Should we attack Iraq?

Should the U.S. attack Iraq?

  • Yes

    Votes: 25 36.8%
  • No

    Votes: 31 45.6%
  • Not sure

    Votes: 6 8.8%
  • Where\'s a flirting thread?

    Votes: 6 8.8%

  • Total voters
    68
Re: Re: Re: Earth to Jim, come in, JMJ . . .

MoonWolf said:
Which we participated in his ability to obtain.

So what? By your logic here, you shouldn't try to stop a person from killing someone because you gave them the gun? That's stupid.

That's cause he thinks he's GOD.

No, he thinks he's Stalin. There's a difference, and it makes him very dangerous.

But he's a nimrod and couldn't do anything without our help. We just need to cut him off. COLD WAR TIME!

YOu mean that we should place him and his country under an embargo where we don't buy anything from him or sell him anything, right? We already do that. That was yet another impotent UN resolution.

His support is moral? What planet are you from? And he can't develope anything if he's cut off from a cold war.

"Moral" as in "moral support". Part of the support he gives those terrorist organizations is rooting them on. He helps give them hope that they can continue doing what they're doing.

And, yes he can. He has. He still is. He develops his materials inside his country. He buys the other stuff he needs from countries like Libya.

We only got involved in the first place because he threatned Papa Bush's oil. He's not threatning that right now, so he's Okie Dokie in the bush world.

Okay, that's almost too dumb a comment to dignify. He didn't threaten Papa Bush's oil. He threatened your oil. Unless, of course, you don't drive a vehicle, take mass transportation, wear synthetic-fiber clothing, use plastic goods, or anything else that requires petroleum.

We need oil. We didn't need the oil that was in Kuwait, necessarily, but we did need the oil that was in Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. We've already learned that once he had settled into Kuwait, he was coming after SA next and they were absolutely unable to stop him. Then, he'd have the vast majority of the oil in the Middle East. That's a big deal to everyone, not just the people you don't like.

And I don't know if you've been paying attention, but deposing Hussein has been high on the Bush priority list way back when he was running for President. He's always maintained that Hussein should be removed from power immediately. He's never backed down from that either.

Attacking Iraq right now would be a political error in judgement making the US look like a bully.

How? By doing something that needs to be done?

Look, Milosevic killed thousands in Yugoslavia with tanks and guns and bombs. Hussein has killed thousands using all that and more horrible weapons. He has demonstrated beyond any doubt that he has no problem whatsoever with using any of those weapons far outside his borders, against anyone he pleases. He openly supports people who have pledged our deaths (your death, too, assuming you live in America. Terrorists don't exactly ask whether or not you agree with your country before they kill you do they?). He has shown himself to be an order of magnitude worse than Milosevic and there was no problem at all removing him.

Remove Hussein, too. I'd rather not have to later wonder why more and more people had to die at his behest while we sat here, trembling at what a few other countries thought of us. Didn't the near-begging from the leader of the Kurds mean anything to you? Wasn't it telling to anyone that this man risked his life to openly plead for us to use his people's territory to stage attacks against Hussein? He's begging for his life. We ought to save it if we can.
 
Re: Whatever

REDWAVE said:
Yeah, okay, Oasis, whatever you say. I tell you what-- you and Jabo lead the way & the rest of us will follow you later-- I promise . . .
:rolleyes:

Hi Redwave - I think it is time for us to begin organising the US for conscription of all the poor people, you know, all those citizens who went to state owned schools, are not WASP or WASR, can think independently and are prepared to hold an opinion different from the undemocratically appointed Dubyah Administration.

If the US security forces are so good, by their own definition which has been found wanting, why did they ALLEGEDLY have no knowledge of the 9/11 incident???

How do you know that the present situation proposed by the Dubyah Administration is not just as badly advised??

Who have been the only beneficiaries of the 9/11 incident??? Was the CIA, or a rogue element of the CIA involved in 9/11??? The objective evidence is mounting.

"Make Peace not War" means "Make Profits not Problems".
 
Before the attack....

