512 Architects & Engineering Professionals

Was 9/11 an Inside Job?

  • Yes, the buildings were controlled demolitions with the Terrorists used as decoys.

    Votes: 56 71.8%
  • Yes, Osama Bin Laden is actually a CIA operative. That's why everyone lets him escape all the time.

    Votes: 17 21.8%
  • Yes, the Republicans are evil and the whole thing was used to hide and delay a huge stock market cra

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • No, it was Ishmael and you can clearly see him throwing people out the windows. Nobody jumped.

    Votes: 16 20.5%
  • No, the buildings were just ready to fall down anyway....chipboard!

    Votes: 8 10.3%
  • SusyQ controlled the terrorists with her blowjobathic powers.

    Votes: 11 14.1%

  • Total voters
    78
Nope, acid rain caused the steel to melt.

It's a first.

In 1975 there was no eutectic reaction because , um...acid rain didn't exist then.

You win.
Turd, I don’t know about you but, I wasn’t treating this as a childish game of tag “I win you loose.”

For me it was a look at your claims of “evidence” that there were Nukes in the buildings. If your claims held any water I would change my stance and be very interested in pursuing this further.

You presented your “evidence” in three parts.

1/ Missing 10s 000 of tons of steel. Citing an incomplete, un-reference, and not verifiable News article.

On closer examination with correct verifiable sources from the agencies that were actually responsible for carrying out the task we found that in fact all of the steel was recovered. There is no missing steel.

As a side note to this you should have become aware that you tube and some News sources are not a reliable source of information that you/we can use in coming to our conclusion about events in the world. I am surprised that you insist in continuing with this even going so far as to citing a 911 site in trying to bolster your claims. These are self evidently biased and cherry pick quotes, which weren’t even from the Doctor in the first place, but from another news reporter. This is not far removed from propaganda and not worthy of serious consideration.

2/ A photo of a piece of steel that you claimed was evidence of high temperatures and steel melting/vaporizing.

On closer examination we found that this was a piece of steel that had undergone a eutectic reaction. Which is an indication of low temperatures and is in fact an indication of sub 1000C temperatures.

3/ The steel/iron in the dust. Citing that it came from the structural steel and noting that it is impossible for steel to smash into microscopic pieces by dropping one steel beam on another from 1000ft.

On closer examination, it is not necessary as there are multiple other ways in which the Iron could have become present in the dust. The largest of which would have been the 1.5 million tons of concrete itself. Both through intentional means, through the fly ash and through un-intentional means during construction. Add in all the other means from the construction phase, modification, surface oxidization and repair and there we have it.

I think we can, at this point, safely say that there is no evidence of Nukes in the buildings. Your attempts to shift focus from what we have been discussing only underlines this further. Your “evidence” of Nukes, not that you had any in the first place, does not stand up examination.

Woof!
 
Nope, acid rain caused the steel to melt.

It's a first.

In 1975 there was no eutectic reaction because , um...acid rain didn't exist then.

You win.

Ok I don’t really wish to engage in your bouncing from topic to topic to cloud the intent of what we were originally discussing.

But, for one last time I am going to clear-up your confusion (intentional or un-intentional) regarding eutectic reactions and what caused them, specifically the acid rain issue that you choose to attempt to deride.

Acid rain is only one of several possible ways, cited, in which the sulphur is proposed to have become in contact with the steel. The others are to name a few, rubber and plastic all of which were in the building in abundance.

The other thing to note is they are not really sure at what point the eutectic reactions took place. Whilst the building was still standing or in the debris pile after collapse and as you rightly pointed out earlier thousands of gallons of water were poured on the debris pile.

So although your attempts to deride eutectic reactions by trying to visualise rain inside the building seems funny to you to everyone else who has read the report, whilst they are laughing too, it is more at you than with you. Which kinda neatly brings us back to the beginning of this discussion. You Pookie and the core.

http://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_apc.pdf

http://www.wpi.edu/News/Transformations/2002Spring/steel.html

Woof!
 
