"Top Kill" fails

Yes.

No amount of regulation was going to prevent it either, all it does is retard everyone else, including any potential competition to BP. As bad as a Monopoly is a State-Directed Oligarchy.


So, in essence you're saying that we should get rid of the regulations on dumping chemicals in streams and lakes - because an up-and coming chemical company might not be able to afford disposing of their toxic waste according to existing regulations, and that company might be the one to cure cancer?

And after he cures cancer - we can sue him to make him clean up the mess?
 
So, in essence you're saying that we should get rid of the regulations on dumping chemicals in streams and lakes - because an up-and coming chemical company might not be able to afford disposing of their toxic waste according to existing regulations, and that company might be the one to cure cancer?

And after he cures cancer - we can sue him to make him clean up the mess?

Sort of like Pelosi saying let the drugs through the border, the money is better spent on rehab.
 
Sort of like Pelosi saying let the drugs through the border, the money is better spent on rehab.

I happen to agree with legalisation and regulation for sale of most drugs. We've spent hundreds of billions fighting them for 60 years, maybe it's time for a different approach.

It is clear that we've lost the war on drugs by fighting it with cops and prisons.
 
I happen to agree with legalisation and regulation for sale of most drugs. We've spent hundreds of billions fighting them for 60 years, maybe it's time for a different approach.

It is clear that we've lost the war on drugs by fighting it with cops and prisons.

"War on Drugs" is an oxymoron.

Unless the drug is Nazi-invented methamphetamine.

:p
 
Yes.

No amount of regulation was going to prevent it either, all it does is retard everyone else, including any potential competition to BP. As bad as a Monopoly is a State-Directed Oligarchy.

The role of government is to provide justice to the harmed because as we can clearly see, they can't protect them because they make political decisions, not business decisions, not scientific decisions, but decisions based on the industry experts and the deep pockets that provide their means to reelection.
Have you ever heard of "building codes"? Don't you ever wonder why earthquakes of equivalent force that cause minimal damage in the US kill tens of thousands in Mexico or Armenia? Do you regard such "regulations" as stifling free enterprise?

BP was cutting corners, and it's not true that government-enforced standards wouldn't have prevented what happened.

From what you're saying, apparently you'd be in favor of the abolishment of the Atomic Energy Commission. Let's just let "private industry" and the "profit motive" do things as they see fit, and after America's Chernobyl, the government can "provide justice to the harmed."

The only problem with your plan is that the government may not have deep enough pockets to provide "justice" to 10,000 dead and 100,000 victims of cancer, or to the entire midwest where crops can't be grown for 50 years because of radioactive fallout.

__________________
It was Thomas Edison who brought us electricity, not the Sierra Club. It was the Wright brothers who got us off the ground, not the Federal Aviation Administration. It was Henry Ford who ended the isolation of millions of Americans by making the automobile affordable, not Ralph Nader.
Thomas Sowell
I normally enjoy Sowell, but he must be getting old, to string three tautologies together as though three times zero meaning would have more than zero meaning.
 
So, in essence you're saying that we should get rid of the regulations on dumping chemicals in streams and lakes - because an up-and coming chemical company might not be able to afford disposing of their toxic waste according to existing regulations, and that company might be the one to cure cancer?

And after he cures cancer - we can sue him to make him clean up the mess?

I'm saying mostly that the regulations won't stop the dumping; they never really do. The desire to be a good steward, a good citizen, and the business maxim of perception will rule most companies.

Regulation protects the existing and closes the door to opportunity hurting the poor, women and minorities the most, for they don't possess the connections and observed educations that the sons and daughters of privilege are afforded.

As time goes by, as per DeTocqueville, the men at the top truly become corrupt and greedy and regulation and becoming infused with government to create Aristotle's Oligarchy is the best way to do that, step one being to turn a Republic into a Democracy so that the selfish mob can loot the "selfish" man whose only calrion call to government is "Get out of my way (just let me create, yes I might get rich, but I'll employ people too...)."