I need a "Cuban Missle Crisis" type of briefing from the President showing satellite pics of training camps, missle depots, bio labs...confirmed. I already did my bit with a war that started in the Gulf of Tonkin by that Socialist piece of shit Johnson, which was a bogus event contrived and escalated by a Democrat by the way.
If the legally elected President Bush provides verified evidence, I'll support the operation 1000%. If they need me, I'll go there and wade in the guts too.
After the Iraqi operation, we still have unfinished business in Mogandishu. Think about it.

*Peace through superior firepower. :D
 
Absolutely not. If the United States is going to take on the responsibility of invading nations which may potentially pose a threat to national security then Iraq is just the tip of the iceberg, we'd have to declare world war III against over a dozen targets. As much support as there seems to be in this country for action against Iraq I think that people are underestimating just how much damage we could take in the process. While Iraq isn't a superpower it would be unwise to pick an unnecessary fight out there. If the United States were to declare war out there does anyone doubt that Saadam could retaliate by releasing a chemical, biological, or even a nuclear weapon in response?
 
70-30
“I was hedging toward yes until the Russians came out yesterday with the $40Billion package for Iraq. Ishmael had me convinced that Russia would be the prime occupying entity after the overthrow-on the contrary, they are more likely to defend Iraq. I feel better about myself though-in early 1999 I had to do a position paper in Global Politics about what the New World Order would be. My answer was the Cold War never ended but that it has turned into a two vs. one-Russia and China against the USA. All this terrorism crap sorta proved I was off but I've been redeemed in a big way. But as a nation we are screwed every which way-no allies to speak of except the fuckin' psycho Jews and Putin isn't a clear enough villain to pursue.”

I beg to differ. Russia is in free fall, desperate to keep the country from imploding and under pressure from the Chinese whom are in an expansionary phase. It is true that neither party are our friends. But the cold war is over. WWIV started with a declaration of jihad, I think in ’96. It is over religion and beyond rational. If we fail to invade, then the Arab/Muslim world will for centuries lose the opportunity to be free as we will, once again, be seen as a paper tiger. We must also topple the “new” monarchies of the Arab world and remove the dictators of the Arab world.

Here’s an excerpt from Barry Faber (at Newsmax.com):

The most bone-marrow-curdling theory I've heard since 9-11 was put forth by former Special Forces Sgt. Keith Idema, about which much has and should be written that has nothing to do with Iraq. Idema was a hero of the discovery that former Soviet weapons-grade nuclear material was pouring into the international terrorist underground after the Soviet Union collapsed. Though retired, he sped to Afghanistan immediately when his younger buddies invaded and actually became a leader in the anti-Taliban Northern Alliance.

Shortly after 9-11 Keith theorized as follows. "The Jihadists tried to blow up the World Trade Center in 1993. They failed miserably. Were it not for the six fatalities, you could say they failed comic-operatically.

Al-Qaeda then goes to an America-hating state that has atomic weapons or is on a fast track to procure them: Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, you name it. They ask for an atomic bomb with which to teach America the Mother of All Lessons.

"The rogue-state quartermasters in charge of atomic weaponry, in hand or coming soon, listen politely. They then refer the al-Qaeda representative to Casey Stengel's book about the early New York Mets, "Can't Anybody Here Play This Game?" with perhaps "The Gang That Couldn't Shoot Straight" as parallel reading.

Al-Qaeda gets the Islamic brush-off: "Blessed be our solidarity in Jihad, but you look to us like a band of cuckoo birds."

Then they do 9-11.

After which they have a better resumé to present, don't they?

End of C&P

Russia cannot control itself, let alone be the major player in a new Iraq. That will be the United States…



Violette – The military cannot find bin Lauden because he was mortally wounded at Tora Bora. His side cannot admit that he is dead. They need him as a figurehead to secure WMD. The doves cannot admit that he is dead, because they need Bush to be a failure to fight the war effort. Since the body is well hidden, buried in a secret place, it will be impossible to prove him dead. If he were alive, he would have given a message by now to demoralize his enemy and exhort his followers. That is why one of his sons has now been proclaimed leader of Al Qaeda…



Oasis69 – “and not so coincidentally those same very conservative Republicans have taken millions in campaign donations from the Saudi Royal Family and, if history repeats itself, will get even larger payments from the Saudi's once they leave office, but of course, the payments will be for giving speeches, not political favors. Right. Those same very conservative Republicans are the same ones who advise the President and influence policies.”

