Should we attack Iraq?

Should the U.S. attack Iraq?

  • Yes

    Votes: 25 36.8%
  • No

    Votes: 31 45.6%
  • Not sure

    Votes: 6 8.8%
  • Where\'s a flirting thread?

    Votes: 6 8.8%

  • Total voters
    68
Re: Re: It's hell . . .

Schleicher said:


LOL! Nice. While you're at it, stand up to Bush funnelling money into religious tax shelters. The last thing we need is Al Queda setting up a homeless shelter or some kind of charity and receiving a tax exemption from the IRS while Bush's pet projects help fund them.

I'd love to be in Australia, sitting on a beach, drinking something Australian when Bush finally gets the appropriate political climate to admit he's always wanted to go to war with Iraq. I wish the economy didn't suck; nobody wants to go to war when there are better jobs. Right now I'm the holder of a fresh computer science degree and I'm waiting tables.

So go to the Oz Embassy and apply. Apply to a multinational computer company for a job in Oz. It's easy - but come conscription for Iraq cannon fodder we will all have to go back to the Vietnam network.
 
Yeah, shifting alliances and Arabs! How funny does it get? REDWAVE, these people turn on EACH other ALL THE TIME! The fact that the United States would do it to them at some point was factoredinto their plans by the VERY NATURE OF WHO THEY ARE :D !



Don, ask ISH! As far as I am concened the only difference between the Gambino family and the Saudis, the Palestinians, the Iraqi's, Mugabee, Iran, Russia, China, you name it, is the degree to which they are either within or outside of the government!

You're only called Mafia when you are outside of the government...

Elsewise you are a MFN member, or an ally in the war on drugs, or an ally in the war on terror,...
 
Pleas note too REDWAVE that with the force of the left-tilted world press against our side, your poll is awfully close...

only 5 votes difference!







Rush Limbaugh's theory is that once again, Bush has gone on vacation and shut up to let his critics go bananas yet again, then he's gonna come back, announce his plans and intentions and just shatter their attack yet one more time.

On September 12, his poll numbers are gonna go back up again. Way Up!
 
SINthysist said:


Our President said clearly that those who harbor terrorists will be in the crosshairs. Saddam knew that. Nidal was on his turf…

So when do we attack Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Lybia, Egypt, etc?
 
mountainman, I am in favor of running the board Risk-style...

...as long as we're there.
 
Opposite

As usual, I have the opposite take on things from you, SINthysist. The overwhelming majority of the people on Lit. are Americans. Even with the constant drumbeat of war propaganda coming from the TV news stations, most Americans oppose aggression against Iraq.

If there was anything like "fair and balanced" news coverage, an overwhelming majority of Americans would be opposed.
 
Too much "if" and "would be" for my taste, dear REDWAVE.

The amount of replies and views on this thread is 82 to 600.
The poll counts 59 votes so far.
That means less than 10% of those viewers have voted.

Does that mean the overwhelming majority has no opinion ?

How do you know what this overwhelming majority of non-voters think about it ?
 
I know your PM is against it!

Obviously, I don't know what the people who didn't vote think. And this poll is unscientific and proves nothing. However, it does indicate clearly that there is far from overwhelming support for an attack on Iraq even in the U.S. And most of the rest of the world is stronly against it-- including your own PM, Gerhard Schroeder.
 
Re: I know your PM is against it!

REDWAVE said:
Obviously, I don't know what the people who didn't vote think. And this poll is unscientific and proves nothing. However, it does indicate clearly that there is far from overwhelming support for an attack on Iraq even in the U.S. And most of the rest of the world is stronly against it-- including your own PM, Gerhard Schroeder.

Same false indicator ??

Just because our Chancelor is against it doesn't mean the majority of germans thinks the way he does.
Just because Mr Blair is pro doesn't mean the Brits are overwhelming pro.

Same thing when you look at the socalled "published opinion" by mass media of all colors.

Oh - before i forget to mention this: Just because a majority has a certain opinion doesn't mean they are right either way, politically or morally.

Since we are discussing about "Should we attack anybody ?", I think even if the majority votes "yes" it doesn't show that we really should..... or viceversa.
Chamberlain voted "No" once, and he was wrong. No doubt about it.

