The AI Rejection Conversation Matters

My latest submission got flagged for suspected AI use. I've re-submitted with an expanded admin note, but based on the experiences of others, I'm expecting to be asked to make edits in the dark to attempt to make it past the AI gatekeeper.

Even more unpleasantly, the rejection seemed to trigger a chain reaction. My three other stories (previously published with no issues) have been retrospectively rejected for the same reason. It all happened within minutes of my clicking publish, so surely automated. Has anyone seen that before? I've messaged Laurel, but again, I'm not hopeful of a reply based on what I've read on here.

The return of my back catalogue worries me. I've had feedback on those already, so I have no drive to re-edit them to meet Lit's AI's satisfaction. I wonder though, if I make edits and have my new story accepted, will it get rejected again at the time of my next submission (or when the AI detection programme gets an update)?

I've been wondering about that as well. Getting flagged for AI use, regardless of the veracity of the detection, flags your account for stricter filtering. Though in one case all my submissions got rejected at once, except for one that was approved. Then once rejected, it takes 2-4 weeks (often 3-4) for your submission to be looked at again. This makes trying to figure out the actual problem almost impossible, especially when the problem could be that Laurel herself thinks its AI. In which case, I wonder if having AI rewrite parts your story (and telling it to avoid common AI writing cues) is the best approach, because Laurel's problem is with your writing style. Because most editors aren't going to want to help you with this task.

It seems like sometimes Laurel will manually look at all your stories at the same time, and then manually choose to reject or approve them. And if she thinks one of them is AI, then you're at a disadvantage when she looks at the other ones.

I've seen people say that deleting all mention of the story from your account, and then resubmitting it could help. That might get the story specific flag removed if it works.
 
It is indeed a complex issue and if they pull other stories from your archive then that will deter long time writers, like myself, to hesitate to post again. Especailly since there seem to be no dialogue, just an indiscriminate banhammer.
 
Back
Top