Cynthia McKinney – the lone dissenter in support of the president on Sept 12 and afterwards (the only won to vote against him) is the largest recipient of Arab-Muslim money in the country, even taking in thousands of dollars in contributions ON SEPTEMBER 11!



STAR – “Plus, if we're concerned about nukes, then why aren't we declaring war against North Korea?”

Because North Korea was, is, and will continue to be a vassal state of China. Been that way for centuries. Even when independent, the Northern Kingdom’s influence and eyes have always been on China.
 
ROTTING GARBAGE!!!

SINthysist said:
70-30

Here’s an excerpt from Barry Faber (at Newsmax.com):

The most bone-marrow-curdling theory I've heard since 9-11 was put forth by former Special Forces Sgt. Keith Idema, about which much has and should be written that has nothing to do with Iraq. Idema was a hero of the discovery that former Soviet weapons-grade nuclear material was pouring into the international terrorist underground after the Soviet Union collapsed. Though retired, he sped to Afghanistan immediately when his younger buddies invaded and actually became a leader in the anti-Taliban Northern Alliance.

Shortly after 9-11 Keith theorized as follows. "The Jihadists tried to blow up the World Trade Center in 1993. They failed miserably. Were it not for the six fatalities, you could say they failed comic-operatically.

Al-Qaeda then goes to an America-hating state that has atomic weapons or is on a fast track to procure them: Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, you name it. They ask for an atomic bomb with which to teach America the Mother of All Lessons.

"The rogue-state quartermasters in charge of atomic weaponry, in hand or coming soon, listen politely. They then refer the al-Qaeda representative to Casey Stengel's book about the early New York Mets, "Can't Anybody Here Play This Game?" with perhaps "The Gang That Couldn't Shoot Straight" as parallel reading.

Al-Qaeda gets the Islamic brush-off: "Blessed be our solidarity in Jihad, but you look to us like a band of cuckoo birds."

Then they do 9-11.

After which they have a better resumé to present, don't they?

End of C&P

Russia cannot control itself, let alone be the major player in a new Iraq. That will be the United States…


SIN, This is the greatest pile of speculative rotting garbage I have ever seen. There is no attempt at substantive argument, just waffle, waffle and more waffle!!! This post detracts from your previous logical arguments. :)
 
HELL NO

it is not our issue, it is not our problem, and it is not our right. Why do our tax dollars and men and women have to be put on the line? To hell with the Middle East I say, I could care less about them if they dont have the balls to do the job. Screw em, lets get the oil out of Alaska and give them the finger. It is so simple to fix this problem its sickening. But when does common sense prevail anymore.
 
You see, I subscribe to the belief that Saddam believes himself to still be at war with the United States. Since he expelled the inspectors and nothing bad happened, in fact, he's gotten more aid and been allowed to sell more oil, he now considers the phase as a cease-fire.

Now that Al Qaeda has proven to be an effective delivery vehicle, I do not believe to be a stretch of logic to assume that if he had weapons that could turn the tide of this war in his favor, that he would turn them over to Al Qaeda for de-stabalizing strikes on America and American Interests (spelled I-S-R-A-E-L).

Barry Faber just has some interesting takes and contacts in the middle east and makes good food for thought.
 
What a difference a year makes!

What a difference in the American political climate from eleven months ago! In the period following Sept. 11, support for Bush soared, flags were everywhere, the public was ready to support invading almost anywhere. Now, with the economy soured, Bush and his cronies at big corporations (like Enron) unmasked as nothing more than a bunch of scam artists, and the mood of "patriotism" largely evaporated, the country is deeply divided over an attack on Iraq, as this poll indicates. If there's so much opposition now, before the attack, imagine what it will be like if there are substantial American casualties?

But there's one group that's happy: the defense contractors. Since 9/11, they've been making record profits!
 
