Dear Bill Gates,

Are you suggesting he submitted his abstract saying he changed his mind, then waited for his conference invitation to decide whether or not he actually had?

Every submitter to every scientific publication is paid as well...
The anti-science crowd love to point at rogue scientists and claim scientific proof of their anti-science views.
 
This thread taught me some stuff. Thanks for starting it, Neci.
 
The anti-science crowd love to point at rogue scientists and claim scientific proof of their anti-science views.
He's not a scientist. Scientists know the anti-GMO stuff is absurd. He's the guy who started the anti-GMO stuff.

He now says he was wrong, that his initial position recklessly rejected the science at hand, that the residual effects have done more harm than good, and that he regrets his role in the absurdity.

Other than that, you're really onto something here.
 
not sure if the food itself is poisonous.
but, they manipulated the genes to make the plants not to die by weed killer, round up, and pesticides. you can't wash all that shit off before you eat it. or can it, or whatever. round up and these pesticides are harmful to air, water, and even beneficial insects, like, BEES.
guess who makes round up and many of these pesticides.
some of the plants have been manipulated to have a terminator gene. that means you can't save the seed. it won't grow the next generation. these can pollinate other plants that have never been genetically manipulated. thus kiss your seed goodbye.
some have been maipulated to where they have a BTi in them. so if a bug eats the plant, it kills it. but it can cross pollinate with others. the BTi will kill butterflies.

Insecticides, salt based nutes, fungicide etc are already all over all your food and all over the environment man, unless you buy organically grown food you contribute to this....period.

The terminator gene will only last one generation if cross pollinated....better call big M and order some seeds for next years crop....;)
 
We can kill off all the bugs and do the polllenization ourselves. That will ensure full employment.
 
It's right to say we're the product of genetic modifications. It's almost as if creating genetic diversity is the point of sexual reproduction.... :cattail:

However, human attempts at controlling reproduction has, up until recently, been very non-invasive.
The only trick was pretty much to take a male and a female with attributes that you wanted, letting them breed and then keeping your fingers crossed that the offspring was as good as, or better, than its parents. Keeping at it long enough and you would succeed in modifying the animal variety.
In spite of the non-invasiveness of this method, human interference often had unforeseen consequences. For instance, most varieties of chickens today are so fucked up from our interference that they would probably find it impossible to survive in environments not controlled by humans. They're sickly, bad mothers and cannibalistic which is why most smallholders try to find old, less "bred" varieties of poultry. Pigs too have suffered, being bred to produce lots of chops and bacon, and huge litter, which they are unable to birth without the aid of a vet. So yes, livestock too has been genetically modified for a long time.

It's the same when it comes to plants. Horticulturalist a have selected, cross-pollinated and grafted since agriculture began. This increase in diversity created new varieties which enabled people to grow crops under some pretty inhospitable conditions.
But when industrial agriculture came into its own, all this changed. Machines were expensive and it became more convenient to fit the crop to the tool rather than the other way around. Suddenly wheat (as an example), which used to be tall and varied, became uniformly short to facilitate harvesting.

Also, centralisation and mass production of foods like bread and pasta meant that growing wheat varieties with higher than normal gluten content became a profitable object. Another commercial convenience added into the cauldron of reasons to modify. Btw, some people claim this increased form of gluten in wheat is the cause of the recent increases in gluten intolerance.

So the reasons for crop modifications evolved - they were no longer modified only for quality, yield or adaptability to its environement, but to fit the machines used to farm and the processing of the food once it was harvested and this affected diversity severely. As a consequence, the numbers of plant varieties that are grown today are much lower than they were a couple of generations ago. This reduction of diversity will quite likely continue because of the relentless lobbying by agribusiness for controlling who exactly can save seeds and how those seeds can be shared.

In fact, it seems to me that every step that Monsanto and other companies in the agribusiness take, leads towards a reduction of diversity, not an increase - the creation of hybrid plants that do not grow true from seeds, the attempts to patent plants (Basmati rice is an example) and in their legal processes trying to stop farmers from storing and using their own seeds. All this prevents small farmers from growing affordable staple crops and does not in any way increase food yields.