Rex :rose:
 
Hussein ain't Hitler

Oh, come on, Rexie, you know full well Hussein ain't Hitler, and Iraq isn't Nazi Germany. Iraq is not a serious threat to the U.S. Analogies to Munich 1938 are totally misplaced here.

Of course, I agree the majority is not always right. I'm certainly not afraid to take a minority stand, even to stand alone, if I'm truly convinced I'm right. But while the majority is not always right, in a democracy the majority rules, or is supposed to at least. (That sure didn't happen in the last U.S. Presidential election!)

And re German public opinion, I haven't seen any polls, but I would bet almost any amount a majority of Germans are against a U.S. attack on Iraq-- a majority of all Europeans, in fact. For instance, when Bush recently visited Berlin, the anti-Bush demonstrators outnumbered the pro-Bush ones, by a factor of about 100 to 1.

BTW, Rex, since you have a background in German intelligence, what can you tell us about the speculation that the recent takeover of the Iraqi embassy in Berlin was actually done by Western intelligence, either German or U.S? Hmmm?
 
TB4P

Oh, yeah, I live in constant fear of the mighty Iraqi military overrunning the puny, pathetic U.S. Iraq doesn't even have a navy any more, but those Iraqis are strong swimmers. I constantly look out my window, expecting Iraqi paratroopers to land on my head any second now . . .

Puleeeze! Give me a break!
:p
 
Polls and majorities

Has anybody seen public opinion polls regarding US military action in Iraq. I'm talking about intensified action rather than the US military presence in place patrolling the no-fly zone.

While I agree the media doesn't paint any sort of accurate picture of the reasons to go to war, I wonder what a real current public opinion would amount to. Clearly something nasty happening on Sept. 11 again could give Bush the impetus to come out harshly in his "war on terrorism." But really, how many "wars" of that sort have we won? The "war on poverty"? The "war on drugs"? It seems like a sure way to never accomplish anything in this country is to declare war on it...
 
Re: Hussein ain't Hitler

REDWAVE said:
Oh, come on, Rexie, you know full well Hussein ain't Hitler, and Iraq isn't Nazi Germany. Iraq is not a serious threat to the U.S. Analogies to Munich 1938 are totally misplaced here.
Like Nazi Germany was not a serious threat to anybody in Chamberlains eyes. That's the analogy.
And therefor my point is most definately not misplaced here.

What has to happen next before you realise, that Saddam Hussein is a sick weirdo ?
Another killing of the kurds ?
Another killing of the shiite minority in the south ?
Another invasion of Kuweit ? Another war against Iran ?
Ongoing support for all those terrorists hiding under his wings?

Of course, I agree the majority is not always right. I'm certainly not afraid to take a minority stand, even to stand alone, if I'm truly convinced I'm right. But while the majority is not always right, in a democracy the majority rules, or is supposed to at least. (That sure didn't happen in the last U.S. Presidential election!)

We had this discussion about Republic/Democracy earlier. I'm not going into another argument regarding the electial system of the USA since I'm no citizen and it's non of my business...

And re German public opinion, I haven't seen any polls, but I would bet almost any amount a majority of Germans are against a U.S. attack on Iraq-- a majority of all Europeans, in fact. For instance, when Bush recently visited Berlin, the anti-Bush demonstrators outnumbered the pro-Bush ones, by a factor of about 100 to 1.

"In fact" ? See I truly doubt that statement.
Nothing personal REDWAVE.
But these kind of facts are way too often too far away from reality since we both know how polls are manipulated by all involved parties (and i really mean all colors of the political spectrum) and the published opinion doesn't prove anything.

The anti-Bush demonstrators are pretty much the same who demonstrate against nearly everything on the daily political agenda. And most of them are considered only hooligans that like to streetfight against the police whenever they have the chance to.

BTW,Rex, since you have a background in German intelligence, what can you tell us about the speculation that the recent takeover of the Iraqi embassy in Berlin was actually done by Western intelligence, either German or U.S? Hmmm?

To be honest, my background is limited since I left service almost 15 years ago.
One thing I know is that the BND (national intelligence agency) is investigating the activities of that terrorists network here in Germany and outside our country.

It was a group of anti-Hussein activists taking over the iraqi embassy in Berlin as far as I know.
I can't figure out what you're trying to say.
Speculations ? I haven't heard any here.

If you're implying CIA/BND/MI5/Mossad or any other service is trying to manipulate public opinion towards pro "US vs Iraq" wouldn't it be much more clever to act under the flag of terroristic group supported by Saddam let's say taking over US embassy in Israel ??

