The Post-Filibuster Scoreboard

RobDownSouth

Stop The Genocide
Joined
Apr 13, 2002
Posts
81,124
Post-filibuster reform scorecard:
  • Deborah Lee James - Secretary of the Air Force.
  • Heather Anne Higginbottom - Deputy Secretary of State
  • Patricia M. Wald - Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board
  • Elizabeth A. Wolford - United States District Judge
  • Landya McCafferty, of New Hampshire - United States District Judge
  • Brian Morris - United States District Judge
  • Susan P. Watters - United States District Judge
  • Chai Rachel Feldblum- EEOC
  • Cornelia Pillard - United States District Judge
  • Mel Watt -Director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency
  • Patricia Ann Millett - United States District Judge
  • Anne W. Patterson - Assistant Secretary of State (Near Eastern Affairs) 12/16
  • Jeh Charles Johnson - Secretary of Homeland Security 12/16

Score so far: America 13, Republicans 0

Republicans filibustered each of the above nominees according to filibuster rules: they got up and talked about why each of the above nominees were unfit to hold public office.

After their complaints were duly noted, an up-or-down vote was held on each of the nominees. Each of the above nominees was confirmed by majority vote of the United States Senate.

The system works.
 
Last edited:
Were there arguments presented about why each of the above nominees were unfit to hold public office?

Cause there were no such arguments voiced för many of the nominees before, when they were Boeing held up just because.
 
Were there arguments presented about why each of the above nominees were unfit to hold public office?

Cause there were no such arguments voiced för many of the nominees before, when they were Boeing held up just because.
godddamnautocorrect
 
Were there arguments presented about why each of the above nominees were unfit to hold public office?

Cause there were no such arguments voiced för many of the nominees before, when they were Boeing held up just because.

y'know, that's an excellent question.

I'll see if I can find some sort of Congressional Record activity, I'd be interested in reading exactly what the 'for the record' objections the Republicans had for these fine nominees.
 
The Republicans filibustered Susan P. Watters, of Montana, to be United States District Judge for the District of Montana, Nomination Confirmed (77-19).. and then she was confirmed with a solid vote.

Deborah Lee James, of Virginia, to be Secretary of the Air Force Confirmed: 79-6


Why were they being filibustered if Republicans supported their confirmation all along?
 
Heather Higgenbottom, nominee for Deputy Secretary of State confirmed 74-14.
 
Elizabeth Wolford confirmed District Court Judge confirmed 70-28.
 
Jeh Johnson to Homeland Security, 78-16.

Dem: Can we get this done?
GOP: No!
Dem: Please?
GOP: No!
Dem: Why not?
GOP: Because no!
Dem: That's not really an answ...
GOP: Fuck you, no!
Dem: You know what? I'm not even gonna ask what you think.
GOP: No! Er... I mean yes! I meant yes all along!
 
We now know "RobDumbSouth" is an alt troll.

Nobody is this anti-Constitution. Even someone who is this obsessed with Republiphobic hate is this anti-Constitution.

"RobDumbSouth" now exposed.
 
Oh, also, it appears DumbSouth might be Rory, since Rory regularly uses the stupid Thumbs Up and Thumbs Down next to her thread titles.
 
We now know "RobDumbSouth" is an alt troll.

Nobody is this anti-Constitution. Even someone who is this obsessed with Republiphobic hate is this anti-Constitution.

"RobDumbSouth" now exposed.

I don't agree that changing the rules was the right thing to do. Or at least that doing it this way was the best way. But a) it's constitutional and you know it, and b) it did expose beyond a shadow of a doubt that the nominees were being blocked for political sabotage, not because the nominees were unacceptable.
 
I don't agree that changing the rules was the right thing to do. Or at least that doing it this way was the best way. But a) it's constitutional and you know it, and b) it did expose beyond a shadow of a doubt that the nominees were being blocked for political sabotage, not because the nominees were unacceptable.

Ok, maybe "Constitutional" in a strict sense of the term. Why is DumbSouth so obsessed with this though? He's been going on for weeks about how great this is, always with that stupid "Thumbs Up" sign next to the thread title.
 
Ok, maybe "Constitutional" in a strict sense of the term. Why is DumbSouth so obsessed with this though? He's been going on for weeks about how great this is, always with that stupid "Thumbs Up" sign next to the thread title.

Everyone has their pet peeves. Why are you so obsessed with Mandela?
 
Ok, maybe "Constitutional" in a strict sense of the term. Why is DumbSouth so obsessed with this though? He's been going on for weeks about how great this is, always with that stupid "Thumbs Up" sign next to the thread title.

Sounds like you's a pressed basic beige bitch, Renard.
 
Were there arguments presented about why each of the above nominees were unfit to hold public office?

Cause there were no such arguments voiced för many of the nominees before, when they were Boeing held up just because.

I don't think they had a concrete objection to any of them as individuals. In a lot of cases, it was simply that they don't agree that a particular agency "should" exist, or that the sorts of people a Democratic president would appoint would make the kinds of decisions they would agree with (the woman at the EEOC, or Mel Watt).

In the case of the three people nominated for the D.C. Circuit, they were pretty open about it: they were going to filibuster anyone Obama sent up due to a desire to preserve what had been a 4-4 Republican/Democrat tie on what's normally an 11-person court (though one that still leans Republican because retired judges, almost all of whom are Republican-appointed, still have duties here and there).

I think most of it can be summed up by the argument you see on the GB all the time, which is that there was something inherently unfair about Obama winning an election, so they have the right to lash out.
 
I don't think they had a concrete objection to any of them as individuals. In a lot of cases, it was simply that they don't agree that a particular agency "should" exist, or that the sorts of people a Democratic president would appoint would make the kinds of decisions they would agree with (the woman at the EEOC, or Mel Watt).

In the case of the three people nominated for the D.C. Circuit, they were pretty open about it: they were going to filibuster anyone Obama sent up due to a desire to preserve what had been a 4-4 Republican/Democrat tie on what's normally an 11-person court (though one that still leans Republican because retired judges, almost all of whom are Republican-appointed, still have duties here and there).

I think most of it can be summed up by the argument you see on the GB all the time, which is that there was something inherently unfair about Obama winning an election, so they have the right to lash out.

And the funny part about that, is that once a judge gets the lifetime gig, they are notoriously independent. Sure they have their own ideology, but who nominated them is no real indicator of what they will do on the bench.

Case in point: A district court judge appointed by GWB just declared the NSAs collection of phone records unconstitutional - in direct opposition to a USSC decision he said was outdated.
 
How many to go, now? That is, are there more unconfirmed nominees in the pipeline?

They are debating the Commissioner of the IRS and the Deputy Secretary of Homeland Security today. Not sure how many are left.
 
Why is DumbSouth so obsessed with this though?

Well, who staffs the highest federal executive and judicial offices, and whether the offices go vacant because of partisan gridlock, is all pretty damned important, isn't it?
 
:rolleyes: So let them propose a plain honest bill to abolish the agency. If it passes it passes, if it fails it fails.

They don't have the votes, and they have a Landslideresque inability to accept the will of the people. Therefore, they've rationalized their actions "by any means necessary" to accomplish their primary goal: "Better Murica Fail Than A Negro President Succeed".
 
Back
Top