Of course, increasing food yield has never been Monsanto's intention - have a look on their site and you'll see that their genetically modified seeds are all bred for" in-plant tolerance" to their herbicides and pesticides and to be used exclusively in conjunction with their own brands.

Whichever way they try to sell it ("Maximum profit opportunity with no-till and the Roundup Ready System. Efficiency—with reduced tillage and the system's unmatched weed control and flexibility, you get more time to spend where you need it most. Convenience—the system's simple, unsurpassed weed control takes the worry out of crop production" http://www.monsanto.com/products/Pages/monsanto-agricultural-seeds.aspx) their claim that somehow this will lead to less herbicide use goes counter to human nature. If your wage crop is not harmed by the herbicide, you'll use it more often, not less.

This post is way too long and I apologize. I just want to say that there have been loads of disasters caused by humans introducing species or varieties into a new environment. The European wine business was nearly destroyed by phylloxera, brought over on American vines and although it was saved by grafting old European varieties onto resistant rootstock, European wine was changed forever.
Japanese knotweed is still wreaking havoc in the British countryside, American grey squirrels have all but destroyed our native red ones, the innocent rabbit caused untold damage in Australia....etc.
Life is hard to predict and even harder to control and I think it's reasonable to place the burden of evidence on companies like Monsanto to prove that, at the very least, their product does not cause harm. Neither biological nor cultural/financial harm.
 
It's right to say we're the product of genetic modifications. It's almost as if creating genetic diversity is the point of sexual reproduction.... :cattail:

However, human attempts at controlling reproduction has, up until recently, been very non-invasive.
The only trick was pretty much to take a male and a female with attributes that you wanted, letting them breed and then keeping your fingers crossed that the offspring was as good as, or better, than its parents. Keeping at it long enough and you would succeed in modifying the animal variety.
In spite of the non-invasiveness of this method, human interference often had unforeseen consequences. For instance, most varieties of chickens today are so fucked up from our interference that they would probably find it impossible to survive in environments not controlled by humans. They're sickly, bad mothers and cannibalistic which is why most smallholders try to find old, less "bred" varieties of poultry. Pigs too have suffered, being bred to produce lots of chops and bacon, and huge litter, which they are unable to birth without the aid of a vet. So yes, livestock too has been genetically modified for a long time.

It's the same when it comes to plants. Horticulturalist a have selected, cross-pollinated and grafted since agriculture began. This increase in diversity created new varieties which enabled people to grow crops under some pretty inhospitable conditions.
But when industrial agriculture came into its own, all this changed. Machines were expensive and it became more convenient to fit the crop to the tool rather than the other way around. Suddenly wheat (as an example), which used to be tall and varied, became uniformly short to facilitate harvesting.

Also, centralisation and mass production of foods like bread and pasta meant that growing wheat varieties with higher than normal gluten content became a profitable object. Another commercial convenience added into the cauldron of reasons to modify. Btw, some people claim this increased form of gluten in wheat is the cause of the recent increases in gluten intolerance.

So the reasons for crop modifications evolved - they were no longer modified only for quality, yield or adaptability to its environement, but to fit the machines used to farm and the processing of the food once it was harvested and this affected diversity severely. As a consequence, the numbers of plant varieties that are grown today are much lower than they were a couple of generations ago. This reduction of diversity will quite likely continue because of the relentless lobbying by agribusiness for controlling who exactly can save seeds and how those seeds can be shared.

In fact, it seems to me that every step that Monsanto and other companies in the agribusiness take, leads towards a reduction of diversity, not an increase - the creation of hybrid plants that do not grow true from seeds, the attempts to patent plants (Basmati rice is an example) and in their legal processes trying to stop farmers from storing and using their own seeds. All this prevents small farmers from growing affordable staple crops and does not in any way increase food yields.

