World building

Heavy worldbuilding has been part of the genre from the beginning with Tolkien. The notion that going overboard with worldbuilding is why it's a niche category on Lit is preposterous.
The thing about Lit is that we're all amateurs. We don't have editors to reel us back in when we let the worldbuilding take over. You see the same thing with published mainstream authors if they reach the point where they don't think they need an editor. Robert Jordan springs to mind, and JKR too.

And sadly readers *will* nope out if they open a story and it begins with an infodump. They have no investment to keep them interested. And they'll probably avoid the author's other stories after that.

I'm not saying it's the only factor - clearly part of it is that sci-fi and fantasy lovers have other places to go to get their fix, whereas Lit is the place to be for sex stories in general - but poor writing makes for bad advertising.
 
The thing about Lit is that we're all amateurs. We don't have editors to reel us back in when we let the worldbuilding take over. You see the same thing with published mainstream authors if they reach the point where they don't think they need an editor. Robert Jordan springs to mind, and JKR too.
I'll fight you on that. In Jordan's case, worldbuilding was one of the best aspects of his series. It's his writing that was lacking, as was the fact that he would fill the book with endless, pointless scenes that did nothing for the characters or the story.

The middle part of the series is especially full of such content. It effectively murdered the pacing of the story and made many readers quit, so only those invested enough stayed until the series became better. You could probably shave off 3-4 books of text from the series and improve it considerably.
 
I'll fight you on that. In Jordan's case, worldbuilding was one of the best aspects of his series. It's his writing that was lacking, as was the fact that he would fill the book with endless, pointless scenes that did nothing for the characters or the story.

The middle part of the series is especially full of such content. It effectively murdered the pacing of the story and made many readers quit, so only those invested enough stayed until the series became better. You could probably shave off 3-4 books of text from the series and improve it considerably.
But that's what I'm talking about. He was so enamoured with his world and his characters that he lost sight of storytelling. The first four books or so - maybe even the fifth as well - balanced worldbuilding with storytelling. But beyond that, he was just mucking around in his playground.
 
It's funny, I was going to use Pratchett as an example of why worldbuilding is optional. He was wildly successful despite Discworld being a pastiche of barely-disguised real places thrown together for the needs of the latest story. He was a great writer and Discworld was a great series, but place names were puns and his idea of continuity was "the History Monks were on vacation that day." Using "worldbuilding" to describe both Middle-earth and Discworld makes it so broad as to be almost meaningless.
Pratchett isn't interested in maps or Tolkien-style histories going back millennia, but he's very interested in how his society hangs together (or falls apart) and that's also a form of worldbuilding.
 
As with almost anybody who opines on The Correct Way To Write, I think Harrison overreaches. It's like saying nobody should paint landscapes because what people want to look at is portraits.

Does SF suffer from an excess of lacklustre world-building? Absolutely. Can good world-building strengthen a story, or even carry it? Sure can.
 
Well, maybe some backstory on the fucking tree branch if they're doing an Ent story, but the non-fucking branches probably not so much.
Biology person here: for green plants, many have only fucking branches (because they have sex organs [flowers] on them). There are plants that bear flowers on separate fuck-branches, though.

The thing about Lit is that we're all amateurs. We don't have editors to reel us back in when we let the worldbuilding take over. You see the same thing with published mainstream authors if they reach the point where they don't think they need an editor. Robert Jordan springs to mind, and JKR too.
It's happening to Brandon Sanderson. He isn't there yet, but he's drifting that way. Mr. Sanderson publicly said that his last big novel needed one more editing pass, but he didn't have the time to do it.
 
The thing about Lit is that we're all amateurs. We don't have editors to reel us back in when we let the worldbuilding take over. You see the same thing with published mainstream authors if they reach the point where they don't think they need an editor. Robert Jordan springs to mind, and JKR too.

Terry Goodkind! Love most of the series, but those last few books (3-4?) started to get painful I think I noted a hundred page section that's a vision that Richard has that's not only excessively detailed but repeated over a few novels. While I realize it's important for his motivation, it drags! My first thought was that he'd gotten so big that he no longer listened to his editor.
 
But that's what I'm talking about. He was so enamoured with his world and his characters that he lost sight of storytelling. The first four books or so - maybe even the fifth as well - balanced worldbuilding with storytelling. But beyond that, he was just mucking around in his playground.
I see your point.
I think it's hard to say why his middle books came out the way they did. I watched a few interviews with him from 20 years ago or so, but they didn't have any clues.

