Angeline
Poet Chick
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2002
- Posts
- 27,191
I know Zhuk from when he used to post here, and I'm sure he wasn't casting aspersions on anna or this thread. I think everyone here agrees it's an excellent thread and really appreciates that anna puts the work in to share this information.
And RainMan is right that one person's crap is someone else's gold, but who here hasn't looked at poetry in so-called top journals/magazines, etc., and thought "I know I've written better poems than that"? I sure have and not because I think what I write is so good, but because I know that a place like, say, New Yorker will leap to publish pretty much whatever Poet X of Reputation X submits. That is a sort of cronyism and it's just, imo, a reality of poetry publishing. I've read poems by everyone who posts in this thread, as well as others on this forum, that I think are as good or better than stuff I seen in the "best places."
I think I've been lucky to be accepted by some of the zines in this thread. They may not all post top tier poets--in terms of reputation--but most of them publish really good poetry, which is what matters most, at least to me.
Maybe someday I'll be in New Yorker, most likely not though I'll keep trying to get into more selective journals. Isn't that what many here are trying to do? I feel like I'm on a path with my writing that I'll stay on no matter where it takes me. It's the journey, not the destination and the writing is the journey.
And RainMan is right that one person's crap is someone else's gold, but who here hasn't looked at poetry in so-called top journals/magazines, etc., and thought "I know I've written better poems than that"? I sure have and not because I think what I write is so good, but because I know that a place like, say, New Yorker will leap to publish pretty much whatever Poet X of Reputation X submits. That is a sort of cronyism and it's just, imo, a reality of poetry publishing. I've read poems by everyone who posts in this thread, as well as others on this forum, that I think are as good or better than stuff I seen in the "best places."
I think I've been lucky to be accepted by some of the zines in this thread. They may not all post top tier poets--in terms of reputation--but most of them publish really good poetry, which is what matters most, at least to me.
Maybe someday I'll be in New Yorker, most likely not though I'll keep trying to get into more selective journals. Isn't that what many here are trying to do? I feel like I'm on a path with my writing that I'll stay on no matter where it takes me. It's the journey, not the destination and the writing is the journey.