (+/-) people on this globe that just aren't needed for anything. They're consuming resources and producing nothing, mucking up the environment, endangering species that are cute to go visit on holiday, and contributing to AGW (whether that turns out to be fact or not, it is a perception). So they will collectively decide to cull the human race.

Ahhh, to be able to take a peek into the future.

Ishmael
 
Last edited:
And once you did know, did you have other children anyway?

( I'm not certain after reading your post.)

Yes I did. Because it wasn't until almost 6 yrs after that a cousin lost her baby for the same reason and we all got tested.
 
I know this will sound horrible but some of these genetic disorders put huge strain on the medical system. As hard as it is for some people they should consider adopting instead of having their own children.
I got "fixed' when i was 25 as my chances of passing down schizophrenia were high due to my family history. That being said I had to fight to get my tubes tied because of my age. Almost 10 years later and Im glad I made the decision I did.
 
Yes, if it is defective, then terminate it.

Yes.

Perfect children are the future.

Hell know, super immune systems, intellect, numerous physical augmentations, why wouldn't I give my kid every advantage?

Hell, I'd give him viper spit and IR vision if it's optional.

There is no such thing as perfect children. :)

Even having one leg longer than the other and they are not perfect.

Some of the most brilliant minds may have defective bodies yet they lead amazing lives and without them our world would be missing out on their brilliant input.

For example Stephen Hawking :)
 
Worth noting that Mr. Hawking deteriorated to his present condition and was not born in that state.
 
Worth noting that Mr. Hawking deteriorated to his present condition and was not born in that state.

But if there was a test for ALS during pregnancy, then what? Most might get abortions because it's a horrible disease and maybe one of the worst deaths ever but it hits later in life and some like Hawking do wonderous things.
 
Best answered by those that have suffered thru the disease. Some have had a short but brilliant life while others, with less resources and support, have less.
 
In a way, the question of selective reproduction is already being answered by all of us. In the US, wiki says 67% of all known Downs babies are aborted. In Europe, it's over 90%. And sex-selective abortion has been practiced for decades in various parts of the world. Selective abortion is the first and easiest step towards selective reproduction and we've shown little hesitation (as a group, anyway) to embrace it. And as we get more opportunities to identify and choose a fetus's traits, I think we'll continue to use that info, and those techniques, to instill traits in our kids which we perceive to be superior.

I wonder if certain "fashions" of kid-types (really tall or whatever) will become dated, like kitchen counter-tops (it's so nineties!). Probably wouldn't be fair to Junior to go with all the crazy fads of the moment since he'll be stuck with them for life.
 
My son has autism. He's 24 now and if I had a chance to make the autism go away, I'd do it in a snap. But would I have aborted him if I'd known about it in advance?

I don't know. He's a child of rape. Abortion was on the table very early on. My parents promised their full support no matter what I chose, and I chose to keep him. So then I wonder, had the information about his autism been available to me, could it have tipped my choice to abortion?

I still don't know, but I think maybe so. Thing is, I was 16 at the time. I've had 24 years since then to learn about children with autism, and specifically about my child with autism. At 16, had I known, in my ignorance I might have gotten scared and made a decision that today would seem inconceivable to me. My son has autism, but I would never not want him in our world.

This is a very conflicting subject. It's seems easy to answer for humans as a group. Not so easy as an individual.
 
Our 5th child had a 40 year-old father and a 38 year-old mother. Downs is always considered a possibility with older parents. Modern medicine is lawsuit-defense as much as anything. They wanted to test for downs in utero, so we could not complain later about the burden such a child might be. We both emphatically declined.

This child was unplanned, but always, therafter wanted. She is beautiful, very bright, and mildly autistic.

If she had been born with Downs she would be far less of a handfull, but more of a worry in surviving beyond my survivng lifetime needing care.
 
Last edited:
Would you...should you...reproduce if you knew you had a genetic predisposition to (for example) Autism, Retardation, Down Syndrome, Cystic Fibrosis or some other major defect?

Should you have the power to design your own child?

Or would you rather leave it to chance?

No, no and yes.

Chance in this context has an expiration date...we don't know when it is but it's coming.

Why put kids through an unnecessarily difficult time, let alone the stigma?
If such a procedure that zapped the Down symdrome gene or so on was widely available, I'm sure that most people would take advantage of it.
And I don't think it will all backfire and lead to a "Gattaca"-type society either.

