"Top Kill" fails

Nice example Byron of what happens when an industry is run by and protected by the state...


By a state which placed no value on its citizens, and only on its ruling class.

How different than an industry run only for the gain of its stockholders and Board of Directors? Want to see those pics - they're on the news every day now and on the beaches.
 
By a state which placed no value on its citizens, and only on its ruling class.

How different than an industry run only for the gain of its stockholders and Board of Directors? Want to see those pics - they're on the news every day now and on the beaches.

Again, it appears that BP was tighter with the administration than any of the above. They were buying indulgences from the Holy State Religion of Gaia's Priest Class. Only you and I are small enough to actually go to hell...

Did you read the Stossel?
 
Last edited:
By a state which placed no value on its citizens, and only on its ruling class.

How different than an industry run only for the gain of its stockholders and Board of Directors? Want to see those pics - they're on the news every day now and on the beaches.

Sorry K, your argument falls apart. Government is by definition a monopoly and in may respects has an even worse record as far as ecological responsibility than many for the corporations you're slamming with your sarcasm.

Now, if I were an executive with 'Mighty Green Oil Company' I'd be all over this like stink on shit.

<start montage of oil encrusted dead birds, belly-up fish, blackened beaches>

Voice over - "We've all seen the results of the mismanagement and incompetence of some of the companies in our industry. The unparalleled destruction of our precious natural heritage."

"We at 'Mighty Green Oil' have dedicated ourselves to the protection of our childrens legacy and as such we are going to donate a portion of the profit of EVERY gallon of gasoline that you purchase from 'Mighty Green Oil' to an environemntal fund to help clean up these messes, yes, even messes made by our irresponsible competitors."

<start montage of happy birds nesting in tidal marshes, cute fish, adorable otters>

"'Mighty Green Oil, the responsible petroleum company."


There, that ought to be good for a 5pt jump in market share.

Ishmael
 
Again, it appears that BP was tighter with the administration than any of the above. They were buying indulgences from the Holy State Religion of Gaia's Priest Class. Only you and I are small enough to actually go to hell...

Did you read the Stossel?


Yes, and as usual, it is only partially relevant. When speaking of the local level crooks who can be dealt with by competition (garages, grocers, etc..) it is one thing. When dealing with a hundred billion dollar multi-national company who has politicians in every pocket and lawyers in both hands, it is quit another thing.

Without government standards (applied by an impartial government inspector), industry has consistently proved that it will cut every possible corner and damned be the consequences. The vaunted good stewardship generally begins and ends in the PR department but the boardroom talks differently.

Nobody here, Byron or me is demanding that Government take over anything. Only that Government (because nobody else can) set standards - tough standards and your sacred Randian innovation can then work to meeting them. They'll still reap Rand's rewards for being the best and brightest - only they'll have to keep working their minds instead of sitting on their lawyer... er laurels.
 
Sorry K, your argument falls apart. Government is by definition a monopoly and in may respects has an even worse record as far as ecological responsibility than many for the corporations you're slamming with your sarcasm.
Her argument holds just fine.

What's the difference between a government (like the USSR) which has no restrictions on its operations and isn't accountable to the people, and a private corporation which has no restrictions on its operations and isn't accountable to the people?
 
Sorry K, your argument falls apart. Government is by definition a monopoly and in may respects has an even worse record as far as ecological responsibility than many for the corporations you're slamming with your sarcasm.


Her point holds together quite well. Remove accountability and restrictions, and it really makes little difference in the end if it is a Government or a Corporation that destroyed your property and/or life.
 
Yes, and as usual, it is only partially relevant. When speaking of the local level crooks who can be dealt with by competition (garages, grocers, etc..) it is one thing. When dealing with a hundred billion dollar multi-national company who has politicians in every pocket and lawyers in both hands, it is quit another thing.

Without government standards (applied by an impartial government inspector), industry has consistently proved that it will cut every possible corner and damned be the consequences. The vaunted good stewardship generally begins and ends in the PR department but the boardroom talks differently.

Nobody here, Byron or me is demanding that Government take over anything. Only that Government (because nobody else can) set standards - tough standards and your sacred Randian innovation can then work to meeting them. They'll still reap Rand's rewards for being the best and brightest - only they'll have to keep working their minds instead of sitting on their lawyer... er laurels.

So your contention is that these fellows are so fucking greedy that they will fuck themselves and kill the goose, when it is clearly apparent that with just a little restraint, and little goose feed, they can keep "the golden eggs" flowing into their children's children's coffers...

That still sounds more of a emotional stance than a logical stance.

