Should prison be abolished?

renard_ruse

Break up Amazon
Joined
Aug 30, 2007
Posts
16,094
Should the medieval and archaic idea of prison finally be abolished?

Does the state even have a moral right to kidnap and hold people against their will?
 
Should the medieval and archaic idea of prison finally be abolished?

Does the state even have a moral right to kidnap and hold people against their will?

No. Although there are many people incarcerated who don't need to be incarcerated, there are also some so crazy and violent that they should never see day light.
 
Should the medieval and archaic idea of prison finally be abolished?

Does the state even have a moral right to kidnap and hold people against their will?

Seriously though - where would you put the criminals? There are many people in there I'd hate to meet on the outside.

Should we execute more convicts?
 
Should the medieval and archaic idea of prison finally be abolished?

Does the state even have a moral right to kidnap and hold people against their will?

No. Prisons should not be abolished.

Yes, the State, through the will of the people, have the right to do anything that it decrees against the will of an individual. This question has been debated and decided in many societies and cultures all around the world.

There needs to be a quantum leap to where the punishment of a criminal is not decided by the State but by the victims of the criminal activity.

Someone steals my car and they get caught I should get to decide how they are punished. Likewise, someone murders a person in my family, then I get to decide if they live or die, or even if someone in their family lives or dies.
 
Should the medieval and archaic idea of prison finally be abolished?

Does the state even have a moral right to kidnap and hold people against their will?


I definitely think prison is a useful part of the judicial system. That being said, I think the prison system in the United States is long overdue for complete overhaul.....there are far too many for-profit prisons in the US, and far too many peeps making plenty of $$ off of the needless incarceration of other human beings.

We should still have prison, but use it more sparingly.
 
I suggest that if they do get abolished you could invite the criminals into your home. ;)
 
81% of persons incarcerated inprisons in the U.S. are in for drug charges. 60% of those are for single personal use possession. Our prisons are cruel and unusal punisment as outlawed by the bill of rights. Only very recently (about a year I think) has congress passed a bill to crack down on rape in our prisons. So fr, only one prison has complied with the provisons of the bill.

Twenty years ago, Portugal decriminalized posession of all drugs for personal use. Since then, all drug use, even prescriptions have steadily declined.

One last thing. Our prisons are very big business. One of the larger companies is owned by Laura Bush.
 
81% of persons incarcerated inprisons in the U.S. are in for drug charges. 60% of those are for single personal use possession.

So if we stop punishing drug crimes, we don't need prisons?

Well, I can see how there would be a Darwinistic effect - without the law as an obstacle many drugheads would cull themselves from the gene pool. I'm all for letting people kill themselves, if that's what they want.

But there are still a lot of other criminals we need to put away.


Our prisons are cruel and unusal punisment as outlawed by the bill of rights.

That's a stretch. Incarceration is accepted world wide as a normal form of punishment. All countries have prisons.


Twenty years ago, Portugal decriminalized posession of all drugs for personal use. Since then, all drug use, even prescriptions have steadily declined.

Wouldn't happen here, unless you claim that people are on drugs for no other reason than because they are illegal. It would be like reducing the average speed by removing all speed limits.
 
I suppose Britain could re-introduce transportation, there's still lots of space in Australia.

Seriously though, I believe that in most countries a significant number of people in prisons could be punished in the community, tagging, curfew, or house arrest.

But like other posters have said there are a lot of people who shouldn't be on the streets.
 
81% of persons incarcerated inprisons in the U.S. are in for drug charges. 60% of those are for single personal use possession. Our prisons are cruel and unusal punisment as outlawed by the bill of rights. Only very recently (about a year I think) has congress passed a bill to crack down on rape in our prisons. So fr, only one prison has complied with the provisons of the bill.

Twenty years ago, Portugal decriminalized posession of all drugs for personal use. Since then, all drug use, even prescriptions have steadily declined.

One last thing. Our prisons are very big business. One of the larger companies is owned by Laura Bush.

^^^^^This imbecile is cherry picking criminal records.

Rap sheets often start with possession charges but what lands people in jail are forging prescriptions, selling drugs, and sales/possession of heroin, oxycodone, phenobarbital etc. No one goes to jail for pot.
 
:eek:


"There needs to be a quantum leap to where the punishment of a criminal is not decided by the State but by the victims of the criminal activity. "


:shudder:
 
:eek:


"There needs to be a quantum leap to where the punishment of a criminal is not decided by the State but by the victims of the criminal activity. "


:shudder:

Taking the rights of the victim more into consideration wouldn't be a bad thing.
 
Taking the rights of the victim more into consideration wouldn't be a bad thing.

Our system of jurisprudence is based on the idea of surrendering the right of revenge to the state. The victim is taken into consideration during the sentencing phase.

What needs to change is the idea of what a sentence is from a time served to change observed. Those who just cannot adapt to rules or to undergo improvement should remain outside of society. I would like to see a prison remade in layers and the inmate working his way from more to less restrictions, from forced obedience to voluntary compliance so that when he leaves the last layer, he has been living an almost normal life, working and interacting and proving that he is reformed and ready. We keep putting them back out there unreformed and unrepentant with little chance of surviving their abrupt reintroduction.
 
Back
Top