The only thing Gattaca got wrong was the fact that an inferior hominid is still around.
 
Last edited:
Poignant post....yes, making decisions from the chair of the hypothetical is one thing, but for many here, the choice has already been made.

My son has autism. He's 24 now and if I had a chance to make the autism go away, I'd do it in a snap. But would I have aborted him if I'd known about it in advance?

I don't know. He's a child of rape. Abortion was on the table very early on. My parents promised their full support no matter what I chose, and I chose to keep him. So then I wonder, had the information about his autism been available to me, could it have tipped my choice to abortion?

I still don't know, but I think maybe so. Thing is, I was 16 at the time. I've had 24 years since then to learn about children with autism, and specifically about my child with autism. At 16, had I known, in my ignorance I might have gotten scared and made a decision that today would seem inconceivable to me. My son has autism, but I would never not want him in our world.

This is a very conflicting subject. It's seems easy to answer for humans as a group. Not so easy as an individual.
 
People with hereditary illnesses should be forcibly sterilized.

Most of these illnesses have a percentage rate of being passed down. What should be offered is good genetic counseling.
And right now those of us who did want sterilization because of genetics had to fight for it and were turned down often.
Also in sex education in schools perhaps they should talk about abortion as an option. Right now most schools don't.
 
Genetic Counsellor:

"Autism Gene....tell us about your childhood."


Autism Gene:

(silence, looks away)

Good one Lance. *chuckle*

As far as counseling goes it's going to be a menu driven system. This is what you get, this is what you pay. Most of you will never get to see the menu let alone visit clinic.

Ishmael
 
Genetic Counsellor:

"Autism Gene....tell us about your childhood."


Autism Gene:

(silence, looks away)

There are many more diseases that you can know the pass down rates about. Such as cystic fibrosis. Obviously autism isn't one of them

Why conceive if you know that the child will probably be sick. I bet those parents who have done mercy killings wished they could have been tested.
 
There are many more diseases that you can know the pass down rates about. Such as cystic fibrosis. Obviously autism isn't one of them

Why conceive if you know that the child will probably be sick. I bet those parents who have done mercy killings wished they could have been tested.


MRI scans of autistic patients have revealed abnormalities in the white matter – the wiring tissue responsible for connecting brains areas. Some scientists have drawn comparisons with multiple sclerosis, in which inflammatory processes attack the myelin sheath around the axons of brain cells, slowing down signalling and making it less efficient.

Warrior Queen had children after losing one to a genetic defect.
 
i don't post on here very much but this one i had to. I work with special needs kids. I'm around the same kids from the time they enter kindergarten to 4th grade so I get to know them. I have seen autistic kids who were diagnosed as nonverbal learn to speak better than typical kids their own age and read grade level. I have seen Down's kids with personalities that draw people to them. I have worked with kids who were typical at birth but through car wrecks were put into wheel chairs having to be fed and changed and probably will be for the rest of his life. He can't speak but he expresses himself in other ways. They have limitations and they do learn slower usually but they can learn. They can be sweet and they can be real jerks. You know, like anybody else.

I've learned the time I've been around them that nobody can predict what they will be able to achieve. They surprise me every day.
 
Warrior Queen had children after losing one to a genetic defect.

Yes - but at the time I was unaware that I carried a gene that caused my childs abnormality.
Like I said, had I known, things may have been very different.
 
In the bright future we'll all be able to redesign our own and our offsprings' DNA to any genotype, gender, ethnicity, or species we wish, maybe sculpted with a little surgery.

I will rebuild myself as an orang-utan.

Kiss me.
 
i don't post on here very much but this one i had to. I work with special needs kids. I'm around the same kids from the time they enter kindergarten to 4th grade so I get to know them. I have seen autistic kids who were diagnosed as nonverbal learn to speak better than typical kids their own age and read grade level. I have seen Down's kids with personalities that draw people to them. I have worked with kids who were typical at birth but through car wrecks were put into wheel chairs having to be fed and changed and probably will be for the rest of his life. He can't speak but he expresses himself in other ways. They have limitations and they do learn slower usually but they can learn. They can be sweet and they can be real jerks. You know, like anybody else.

I've learned the time I've been around them that nobody can predict what they will be able to achieve. They surprise me every day.


Do you think children and the elderly are becoming disposable.... Or are we becoming more inclusive of people with special needs ?
 
Back
Top