stickygirl
All the witches
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2012
- Posts
- 23,761
Finally - Ammonite arrived. US import that happily it played on my DVD
I've had 24hrs to mull it over but my opinion hasn't changed. Firstly - good little film, Kate Winslet is amazing, Saoirse not at her best and sundry others who I recognised but can't name in strong support.
Good things first: it flies the flag for Mary Anning, who was a leading fossil expert in the 1800s when England was stiff with a class based and patriarchal society. Her discoveries were regularly 'claimed' by rich men of influence. You can Google her story, so I won't say any more. Hurray for women being acknowledged.
It's a lesbian love story and there are some 'Oh my gosh' scenes as well as lots of long meaningful looks from Mary, but Saoirse as Charlotte was two dimensional.
Disappointing things: it does neither very well. The sex feels shameful and hurried and the down-trodden poor woman felt cliched. Comparing it to Portrait of Young Woman on Fire might be unfair, but that film totally nailed it. It had a fantastic sound-scape, it felt paced better and was beautifully composed with vistas that are a delight.
What a pity that Ammonite missed those tricks. Don't get me wrong - it is still worth seeing and I will guard my imported copy with my life and rewatch it, but I just felt a bit cheated.
I've had 24hrs to mull it over but my opinion hasn't changed. Firstly - good little film, Kate Winslet is amazing, Saoirse not at her best and sundry others who I recognised but can't name in strong support.
Good things first: it flies the flag for Mary Anning, who was a leading fossil expert in the 1800s when England was stiff with a class based and patriarchal society. Her discoveries were regularly 'claimed' by rich men of influence. You can Google her story, so I won't say any more. Hurray for women being acknowledged.
It's a lesbian love story and there are some 'Oh my gosh' scenes as well as lots of long meaningful looks from Mary, but Saoirse as Charlotte was two dimensional.
Disappointing things: it does neither very well. The sex feels shameful and hurried and the down-trodden poor woman felt cliched. Comparing it to Portrait of Young Woman on Fire might be unfair, but that film totally nailed it. It had a fantastic sound-scape, it felt paced better and was beautifully composed with vistas that are a delight.
What a pity that Ammonite missed those tricks. Don't get me wrong - it is still worth seeing and I will guard my imported copy with my life and rewatch it, but I just felt a bit cheated.

Welcome!