Dear Bill Gates,

leaving politics (I hope) out of it I will say the anti GMO crowd through anecdotal observation (cough Instagram cross-postings to FaceBook....hack cough) seems to use a lot of the same language and persuasive tactics that appeal to fairly low information threshold persons. This is NOT intended as a slam on anyone. We all have areas of specialized interests and areas that whether we know it or not we are only absorbing information in a superficial way.

I don't like emotional bomb-throwing such as "Do your research!" and so forth. It implies that one person's point of view is somehow more valid because they have garnered information from a source that they feel (feeling is not empirical, remember) they can trust.

On any subject (GMO's only a small subset of those possible avenues of enlightened reading) I am delighted to learn things. If people have interesting point and counterpoint material, or even just reasoned argument, I feel I am feasting at some trough of knowledge.

Whenever I see snark that shuts down the conversation with no actual source material involved I find that disappointing.

As we had an actual Botanist weigh in I am inclined to want to pick his brain a bit more than some general conspiracy-minded group-speak. Now as Freud said even paranoids have enemies and Gates fortune was based on unlawful conversion of what was Sun Microsystem's misplaced intellectual property, then bullying and intimidation of others into believing he had some right to monopolizing what was essentially open source code...well I wouldn't put it past him to engage in malfeasance.

That said I have only the high school version of honors biology to fall back on and this mind you was prior to Dolly being cloned, so I don;t know what the inherrant risks might be.

My basic understanding of the process of gene-splicing (which I believe is the core of the for and against arguments here) is that we are merely (in exponential ways, mind you) speeding up the process of evolving things to be more useful to humankind. Trial and error, one generation at a time evolution takes eons...we may not have that before we have mass starvation.

I admit, adding a fish gene to rice to get rice with omega-3 in it seems a bit sewer-turtles licking up nuclear cast-off, but lets take that case. If tribesman with very short life-expectancy live long enough to even experience side effects, is that not a win?

I agree that the caveat of lets not poison a downwind village eradicating some vector from the upwind village...but lets take that literally. Lack of DDT has caused malaria to once again be prevalent killing untold thousands (millions?) . Silent Spring was propaganda. Well meaning propaganda, but it was anecdotes substituted for actual observable, repeatable science.

Follow the money. DDT's patent had run out. Has Monsanto's patents run out and they now need their new and improved methodology blessed by some government agency that ought not exist??
 
We try to avoid eating any genetic modified food. It IS poison and especially harmful to children's reproductive organs! In China, you can't trust the word "organic" though. Another reason for our move to MA.


Yes...
 
My basic understanding of the process of gene-splicing (which I believe is the core of the for and against arguments here) is that we are merely (in exponential ways, mind you) speeding up the process of evolving things to be more useful to humankind. Trial and error, one generation at a time evolution takes eons...we may not have that before we have mass starvation.

I admit, adding a fish gene to rice to get rice with omega-3 in it seems a bit sewer-turtles licking up nuclear cast-off, but lets take that case. If tribesman with very short life-expectancy live long enough to even experience side effects, is that not a win?

Here is the deal with gene splicing.

All organisms are just chemical computers....DNA is the OS programming code.

Now, since most organisms share a HUGE chunk of the same genetic material, that OS code can work in a plethora of computers.

Gene splicing is like taking a line of code from one computer...and sticking it into a different computer to give it the characteristics you want. A new program if you will that does whatever you want. As long as it stays within the realm of the OS. That is to say you can't make potato's produce VX nerve toxin any more than you can make I tunes play vinyl. No matter how hard you cram that record into your CD ROM, ain't never going to happen.....

The Omega 3 gene is in there...it's just dominant in fish not rice....but if you take that specific dominant code from a fish and program it into rice...you get OM3 rice.

It's really not TMNT as it seems...in fact it's pretty elementary, and just a toe dip into the world of genetics. I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if in 10 years the kids showing up in lab look at me like we look at computer scientist of 1990.

I agree that the caveat of lets not poison a downwind village eradicating some vector from the upwind village...but lets take that literally. Lack of DDT has caused malaria to once again be prevalent killing untold thousands (millions?) . Silent Spring was propaganda. Well meaning propaganda, but it was anecdotes substituted for actual observable, repeatable science.

Oh for sure...like I said I was never trying to defend a scum bag company for scumbag business practices.

But as far as I can tell there is more science fiction in the claims against their product than there is science.

