Writing as a Two-Stage Process

I agree that good writing is definitely a two stage process. Writers have to make decsions constantly....is it enough, does it need more, does it make sense. I think it is amazing with all the choices we have we can get a good story telling across.

When younger I use to write nearly as is. I was so intense as I went along I only reread for proofreading. OMG those were the days but I wrote so intensely I think I burned myself. Now older I could not even write that way getting all descriptions and varied words in one writing.

But now I fell less stressed about it all. If I get more of an outline first go around, I just plump it up in rewrites. I find where before I could not write now I can again.

So maybe even 3 or 4 stage as you age lol

Great topic!
 
the more I see someone, anyone, reference something they do in writing as a "must," the less heed I pay to it.

at LJWC a couple years ago I listened to a very well-known and extremely successful writer tell everyone how he worked and endorse it as positively without a doubt the best way for everyone to write. I can't argue with his success, but he was so incredibly structured that it almost repelled me. Up at 6 am, workout for an hour, write ten pages, edit the ten from the day before, then do the business side of things in the afternoon.

Hey, it worked for him. But believe me, you DO NOT want to read what I write at 7 a.m.

Charley, with all respect, I do believe planning can be AN important part of A process. But I DO NOT believe that it is impossible for a work of value to come out of improvisational writing.

I respect you thoughts, Bel. I suppose we might never agree on this point. :kiss:
 
I think that's why we learn to write by reading, and why, when we're stuck in writing, the best course is to suck it up and force ourself to write through it, no matter how bad it is. We have a much better chance of fixing bad writing than we do of waiting till we get it right the first time through.
That's probably true. If you have a need for a constant output to show off.

When it comes to fiction, I also have a two stage process:

1. Think.
2. Write.

Then I read what I wrote. If I didn't get it right (save from pure errors and the occasional phrasing that can be sharpened), I scrap it. I'm good at producing quality text and quality disposition on cue. If it doesn't feel right, it's almost always because I didn't think well enough before I started writing, and the actual idea behind the story is flawed.

Trying to patch up shoddy ideas amounts to no more than cheap lipstick on a fugly pig. For me, at least.

But then again, I don't have the need to tell any specific story, if I write a story and then delete it because it wasn't good enough, I'm not bothered. They're not my babies, they're failed communication of failed ideas.
 
Last edited:
CHARLEYH

Well, porn without the premise or moral is in the same class of writing as jokes or anecdotes.
 
CHARLEYH

Well, porn without the premise or moral is in the same class of writing as jokes or anecdotes.
I think good porn (or erotica, whatever) is about sex and sexuality, and that in addition to wanting to tittilate, the author must have something to say about the subject matter. And then says it through a narrative.
 
I think good porn (or erotica, whatever) is about sex and sexuality, and that in addition to wanting to tittilate, the author must have something to say about the subject matter. And then says it through a narrative.
Thank you, Liar. Well said.
 
HMMMMM

If I understand you correctly, I have the same problem; I can generate ideas quicker than I can execute them. I come up with at least 2 ideas a day. And theyre dandy ideas, not a runt in the litter.

But what I complete I feel inspired to write.

You understood. Thank you.

There's more, but I can't think of how to whittle it down. It brings back the novel, plus assumption, the obvious. I suspect a tendency to assume that what's obvious to us is equally obvious to others. So, why say it? Or, if it must be said why not try to find a novel way to say it? Or skip over the parts we think are too obvious. That's probably what creates some confusion. It'll piss off some people/readers/listeners. But it can make things interesting too. Allows more freedom for the listener/looker/reader/person to form their own impression. Or causes equal measures of pain for others. Whaddya do?
 
You understood. Thank you.

There's more, but I can't think of how to whittle it down. It brings back the novel, plus assumption, the obvious. I suspect a tendency to assume that what's obvious to us is equally obvious to others. So, why say it? Or, if it must be said why not try to find a novel way to say it? Or skip over the parts we think are too obvious. That's probably what creates some confusion. It'll piss off some people/readers/listeners. But it can make things interesting too. Allows more freedom for the listener/looker/reader/person to form their own impression. Or causes equal measures of pain for others. Whaddya do?
Hmmnmm
 
Last edited:
I think good porn (or erotica, whatever) is about sex and sexuality, and that in addition to wanting to tittilate, the author must have something to say about the subject matter. And then says it through a narrative.

