512 Architects & Engineering Professionals

Was 9/11 an Inside Job?

  • Yes, the buildings were controlled demolitions with the Terrorists used as decoys.

    Votes: 56 71.8%
  • Yes, Osama Bin Laden is actually a CIA operative. That's why everyone lets him escape all the time.

    Votes: 17 21.8%
  • Yes, the Republicans are evil and the whole thing was used to hide and delay a huge stock market cra

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • No, it was Ishmael and you can clearly see him throwing people out the windows. Nobody jumped.

    Votes: 16 20.5%
  • No, the buildings were just ready to fall down anyway....chipboard!

    Votes: 8 10.3%
  • SusyQ controlled the terrorists with her blowjobathic powers.

    Votes: 11 14.1%

  • Total voters
    78
Tell me again how a falling steel beam can "pulverize" another steel beam below it into fine dust or powder.

This is good. It's never happened in the history of steel beams.

:D
From the article:

Dr. Frank A. Moscatelli, a professor of physics at Swarthmore College in Pennsylvania, calculated that the total energy released in the disaster was equivalent to the explosion of 600 tons of TNT. This energy discharge, which takes into account the weight of the airplanes that struck the buildings, their speed at impact, the jet fuel and the mass of the buildings, is about one-twentieth of that released by the 10-kiloton atom bomb dropped on Hiroshima, he said.

''And most of this energy was supplied by gravitational collapse,'' Dr. Moscatelli said. ''People don't think of an item sitting still as having energy, but it does. The energy from gravitational collapse is what the controlled demolition people use to take down structures, and it is very powerful.''

Once the mass of the upper part of a building begins to fall, Dr. Moscatelli said, it gains momentum that adds to the force the structure below has to resist. ''If the rest of the building can't do it, everything begins to fall straight down,'' he said.

Jon D. Magnusson, chairman and chief executive of Skilling Ward Magnusson Barkshire in Seattle, a structural engineering company that worked out the original World Trade Center design, said the enormous energy released in the collapse was enough to pulverize the 110-story towers and their contents.

As the buildings fell, large plumes of dust billowed from the structures in what appeared to be high-speed jets. Engineers said compression of the buildings' air propelled the dust.

''People don't think about it, but there is a large amount of air in a structure,'' said James Redyke, president of Dykon Blasting, a demolition company in Tulsa, Okla. ''A building is like an accordion, and when it collapses the air has to exit someplace. It exits at a pretty good volume, carrying all the dust from concrete, sheetrock and other things inside.''

An initial analysis of the World Trade Center disaster released last week by Risk Management Solutions of Newark, Calif., a company that analyzes catastrophes for the insurance industry and others, estimated that the pancake collapse of the tower floors produced a major airborne ''debris surge.'' This cloud, which it said initially spread at more than 50 miles per hour, dumped significant deposits of dust more than a half mile from the site and small amounts up to two miles away.

Now it's your turn. Quote things for me from their neutron bomb article.
 
I'm out, but maybe ya'll can convince me that jet fuel and the collapse turned heat-treated, UL tested , rolled structural steel beams into dust.

It is an amazing feat that has never happened before in any building collapse or fire.

However, it could be possible, if you smashed two steel beams together with the force of some type of atom bomb.

Night.
You're stalling, bilko.
 
I wish Rat_Patrol would log on. He could settle all of this for us.
 
no. now do it with hundreds of thousands of tons of steel and hundreds of thousands of concrete.

If this theory were plausible, the downward crushing force would have penetrated the concrete "tub" foundation. The "bathtub" foundation was unharmed. If the force of the building coming down could turn steel beams to dust, it would have gone through the concrete foundation like butter. But it didn't.
 
I'm out, but maybe ya'll can convince me that jet fuel and the collapse turned heat-treated, UL tested , rolled structural steel beams into dust.

It is an amazing feat that has never happened before in any building collapse or fire.

However, it could be possible, if you smashed two steel beams together with the force of some type of atom bomb.

