How do you define literate?

Weird Harold said:
Is teaching "how to learn" as important as teaching mere facts?

It's not just as important - it's vastly more important. It should be the goal of our education system, because that's what makes a person truly intelligent. I've dealt with more than my share of highly degreed clods who can spout textbook facts at you all day long, but can't handle a crisis with a client or can't think through a technical problem to save their lives.

Public education should prepare kids to succeed in the real world. In the real world, a head full of facts and numbers may make you the life of the party, but it's not extremely helpful in day-to-day life. What IS helpful is being able to understand systems. An example...I saw a woman learn to use Photoshop in less than an hour. She was able to see the program as a whole entity, to see that if selecting a tool and holding down shift does one thing, then selecting another tool and holding shift would do something as well. She never needed a manual - she learned new features by trying different keys and making logical connections. And because most photo manipulation products out today are modeled on Photoshop, she could then work with any of them because she understood the principle behind the software. Another man I know spent months on the program and STILL couldn't do anything that he hadn't read about in the manual. Instead of seeing the program as a rational system, he saw Photoshop as a series of unrelated and mystifying key commands.

People who don't truly know how to learn go through life memorizing every new set of tasks, rather than seeing patterns in systems. Rather than saying, "In this other situation, I did A and got B, so in this very similar situation I can also do A and get B." No matter what profession a person chooses, it is a huge asset to be able to learn rather than memorize.

Can "how to learn" even be assessed quantitatively? Does it need to be?

Yes and Yes. In my elementary school G.A.T.E. class, we were broken into groups, given a little word problem of some sort and asked to find solutions to these scenarios - to come up with as many as we could, then weight them all by how effective each would be. We then discussed our answers. The teacher would lead us in exploring why each solution was good or bad. She'd also give us plastic cube puzzles to solve. You'd have to figure out how the puzzle worked - how the pieces came apart - then take them apart in the correct order to get to the center and remove the "goodie". You'd then have to put it all back together again. The first team to do so got to go to recess a little early.

I think these skills can be tested, though I'm not sure you could a A-F scale. Possibly more of a pass/fail situation. Either a kid can learn or they can't.
 
Analog minds in a digital world.

Laurel said:
It's not just as important - it's vastly more important. It should be the goal of our education system, because that's what makes a person truly intelligent. I've dealt with more than my share of highly degreed clods who can spout textbook facts at you all day long, but can't handle a crisis with a client or can't think through a technical problem to save their lives.
...
Another man I know spent months on the program and STILL couldn't do anything that he hadn't read about in the manual. Instead of seeing the program as a rational system, he saw Photoshop as a series of unrelated and mystifying key commands.

People who don't truly know how to learn go through life memorizing every new set of tasks, rather than seeing patterns in systems. Rather than saying, "In this other situation, I did A and got B, so in this very similar situation I can also do A and get B." No matter what profession a person chooses, it is a huge asset to be able to learn rather than memorize.

Some people are just not capable of learning to follow a logical sequence. My Ex- wife is one of those with an analog mind trying to live in a digital world. She is quite capapble of learning something by rote, but totally incapable of applying that rote memorization to a similar situation. This is not a failure of the educational system, although the systam failed her in many other ways.

My Ex-wife and others simply do not have the mental wiring to follow a cause and effect relationship or understand that If A, Then B means that every time A happens, then B will also happen. The public school system labeled this condition "a Learning Disability" and shunted her into the "teen babysitting" -- er "Special Education" track and ignored her education from then on.

Despite that, I consider her to be literate -- if barely so.


Can "how to learn" even be assessed quantitatively? Does it need to be?

Yes and Yes.
...
I think these skills can be tested, though I'm not sure you could a A-F scale. Possibly more of a pass/fail situation. Either a kid can learn or they can't. [/B]


You contradict yourself here, possibly because I didn't make the question clear. Quantitatively means on an A-F scale in this context. A pass/fail grading is a "qualitative" assessment -- They either can or can't without regard to whether some are better than others.

Are the problem-solving exercises you went through really "teaching how to learn" or are they merely opportunities to practice innate skills.

Problem solving is a talent which, like story telling, can be trained, but it can't be taught. Most people have some degree of this talent, some degree of logical reasoning ability, and they can learn to solve problems relatively efficiently. However, those who don't have at least a spark of the talent simply can't learn a rational means of problem solving.

This is one reason that standardized testing is inherently unfair -- Tests are first and foremost problems to be solved. Those whose minds are more intuitive than rational often fail tests on material they understand better than rational thinkers.