Russia and China are far from enemies, they've been meeting on a regular basis the past 10years signing various agreements that Don might know something about. They have a mutual foe, the United States. Sure China's future is brighter but Russia is far from insignificant. Look for Russia to continue to get cozy with any country that has a major problem with us while Putin continues to act friendly with GWB. China will continue to develop and stay in the intermediate background.

Maybe Donny and Dick want to scuffle with Russia a bit since Putin hasn't been bowing enough. But assuming everything goes good in the Saddam overthrow, the USA will have to have keep an enormous number of troops there for up to 10years. I think the full tab will pass $1trillion sooner than you think, maybe it is worth it. Personally I agree with much of what Biden, Powell, Hegel, Myers, etc are saying, we need some international support, problem remains it is so easy for other countries to hate Bush. I don't think anything is going to happen soon since Iraq isn't completely distancing themselves from Mid East neighbors and Russia.
 
Last edited:
Re: Welcome!

REDWAVE said:
Welcome to Lit., Schleicher. You make a very lucid argument there.

Thanks for the welcome. Long-time story reader, newbie on the boards.

Thanks for the compliment. I was actually expecting a lot more flack for my perspective, but world politics probably isn't on the minds of most people when they go to Literotica. I've kind of wanted to start writing my own erotica, but to a certain extent I like the idea that my private fantasies stay private. So far the boards are just an extension of my usage of boards from other sites.
 
REDWAVE.

The stock Market is rebounding.

The anniversary is coming up.

Everyone is saying it's gonna be low-key...



Uhn-Uhn.



People are going to be re-Patriotized, energized, and ready for the fight.
 
Closed thread ??

I'm one of those non-americans
but since it's 08/20 I say

Send Saddam to Allah, he'll judge.

Bomb Baghdad to make that happen unless you know a better solution.

Iraqi people, all those minorities in the north and south will be happy to see that dictator disappear.
Feed those hungry children, rebuild the infrastructure and make sure there's no lack of power after the soldiers leave battlefield. Install a stable government and administration and welcome back Iraq in the global community.

And for the endless list of interests groups having an eye on this country like Russia, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, the entire muslim world, maybe even China or Europe, not to forget all that big oil business. Iraq without Saddam will be a safer place for all of us.

Rex :rose: :kiss:
 
Vox Populi, vox dei

The people have spoken. 23 against and only 17 for. There is clearly no consensus for going to war against Iraq.

Sin, old buddy, the market did shoot up yesterday, but so far it's back down again today. The more important and revealing fact yesterday was the leading economic indicators were down. The economy is far from hitting bottom; the worst is yet to come.

Yes, it's been almost a year since 9/11, and still there has been no public investigation of why it happened and what went wrong. (Congress is holding an "investigation," but in secret-- and even its whitewash has been stymied by FBI intimidation, in flagrant violation of the doctrine of separation of powers.) Obviously, the powers that be have a lot to hide about 9/11-- namely, how (if they didn't do it themselves) they knew it was coming and did nothing to stop it.
 
Re: Closed thread ??

Rex1960 said:
I'm one of those non-americans
but since it's 08/20 I say

Send Saddam to Allah, he'll judge.

Bomb Baghdad to make that happen unless you know a better solution.

Iraqi people, all those minorities in the north and south will be happy to see that dictator disappear.
Feed those hungry children, rebuild the infrastructure and make sure there's no lack of power after the soldiers leave battlefield. Install a stable government and administration and welcome back Iraq in the global community.

And for the endless list of interests groups having an eye on this country like Russia, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, the entire muslim world, maybe even China or Europe, not to forget all that big oil business. Iraq without Saddam will be a safer place for all of us.

Rex :rose: :kiss:

See I disagree. I think the average Iraqi will be more likely to fight and die because nobody is pretending that religion isn't a factor. That coupled with the USA being the aggressor this time and bent on occupation. There just might be civilian ambushes and suicide attacks because of the perceived courage the Palestinians display. If you can get away with primarily sending in airstrikes then OK but still it'll kill a lot of civilians and really piss them off for a long time. Remember we can't forget some country's troops will have to be stationed in the vacinity for years afterward. We have freako religious nuts even in America, can only imagine what it is like in the Middle East-I think they'll keep coming even after we feel we've won.