You've never posted any evidence supporting temperatures anywhere near that high in the buildings themselves. The material evidence from the steel beams that were analysed showed that the maximum was far less than that.
I’ve posted a lot of evidence of the temperatures in the fires. You just pretend not to have seen it. Like here for example that you never answered?

We know that there were Jet Fuel fires inside the towers no??? Or didn’t that happen?

We know that Jet fuel burns at between 1000-1300C ergo there were temperatures like that inside WTC.

NIST also have published evidence of steel beams exhibiting temperatures of 625C and also state they abandoned this line of enquiry as they couldn’t tell when the heating of the beams took place, before the collapse or in the debris pile. So that line of investigation was un-reliable.

By what method would you propose to eradicate that difficulty? If they produced beam after beam showing beam temperatures of 1000C you would be one of the first to shriek “dishonesty, sign of a cover-up” and you would be right. Fortunately they chose an honest route and say they can’t distinguish pre or post collapse temperature. It is this that you are now attempting to exploit. It can been seen who is being dishonest here.

It is well known through experiments and observations of other fires that 1000C is quite reasonable for office fires. We only need temperature of about 500C for the towers to be in serious difficulty.

I’ve been over this countless times with LN, so you know this. You will also know her dishonest attempt to alter the NIST report to take out this qualification. Or may-be it was you.

It's already been shown quite well that molten steel and iron, still hot and liquid, was a major problem 7-8 weeks after the collapses.
Has it been proven that there was molten steel and Iron? Care to post evidence of this? By evidence I mean something verifiable and not a pile of quotes of “it looked like.”

I hate the idea of nukes, but the batshit loony is correct on this. How can you explain this without nukes of some sort being used down in the basements? Don't simply pretend the molten metal didn't exist, because it did, so tell me a rational reason for it without the use of nukes? Can you?
So you too are now going with Nukes in the basement? Does that mean you have abandoned your previous Thermite, Thermate, cutter charges theory. Or are you adding the Nukes to this?

Quite a lot of bombs about don’t ya think?

You know that Turd has also claimed incendiary bombs to set light to WTC 7 don’t you. You wanna pick them too for your 911 bomb buffet?

Woof!
 
Last edited:
Turd, I don’t know about you but, I wasn’t treating this as a childish game of tag “I win you loose.”

For me it was a look at your claims of “evidence” that there were Nukes in the buildings. If your claims held any water I would change my stance and be very interested in pursuing this further.

You presented your “evidence” in three parts.

1/ Missing 10s 000 of tons of steel. Citing an incomplete, un-reference, and not verifiable News article.

On closer examination with correct verifiable sources from the agencies that were actually responsible for carrying out the task we found that in fact all of the steel was recovered. There is no missing steel.

As a side note to this you should have become aware that you tube and some News sources are not a reliable source of information that you/we can use in coming to our conclusion about events in the world. I am surprised that you insist in continuing with this even going so far as to citing a 911 site in trying to bolster your claims. These are self evidently biased and cherry pick quotes, which weren’t even from the Doctor in the first place, but from another news reporter. This is not far removed from propaganda and not worthy of serious consideration.

2/ A photo of a piece of steel that you claimed was evidence of high temperatures and steel melting/vaporizing.

On closer examination we found that this was a piece of steel that had undergone a eutectic reaction. Which is an indication of low temperatures and is in fact an indication of sub 1000C temperatures.

3/ The steel/iron in the dust. Citing that it came from the structural steel and noting that it is impossible for steel to smash into microscopic pieces by dropping one steel beam on another from 1000ft.

On closer examination, it is not necessary as there are multiple other ways in which the Iron could have become present in the dust. The largest of which would have been the 1.5 million tons of concrete itself. Both through intentional means, through the fly ash and through un-intentional means during construction. Add in all the other means from the construction phase, modification, surface oxidization and repair and there we have it.

I think we can, at this point, safely say that there is no evidence of Nukes in the buildings. Your attempts to shift focus from what we have been discussing only underlines this further. Your “evidence” of Nukes, not that you had any in the first place, does not stand up examination.

Woof!

I respect your views. I think it's imposible to know how much steel was or was not missing, since no one can even come to a conclusion of the exact amount actually used in the original construction.