Follow the money. DDT's patent had run out. Has Monsanto's patents run out and they now need their new and improved methodology blessed by some government agency that ought not exist??

Yup...not only that but think of the benefits to a seed company that produces seeds who's plant's are incapable of reproducing, super simple, really great for business.

People bitch...I say learn to propagate...they can change the program all they want but the hardware as of now is still the same ;)

If you really want to get into it weed/apples/tulips/potatoes...most advanced areas of botanical genetic research by a landslide.
 
Last edited:
We try to avoid eating any genetic modified food.

So you don't eat??:confused:

Eat all the organic you want...damn near all of it is genetically modified...can't think of a single crop/live stock species that isn't directly modified by human interaction. From potato's to cows.

If you want to get real broad every organism in existence is genetically modified by it's environment.
 
Last edited:
We've been genetically modifying since the beginning of time.

It's health-food-store nonsense.

Don't fall for it.

What are you talking about? Damn near every food we consume is genetically modified. From free range live stock to organic carrots....every last one of them.

Your pet dog....a genetically modified wolf....unless it's a chihuahua, they are thought to come from a small central american Fox originally.

The flowers in your garden....HIGH probability that if they aren't indigenous, they are genetically modified. Roses...tulips...weed...all of it.

Genetics.....check it out.


☝​
★★★★★

​
 
All food is organic. Except maybe the odd mineral, like salt.

And unless you go out and shoot yourself wild game, or pick berries in the forest, all food is genetically altered, through one technique or another.

All of a sudden, the latest in a long line of techniques to modify species, is having people up in arms.
 
Last edited:
Anti-GMO Activist Recants​

Former anti-GMO activist Mark Lynas, who opposed genetically modified food in the 1990s, said recently, at the Oxford Farming Conference: 'I want to start with some apologies. For the record, here and upfront, I apologize for having spent several years ripping up GM crops. I am also sorry that I helped to start the anti-GM movement back in the mid 1990s, and that I thereby assisted in demonizing an important technological option which can be used to benefit the environment. As an environmentalist, and someone who believes that everyone in this world has a right to a healthy and nutritious diet of their choosing, I could not have chosen a more counter-productive path. I now regret it completely. So I guess you'll be wondering — what happened between 1995 and now that made me not only change my mind but come here and admit it? Well, the answer is fairly simple: I discovered science, and in the process I hope I became a better environmentalist.'

To vilify GMOs is to be as anti-science as climate-change deniers, he says. To feed a growing world population (with an exploding middle class demanding more and better-quality food), we must take advantage of all the technology available to us, including GMOs. To insist on 'natural' agriculture and livestock is to doom people to starvation, and there’s no logical reason to prefer the old ways, either. Moreover, the reason why big companies dominate the industry is that anti-GMO activists and policymakers have made it too difficult for small startups to enter the field.

http://m.slashdot.org/story/180115
 
Here is the deal with gene splicing.

All organisms are just chemical computers....DNA is the OS programming code.

Now, since most organisms share a HUGE chunk of the same genetic material, that OS code can work in a plethora of computers.

Gene splicing is like taking a line of code from one computer...and sticking it into a different computer to give it the characteristics you want. A new program if you will that does whatever you want. As long as it stays within the realm of the OS. That is to say you can't make potato's produce VX nerve toxin any more than you can make I tunes play vinyl. No matter how hard you cram that record into your CD ROM, ain't never going to happen.....

The Omega 3 gene is in there...it's just dominant in fish not rice....but if you take that specific dominant code from a fish and program it into rice...you get OM3 rice.

It's really not TMNT as it seems...in fact it's pretty elementary, and just a toe dip into the world of genetics. I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if in 10 years the kids showing up in lab look at me like we look at computer scientist of 1990.



Oh for sure...like I said I was never trying to defend a scum bag company for scumbag business practices.

But as far as I can tell there is more science fiction in the claims against their product than there is science.



Yup...not only that but think of the benefits to a seed company that produces seeds who's plant's are incapable of reproducing, super simple, really great for business.