Of course, increasing food yield has never been Monsanto's intention - have a look on their site and you'll see that their genetically modified seeds are all bred for" in-plant tolerance" to their herbicides and pesticides and to be used exclusively in conjunction with their own brands.

Whichever way they try to sell it ("Maximum profit opportunity with no-till and the Roundup Ready System. Efficiency—with reduced tillage and the system's unmatched weed control and flexibility, you get more time to spend where you need it most. Convenience—the system's simple, unsurpassed weed control takes the worry out of crop production" http://www.monsanto.com/products/Pages/monsanto-agricultural-seeds.aspx) their claim that somehow this will lead to less herbicide use goes counter to human nature. If your wage crop is not harmed by the herbicide, you'll use it more often, not less.

This post is way too long and I apologize. I just want to say that there have been loads of disasters caused by humans introducing species or varieties into a new environment. The European wine business was nearly destroyed by phylloxera, brought over on American vines and although it was saved by grafting old European varieties onto resistant rootstock, European wine was changed forever.
Japanese knotweed is still wreaking havoc in the British countryside, American grey squirrels have all but destroyed our native red ones, the innocent rabbit caused untold damage in Australia....etc.
Life is hard to predict and even harder to control and I think it's reasonable to place the burden of evidence on companies like Monsanto to prove that, at the very least, their product does not cause harm. Neither biological nor cultural/financial harm.

thank you for your post.

they are in no way a sustainable company. they hold a monopoly on large scale agriculture in the US, and continue this monopoly through patented seeds and the use of toxic chemicals, designed to go with the seeds, which in turn poison our land.

roundup ready soybeans - 90% of all soy produced in the USA.

roundup ready corn. roundup ready alfalfa.

the genetic alteration is so you can apply a stronger poison to the plant without killing it. the poison does not just disappear as wiki would lead you to believe. the poison is disposed back into the land from the factories who create the poison as well as the farmers who apply it to their land. you don't need to be a scientist to figure that out. you don't need to be a scientist to realize they are trying to create a dependent relationship with the farmers, where by the only way their plants will grow is with more chemicals. sterile seeds is only the beginning.


what is a weed?
horseweed/fleawort - medicinal uses? the indians knew. why are we studying how to kill this plant and not studying how it is beneficial to us? i would rather eat fleawort than soy.
 
The lack of bio diversity is obviously going to leave us open to famine and huge issues with our food supply.

I think that much is clear. But monsanto has the politicians in their pockets, and they're not going to stop getting laws passed that benefit them.

All that you can do, is act locally, and do what you want to do... or at least until they try to pass laws against gardening and farming on your own property... Who knows what the future holds?
 
thank you for your post.

they are in no way a sustainable company. they hold a monopoly on large scale agriculture in the US, and continue this monopoly through patented seeds and the use of toxic chemicals, designed to go with the seeds, which in turn poison our land.

roundup ready soybeans - 90% of all soy produced in the USA.

roundup ready corn. roundup ready alfalfa.

the genetic alteration is so you can apply a stronger poison to the plant without killing it. the poison does not just disappear as wiki would lead you to believe. the poison is disposed back into the land from the factories who create the poison as well as the farmers who apply it to their land. you don't need to be a scientist to figure that out. you don't need to be a scientist to realize they are trying to create a dependent relationship with the farmers, where by the only way their plants will grow is with more chemicals. sterile seeds is only the beginning.


what is a weed?
horseweed/fleawort - medicinal uses? the indians knew. why are we studying how to kill this plant and not studying how it is beneficial to us? i would rather eat fleawort than soy.
Yeah, you do need to be a scientist to figure that out. If you're not then you're just assuming based on extremely limited knowledge.
 
what is a weed?
horseweed/fleawort - medicinal uses? the indians knew. why are we studying how to kill this plant and not studying how it is beneficial to us? i would rather eat fleawort than soy.
They have, but it's secrets were discovered long ago. It's predominant medicinal ingredients are alkaloids and tannic acids which are or were both routinely used in pharmaceuticals. Tannic acids not as much these days iirc.