Rex :rose:
 
Re: TB4P

REDWAVE said:
Oh, yeah, I live in constant fear of the mighty Iraqi military overrunning the puny, pathetic U.S. Iraq doesn't even have a navy any more, but those Iraqis are strong swimmers. I constantly look out my window, expecting Iraqi paratroopers to land on my head any second now . . .

Puleeeze! Give me a break!
:p

Now that you had your break can you

puleeeze

get your brain back to proper work ??

You don't need this lame statement, REDWAVE, you're too clever for that.

Just look at NYCs "Ground Zero" and you know what we are talking about.

Rex :rose:
 
Of ships and sealing wax . . .

Schleicher, the last scientific poll results I've seen showed only about 52% of the American public supported the attack on Iraq, but that was some time ago.

Rex, I find all your points about Saddam singularly unconvincing. The Kurds in northern Iraq have a de facto independent state, under the protection of the U.S. "no fly" zone. Meanwhile, Kurds in Turkey (staunch U.S. "ally"-- i.e., client state) are viciously oppressed. I don't hear Bush calling for the liberation of the Turkish Kurds. The U.S. government is deathly afraid of Iraq becoming another Shiite theocracy like Iran. (BTW, I think the Shiites are the majority in Iraq, comprising 60% of the population). Kuwait? Iraq & Kuwait recently made nice and all kissy face with each other. War with Iran? The U.S. government supported Iraq during its war with Iran, with no criticisms then of Iraq's use of chemical weapons.

Re the embassy takeover, there's a link on www.cursor.org to a story on that.

Finally, the Sept. 11 atacks were a tragedy, but hardly constituted a serious threat of invasion. Also, there's no evidence linking Iraq to 9/11. Besides, something that big can only happen if the U.S. government lets it happen.
 
Re: Re: Hussein ain't Hitler

Rex1960 said:

Like Nazi Germany was not a serious threat to anybody in Chamberlains eyes. That's the analogy.
And therefor my point is most definately not misplaced here.

What has to happen next before you realise, that Saddam Hussein is a sick weirdo ?
Another killing of the kurds ?
Another killing of the shiite minority in the south ?
Another invasion of Kuweit ? Another war against Iran ?
Ongoing support for all those terrorists hiding under his wings?

That's an analogy that reveals your complete and total disregard for any level of intelligence in your opinion. By that logic the US would be totally justified in conquering the Federated Islands of Micronesia. Chamberlain made a gross and fatal calculation, that does not mean that anybody who a country wants to attack is Hitler. Grow up, jackass.
 
Let us consider this from the view point of basic tactics rather than basic vengance, because that is the biggest point of this whole debate. Argue all you like, those seeking the blood of Saddam are doing so out of vengance, the need to strike out at something they hate because they are unable to find Bin-Laden.

However, think carefully on this: We already have troops in Afghanistan searching for Bin-laden and the rest of his terrorist organization. Certanily a great deal of it has been rooted out and broken, but there are still a number of problems there that need resolving, and pulling our military forces out at this point would be a bad mistake.

However, you insist that we strike out at Saddam while we continue to hold ground in Afghanistan. You would have us fight a war on two fronts? You would divide our forces, our resources, and our strategic focus? Forget about politics and morality and look at what you propose from the view point of black and white tactics. The move would be stupid. While we do, indeed, have one of the most powerful military forces on the face of the planet, we are not all powerful. The death toll would be massive, the cost would be astronomical, and the last time we attempted such a feat, we failed to capture the man in question. Are we to press on without learning from our mistakes?

And then there is the matter of the power vaccum. Let us, for the sake of argument, say that we do manage to capture or kill Saddam. You do know he has two sons, correct? You do know that a hundred other would-be warlords would be scrambling to take his place, yes? The ensuing chaos would tear Iraq apart, and would have repercussions that would go well beyond the Middle East.

"Do not be to eager too deal out death and judgement. Even the very wise cannot see all ends."

I've also noticed how easy it is for some of you to sit back and say "To war!" I believe someone mentioned something about we "bleeding hearts" having our heads in the sand? Are you not doing the same? Maybe you don't have friends, family, brothers, sisters, lovers who are a part of the military. Maybe you don't have to worry about what will happen to the nameless soldiers who go off to war because they're no one that you know, six degrees of seperation and all that.

