Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Unclebill said:Why am I not at all surprised that FAIR said there's no bias. I've seen a couple of their people and they would see Bill Press as middle-of-the-road and he's a Socialist. Try a somewhat objective source. Here are a couple of references: "Coloring the News" by William McGowan, "Bias" by Bernard Goldberg, and "It Ain't Necessarily So" by David Murray, Joel Schwartz and S. Robert Lichter.
Edited to expand post
I won't argue your point there. And obviously, my memory was deficient here. To be honest, I didn't even remember that it had gone to the Supreme Court.Originally posted by lavender
Shit. This is the most blatantly inaccurate statement I have seen from you, EVER.
. . . Additionally, if you will look to the recent Supreme Court case of Kyllo, which is the case about thermal imaging, it is evident to see that more conservative justices were in favor of that infringement on our liberties. Although Thomas and Scalia were in the majority (along with ALL of the liberal justices: Ginsburg, Stevens, etc.) the dissent, those who believed that thermal imaging did not infringe upon our rights were O'Connor, Souter, and Rehnquist (mind you ALL Republican appointees.)
Again, I won't contest your point. As to the tests you address, where would I see any evidence of them being applied? We have in force today laws which clearly violate Constitutional authority granted the Federal government.Originally posted by lavender
If you don't follow the court cases than you really don't have any leg to stand on if you are truly discussing the 4th Amendment. You may say that you look to what the legislature does, however, without understanding the tests that have been established by the Supreme Court you provide yourself with no basis by which you may measure the legislature's actions. When it comes to creating law, the legislature looks to past Supreme Court decisions and discusses whether they believe that the Act that was passed will survive Constitutional scrutiny.
It's the conservative justices, appointed by the Republicans, who have so narrowly drawn the tests to allow for action by the legislature, from BOTH parties, that leads to the infringement of rights.
UncleBill, you cannot look at these 2 branches of government so separately when you are asserting claims of individual rights, especially when you are citing this specifically to the 4th Amendment.
The restraints I note are those placed on the Federal government; Article 1 Section 8 specifies the explicitly enumerated powers of Congress. I challenge you to find authority there for enactment of drug prohibition laws, civil asset forfeiture laws, anti-trust laws, Social Security, social welfare, the DEA, the FDA, the EPA, etc. The Constitution explicitly states those powers assigned to the Federal government. That requires no interpretation. Do you disagree that it is explicit and distinct in this declaration?Originally posted by lavender
First you discuss constitutional restraints. But whose restraints are these? You say you don't follow court cases and then you boldly discuss constitutional restraints. I suppose this is YOUR interpretation of the constitution. We all have our interpretations, but you have to realize that the restraints that are currently being used are those that have been established due to conservative majorities on the court.
Your environmental analogy is so far away from your original statement about the 4th Amendment. There is little to no link between environmental laws and the 4th Amendment. Unless a governmental official, or some other official that triggers "state action" and therefore incorporates the first 10 Amendments via the 14th to apply to the states, then there is no issue. In order to get state action for a 4th Amendment claim there must be a search OR seizure. And there must be the question as to whether this search or seizure was legal. Environmental laws do not trigger this.
Your argumentation is not following any logical pattern in this post. You make bald assertions about the 4th Amendment and then you provide examples that have absolutely nothing to do whatsoever with the privacy protection afforded to citizens under this Amendment. I'm at a loss. Your posts are normally much more lucid and logical than this.
The 4th Amendment's application to economic rights only applies if there is a seizure of economic benefit that is done so without warrant or probable cause.
I'm trying to find how you think we should reinterpret the 4th Amendment to handle the issues you present.
And Amendment X says that powers not delegated to the Federal government are reserved for the states or the individual.The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite.
James Madison, Federalist No. 45
I'm not sure what you mean this reference [narrow conception] so apparently I don't. Can you explain?Originally posted by lavender
You know how I feel about your narrow conception of individual rights. In the libertarian world property rights and economic rights reign supreme, and all other rights are subject to those. It's simply not my concept of individual rights. I think it's a shallow and narrow interpretation of the rights we possess under our Constitution.
I have not and will not deny that the Fascist or other totalitarian elements exist in all of our political parties. One notable exception, the Libertarian Party. If you recall, on more than one occasion, I have said the difference between Republican and Democrat political goals is not notable in concept, only in degree. One substantial difference is that since Roe v. Wade, the conservatives have abided by that ruling and their infringements have not been advanced. And I grant many wish to see it overturned. Conversely, the liberals in Congress have expanded their control and disposition power over private property continually becoming more oppressive in that same time.Originally posted by lavender
The liberals micromanage economics. The conservatives want to micromanage my choices about my body. The conservatives want to micromanage choices about human sexuality. I would much rather them micromanage the paper money that is so easily dispensible, than to have them micromanage those things that I hold so personally dear to me. It's just a difference of priorities, UncleBill. There are "fascist" elements to both parties and both ideologies. Although, I cringe to hear you use the word fascist. I think it takes away the credibility of your argumentation. It's like using analogies to Nazism or Stalinism to prove a point. It provides extremism into a debate that should remain more focused.