Disclaimer: IANAS (I Am Not A Scientist), I just watch docus on TV.
 
Yeah, you do need to be a scientist to figure that out. If you're not then you're just assuming based on extremely limited knowledge.

Except for (obviously) if you're a pro-GMO non-scientist. http://forum.literotica.com/showpost.php?p=45289289&postcount=53

Not only is he not a scientist, but he was never a driving force behind the anti-GM movement either. He has a bit of the Bjørn Lomborg about him...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/oct/20/europabio-gm-ambassadors-europe?intcmp=239

http://www.alternet.org/food/uncovering-real-story-behind-conversion-mark-lynas-climate-change-journalist-cheerleader
 
I've talked to two kinds of people about GMOs. The first are people in health food stores. They all know they're bad for us.

The second are geneticists. They have nothing to do with GMOs or biotech, I'm talking about the people working on decoding the genome and the like. They all think the first group of people are foolish, uninformed bozos, who don't realize that we've been "genetically modifying" since literally the beginnings of life on Earth.

Since I'm smarter than the first group and not as smart as the second group, I'm going to defer to the second group.
 
They have, but it's secrets were discovered long ago. It's predominant medicinal ingredients are alkaloids and tannic acids which are or were both routinely used in pharmaceuticals. Tannic acids not as much these days iirc.

Disclaimer: IANAS (I Am Not A Scientist), I just watch docus on TV.

Tannic acid is used to "fine" beer, ie make it clear.
 
I've talked to two kinds of people about GMOs. The first are people in health food stores. They all know they're bad for us.

The second are geneticists. They have nothing to do with GMOs or biotech, I'm talking about the people working on decoding the genome and the like. They all think the first group of people are foolish, uninformed bozos, who don't realize that we've been "genetically modifying" since literally the beginnings of life on Earth.

Since I'm smarter than the first group and not as smart as the second group, I'm going to defer to the second group.

I certainly agree with most of what's in your second paragraph.
It's unfortunate that those people you're talking about are not the ones informing development in Monsanto & co.

Spoken in my layperson voice.
 
the genetic alteration is so you can apply a stronger poison to the plant without killing it. the poison does not just disappear as wiki would lead you to believe. the poison is disposed back into the land from the factories who create the poison as well as the farmers who apply it to their land. you don't need to be a scientist to figure that out.

Really? Do you understand how any of these chemicals actually break down or how the plant interacts with them?? Do you know what dose/rate these chemicals are being applied? What about how the human body reacts to food treated with X amount of these chemicals?

Or are you just blowing second hand smoke?

you don't need to be a scientist to realize they are trying to create a dependent relationship with the farmers, where by the only way their plants will grow is with more chemicals. sterile seeds is only the beginning.

You don't need to be a scientist to realize this b/c it has nothing to do with science and everything to do with business, economics and politics.

What's wrong with sterile seeds? Sounds like a legit business move for a seed co.


All that you can do, is act locally, and do what you want to do... or at least until they try to pass laws against gardening and farming on your own property... Who knows what the future holds?

They are already pressing that via the FDA....tried legitimately back in 08, the response from urban farmers/home gardeners nation wide put that one down reaaaally fast, wouldn't shock me though if they keep trying to push/sneak the issue at some point.
 
They are already pressing that via the FDA....tried legitimately back in 08, the response from urban farmers/home gardeners nation wide put that one down reaaaally fast, wouldn't shock me though if they keep trying to push/sneak the issue at some point.

Yup, under the guise of "food safety". You know what's not safe about the way our food is grown? Lack of genetic diversity... Seriously, if we ever see crop failure and famine in this country, we'll have that to thank for it. It's what caused the Irish potato famine.
 
Round-up ready crops produce their own herbicides, no need to spray them. Herbicides are good for you, eat up.
 
Back
Top