People bitch...I say learn to propagate...they can change the program all they want but the hardware as of now is still the same ;)

If you really want to get into it weed/apples/tulips/potatoes...most advanced areas of botanical genetic research by a landslide.
thankyou. this says what i believe. and if a company's shitting on a specific environment/population, then that needs addressing - not attack the science being developed to help problems we're facing.
Anti-GMO Activist Recants​

Former anti-GMO activist Mark Lynas, who opposed genetically modified food in the 1990s, said recently, at the Oxford Farming Conference: 'I want to start with some apologies. For the record, here and upfront, I apologize for having spent several years ripping up GM crops. I am also sorry that I helped to start the anti-GM movement back in the mid 1990s, and that I thereby assisted in demonizing an important technological option which can be used to benefit the environment. As an environmentalist, and someone who believes that everyone in this world has a right to a healthy and nutritious diet of their choosing, I could not have chosen a more counter-productive path. I now regret it completely. So I guess you'll be wondering — what happened between 1995 and now that made me not only change my mind but come here and admit it? Well, the answer is fairly simple: I discovered science, and in the process I hope I became a better environmentalist.'

To vilify GMOs is to be as anti-science as climate-change deniers, he says. To feed a growing world population (with an exploding middle class demanding more and better-quality food), we must take advantage of all the technology available to us, including GMOs. To insist on 'natural' agriculture and livestock is to doom people to starvation, and there’s no logical reason to prefer the old ways, either. Moreover, the reason why big companies dominate the industry is that anti-GMO activists and policymakers have made it too difficult for small startups to enter the field.

http://m.slashdot.org/story/180115
and thankyou, sonny.

this whole poisoning the water, poisoning the crops, poisoning the air, climate-change is a hoax . . . all this stuff (and illuminati and more) is what i have to listen to from no2 son on a regular basis. his most recent was kicking off about poisoning the water with flouride - how it's killing us all. never mind the fact he's never had to have a filling or tooth extraction and none of us are dead yet. :rolleyes:
 
thankyou. this says what i believe. and if a company's shitting on a specific environment/population, then that needs addressing - not attack the science being developed to help problems we're facing.

Np....and word. :cool:

this whole poisoning the water, poisoning the crops, poisoning the air, climate-change is a hoax . . . all this stuff (and illuminati and more) is what i have to listen to from no2 son on a regular basis. his most recent was kicking off about poisoning the water with flouride - how it's killing us all. never mind the fact he's never had to have a filling or tooth extraction and none of us are dead yet. :rolleyes:

I'll give him this....fluoride is some NASTY shit, bad juju on your soft tissues. That being said we get insano small doses in municipal water. After going 4 1/2 years without it, I'm still to this day fighting the de-calcification of my teeth. Ready to just have them all pulled and have fake's put in.
http://www.invisibledisabilities.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/GaryBusey.jpg

Granted, spending most of that time borderline malnourished and under severe stress probably had more to do with it than the water...but it didn't help! :mad:
 
Last edited:
Anti-GMO Activist Recants​

Former anti-GMO activist Mark Lynas, who opposed genetically modified food in the 1990s, said recently, at the Oxford Farming Conference: 'I want to start with some apologies. For the record, here and upfront, I apologize for having spent several years ripping up GM crops. I am also sorry that I helped to start the anti-GM movement back in the mid 1990s, and that I thereby assisted in demonizing an important technological option which can be used to benefit the environment. As an environmentalist, and someone who believes that everyone in this world has a right to a healthy and nutritious diet of their choosing, I could not have chosen a more counter-productive path. I now regret it completely. So I guess you'll be wondering — what happened between 1995 and now that made me not only change my mind but come here and admit it? Well, the answer is fairly simple: I discovered science, and in the process I hope I became a better environmentalist.'

To vilify GMOs is to be as anti-science as climate-change deniers, he says. To feed a growing world population (with an exploding middle class demanding more and better-quality food), we must take advantage of all the technology available to us, including GMOs. To insist on 'natural' agriculture and livestock is to doom people to starvation, and there’s no logical reason to prefer the old ways, either. Moreover, the reason why big companies dominate the industry is that anti-GMO activists and policymakers have made it too difficult for small startups to enter the field.

http://m.slashdot.org/story/180115
Who hired him to speak at the conference?
 
Np....and word. :cool:



I'll give him this....fluoride is some NASTY shit, bad juju on your soft tissues. That being said we get insano small doses in municipal water. And after 4 1/2 years without it and I'm still to this day fighting the de-calcification of my teeth. Ready to just have them all pulled and have fake's put in.
http://www.invisibledisabilities.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/GaryBusey.jpg
seems our water here has enough to help and not enough to cause problems; i suppose if people were taking supplements and swallowing toothpaste by the tube and otherwise taking excess fluoride into their bodies then it's gonna spell Trouble.

i've tried, very patiently (till i end up feeling browbeaten by his determination to 'help me' :rolleyes: ) to explain that just about anything is harmful to us in the wrong doses. and i'm not so naive to think most companies are driven by morality rather than profit. when he potificates too much, though, i simply point out the fact he smokes. but of course, according to him, that's not 'his' fault - it's the fault of tobacco companies that got him hooked on tobacco in the first place.

there's no excuse: people of his age were well-informed of how toxic tobacco is to their bodies and still chose to smoke.