Why can't it show it through the actions or dialogue of the characters? Why does it have to be in the narrative? You lose me. I think the reader can even be guided to fill it in themselves rather than flatly providing it in the story. That's what's great about writing--there are so many ways of doing it.

(And we always seem to move toward these absolutist statements--like all that "required" architectural stuff--I made a nice chunk of change off of improvisionally written short stories last year. Lots and lots of preparation and flow charts and outlines are a death knell to my writing. But then I have a very organized mind to begin with.)
 
Why can't it show it through the actions or dialogue of the characters? Why does it have to be in the narrative? You lose me. I think the reader can even be guided to fill it in themselves rather than flatly providing it in the story. That's what's great about writing--there are so many ways of doing it.
Narrative. Not narration. They're two different things.
 
Oh . . . if you think so.
Heh, let me elaborate on that. I'm a rethorics major, so my use of the terms seems to be of the "academic geek" variety. ;)

Narrative is the key progression of a story. All the elements of it that makes it the story it is. The synopsis, of you like.

Narration is "Bob thought Shiela was hot, and wanted to stick his peener in her. So one day he did." The actual typed out telling of things.

Narrative can be presented in all shapes and forms. As narration, as characters saying and doing stuff, as things merely implied and alluded, as a reader who connectws the dots when things are left unsaid...

So yeah, I think we're talking about the same thing here. The entireness of the story.
 
Last edited:
Heh, let me elaborate on that. I'm a lrhethorics major, so my use of the terms seems to be of the "academic geek" variety. ;)

Narrative is the key progression of a story. All the elements of it that makes it the story it is. The synopsis, of you like.

Narration is "Bob thought Shiela was hot, and wanted to srtick his ppener in her. So one day he did." The actual typed out

Narrative can be presented in all shapes and forms. As narration, as characters saying and doing stuff, as things merely implied and alluded, as a reader who connectws the dots when things are left unsaid...

So yeah, I think we're talking about the same thing here. the entirelness of the story.

Thanks. That explains it nicely.
 
Gee, thanks for quoting my seven million typos, before I could correct them. :D
 
I'm not like a method actor who follows some set of rules that guide me in my writing. I am, however, guided by two basic principles:

1. Simplify the complex.
2. Be original.
 
HMMMM

I dont know the answer, because I dont know how you be all things to all readers.

I'm reading an old Western writer named Alan LeMay. He was a cowboy turned writer back in the 30s. Everyone in the world bought his stories, and they werent pulp magazines. Two of his novels were made into classic cowboy movies, THE SEARCHERS and THE UNFORGIVEN.

THE UNFORGIVEN, I think, is the best cowboy movie ever made.

But I dont get his short stories. I scratch my head trying to fathom why major magazines bought them. There is no story, no dialogue, no narrative, not much action. Like this one:

Two prospectors are working an old claim for gold. A third guy shows up and accuses them of jumping his claim. They then say, YOURE RIGHT, WE'RE VERY SORRY, and they leave. They move on to a new place. The sheriff shows up and wants to arrest them for murdering some guy years ago. They say WERENT US. The sheriff say OKAY and leaves. End of story. Huh?

GIT ALONG LITTLE DOGIE is the most complicated prose in the story. You could read it to the average dog, and the dog would get it.

THE UNFORGIVEN, on the otherhand, is serious stuff with wonderful subplots and divine prose. Its how you should write a story. Brilliant. Its about a racist who has a change of heart.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehnkaOVla0k&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFs4gwUgAUE&feature=related
 
Last edited by a moderator:

LOL!!!

I wrote an off the wall review of the movie (and I highly recommend it) for friends that went all deep about the external crutches being a metaphor for their broken souls needing blah, blah, blah - wish I could find it. Anyway, I ended with the message of the movie being "wear your seatbelt, but not your underwear."
 
DEE ZIRE

No. Le May died in the 60s I think, and his word count is a lot higher than Carver's, but his vocabulary is about 50 words...dogs know 200 words. But he was capanble of some serious writing.
 
And tried to go to the same well with 'Angels and Demons.'

Would you believe that Angels and Demons (2000) was written/published before Da Vinci Code (2003)--and is a better version of the book?
 
Back
Top