cantdog
Waybac machine
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2004
- Posts
- 10,791
dr_mabeuse said:No, and the fact that there aren't any blue monkeys flying out of my butt doesn't mean that there will never be blue monkeys flying out of my butt. I mean, sure, there could be all sorts of evidence we don't know about, but it's kind of silly to start building castles in the air. Maybe Jesus was an extraterrestrial, or maybe he had a drinking problem, or maybe he was high on ergot fungus and that's why he thought he was God on earth (that's someone else's theory). In other words, if all bets are off, then all bets are off and anything is possible.
In Tom Robbins' The Last Roadside Attraction, the secret is that the Vatican has Jesus' body down in the vault, which means that the whole resurrection was a fraud. Now that's a secret worth keeping!
---dr.M.
The closest thing to a contemporary record is the Gospels and the works of Josephus, who chronicled the Jewish revolt (Masada and all that). There are indeed some references in Josephus which may be to this Joshua or Jeshua fellow. The early church left some traces, but again, a century later.
What language the sources use is really moot, I think, doc.
But all bets, especially absolutely all bets, I don't think can be off. You'd have to harmonize your wild tale of speculation with some of the sources in the epistles and the gospels, Josephus (although his doesn't limit you much, frankly) and Justin Martyr, the Coptic Christian traditions, and so on. But there's room for a lot of movement.
I like the Wandering Jew stories, myself. At one point Christ tells a crowd that not everyone in the crowd will have died by the time the Kingdom comes. This has been taken to mean that one member of the crowd lives on even today. So there's the Wandering Jew tradition. It's a wonderful foil for satire, a real outside observer.