I am one of those "fortunate" few who straddled the changeover from learning Math by rote memorization and "The New Math." For me, the change was beneficial. For others, it completely destroyed any mathematical skills they may have had and destroyed their confidence in their ability to learn. I had several friends in school who went from straight A students to barely passing. In retrospect, I can see where their difficulties understanding "New Math" had a lot to do with the decline.

I wonder how many of your classmates suffered a similar loss of confidence because their minds weren't good at puzzles and spacial relationships, regardless of how good they were at Language Arts, History, Music, and other subjects?
 
Re: Analog minds in a digital world.

Weird Harold said:
Some people are just not capable of learning to follow a logical sequence. My Ex- wife is one of those with an analog mind trying to live in a digital world. She is quite capapble of learning something by rote, but totally incapable of applying that rote memorization to a similar situation. This is not a failure of the educational system, although the systam failed her in many other ways.

See...I truly believe that all people CAN be taught to see things as systems, but I think (like learning a new language) it gets harder as they grow older. If your ex-wife had been caught at an early age and given the necessary attention, things might have been totally different. I disagree that it's an inherently innate all-or-nothing proposition. Some people are naturally better problem solvers, just as some people are naturally better mathematicians. However, I think anyone of normal intelligence can be taught to think through basic problems, just as they could be taught basic addition and subtraction.

You contradict yourself here, possibly because I didn't make the question clear. Quantitatively means on an A-F scale in this context. A pass/fail grading is a "qualitative" assessment -- They either can or can't without regard to whether some are better than others.

Argh. That's what I get for skimming! My apologies...My answer is no then, and I'm not sure that it needs to be measured quantitatively. You can get an "A" in Art class just by showing up and doing the work - the grading has no basis on your artistic ability.

I wonder how many of your classmates suffered a similar loss of confidence because their minds weren't good at puzzles and spacial relationships, regardless of how good they were at Language Arts, History, Music, and other subjects?

I think confidence is the key to the whole thing. Your ex-wife was treated as learning disabled. She began to think of herself as such, and thus quit learning. I truly believe that if she'd been given praise and coaching - if her self-esteem in regards to her learning ability had been raised instead of lowered - she would've been a different person. Would she be solving problems for NASA? Probably not. Would she be better able to get along in daily life? IMHO, yes.

I was told I was no good at math, and to this day I have difficulty with it. I often wonder how much of it has to do with my actual ability and how much has to do with my belief in my own ability.

I'll bet if you take two kids of equal ability and tell one they're genius and the other they're inadequate, the former will indeed become genius at that task and the latter will give up. We tend to live up (or down) to the expectations of those around us.
 
Re: Re: Analog minds in a digital world.

Laurel said:
See...I truly believe that all people CAN be taught to see things as systems, but I think (like learning a new language) it gets harder as they grow older. If your ex-wife had been caught at an early age and given the necessary attention, things might have been totally different. I disagree that it's an inherently innate all-or-nothing proposition.

The problem can be ameliorated by alternative teaching methods, but it IS innate. My younger daughter also suffers from a similar "learning disability, and better teachers made her more literate than her mother. I like to think that the fact I recognized that she needed things explained differently made a difference in her education.



I think confidence is the key to the whole thing. Your ex-wife was treated as learning disabled. She began to think of herself as such, and thus quit learning.

That is so true. She does have an "I'm stupid, so why bother?" attitude. My daughter has an "I'm not the brightest bulb, but there's not much I can't do if I try" attitude. Self-confidence is the difference.

I'll bet if you take two kids of equal ability and tell one they're genius and the other they're inadequate, the former will indeed become genius at that task and the latter will give up. We tend to live up (or down) to the expectations of those around us.

This isn't always true, but it is more often than not. I have known people who overcame low expectations through sheer perversity, but they are rare birds indeed.

We have, however, strayed from the topic I wanted to discuss. I don't think that anyone will disagree that some people need alternative teaching methods to reach their full potential. There are people who will never become literate no matter how good the educational system becomes.

Problem solving or "learning how to learn" is certainly a useful skill for people to have, but is it really something that is below the "minimum requirement" to be considered literate or educated.

I've known many literate people who have no "common sense" when it comes to mechanical things. They can solve theoretical problems by the score, and know "how to learn" new things through research and synthesizing new ideas from conflicting data.

One that comes to mind could pinpoint a problem in a radar system without ever touching it simply by analysing other's description of the problem. He could explain why it was doing what it did far better than I ever could. However, If the problem was something mechanical he was hopeless. His mind knew the theory of how a bolt held things together, but he was incapable of remembering which way to turn one to remove it or how tight it should be tightened.