If it is human nature to be greedy and selfish, then it stands to reason that greed will temper catastrophic loss of wealth.

The market will set the standards under objective laws. You do right by the customer and the board, or you get taken to court for jail-time, fines and you lose your market to the more honest competitor who is unscathed.

In this episode we see protection money, we see a regulated industry being guarded by the bribed, the insider buttering his toast on both sides, and then government also stepping in to say, we'll raise taxes on the competition and the consumer by way of punishing the offender.

Only AFTER taking a hit in the polls, do they consider taking their business partners to court. We see all sorts of unethical behavior from the friends of Obama, all of whom are absolutely convinced that they are too big to fail.

And the cherry on top is that we get to finance all the corruption, all the errors, and they get to march merrily along taking a short term hit, but in no way in danger of ending their long-time partnership, in fact it will be strengthened by demands for more government control, because, again, the experts who guide, write, finance, and oversee, all come from the industry...

And kbate, honey, regulation IS taking control...

I'd rather it be by the industry working it its own selfish interest than the government working in its own selfish interest.
__________________
"The more communal enterprise extends, the more attention is drawn to the bad business results of nationalized and municipalized undertakings. It is impossible to miss the cause of the difficulty: a child could see where something was lacking. So that it cannot be said that this problem has not been tackled. But the way in which it has been tackled has been deplorably inadequate. Its organic connection with the essential nature of socialist enterprise has been regarded as merely a question of better selection of persons. It has not been realized that even exceptionally gifted men of high character cannot solve the problems created by socialist control of industry."
Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
 
Last edited:
Her argument holds just fine.

What's the difference between a government (like the USSR) which has no restrictions on its operations and isn't accountable to the people, and a private corporation which has no restrictions on its operations and isn't accountable to the people?

Really? What restrictions are in place Byron?

Oh, Oh, *waves hand in the air*!!!! I know, I KNOW!!!!!

The restriciton on the financial responsibility in civil law suits resulting from the ecological disasters associated with oil spills such as this. Our government in action looking out for the little guy. You betcha.

Ishmael
 
Sorry K, your argument falls apart. Government is by definition a monopoly and in may respects has an even worse record as far as ecological responsibility than many for the corporations you're slamming with your sarcasm.

Now, if I were an executive with 'Mighty Green Oil Company' I'd be all over this like stink on shit.

<start montage of oil encrusted dead birds, belly-up fish, blackened beaches>

Voice over - "We've all seen the results of the mismanagement and incompetence of some of the companies in our industry. The unparalleled destruction of our precious natural heritage."

"We at 'Mighty Green Oil' have dedicated ourselves to the protection of our childrens legacy and as such we are going to donate a portion of the profit of EVERY gallon of gasoline that you purchase from 'Mighty Green Oil' to an environemntal fund to help clean up these messes, yes, even messes made by our irresponsible competitors."

<start montage of happy birds nesting in tidal marshes, cute fish, adorable otters>

"'Mighty Green Oil, the responsible petroleum company."


There, that ought to be good for a 5pt jump in market share.

Ishmael

Wrong. The Soviet government operated much as the board of directors of a huge corporation - their entire population and we saw the results. They even divided their government into branches to cover nearly every different industry - much as a corporation has various divisions. Their failing was that they had no reason for morals and a national history of peasants being fodder for the ruling class.

Even our own government is not a monopoly - The several states each have their own governments, hopefully trying to do the best to protect their people as well. Just read about Arizona and your argument about monopoly falls apart instantly.

I have not once claimed that Government is a great steward of anything - especially the Soviets. They simply didn't care - and neither does the boardroom in any giant company who is trying to cut costs and raise profits. If they can hide an environmental problem behind a facade of lawyers and compliance tests - they will.

Your last post, indicating the need for government standards and testing - is exactly what I seek. Government set standards - monitored by state inspectors who are monitored by a federal office. I want this even for industries like the TSA - which would be a perfect place for government to set "safety standards" and decertify any airport which fails to meet them.
 
So your contention is that these fellows are so fucking greedy that they will fuck themselves and kill the goose, when it is clearly apparent that with just a little restraint, and little goose feed, they can keep "the golden eggs" flowing into their children's children's coffers...

The problem with your blind trust in the good nature of people is that in this day and age it literally can only take one person from a big group of people to kill the goose.
 
I really think you missed Stossel's point.




Above the local level, the crook is the government.

The press is supposed to be the watchdog, but as we watch the press, like the oil companies, pass in and out of government, favoring one party over the other, we see that they too, have become vested partners in the enterprise...
 
Back
Top