Britva415
"Alabaster," my ass
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2022
- Posts
- 2,568
I think you mean "have done"Don't you mean:
Had you danced, had you drunk, and had you screwed, because there had been nothing else to do?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I think you mean "have done"Don't you mean:
Had you danced, had you drunk, and had you screwed, because there had been nothing else to do?
Like I mentioned upthread, it helps to distinguish the letters. But then you might as well learn modern Greek.That reminds me,
Would learning Greek for the purpose of reading 2000-year-old classics be of any use for conversation in contemporary Greece?
I think you mean "have done"
As long as we're niggling, I don't think it's present perfect, partly because those two words were only part of the complete construct which would have been in infitive form and necessarily subordinate to the previous verb anyway, and partly because the interrogative, which concerned the past in the first place, renders it "not real."That wouldn't be past perfect. That's present perfect.
I read 'to do' as an enquiry about boredom and 'to have done' as a bucket-list question, 'What else was left to tick off?'As long as we're niggling, I don't think it's present perfect, partly because those two words were only part of the complete construct which would have been in infitive form and necessarily subordinate to the previous verb anyway, and partly because the interrogative, which concerned the past in the first place, renders it "not real."
I'm not sure exactly what it is, I think it's more like a perfect form of a timeless, subjunctive-like mood. It can't be present perfect because it doesn't make any sense for that part of the sentence to not be in the same timeframe as the rest of it - the past.
It's not that now there might be nothing to have done, it's that at the time there might have been nothing to have done. In both cases, "to have done" is infinitive formed, which I grant I didn't include in my humorously-intentioned reply, so I can see how just latching on to the two quoted words would lead you to go "Aha! Present perfect!"
How did I do?
Tell that to ProustFlashbacks are a lazy device.
I will in my next flashback.Tell that to Proust