I worked with other technicians that were, by comparison, "strong as an Ox and almost as smart." People who moved their lips when they read the checklists, but seemed to instinctively know how things fit together.

these people were at opposite extremes as far as the application of what they knew or learned, but all were well above the theoretical "minimum level of literacy."

The "How things are taught", "how knowledge is tested", and "How do we pay for all this" questions are interesting but irrelevant to what I'm asking. Without a concrete idea of where the dividing line between literate and semi-literate lies, they are moot points.

I'm more interested in hearing each poster's idea of what aan "educated person" should be expected to know.

Many "educated" people know a lot of specific history -- dates and places and important events. Other "educated people" are clueless about history and see no reason they should regret the lack. Is just enough literacy to live day to day enough to be considered "educated" sufficient? Or is there some minimum level of history that should be known?
 
I know this doesn't exactly follow along with the original question for this thread, but I think, a child should learn the basic math skills which will be with them for their rest of their lives; addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. Unless they go into a field where knowledge of geometry, logarithms and "advanced" mathematical equations are relavent, then this type of math isn't necessary.

As far as reading goes, I think they need to get back to the basics of understanding how to form a proper sentence. To be able to comprehend what they are reading so they can follow a story, invision in their minds what the characters are feeling, and perhaps relate to the characters.

I was appalled the other day. The restaurant I work in caters to the High School kids at lunchtime. A group of boys were discussing a novel they were reading in English class, "Lord of the Flies". A good book, but not a great book, in my opinion. I interrupted their conversation and asked them what other books they were required to read. I only recognized 2 titles out of 7. No mention of what I had read in school, books I had considered classics. No Mark Twain, no John Steinbeck, no Ernest Hemingway. They had never heard of Old Yeller, Of Mice or Men, the Old Man and the Sea.

One of the girls at a nearby table informed me that those books were now banned in this school system. It seems to me, that books which were once taunted as great writings are now being labeled discriminating, violent and noneducational. I have read "Lord of the Flies", and this book seems to me to be very discriminating and violent.

Do they still require Shakespeare? Creative writing? The ability to figure a simple math equation without the use of a calculator?
 
Ksss said:
I know this doesn't exactly follow along with the original question for this thread, but I think, a child should learn the basic math skills which will be with them for their rest of their lives; addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. Unless they go into a field where knowledge of geometry, logarithms and "advanced" mathematical equations are relavent, then this type of math isn't necessary.

As far as reading goes, I think they need to get back to the basics of understanding how to form a proper sentence. To be able to comprehend what they are reading so they can follow a story, invision in their minds what the characters are feeling, and perhaps relate to the characters.

...

Do they still require Shakespeare? Creative writing? The ability to figure a simple math equation without the use of a calculator?

Actually, it's exactly the kind of response I was looking for.

I'm curious as to how you feel about "story problems", Fractions/proportions, and exponents. Are they part of basic artimetic, or are they "higher math" required only for certain careers?

On reading, would the kind of reading comprehension you describe be necessary for following the instructions on an ATM screen? (to pick just one example)

I don't think Shakespeare and creative writing are completely gone from the schools, but are relegated to elective courses in many cases. My grandaughter is not allowed to use a calculator in first grade, but she does use a computer.
 
Just a quick thought here, and then back to the wonderful debate going on here.......

:p
 
You do have a point there Siren.

As to Wierd Harold's question. Comprehension to have the ability to define the lesson to be learned from the writer. Yes, a certain comprehension must be used to manipulate an ATM, the ability to read and follow instructions. Comprehending what the instructions are telling you to do next.

Fractions are a part of every day living as are ratios, but the use of a quadratic equation isn't necessarily a need to know item, so I think would be termed as advanced math. The ability to count back change, the ability to approximate monthly bills...all obtained by the use of simple math:addition, subtraction.

When my son was taking his Regents math examine ( I live in NY state), I was appalled to learn he was required to have a calculator, along with his number two pencils. Since I have been out of High School for over 20 years, has the time alotment for exams lessened, making it necessary for the students to rely on a calculator to figure their math equations instead of their minds?

A question for you Harold...Is technology replacing our children's minds? Making them have to think less? Leaving them time to use their brains for what?
Oops, sorry, that was three questions.
 
Ksss said:
You do have a point there Siren.

Siren: "Just a quick thought here, and then back to the wonderful debate going on here.......
But isnt this an awful lot of words for some of the
semi-literates to be able to read and grasp?

I mean it is about them that we are all talking about
isnt it?"