Two of my favorite writings go to this (sorry about the length):

When you work in a modern factory, you are paid, not only for your labor, but for all the productive genius which has made that factory possible: for the work of the industrialist who built it, for the work of the investor who saved money to risk on the untried and new, for the work of the engineer who designed who designed the machines of which you are pushing the levers, for the inventor who create the product on which you spend your time making, for the work of the scientist who discovered the laws that went into the making of that product, for the work of the philosopher who taught men how to think and whom you spend your time denouncing.
...
Every man is free to rise as far as he's able or willing, but it's only to the degree that he thinks that determines the degree to which he'll rise. Physical labor as such can extend no further than the range of the moment. The man who does no more than physical labor, consumes the equivalent of the material value-equivalent of his own contribution to the process of production and leaves no further value neither for himself, nor others. ... Material products can't be shared, they belong to some ultimate consumer; it is only the values of an idea which can be shared in unlimited numbers of men making all sharer's richer at no one's sacrifice or loss, raising the productive capacity of whatever labor they perform.
...
In proportion to the mental energy he spent, the man who creates a new invention receives but a small percentage of his value in terms of material payment, no matter what fortune he makes, no matter what millions he earns. But the man who works as a janitor in the factory producing that invention receives an enormous payment in proportion to the mental effort that his job requires of him. And the same is true of all men between, on all levels of ambition and ability. The man at the top of the intellectual pyramid contributes the most to all those below him, getting nothing except his material payment, receiving no intellectual bonus from others to add to the value of his time. The man at the bottom, who left to himself, would starve in his hopeless ineptitude, contributes nothing to those above him, but receives the bonus of all their brains. Such is the nature of the 'competition' between the strong and the weak of the intellect. Such is the pattern of 'exploitation' for which you have damned the strong.

John Galt (Ayn Rand)
Atlas Shrugged

I was one of America's first TV consumer reporters. I approached the job with an attitude. If companies ripped people off, I would embarrass them on TV—and demand that government do something. (I now regret the latter—the former was a good thing.)
I clearly had a point of view: I was a crusader out to punish corporate bullies. My colleagues liked it. I got job offers. I won 19 Emmys. I was invited to speak at journalism conferences.

Then, gradually, I figured out that business, for the most part, treats consumers pretty well. The way to get rich in business is to create something good, sell it for a reasonable price, acquire a reputation for honesty, and keep pleasing customers so they come back for more.

As a local TV reporter, I could find plenty of crooks. But once I got to the national stage—20/20 and Good Morning America—it was hard to find comparable national scams. There were some: Enron, Bernie Madoff, etc. But they are rare. In a $14 trillion economy, you'd think there'd be more. But there aren't.

I figured out why: Market forces, even when hampered by government, keep scammers in check. Reputation matters. Word gets out. Good companies thrive, and bad ones atrophy. Regulation barely deters the cheaters, but competition does.

It made me want to learn more about free markets. I subscribed to Reason magazine and read Cato Institute research papers. Then Milton Friedman, Friedrich Hayek, and Aaron Wildavsky.

My reporting changed. I started taking skeptical looks at government—especially regulation. I did an ABC TV special, "Are We Scaring You to Death?" that said we TV reporters often make hysterical claims about chemicals, pollution, and other relatively minor risks. Its good ratings—16 million viewers—surprised my colleagues.

Suddenly, I wasn't so popular with them.

I stopped winning Emmys.

John Stossel (NeoLibertarian)
Reason.com

You see, in an objective government, the real crooks are pretty much small fry who get weeded out at the bottom. Perhaps, in a real competitive market where they had to worry about their reputation due to true market forces, BP would have worried a bit more about their reputation, but it really looks like they had been buying influence and indulgences for years...

;) ;)
__________________
The Executive power in our government is not the only, perhaps not even the principle, object of my solicitude. The Tyranny of the Legislature is really the danger most to be feared, and will continue to be so for many years to come. The Tyranny of the Executive power will come in its turn, but at a more distant time.
Thomas Jefferson
 
Have you ever heard of "building codes"? Don't you ever wonder why earthquakes of equivalent force that cause minimal damage in the US kill tens of thousands in Mexico or Armenia? Do you regard such "regulations" as stifling free enterprise?

BP was cutting corners, and it's not true that government-enforced standards wouldn't have prevented what happened.

From what you're saying, apparently you'd be in favor of the abolishment of the Atomic Energy Commission. Let's just let "private industry" and the "profit motive" do things as they see fit, and after America's Chernobyl, the government can "provide justice to the harmed."

The only problem with your plan is that the government may not have deep enough pockets to provide "justice" to 10,000 dead and 100,000 victims of cancer, or to the entire midwest where crops can't be grown for 50 years because of radioactive fallout.

I normally enjoy Sowell, but he must be getting old, to string three tautologies together as though three times zero meaning would have more than zero meaning.

Have you ever heard of a time when industries set and lived by their own standards since they had the expertise and the know how assembled, rather than having to go through an expensive middle-man called government?

Hell, up until this administration, I believe that's how your doctor worked.