I will state that my opinion that "nukes" were used are based entirely on these sites:

http://nucleardemolition.com/

http://www.saunalahti.fi/wtc2001/military.htm

http://www.wtcnuke.com/

They make good points,. probably better than my own.
 
Who's a liar?

Woof!

I meant in this thread. Obviously any demo. would require devices in the basement levels. And something caused that "pothole".

The official explanation for the pothole is "glaciers". Interesting how there was no mention of such a geological anomaly when they built the bathtub.
 
I respect your views. I think it's imposible to know how much steel was or was not missing, since no one can even come to a conclusion of the exact amount actually used in the original construction.

I will state that my opinion that "nukes" were used are based entirely on these sites:

http://nucleardemolition.com/

http://www.saunalahti.fi/wtc2001/military.htm

http://www.wtcnuke.com/

They make good points,. probably better than my own.

Well Turd that is quite a different matter.

If it is just your opinion (based on little or nothing and you are happy with that) that is something quite different than claiming that you have evidence of such when you clearly don’t.

Your opinion I can respect, made up lies and false evidence I can’t stand.

Woof!
 
Well Turd that is quite a different matter.

If it is just your opinion (based on little or nothing and you are happy with that) that is something quite different than claiming that you have evidence of such when you clearly don’t.

Your opinion I can respect, made up lies and false evidence I can’t stand.

Woof!

I wasn't even there, any "evidence" should be apparent as coming from the internet.

However, I think it's apparent that the tide of public opinion is indeed turning and people are beginning to think there is more to it than what has been given as an explanation.

I consider this to be dangerous, because people are coming to the (in my opinion) false conclusion that the government or elements of the government actually planted bombs and brought down the towers.

That just seems simplistic, as I said, they base this opinion on the notion that "9/11 was necessary to invade Iraq", which I think is false. We would have invaded Iraq with no 9/11.
 
I meant in this thread. Obviously any demo. would require devices in the basement levels. And something caused that "pothole".

The official explanation for the pothole is "glaciers". Interesting how there was no mention of such a geological anomaly when they built the bathtub.

PC said "from another thread" and you have been claiming it over and over again so it is no surprise that he thought this was your position. And really no reason to call him a liar when clearly he was not.

So the Nukes are not in the basement now or they are?

In normal demos, yes you're right, there are devices in the basement. But, this demo is not normal in many ways. Using Nukes, Thermite, Thermate, crashing planes into the building and setting it on fire, to name just a few.

Woof!
 
PC said "from another thread" and you have been claiming it over and over again so it is no surprise that he thought this was your position. And really no reason to call him a liar when clearly he was not.

So the Nukes are not in the basement now or they are?

In normal demos, yes you're right, there are devices in the basement. But, this demo is not normal in many ways. Using Nukes, Thermite, Thermate, crashing planes into the building and setting it on fire, to name just a few.

Woof!

Has was purposely being deceitful per his entire arguement.

Obviously a single bomb in the basement could not have caused the top to collapse. But I never stated there was a single bomb or that there was ONLY a bomb in the basement.
 
I wasn't even there, any "evidence" should be apparent as coming from the internet.
That, of course, is obvious. As does mine, supplemented with some books.

What concerns me are the sources you use and the faith that you place in them. Some are just mistaken and some are evidently propaganda. Yes, I am also aware of state propaganda to in coming to my conclusions. But, engineering and scientific evidence are not part of propaganda, if you can understand it.

However, I think it's apparent that the tide of public opinion is indeed turning and people are beginning to think there is more to it than what has been given as an explanation.

Nope, I think in general the populous are bored and indifferent to the topic. There is no evidence of truth movement’s grand expansion it is more propaganda.

There is more to it than was given as an explanation and the first few lines of your first post in this thread were right on. The problem is that then you drift off in to this Nuke nonsense and every one stops taking you seriously.

I consider this to be dangerous, because people are coming to the (in my opinion) false conclusion that the government or elements of the government actually planted bombs and brought down the towers.

Very few take the truth movement seriously.