*sigh*
 
seems our water here has enough to help and not enough to cause problems; i suppose if people were taking supplements and swallowing toothpaste by the tube and otherwise taking excess fluoride into their bodies then it's gonna spell Trouble.

i've tried, very patiently (till i end up feeling browbeaten by his determination to 'help me' :rolleyes: ) to explain that just about anything is harmful to us in the wrong doses. and i'm not so naive to think most companies are driven by morality rather than profit. when he potificates too much, though, i simply point out the fact he smokes. but of course, according to him, that's not 'his' fault - it's the fault of tobacco companies that got him hooked on tobacco in the first place.

there's no excuse: people of his age were well-informed of how toxic tobacco is to their bodies and still chose to smoke.

*sigh*

Yea...I'm guilty, smoked cigg's for 13 years...regretting that decision. But I quit...3 years this July. Now I just occasionally smoke weed....every day. Which isn't a whole lot better on the health spectrum. So I have gotten into vapes and cooking with cannabis recently as a healthier alternative. Still love a nice cold bong hit but I'm working on it.

Best of luck with the young buck....no one ever said being a responsible adult was easy, but hopefully he grows up and starts owning his life choices sooner than I did.
 
Last edited:
Yea...I'm guilty, smoked cigg's for 13 years...regretting that decision. But I quit...3 years this July. Now I just occasionally smoke weed....every day. Which isn't a whole lot better on the health spectrum. So I have gotten into vapes and cooking with cannabis recently as a healthier alternative. Still love a nice cold bong hit but I'm working on it.

Best of luck with the young buck....no one ever said being a responsible adult was easy, but hopefully he grows up and starts owning his life choices sooner than I did.

i made plenty of poor choices in my life - just never went down the smoking road, fortunately.

he's managed to get himself clean of weed - over a year and a half now. he needed to, as was stealing from me and our home and had other issues due to it. it wasn't easy for him, but he stopped it dead and cut out all contact with the other users he hung about with. i'm proud of his determination and success in this, at least.

thankyou. he's 21 at the end of the week. he'll get there, eventually. and, if i remember rightly back to that age, i believed a whole host of crap too. :eek:
 
My problem with Monsanto isn't GM crops, per se, but the fact that they're trying to patent seeds that have been used for centuries and so monopolise the food supply.
 
My problem with Monsanto isn't GM crops, per se, but the fact that they're trying to patent seeds that have been used for centuries and so monopolise the food supply.

so what's being done to try and block this monopoly-bid? or is it a case of monsanto having more wealth/power than other companies so they cannot be challenged by them over this?
 
Who hired him to speak at the conference?
Are you suggesting he submitted his abstract saying he changed his mind, then waited for his conference invitation to decide whether or not he actually had?

Every submitter to every scientific publication is paid as well...
 
so what's being done to try and block this monopoly-bid? or is it a case of monsanto having more wealth/power than other companies so they cannot be challenged by them over this?

They buy lawmakers.
 
I'm not talking about the shitty business practices...a scumbag company is a scumbag company.

I'm simply addressing the whole sterilizing the population through genetically manipulated crops. Being a botanist and all it kinda strikes my interest just how in the fuck they managed to do that, and better yet, since they are light years ahead of all other humans in the genetics dept. How the fuck did us regular folks figure out these uber geniuses plans??

not sure if the food itself is poisonous.
but, they manipulated the genes to make the plants not to die by weed killer, round up, and pesticides. you can't wash all that shit off before you eat it. or can it, or whatever. round up and these pesticides are harmful to air, water, and even beneficial insects, like, BEES.
guess who makes round up and many of these pesticides.
some of the plants have been manipulated to have a terminator gene. that means you can't save the seed. it won't grow the next generation. these can pollinate other plants that have never been genetically manipulated. thus kiss your seed goodbye.
some have been maipulated to where they have a BTi in them. so if a bug eats the plant, it kills it. but it can cross pollinate with others. the BTi will kill butterflies.
 
Back
Top