Part of me feels that it is good that Saddam has some alignment with Russia if the war doesn't formulate because maybe it'll keep him from going completely sicknut out of desperation in the near future. At this point I don't think Saddam is insane, more that he wants control and increase his power. Killing his "own people" and adjutants routinely doesn't necessarily mean he has a "death wish" which is what an attack on the USA or Israel would essentially be.
 
Re: Vox Populi, vox dei

REDWAVE said:
The people have spoken. 23 against and only 17 for. There is clearly no consensus for going to war against Iraq.

Sin, old buddy, the market did shoot up yesterday, but so far it's back down again today. The more important and revealing fact yesterday was the leading economic indicators were down. The economy is far from hitting bottom; the worst is yet to come.

Yes, it's been almost a year since 9/11, and still there has been no public investigation of why it happened and what went wrong. (Congress is holding an "investigation," but in secret-- and even its whitewash has been stymied by FBI intimidation, in flagrant violation of the doctrine of separation of powers.) Obviously, the powers that be have a lot to hide about 9/11-- namely, how (if they didn't do it themselves) they knew it was coming and did nothing to stop it.

Now Redwave, surely you're not suggesting that the US WASN"T surprised on 9/11??? After all, they have the biggest secret police services in the world - including the KGB.

And the FBI wouldn't hinder an investigation by a secret Congress Committee, after all they learned in the Warren Commission into the Kennedy assassination that killing off witnesses was much more satisfactory than holding a properly conducted investigation where there was half a chance that the truth would come out.

Gary Allen predicted this situation in his series of books - the conspiracy is going according to plan. The fundamentalist Christians are intent on saving a corrupt capitalism at any expense - and preferably at a huge profit seling military hardware.
 
They knew an airliner was going to hijacked in SEPT 01, but I presume they thought it would be a hostage thing and mainly would stir up domestic support their military ambitions. I don't see how so much confidence can be put in our intelligence and military might to control everything that happens in the MidEast. gulf War 1 is used as an example often times but we are going alone, a different objective, the stakes are higher and not as many perks are available. completely different situation-Don maybe you are lucky to be in a country outta the way and we are lucky to have a department of homeland security.
 
In Reply . . .

70/30 said:
They knew an airliner was going to hijacked in SEPT 01, but I presume they thought it would be a hostage thing and mainly would stir up domestic support their military ambitions. I don't see how so much confidence can be put in our intelligence and military might to control everything that happens in the MidEast. gulf War 1 is used as an example often times but we are going alone, a different objective, the stakes are higher and not as many perks are available. completely different situation-Don maybe you are lucky to be in a country outta the way and we are lucky to have a department of homeland security.

Hi 70/30. I agree that I am lucky to be in an out-of-the-way country. It's just that our politicians want to big note themselves and put us into the middle of somebodyelse's fight. Prime Minister "Pig-Iron Bob" Menzies asked to join in Vietnam (after resigning his Army commission on the first day of WWI) Present Prime Minister "Honest" John Howard of the same political party (Liberals) has emulated his hero Menzies so far by asking to be involved in Iraq . . .

lol As to your Department of Homeland Security . . . well . . . the loss of common law rights for all US citizens is very disturbing for all English Common Law countries because it shows that democracy and legal rights are far more fragile than we would like to believe. Parliament giveth and Parliament taketh away.
 
There is never a clear consensus for war in a civilization. That's what brings them down. People get complacent and want nothing more than peace and to live their lives.

History has shown that to not stand up to tyrants generally leads to far greater repercussions. The barbarians are not at the gates, but they are encamped and engaged in the dances of war. For us to declare “PEACE” is childish at best.

Now to what purpose does Saddam Hussein harbor the likes of Abu Nidal and now, according to Rummy and others outside of America, top Al Qaeda leaders?

Our President said clearly that those who harbor terrorists will be in the crosshairs. Saddam knew that. Nidal was on his turf…
 
In Reply . . .

SINthysist said:
There is never a clear consensus for war in a civilization. That's what brings them down. People get complacent and want nothing more than peace and to live their lives.