I fully support these rights. But I also strongly advocate justice and holding accountable those who commit crimes. The rights of the accused must be valued and protected. But how can those who spurn the idea of individual rights and freedom of citizens NOT accused of crimes possible seriously value the rights of one accused of a crime? It is intellectually dishonest or completely irrational suppose that one who advocates subversion of individual rights could possible support the rights of the accused.Originally posted by lavender
UncleBill, regarding criminal prosecution, it's the liberals who are so supportive of upholding the 4th, 5th, and 6th Amendment rights upon which our criminal justice system was based. There is a little thing called the rights of the accused that liberals treasure. I am among the liberals who believe these rights are critical. As a libertarian, shouldn't you support these rights to an even greater extent. I know Rand's philosophy discusses these elements in length.
To imprison a man is the greatest denial of individual rights after taking his life. The liberal courts and the liberal interpretation of criminal prosecution attempts to ensure that along the way none of these rights are abridged. Bringing Clinton into this whole scenario in your typical and tired manner really hurts the logic you present in the remainder of your post.
Here I'm genuinely at a loss. I graduated high school in 1962. I knew BEFORE then that tobacco was a causative factor in lung and other cancers. I don't care what the tobacco companies have said for the intervening 40 years, the American Cancer Society has been providing the same information to which I was exposed in my teens. Anyone who isn't aware doesn't want to be aware, a personal decision and choice.Originally posted by lavender
We sue the tobacco companies for years and years of failing to truthfully and honestly address the information they had about the negative health consequences of tobacco. This country, with regards to the economy, is all about corporate disclosure. The idea of disclosure is clearly evident in one of the most significant areas of our economic ideology: securities law. Complete and accurate disclosure is imperative for any issuance of stock. We require that companies provide this disclosure.
The tobacco companies did not disclose the information they had. In fact, they lied to the consumer, the government, and to the public at large. This is the reason that the tobacco companies are getting hit hard. Apply these disclosure principles to your belief about the economy at large. Disclosure is central to a market economy and to capitalism. Considering how much libertarianism values a free market economy and all the aspects of that: i.e. stock markets, free trading, etc., I would think that your tobacco analogy has some logical fallacies.
Then why are his critics engaging in name calling (the ad hominem attack) and severing their friendship with him instead of offering factual refutation of what he said? I saw the better part of an hour of an interview by Tim Russert and nothing Goldberg offered was ever refuted. Are Russert and others unwilling to present the evidence to refute him? Or is it because he is right? And interestingly enough, Russert agreed with him on several points. So does that mean Russert is in collusion with Goldberg to slander the neutral, fair and honest press?Originally posted by weevil
. . . Do you actually think that Goldberg went into writing his book looking to study the issue of the media and see if there was a bias? No, he went in basing his theories around one news story(which he's 100% wrong about, by the way) and went to bizarre lengths to twist the world to better suit his completely unsubstantiated view that news is biased towards the left.
Do you realize the contradiction you offered here? Socialists are not for individual rights or freedom regardless of the variant and the legislation they offer further supports my position. What you offer is an irreconcilable dichotomy. Then you follow up your statement with a description of intimate and intense government involvement in all manner of personal and private matters where they have no business. And if they are so dedicated to the concept of free speech, why is it this party that is the home of political correctness? And why are they the major proponent of the idea of hate crimes which constitute an effort to punish the criminal not for his criminal act but for his thoughts and emotions ostensible related to the criminal act?Originally posted by KillerMuffin
Democrats are very strongly for the rights of the people. Democrats are socialist, yes, . . .
......... with the demonstrated failures of socialism as well as every other variant of collectivism throughout history, why, when the superiority of freedom and capitalism has been clearly demonstrated do they desire to regress into a system that has repeatedly proven itself untenable? - Unclebill
Stiphy said:
My home is in B.C, which arguably is the most socialist governed province in Canada. It was, until a recent conservative government got elected and fricked everything up, the jewel of Canada and shining example of human compassion along with econmic prosperity. I was, and remain proud of Canada's and B.C's governmental principles of social welfare.
BC is the jewel of Canada? That's like saying Tito was the jewel of the Jackson 5.