For me the government is quite happy with all their nonsense (the government may even promote it!!). All the time everyone is debating the obvious lies and falsehoods of the truth movement who is asking the difficult questions of the government and their failures that day?

That just seems simplistic, as I said, they base this opinion on the notion that "9/11 was necessary to invade Iraq", which I think is false. We would have invaded Iraq with no 9/11.

Why would 9/11 be necessary to invade Iraq? The government didn’t need it. They just made-up a fantasy about Iraqi WMD’s and used that as an excuse and subtly change that to Operation Iraqi Freedom when they realized that they didn’t have any WMD’s and went ahead with it anyway.

Woof!
 
That, of course, is obvious. As does mine, supplemented with some books.

What concerns me are the sources you use and the faith that you place in them. Some are just mistaken and some are evidently propaganda. Yes, I am also aware of state propaganda to in coming to my conclusions. But, engineering and scientific evidence are not part of propaganda, if you can understand it.



Nope, I think in general the populous are bored and indifferent to the topic. There is no evidence of truth movement’s grand expansion it is more propaganda.

There is more to it than was given as an explanation and the first few lines of your first post in this thread were right on. The problem is that then you drift off in to this Nuke nonsense and every one stops taking you seriously.



Very few take the truth movement seriously.

For me the government is quite happy with all their nonsense (the government may even promote it!!). All the time everyone is debating the obvious lies and falsehoods of the truth movement who is asking the difficult questions of the government and their failures that day?



Why would 9/11 be necessary to invade Iraq? The government didn’t need it. They just made-up a fantasy about Iraqi WMD’s and used that as an excuse and subtly change that to Operation Iraqi Freedom when they realized that they didn’t have any WMD’s and went ahead with it anyway.

Woof!

The sources I used seem quite comprehensive.

As for public opinion, I suppose it remains to be seen, but I will agree most are complacent, no doubt.

For the last parts, you just may be spot on.
 
Turd just one question for tonight. One that I have wondered while talking to you.

Why don't you go the whole way and believe the laser beam thing from Judy Wood & co? It is well with-in your realm.

Woof!
 
Turd just one question for tonight. One that I have wondered while talking to you.

Why don't you go the whole way and believe the laser beam thing from Judy Wood & co? It is well with-in your realm.

Woof!

Ha..no evidence of DEW's.

I think I read once about the magnetometer at HAARP had an anomanly that day, or something.
 
The sources I used seem quite comprehensive.

Comprehensive, may-be but unreliable and some down right dishonest. You can't make your opinions about this through You Tube.

As for public opinion, I suppose it remains to be seen, but I will agree most are complacent, no doubt.

The people have spoken they don't trust the Reps on a whole range of issues anymore. It is a new dawn.

Woof!
 
Comprehensive, may-be but unreliable and some down right dishonest. You can't make your opinions about this through You Tube.

He doesn't understand any of the science. Google and Youtube are all he has.
 
Ha..no evidence of DEW's.

I think I read once about the magnetometer at HAARP had an anomanly that day, or something.

Well there's something never thought there would be something too wacky for ya. They could've reverse engineered it and all kinds of stuff. A fertile ground.

Enjoy yer world Turd.

Woof!
 
Well there's something never thought there would be something too wacky for ya. They could've reverse engineered it and all kinds of stuff. A fertile ground.

Enjoy yer world Turd.

Woof!

You must have missed where I posted the theory about secret nuclear reactors under the WTC. Now that has to be "the wackiest" theory.
 
False claim.

Why do you lie?

As part of the general population, not currently under treatment for psychotic delusions, they are a very small percentage.

If a lot of people took the truth movement seriously, there wouldn't be a movement, except for a small group who claimed that two jets hijacked by Islamic extremists crashed into the WTC. They would show links to web pages showing that the structural damage and fires caused the buildings to collapse.

This would all be dismissed by people who knew the real story and they would point to the investigation of people who trained the inside bombers, planted the explosives. The world wide manhunt would bring in a few, and reveal many more who had knowledge before the event. The inside job people would correctly point out that no conspiracy this large, could be kept secret forever.
 
Back
Top