Night.
Interesting you should mention atom bomb. Here's a quote you might like from the article:

This energy discharge, which takes into account the weight of the airplanes that struck the buildings, their speed at impact, the jet fuel and the mass of the buildings, is about one-twentieth of that released by the 10-kiloton atom bomb dropped on Hiroshima, he said.

Now you show me a quote I might like from the neutron bomb article. It'll be fun. We'll share.
 
If this theory were plausible, the downward crushing force would have penetrated the concrete "tub" foundation. The "bathtub" foundation was unharmed. If the force of the building coming down could turn steel beams to dust, it would have gone through the concrete foundation like butter. But it didn't.
__________________

Or should have at least CRACKED the foundation.
 
If this theory were plausible, the downward crushing force would have penetrated the concrete "tub" foundation. The "bathtub" foundation was unharmed. If the force of the building coming down could turn steel beams to dust, it would have gone through the concrete foundation like butter. But it didn't.

says you. and no it wouldn't.
think objectivly about why.
if you can't answer that, even with an answer with which you disagree, you lose intellectual credibility.
 
If this theory were plausible, the downward crushing force would have penetrated the concrete "tub" foundation. The "bathtub" foundation was unharmed. If the force of the building coming down could turn steel beams to dust, it would have gone through the concrete foundation like butter. But it didn't.
__________________

Or should have at least CRACKED the foundation.
Yeah, if only those physics professors had taken that into account.

Say, just wondering. Where's my neutron bomb article? You wouldn't be punking out, would you?
 
If this theory were plausible, the downward crushing force would have penetrated the concrete "tub" foundation. The "bathtub" foundation was unharmed. If the force of the building coming down could turn steel beams to dust, it would have gone through the concrete foundation like butter. But it didn't.

Where did you learn so much about the properties of structural concrete and steel?

If the tub could hold all the concrete and steel while it was standing, why couldn't it hold it after it was crumbled in a pile?
 
Also...if the weight of the falling floors "pulverized" everything below them, including steel, this means the collapse would have been much slower due to energy transfer from the falling floors turning everything below them to dust.

In other words, in order for the lower floors to be vaporized, there had to be a lot of resistance, but there wasn't. They gave way with almost zero resistance as proven by the speed of the collapse. Interesting.
 
Also...if the weight of the falling floors "pulverized" everything below them, including steel, this means the collapse would have been much slower due to energy transfer from the falling floors turning everything below them to dust.

In other words, in order for the lower floors to be vaporized, there had to be a lot of resistance, but there wasn't. They gave way with almost zero resistance as proven by the speed of the collapse. Interesting.
Very interesting. Where's my neutron bomb story?
 
Where did you learn so much about the properties of structural concrete and steel?

If the tub could hold all the concrete and steel while it was standing, why couldn't it hold it after it was crumbled in a pile?

I've been studying 9/11 for 8 years.

If the lower steel beams could hold up the entire building, (since the lower floors had thicker and stronger steel than the upper floors), why would they have turned to dust or gave way when the same amount of weight (plus some plane debris) came down on them (the whole building which these same beams supported).
 
says you. and no it wouldn't.
think objectivly about why.
if you can't answer that, even with an answer with which you disagree, you lose intellectual credibility.

I amended that to say the concrete foundation never even cracked. Obviously there was solid bedrock below it.

Still, if that falling mass could turn huge steel beams to dust, it should have gone through the concrete foundation and bedrock below it, as well, turning those to dust, as well. No?

But the foundation was completely undamaged. Just another anomaly.
 
I've been studying 9/11 for 8 years.

If the lower steel beams could hold up the entire building, (since the lower floors had thicker and stronger steel than the upper floors), why would they have turned to dust or gave way when the same amount of weight (plus some plane debris) came down on them (the whole building which these same beams supported).
All good points. I posted a story that explains one "theory" for this--perhaps you saw it, the one from the New York Times. Would you mind posting some of the credible sources you rely on for the neutron bomb explanation? Or the follow up in the Times where they print the retraction to the crazy "gravity" story?
 