Any complaints?
 
Nice example Byron of what happens when an industry is run by and protected by the state...
It is. Very much so.

It's an example of what happens in the absence of checks and balances.

Chernobyl, Bhopal, and BP's new fiasco are all great examples of this principle.

The government has no business "running" any business. That's not oversight, that's direct involvement.
 
Having fun Byron? :)

Dude, I can appreciate the point you're trying to make but you're not quite pulling it off. The facts are that Chernobyl WAS a government operation. As a matter of fact virtually all major reactor incidents, and all of those associated with loss of life, were government operations.

So to imply that the government is required to oversee the operations of these facilities inorder to insure safety flies in the face of the historical facts.

Now, I don't disagree that some safety oversight HAS to be in place, I'm merely pointing out that the government is not a panacea that should leave us feeling all warm and fuzzy because their track record is worse than industry.

I don't think there's a perfect solution but I would prefer to see the actual inspections being done by employees of the states that have nuclear generation facilities and that the federal government restricts itself to setting the requirements and required training for the state inspectors, as well as test administration for certification. Along with periodic 'pop quizes' of said employees. For obvious reasons the Feds would retain control of the fuel and waste.

Ishmael
 
Have you ever heard of a time when industries set and lived by their own standards since they had the expertise and the know how assembled, rather than having to go through an expensive middle-man called government?
That time is now in Mexico City.

Hell, up until this administration, I believe that's how your doctor worked.

Any complaints?
Yes, actually.
 
Mexico City does not have an Objective form of Jurisprudence.





I see your photo gallery as another appeal to emotion.





Bring your reason to this fight bro...

;) ;)
 
Having fun Byron? :)

Dude, I can appreciate the point you're trying to make but you're not quite pulling it off. The facts are that Chernobyl WAS a government operation. As a matter of fact virtually all major reactor incidents, and all of those associated with loss of life, were government operations.

So to imply that the government is required to oversee the operations of these facilities inorder to insure safety flies in the face of the historical facts.

Now, I don't disagree that some safety oversight HAS to be in place, I'm merely pointing out that the government is not a panacea that should leave us feeling all warm and fuzzy because their track record is worse than industry.

I don't think there's a perfect solution but I would prefer to see the actual inspections being done by employees of the states that have nuclear generation facilities and that the federal government restricts itself to setting the requirements and required training for the state inspectors, as well as test administration for certification. Along with periodic 'pop quizes' of said employees. For obvious reasons the Feds would retain control of the fuel and waste.

Ishmael

I, and a thousand other absolute cold-dead stoners were allowed to build a nuke plant right under the nose of Big Brother...

THAT alone should give one pause...

;) ;) :D

DOH!








...nuts... Hmmmmmmmmmmm....

:nana:
 
The problem is bro, once you're willing to give an inch, the Left wants that green mile...





At any rate, should the Nuke in Kansas melt down, there's gonna be little compensation...



IT'S KANSAS! (Any day now, the last person is going to turn out the lights... :D )
 
Having fun Byron? :)
Yes!

Dude, I can appreciate the point you're trying to make but you're not quite pulling it off. The facts are that Chernobyl WAS a government operation. As a matter of fact virtually all major reactor incidents, and all of those associated with loss of life, were government operations.
I'm well aware of that. You may be missing my point.

When power is concentrated in one place, that's the definition of despotism.

That applies to private corporations as well as to the Soviet government.

So to imply that the government is required to oversee the operations of these facilities inorder to insure safety flies in the face of the historical facts.
So, you think it would be a good idea to do away with the AEC, also?

Now, I don't disagree that some safety oversight HAS to be in place,
Oops...

I'm merely pointing out that the government is not a panacea that should leave us feeling all warm and fuzzy because their track record is worse than industry.
Government needs to set standards and make sure they're enforced, not run the show. It's actually a lot less expensive that way.

I don't think there's a perfect solution but I would prefer to see the actual inspections being done by employees of the states that have nuclear generation facilities and that the federal government restricts itself to setting the requirements and required training for the state inspectors, as well as test administration for certification. Along with periodic 'pop quizes' of said employees. For obvious reasons the Feds would retain control of the fuel and waste.
^ I agree with that.
 
A free market dissipates that power, maybe not soon enough for the observer of the moment, but given time, even the Medici's eventually fell.



Like you say, this is an example of what happens when a company feels its partnership with a corrupt Mexican/Chicago-style government has protected it from the slings and arrows...

What's the answer to the Hilton fortune? We'll always have Paris!
 
Back
Top