My best friend has lost his job because of the failing economy. He's joining the Marine reserves to help stablize the income for him and his wife. He'll be gone in October for six months and may possibly miss his one year anniversary. If he enjoys what he does, he'll go active duty and put in his time. His father was a Marine, and so for him it's a matter of pride and family tradition. This man is like a brother to me and I have never had more respect for him because of what he is doing. Until you've had friends and family who are soldiers and are willing to go die for what they believe in, then you have no right to flippantly decide where they should go and who should kill them.

Most of us don't have the first fucking clue as to what war is really like. Many of us can't even begin to imagine how real and terrible it is. I don't think there are a great deal of people who can say that they know what it's like to kill a man in battle or what it's like to watch one be killed right beside you. I doubt there are many people on this thread who can say that they've stared Death right in the face.

If you're so willing to go after Saddam, and so willing to let other people die going after him, then maybe you should take up a weapon yourself and see what it's really like to wage war. If you're not willing to do that, then why don't you sit down and shut the fuck up.

I've lost loved ones to cancer, I've lost them to accidents, and I've even lost them to old age. I've never lost someone in a war, and I pray that I never do. As bad as dying can be in this day and age, at least most of the time you don't have to die alone. But those men and women on the front lines...they're more alone than anyone can ever be. Thousands of miles from home, in the middle of a desolate wasteland, slugging it out with people they've never met, people that they know nothing about personally. Yet with every pull of the trigger, they have killed someone's son...someone's father...someone's brother. And the same is true when one of ours dies.

Call us liberal as shit, call us bleeding hearts, call us cowards and whatever other clever little title you can come up with. But the simple fact of the matter is that we do not try to prevent war because we are afraid. We try to prevent war because we have people that we love. I'm not too eager to see my brother go off to war and die. If you can't say the same, then you're just as terrible as they are.
 
Last edited:
Those who will have to actually fight the war are generally the least eager to go to war.
 
Finally Some Realism . . .

Merlins Boon said:

<SNIP>

Call us liberal as shit, call us bleeding hearts, call us cowards and whatever clever little title you can come up with. But the simple fact of the matter is that we do not try to prevent war because we are afraid. We try to prevent war because we have people that we love. I'm not too eager to see my brother go off to war and die. If you can't say the same, then you're just as terrible as they are.

Well said, Merlin.

The Masai have a great way of resolving leadership disputes. Take one cattle yard, collect the village around to witness the proceedings, give each leadership opponent a knife, and the living winner is the new chief.

Can you imagine Dubyah getting into a boxing ring with Saddam Hussein?? Most unlikely.

I have noticed that many posters on these type of threads are either agent provocateurs for the CIA or former military apologists re-living their glory service days by justifying the imperialist policies of an undemocraticaly appointed government.
 
Re: Re: TB4P

Rex1960 said:
Just look at NYCs "Ground Zero" and you know what we are talking about.

Rex :rose:

I look at "Ground Zero" and see a country in a constant state of paranoid xenophobia...

ppman
 
Re: Re: TB4P


Just look at NYCs "Ground Zero" and you know what we are talking about.

Nope, sorry I don't. I don't know what NYC has to do with Iraq. The terrorists involved were largely from Saudi Arabia. If we had solid links between 9/11 and Iraq, I think we'd be getting inundated with them daily throughout every medium of the press. There are probably a lot of things suppressed that the public never sees, but I think this would be a piece of PR Bush would want released.
 
Re: TB4P

REDWAVE said:
Oh, yeah, I live in constant fear of the mighty Iraqi military overrunning the puny, pathetic U.S. Iraq doesn't even have a navy any more, but those Iraqis are strong swimmers. I constantly look out my window, expecting Iraqi paratroopers to land on my head any second now . . .

Puleeeze! Give me a break!
I don't live in fear of the Iraqi military, either. They surrendered to television news crews, for Christ's sake. I fear what would happen if Saddam Hussein gets his hands on an ICBM. I hope, for your sake, that Vegas isn't on his short list of potential targets.

REDWAVE said:
Finally, the Sept. 11 atacks were a tragedy, but hardly constituted a serious threat of invasion.
Fuck invasion. Who cares about invasion? Three thousand people were murdered. I care about that. The buildings representing America's financial strength were destroyed. I care about that. You don't, and that's probably why you're so flippant about September 11. Had they instead chose to strike the Socialist Party Headquarters, or the Eugene V. Debs Museum, you'd probably be screaming bloody murder, though.