I've been studying 9/11 for 8 years.

If the lower steel beams could hold up the entire building, (since the lower floors had thicker and stronger steel than the upper floors), why would they have turned to dust or gave way when the same amount of weight (plus some plane debris) came down on them (the whole building which these same beams supported).

What were the lower beams holding up before the planes hit the building?

I've told you this many times before and I am not trying to insult you or demean you in anyway, but you simply do not understand the science or engineering behind what you are talking about.

If it interests you so much, why not go to college and get some of that higher brainwashing?

Do you create these alts just so you can go over these arguments as if you haven't had your head handed to you half a dozen times already? Interesting.
 
I'm just doing a quick check of media outlets across the country, and can't seem to find wtcnuke among them. If I were the suspicious kind, I'd think you posted another conspiracy site. Is there some reason New York's own press wouldn't want to know if someone set off a nuke in their own city?

Maybe we should just check the obits for the deaths from radiation illness.
 
I've been studying 9/11 for 8 years.

If the lower steel beams could hold up the entire building, (since the lower floors had thicker and stronger steel than the upper floors), why would they have turned to dust or gave way when the same amount of weight (plus some plane debris) came down on them (the whole building which these same beams supported).

the towers weren't built with conventional I-beam and core construction... check the engineering please.. wtc 1 and wtc 2 were structural skin with internal i-beam cores to maximise floor space.. totally different from concrete and box stacked i-beam construction..
 
the towers weren't built with conventional I-beam and core construction... check the engineering please.. wtc 1 and wtc 2 were structural skin with internal i-beam cores to maximise floor space.. totally different from concrete and box stacked i-beam construction..

He knows that, because he studied the WTC for 8 years.
 
What were the lower beams holding up before the planes hit the building?

I've told you this many times before and I am not trying to insult you or demean you in anyway, but you simply do not understand the science or engineering behind what you are talking about.

If it interests you so much, why not go to college and get some of that higher brainwashing?

Do you create these alts just so you can go over these arguments as if you haven't had your head handed to you half a dozen times already? Interesting.

I created this alt long before this thread came up. There goes that theory.

Maybe you should explain to me how the lower beams and columns were not holding the entire building up. I understand the concept of redundancy. You must not, though, since the WTC architects designed the buildings to be able to withstand MULTIPLE collisions of the bigest airliner at the time they were designed, per their own words.
 
I created this alt long before this thread came up. There goes that theory.

Maybe you should explain to me how the lower beams and columns were not holding the entire building up. I understand the concept of redundancy. You must not, though, since the WTC architects designed the buildings to be able to withstand MULTIPLE collisions of the bigest airliner at the time they were designed, per their own words.

Looks like they fucked up on that one. Interesting.

Goodnight, TurdOddballRat. See you tomorrow.
 
Hey Batshit, I felt a little bad for you, stuck posting these conspiracy sites instead of any primary sources, so I did you the favor of searching for 'neutron bomb' at the new york times site. Here are the results--maybe you'll find what you're looking for there. If not, I'm sure one of the other sites I gave you will have something for you.

If not, one kind of has to wonder...no one sick, no one theorizing about it, no one talking about it, no one heard it...maybe the tree just didn't fall in the forest. I hate to think of you blindly following something as absurd and unrewarding as this for all these years, but hey--we get those years back at the end of our lives. Wait--don't we?
 
Hey Batshit, I felt a little bad for you, stuck posting these conspiracy sites instead of any primary sources, so I did you the favor of searching for 'neutron bomb' at the new york times site. Here are the results--maybe you'll find what you're looking for there. If not, I'm sure one of the other sites I gave you will have something for you.

If not, one kind of has to wonder...no one sick, no one theorizing about it, no one talking about it, no one heard it...maybe the tree just didn't fall in the forest. I hate to think of you blindly following something as absurd and unrewarding as this for all these years, but hey--we get those years back at the end of our lives. Wait--don't we?


I guess that disproves it...the NYT never specifically mentions "neutron bombs".

You win... :cattail:
 
Back
Top