So, this global warming thing...

islandman

今
Joined
Apr 10, 2001
Posts
66,716
If it's not real, that means that literally thousands of scientists are lying.

I'm having a hard time wrapping my brain around such a scenario.
 
Well, first it's not global warming, it's climate change.

Seasons will shift and weather patterns will become more intense. Winters will be colder, and summers will be hotter. Spring and fall are shortened in length.

Second, you are right. The choice is to believe a bunch of pols with no degree in the subject, or believe thousands of scientists who have dedicated their life to studying it.

I wouldn't go to my congressman for dental work, but many seem to run to them for scientific research.
 
Who are you going to believe? A bunch of talking suits, or your own lying eyes?

:kiss:
 
Well, first it's not global warming, it's climate change.

Seasons will shift and weather patterns will become more intense. Winters will be colder, and summers will be hotter. Spring and fall are shortened in length.

Second, you are right. The choice is to believe a bunch of pols with no degree in the subject, or believe thousands of scientists who have dedicated their life to studying it.

I wouldn't go to my congressman for dental work, but many seem to run to them for scientific research.

Fair points.

But I could also make the case that scientists on the other side of the equation "know" that climate change due to humanity is wrong.

I'll grant you that these scientists appear to have smaller numbers, but still, are they the ones lying?

Food for thought.
 
Fair points.

But I could also make the case that scientists on the other side of the equation "know" that climate change due to humanity is wrong.

I'll grant you that these scientists appear to have smaller numbers, but still, are they the ones lying?

Food for thought.

Follow the money. The scientists that take that position are also paid by oil companies for writing those papers. Give me any profession and I will show you someone who is greedy enough to write anything for the right sum, even if they know it's a lie or don't even believe what they are writing.

For them, it's not about the environment, it's about the economics.
 
Follow the money. The scientists that take that position are also paid by oil companies for writing those papers. Give me any profession and I will show you someone who is greedy enough to write anything for the right sum, even if they know it's a lie or don't even believe what they are writing.

For them, it's not about the environment, it's about the economics.

Conversely, don't scientists who espouse climate change receive grants to further their research?

Seems as though the money trail leads both ways.
 
Look at the reduced size of the Arctic Ice Sheet this year.

Something is happening.

What, and Why?

There are many contradictory explanations but it is shrinking more than ever.

That could mean wetter summers and cooler weather for the UK depending on the ice sheet's effect on the jet stream.

It will mean climate change, but climate is always changing, just not as fast as it has been in recent years.
 
Anthropogenic climate change is a theory. I tend to trust it, due to the number of scientists that espouse it. Nonetheless, it's still just a theory. To take it in context, the top scientists used to believe that the sun revolved around a flat earth.
 
Everyone lies and when billions in research grants and tenured careers are at stake, picking the right lie is important.

It so happens that most scientists are now on board with 'climate change is occurring', but a vocal group still wishes to deny human causation, as if it matters at this point - we can only control the human factors in our attempts to mitigate the effects.

I see no 'lose scenario' if we develop a carbon free energy grid or low carbon energy grid except for the coal miner who will need to retrain as a windmill installer or solar panel assembler.
 
Look at the reduced size of the Arctic Ice Sheet this year.

Something is happening.

What, and Why?

There are many contradictory explanations but it is shrinking more than ever.

That could mean wetter summers and cooler weather for the UK depending on the ice sheet's effect on the jet stream.

It will mean climate change, but climate is always changing, just not as fast as it has been in recent years.

As I understand it, the argument isn't over whether climate change is real and accelerating, but whether humans are principally responsible for the change in rate.
 
Climate change is a reality. The only real problem is when data is cherry picked to create a specific sense of cause.

Some lies were due to being true believers and thinking they were saving the planet. Some were just based on not looking at the range of geologic time.

Also, if you say Global Warming as caused by man is not the absolute truth, get ready to be pilloried in the marketplace unless you have Republican friends.

I don't know the answers, but I know that I don't know.
 
Only an old useless fool would make climate change about politics.

It's quite pathetic.
 
Everyone lies and when billions in research grants and tenured careers are at stake, picking the right lie is important.

It so happens that most scientists are now on board with 'climate change is occurring', but a vocal group still wishes to deny human causation, as if it matters at this point - we can only control the human factors in our attempts to mitigate the effects.

I see no 'lose scenario' if we develop a carbon free energy grid or low carbon energy grid except for the coal miner who will need to retrain as a windmill installer or solar panel assembler.

Undergroung nuclear experiments under the polar ice caps must be performed.
 
As I understand it, the argument isn't over whether climate change is real and accelerating, but whether humans are principally responsible for the change in rate.

Most scientific argument is about the scale of change attributable to human activity.

What is certain is that one major volcanic eruption such as Kratakoa could cause more change in one event than all the human activity.
 
I see no 'lose scenario' if we develop a carbon free energy grid or low carbon energy grid except for the coal miner who will need to retrain as a windmill installer or solar panel assembler.

I see a "lose scenario", albeit a temporary one, in which industries will need to retool in order to fully utilize said grid(s)
 
Most scientific argument is about the scale of change attributable to human activity.

What is certain is that one major volcanic eruption such as Kratakoa could cause more change in one event than all the human activity.

Yes. If you limit your data to after the little ice age it looks terribly alarming. That was why "An Inconvenient Truth" made me so very angry. Whether or not Al Gore made that choice himself or just bought the idea from someone else, it was scientific fraud.

If you look before that, like to ice cores back 600,000 years, it looks different.
 
Most scientific argument is about the scale of change attributable to human activity.

What is certain is that one major volcanic eruption such as Kratakoa could cause more change in one event than all the human activity.

Well, sure.

But in the absence of any such event, are we the change?
 
Back
Top