Hard drive crashes.

Had a hard drive crash in the past 5 years?


  • Total voters
    39
I've lost two in the last few years. A 500GB Hitachi that wouldn't spin up and a 500GB WD that pretty much garbled whatever data you put on it.
 
This is not a truly accurate count, because it's just not that important, but I'll give a close estimate. since 1993, I have owned somewhere around 20 desk top computers. Most of these were purchased in lots of three or four. It's easier when everyone is using the same machine.

In those 21 years, there have been 5 harddrive crashes which lost all data. Besides those, several became unreliable and you never knew if it was going to boot up or not.

That sounds more like it for desktops. And the majority of the failures I experienced were back in the 90's. Some brands/models were notoriously unreliable, to the point where several of the manufacturers are no longer around (Kalok comes immediately to mind).

I've had several laptops come my way that wouldn't boot but was able to mount them in my test jig machine and restore all but one with just the chdsk function.

Ishmael
 
Judging from the poll's results, HDD crashes are more frequent than the OP would have expected.
 
I voted yes, though technically it wasn't a crash since I knew it was failing from SMART alerts emailed to me, so I replaced it before it failed. It was a brand new drive, in service for a day and happened a couple of weeks ago.
Had an old IDE start clicking a few years ago, but can't I remember exactly when.. I trashed it before it failed completely.
 
I guess my previous post was wrong. .

One I got a death virus. The other the hard drive cables sparked.

So zero actual drive fails.
 
I had a solid state drive crash within the last 2 years. I put the os on that and put all the data on the the big spinning drive.
 
My wife has been online with several PC since the 1990 and I have been since 1998. Between us we have owned 8 different PCs and have had one HDD crash. She was also a system Admin. for a health care system for 2 years with 22 PCs and never had a single HDD crash during that time.

Even with the single HDD crash we has a pretty good tech who was able to save every bit of my important data. I did not lose a single bit of my porn.

If it make any difference she swears by Western Digital drives.

Mike
 
It happened to me once, but I wouldn't exactly call it a crash....

More like a wear-out than a crash. Not very much was lost, but it became a game of chance- what can I access today and how many attempts will it take?


Speaking of games of chance... Wasn't the hard drive of Vince Foster's computer found in a crashed state, also?

Maybe it's something that's more likely to happen in DC with all of that humidity and hot air.
 
5 more IRS employees caught up in the current scandal have lost all their e-mails due to hard drive crashes.

Ishmael

Meanwhile Eric "Contempt of Congress" Holder is launching an investigation into an entire police dept. because a cop killed a black thug who was charging him like a fucking grizzly bear.
 
The OP launches this thread with the supposition of hard drives destroying emails and no one challenges the idea. I worked for government, intranet emails aren't stored on slave terminals, they roost where administrators can look at them. You can toss your terminal outta the window to the retention pond and they'll access the intranet stuff all the same.

I suspect IRS and Congress are putting on a show for us.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Judging from the poll's results, HDD crashes are more frequent than the OP would have expected.

You're right, I am a little surprised. Given my experience and the experiences of those folks I know and those whose machines I work on, real hard drive crashes are relatively rare occurrences. As I mentioned before I've been able to recover all but one laptop drive. I will also note the laptops ARE more prone to problems in general (heat, shock, etc.).

Ishmael
 
The OP launches this thread with the supposition of hard drives destroying emails and no one challenges the idea. I worked for government, intranet emails aren't stored on slave terminals, they roost where administrators can look at them. You can toss your terminal outta the window to the retention pond and they'll access the intranet stuff all the same.

I suspect IRS and Congress are putting on a show for us.

Not really, I'm well aware that emails are stored off-site. I started the thread on the premise that so many HD failures are improbable to begin with. Then again, the govm't does purchase from the lowest bidder so I doubt that they're getting the best equipment on the market. Even the best manufacturers have low end, mass market, products.

Ishmael
 
You're right, I am a little surprised. Given my experience and the experiences of those folks I know and those whose machines I work on, real hard drive crashes are relatively rare occurrences. As I mentioned before I've been able to recover all but one laptop drive. I will also note the laptops ARE more prone to problems in general (heat, shock, etc.).

Ishmael

That's right, spanky. 70% of the folks here in your poll have experienced a hard drive crash, but that doesn't fit The Narrative, so you pivot to one of your patented "Appeal to Authority" lectures and blithely announce nobody has 'em.

#Derp
#TheNarrative
 
Not really, I'm well aware that emails are stored off-site. I started the thread on the premise that so many HD failures are improbable to begin with. Then again, the govm't does purchase from the lowest bidder so I doubt that they're getting the best equipment on the market. Even the best manufacturers have low end, mass market, products.

Ishmael

They can use pork n bean cans and string, my point is hard drives are irrelevant for email security as emails are stored off-board. The hard drive argument is nonsense.

IRS knows it, Congress knows it, so whats the show all about!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Blaming hard drive crashes is a convenient way to cover up wrongdoing. There is nothing Congress can do about it. Who is going to investigate these people, the government?
 
They can use pork n bean cans and string, my point is hard drives are irrelevant for email security as emails are stored off-board. The hard drive argument is nonsense.

IRS knows it, Congress knows it, so whats the show all about!

1. I fully understood your point.

2. I'm not making an 'argument' per se. Merely doing some RL fact finding.

I fully understand that in an enterprise setting using the excuse of a HD failure is specious. Even servers are backed up remotely so a server HD crash isn't much of an excuse for data loss.

Ishmael
 
Not really, I'm well aware that emails are stored off-site. I started the thread on the premise that so many HD failures are improbable to begin with. Then again, the govm't does purchase from the lowest bidder so I doubt that they're getting the best equipment on the market. Even the best manufacturers have low end, mass market, products.

Ishmael


There used to be a Minnesota company called Mirror Technology whose drives had at best a 66% failure rate and institutions still bought them.
 
I had a ssd crash two days after I bought one.

It happens.

I doubt theirs did.

I had the same thing happen to my first SSD.
replaced it with another exactly the same and it's been running flawlessly for almost 3 years now.

I've lost at least half a dozen standard hard drives over the past 5 years, both personal and business machines.

Ish, as usual, has no fucking clue what he's talking about. His anecdata isn't standing up to reality.
 
the point is it is rare for a hard drive to fail. this case would be like every hard drive in your entire family crashing at exactly the same time. unlikely to the nth.
 
the point is it is rare for a hard drive to fail. this case would be like every hard drive in your entire family crashing at exactly the same time. unlikely to the nth.

It really isn't. Especially if you're using antiquated computer equipment. Companies (and government entities) tend to buy a whole bunch of computers at the same time. That these machines would all start to fail around the same time isn't all that unlikely.
 
Back
Top