REDWAVE said:
Also, there's no evidence linking Iraq to 9/11.
If you mean, "there's no smoking gun with Hussein's fingerprints all over it," then yeah, I guess. But consider also that Mohammed Atta, the September 11 point man, twice risked detection by flying from the U.S. to Prague to visit Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani, an Iraqi agent later expelled from the Czech Republic as a spy. I doubt they talked about how beautiful the Danube was, or Old World architecture.

Besides, whether or not Iraq had a hand, directly or indirectly, in September 11 is entirely irrelevant. It's now our policy that we won't wait for terrorists or nations to strike us, then fight back as a retaliation. We've learned a costly lesson from that paradigm. Hussein is clearly a threat to the United States, and as such, he must go. How anyone can see this as anything but self-evident is an absolute mystery, at least to me. But what do I know? I'm obviously a CIA provocateur or an old military apologist, or just bitter that we haven't captured Osama bin Laden yet and feel the need to strike out of vengeance, or just a hawk who wants to send other people's sons to die. Yeah, that's it. I couldn't have come to this decision rationally.

REDWAVE said:
Besides, something that big can only happen if the U.S. government lets it happen.
Spare me. Ignorance I can see, but you simply cannot say that we "let" three thousand Americans die with nothing more than flawed logic, circumstance, and a virulent hatred of our governmental system and its current chief.

Merlins Boon said:
However, you insist that we strike out at Saddam while we continue to hold ground in Afghanistan. You would have us fight a war on two fronts? You would divide our forces, our resources, and our strategic focus? Forget about politics and morality and look at what you propose from the view point of black and white tactics. The move would be stupid. While we do, indeed, have one of the most powerful military forces on the face of the planet, we are not all powerful.
Oh please. We're hardly "fighting" in Afghanistan anymore, so your whole "two front" argument is bunk. Besides, we committed half a million troops to Desert Shield/Storm with not a whole lot of effort. We wouldn't even need to bring that much if we'd be fighting the same way we did in Afghanistan.

Merlins Boon said:
The death toll would be massive, the cost would be astronomical, and the last time we attempted such a feat, we failed to capture the man in question. Are we to press on without learning from our mistakes?
A "massive" death toll? You've got to be kidding me.

And so what if Saddam disappears and we never find him? That's exactly what we want: a regime change. If we force him to abdicate and he loses control of his resources, that's exactly what we want.

Merlins Boon said:
And then there is the matter of the power vaccum. Let us, for the sake of argument, say that we do manage to capture or kill Saddam. You do know he has two sons, correct? You do know that a hundred other would-be warlords would be scrambling to take his place, yes? The ensuing chaos would tear Iraq apart, and would have repercussions that would go well beyond the Middle East.
OK, then let us also say, for the sake of argument, that suddenly tomorrow every human being on earth develops immunity to chemical and biological weapons, and that a meteor lands on Baghdad and destroys it, or that Jesus Christ returns to earth. Yes, I know, I'm being silly, and not drawing analogous comparisons, but still: It's patently absurd to make foreign policy decisions based on "for the sake of argument" conjectures, because anything is possible.

It's never acceptable to simply avoid following the responsible course of action simply because the alternative "might" be worse? "Gee, maybe we shouldn't declare independence against Britain, because, just for the sake of argument, what if this whole self-government, rule-by-the-people thing is worse than serving a king?" "Boy, you know, that Hitler is a bad dude, but we shouldn't act to stop him because you never know, Himmler or 100 other people may want to take his place."

Besides, that argument was made before striking the Taliban, and it was proven to be silly then. Here, I'll throw a bone to Don K Dyck and the rest of you conspiracy theorists: whoever takes over in Iraq will have incentive to be friends with us — an end to the U.N. sanctions and renewed oil trade with the U.S.. They get money, we get lower prices at the gas pumps. I call that a win/win situation.

Oh, and one more thing: looking a potential enemy in the eyes and blinking because of fear is worse than any situation that could occur if we move to stop it. You don't accomodate evil, you don't contain evil, you don't allow for evil, and you don't appease evil — you destroy it.

TB4p
 
Back
Top