It could be that he didn't know what to do with the plot and characters at the time, but still wanted to publish and earn some money. Maybe he just stalled the story for that reason. Or maybe it was what you say. The 10th book, Crossroads of Twilight, infamously contains no real plot. Nothing happens in it whatsoever. It's hard to believe that he didn't see it himself.
 
It's happening to Brandon Sanderson. He isn't there yet, but he's drifting that way. Mr. Sanderson publicly said that his last big novel needed one more editing pass, but he didn't have the time to do it.
Sanderson's problem is that he wants to do so many different things at the same time: so many different stories, tv shows, movies, god knows what else. And it shows in his work. I wish he focused on what's his capital work - Stormlight Archive rather than doing all the random YA stuff. The first two books in the series are far above the latter books, especially book 5. I'm starting to lose faith that he will create anything as good as his earlier work was.

I believe that the writer is at their truest self when they start writing, when they publish their first books. Their best storytelling and their real enthusiasm are always there, even if their style is often unpolished at that point.
 
Sir Terry Pratchett made the greatest world the multiverse has ever seen.

"There are no maps. You can't map a sense of humor. Anyway, what is a fantasy map but a space beyond which There Be Dragons? On the Discworld we know that There Be Dragons Everywhere. They might not all have scales and forked tongues, but they Be Here all right, grinning and jostling and trying to sell you souvenirs." - Terry Pratchett, 1989.

IIRC, what triggered Pratchett to make the whole Discworld series is pretty much to prove to people you don't need an extremely detailed world to begin writing fantasy to begin with. That's pretty much on par with his Tolkien rebellion about everyone doing the same thing that Tolkien does because he's to fantasy what Mount Fuji is to Japan.

So what's so bad about worldbuilding?

There's nothing wrong with worldbuilding. From Middle Earth all the way to Warhammer 40K, there's lots of intricate worlds to get lost upon. Some readers prefer stories. Others prefer to deep dive into the lore itself. I know that because I lay in both sides, especially when the worlds are left vague on purpose, such as Fear & Hunger's. RPGs are perfect for worldbuilding because the metaplot is just a set of tools that inspire you to make your own. My version of the Forgotten Realms is not the same as Ed Greenwood's either, starting with the fact that I don't have one.

The problem about worldbuilding is that people are learning the wrong lessons from the authors who created these worlds, all the way back to Tolkien. No one realizes that Tolkien did it for fun, and we weren't even supposed to see the Silmarillion. Plus, Tolkien was a collector of folk, and Pratchett knew that, so he also used existing stuff and put them into Discworld, yet I highly doubt he planned all of this. Out of all the current media, a game dev is the only one I've seen to learn this, as Miro Haverinen has even woven Jungian psychology into his world. He too is also a collector of media.

If there's one author that's perpetuating the wrong lessons about this is Brandon Sanderson. Pratchett proved him wrong before he even published his first book.

Worldbuilding is supposed to be a playground, a laboratory, or a workshop. Not homework.
 
It was possibly bad for Sanderson in the very long term that he actually finished off Robert Jordan's never-ending story so satisfactorily in three volumes. I actually prefer the worldbuilding of Le Modesitt, John Scalzi, and Sanderson's Mistborn series to his latest efforts,
And of course, three cheers for Pratchett. If young men are reading him now, then I hope they can understand why old men like me feel that we can simultaneously feel it would be a funny old world if we thought the same
 
I feel that with erotic fiction in particular, there's a balance between the initial hook to draw the reader in and the drive to keep them invested in the story and the setting, and worldbuilding and sex can both work together to keep the readers engaged. An erotic encounter between an orc and an elf doesn't need an entire Silmarillion's worth of backstory to be good, sexy fun, but the initial encounter can build outward as the world and relationship are explored.
 
I see your point.
I think it's hard to say why his middle books came out the way they did. I watched a few interviews with him from 20 years ago or so, but they didn't have any clues.

It could be that he didn't know what to do with the plot and characters at the time, but still wanted to publish and earn some money. Maybe he just stalled the story for that reason. Or maybe it was what you say. The 10th book, Crossroads of Twilight, infamously contains no real plot. Nothing happens in it whatsoever. It's hard to believe that he didn't see it himself.
Apparently he had the whole story plotted out before he began to write. He told the publishers "This won't be a trilogy" (because until then the trilogy was the default for fantasy). He foresaw five books, but the plot was all there.

I suspect what happened was a combination of feedback about how much the fans loved the world, and the money he was getting for each book. Essentially he felt he was giving the fans what they wanted, and the publishers let him because he was bringing home the bacon. But he took it too far.

He's still sold more books than I have, of course, so maybe my opinion doesn't carry as much weight as his.
 