History has shown that to not stand up to tyrants generally leads to far greater repercussions. The barbarians are not at the gates, but they are encamped and engaged in the dances of war. For us to declare “PEACE” is childish at best.

Now to what purpose does Saddam Hussein harbor the likes of Abu Nidal and now, according to Rummy and others outside of America, top Al Qaeda leaders?

Our President said clearly that those who harbor terrorists will be in the crosshairs. Saddam knew that. Nidal was on his turf…

Hi SIN,

Have just heard a book launch for John Pilger's "The New Rulers of the World". Another of his "objectively" critical essays well based on official documents outlining how US foreign policy has recently double crossed the tyrants which they put in place under Carter and Reagan. Also an interesting commentary on the family relationships with the "terrorist" regimes of today. Now who was it said that being an Ally of the US was a dangerous business?
 
It's hell . . .

It's hell being a pawn of U.S. imperialism. The U.S. government just uses you, and then casts you aside when it no longer needs you. Just ask Hussein, who was a CIA asset until Bush, Sr. set him up and then turned on him.

Actually, SIN, sometimes there is a clear consensus for war, like right after Pearl Harbor, for instance. But that's a whole different story . . .

I agree we need to stand up to tyrants. That's why I'm standing up against Bush and his plans to turn this country into a police state.
 
Re: It's hell . . .

I agree we need to stand up to tyrants. That's why I'm standing up against Bush and his plans to turn this country into a police state.

LOL! Nice. While you're at it, stand up to Bush funnelling money into religious tax shelters. The last thing we need is Al Queda setting up a homeless shelter or some kind of charity and receiving a tax exemption from the IRS while Bush's pet projects help fund them.

I'd love to be in Australia, sitting on a beach, drinking something Australian when Bush finally gets the appropriate political climate to admit he's always wanted to go to war with Iraq. I wish the economy didn't suck; nobody wants to go to war when there are better jobs. Right now I'm the holder of a fresh computer science degree and I'm waiting tables.
 
All too common

That sort of thing is all too common these days, Schleicher. I'm an unemployed lawyer myself. Capitalism wastes human capabilities to an enormous extent.
 
The Wizard speaks...

"There comes a time when every student and many a passing merchant, farmer, and king, too, demands the same answer of me. Why, O meddler and mighty mage, do ye not set the crooked straight? Why not strike directly against the evils that threaten the world? Why do not all mighty folk of good heart not simply make everything right?

I've heard that cry so many times. Now hearken once and for all, to my answers as to why the great and powerful don't fix Earth entire every day.

First, it is not at all certain that those of us with the power or the inclination can even accomplish a tenth of the deed asked of us. The forces arrayed against us are dark and strong indeed. I might surprise Osama or old Saddam and burn him from the face of the world - or he might do the same to me. It's a rash and short-lived hero who presses for battle when victory is not assured.

Second, the wise amongust us know that even gods can't foresee all the consequences of their actions-and all of us have seen far too many instances of good things turning out to cause something very bad, or unwanted. We've learned that meddling often does far more harm than good.

Third: Few folk can agree on what is right, what should be done, and what the best end result would be. When ye consider a mighty stroke, be assured that every move is apt to be countered by someone who dosen't like the intended result, is determined to stop it, and is quite prepared to lay waste to you, your kingdom, and anything else necessary to confound you.

Point the fourth: Big changes can seldom be effected by small actions. How much work does it take just to build one house? Rearrange one room? How many simple little actions, then, will it take to destroy one kingdom and raise another-with name, ruler, and societal order of your choice-in its place?

Finally: D'ye think we "mighty ones" are blind? Do we not watch each other, and guess at what each is doing, and reach out and do some little thing that hampers the aims of another great and mighty? We'll never be free of this problem, and that's a good thing. I would cower at the thought of living in any world where all the mighty and powerful folk agreed perfectly on everything. That's the way of slavery and shackles and armed tyranny...and if ye'd like to win a bet, wager that ye'll be near the bottom of any such order.

Right. Any more silly questions?"

-Elminster of Shadowdale, with cultural changes by Merlins Boon
 
Back
Top