It could be that he didn't know what to do with the plot and characters at the time, but still wanted to publish and earn some money.
Or maybe was obligated to, by a multi-book contract with deadlines.


The thing about Lit is that we're all amateurs. We don't have editors to reel us back in when we let the worldbuilding take over. You see the same thing with published mainstream authors if they reach the point where they don't think they need an editor.
More frequently, I think the important factor is that their publisher doesn't think so. After a certain amount of story-editing, they're motivated to edit for a certain linguistic polish in service of publishability, not for story polish, because that is a lot more costly in professional expense as well as in production-calendar time. It's a rare author who really gets to call the shots in this regard, and tell the publisher "No story-editing."
 
Had to google all three. Did I miss out by not reading anything they wrote? Any nice fantasy or scifi book series?
Scott Lynch: The Lies of Locke Lamora and two sequels. Gorgeous prose, an intriguing setting, grim and gritty characters. The first book blew me away. It's about a group of conmen in a fantasy Renaissance city, dealing with competing gangs while they're trying to run a long con.

Saladin Ahmed: Throne of the Crescent Moon (and the prequel novella "Where Virtue Lives"). Arabian Nights setting, about a ghoul hunter and his dervish sidekick. Again, gorgeous prose and a well-crafted setting, but the sequels never emerged. SA also wrote several brilliant short stories (check out "Engraved On The Eye"), but I think he got sidetracked into writing graphic novels.

David Gunn: A military sci-fi trilogy about a supersoldier and his motley crew of sidekicks dealing with planetary warfare and insurrection and so on. Again, the story was never finished. It ended with the heroes teleported to an uninhabited outside the galaxy, I think. There were supposed to be three more, but they never emerged.

Sterling E. Lanier: Hiero's Journey and The Unforsaken Hiero. A pair of post-apocalyptic science-fantasy novels from the 1970s, I think. About a telepathic priest going on a journey of exploration (to find a "computer"!), and encountering an intelligent bear, a runaway princess and of course all kinds of evil baddies. The conceit is points-of-light seven thousand years after a nuclear war, in a vast forest that covers what's now the border between Canada and the US.
 
Sterling E. Lanier: Hiero's Journey and The Unforsaken Hiero. A pair of post-apocalyptic science-fantasy novels from the 1970s, I think. About a telepathic priest going on a journey of exploration (to find a "computer"!), and encountering an intelligent bear, a runaway princess and of course all kinds of evil baddies. The conceit is points-of-light seven thousand years after a nuclear war, in a vast forest that covers what's now the border between Canada and the US.
I almost forgot about the bad-arse druid, the fairy tree and the hyper-intelligent giant slug.
 
Saladin Ahmed: Throne of the Crescent Moon (and the prequel novella "Where Virtue Lives"). Arabian Nights setting, about a ghoul hunter and his dervish sidekick. Again, gorgeous prose and a well-crafted setting, but the sequels never emerged. SA also wrote several brilliant short stories (check out "Engraved On The Eye"), but I think he got sidetracked into writing graphic novels.
By my understanding it wasn't that he abandoned TotCM for graphic novels; it was that he got seriously ill (MDD) and couldn't write anything for quite a while, and then found he could manage GNs more easily than novels. I doubt a contracted deadline would have helped matters. IIRC there may also have been a marriage breakdown with parenting responsibilities in the mix but I can't verify that now.

Something often missed in these discussions is that writing isn't fungible. I often see fans going "why did you do twenty thousand words on Y when you could have done twenty thousands of words on completing X?" and I understand the feeling, but for a lot of writers that's just not how it works. Different kinds of writing require different energies and having the energy to write Y doesn't mean they could've written X instead.
 
Sterling E. Lanier: Hiero's Journey and The Unforsaken Hiero. A pair of post-apocalyptic science-fantasy novels from the 1970s, I think. About a telepathic priest going on a journey of exploration (to find a "computer"!), and encountering an intelligent bear, a runaway princess and of course all kinds of evil baddies. The conceit is points-of-light seven thousand years after a nuclear war, in a vast forest that covers what's now the border between Canada and the US.
Lanier suffered a traumatic brain injury that prevented his writing. His goddaughter finished the trilogy.

https://sanctum.media/blog/index.php/2025/04/04/news-hiero-desteen-returns/
 
I suspect what happened was a combination of feedback about how much the fans loved the world, and the money he was getting for each book. Essentially he felt he was giving the fans what they wanted, and the publishers let him because he was bringing home the bacon. But he took it too far.
You see the same thing on Lit re: book 64 chapter 512.
 
Back
Top