I did consider doing another thread with the same question phrased in words of no more than three syllables. :p




[/b]Fractions are a part of every day living as are ratios, but the use of a quadratic equation isn't necessarily a need to know item, so I think would be termed as advanced math. The ability to count back change, the ability to approximate monthly bills...all obtained by the use of simple math:addition, subtraction. [/b]

Perhaps quadratic equations themselves aren't a part of everyday life, but the logical thinking required to manipulate them has certainly made my life easier.

Boolean Algebra is another "higher math" that has far more impact on our daily lives than one might think. (actually It's a lack of Boolean math in others that impacts my life the most. :p)


Since I have been out of High School for over 20 years, has the time alotment for exams lessened, making it necessary for the students to rely on a calculator to figure their math equations instead of their minds?

As was explained to me when slide rules were permitted on a high school math test: "It is assumed that you are capable of simple arithmetic. The test is to see whether you know how to manipulate the variables, not on whether you can add and subtract accurately."

A question for you Harold...Is technology replacing our children's minds? Making them have to think less? Leaving them time to use their brains for what?
Oops, sorry, that was three questions.

Isacc Asimov certainly thought so when he wrote The Feeling Of Power in 1957. (the story of an amazing man who could actually do arithmatic in his head instead of using a calculator and his revolutionary impact on society.)

I don't think his view of the future was correct. He was far too pessimistic. I think that calculators and the ease of finding information on the web challenge minds in different ways than pre-technology minds were challenged. Lazy minds have technology to help them hide the laziness, but lazy minds still accomplish less than active ones.

One advantage of technology is scientific calculators that replace thick volumes of Trig tables so solving an equation now takes less time than seting it up. You still need to know what each trig function does, and how to use it to set up the equation in your calculator. You just don't have to go through the laborious and error-prone process of looking up each value and re-writing the formula with the variables replaced.

Used properly, as tools, technology frees the mind to think about problems instead of wasting brain-cells on tedious calculations to solve them.
 
The minimum standard for education? I think we're all making this far too difficult.

A person ought to be able to read well enough in the predominant language to understand the content, if not all of the ramifications, in the newspaper.

A person ought to be able to do enough math that if their calculator broke when you're standing in their line at the cash register, you don't have to figure out your own change.

A person ought to know enough about society and government to recognize the importance of participating in that society and government as well recognizing that there is cultural differences.

A person ought to know enough about auto mechanics to pump their own gas, check their own oil, put on the spare tire, and recognize when the car should be maintained.

A person ought to know enough about science to realize that chemicals should be treated with respect, stuff falls when you drop it for a reason, and that when you're sick, you go to the doctor.

We call them MINIMUM standards for a reason. Some people DO NOT care to be educated. They'd rather subsist down at the bottom of the socio-economic food chain. Someone has to manage McDonalds and swab the deck.

None of the minimum standards to get by in today's society should have anything to do with cultural bias. How can you culturally bias math and basic reading? English is English. Addition and subtraction is addition and subtraction. When it comes to MINIMUM standards of education for a person to subsist in this world, you're talking about a cultural bias already. These people are from all cultures and share one thing in common, poverty.

If you want to raise the standards, to give them a stronger education and a better future, then you can get into cultural biases. This is where things like history and creativity come into play. Face it, the minimum standard does not equate with the ideal minimum standard.
 
KillerMuffin said:
The minimum standard for education? I think we're all making this far too difficult.

A person ought to be able to read well enough in the predominant language to understand the content, if not all of the ramifications, in the newspaper.

I pretty much agree with all of your other minimums, but This one I think is way above "minimum."

First of all, Which newspaper? The reading level of the National Enquirer is much lower than USA today, and The New York Times is orders of magnitude higher than USA Today. The Christian Science Monitor isn't an easy read even for me, and I assure you I'm very literate as far as reading skills are concerned.

I think a job application or other form is pretty close to what I would consider minimum reading level. Of course that presumes the person who wrote the instructions for the form was literate enough not to write it in professorese.

None of the minimum standards to get by in today's society should have anything to do with cultural bias. How can you culturally bias math and basic reading? English is English. Addition and subtraction is addition and subtraction. When it comes to MINIMUM standards of education for a person to subsist in this world, you're talking about a cultural bias already. These people are from all cultures and share one thing in common, poverty.

Cultural bias in a reading assessment tests is rampant. Since a reading assessment test has to assess the high level readers as well as identify the illiterate, it must be hard to read.

If, for example, you were to take a test that assessed your ability to read porno that was written by a Brit, you might have trouble with the difference in idioms. Especially if the questions focussed on things like fannies, pants, vests, knickers, boots and bonnets. I don't actually think that You, KM, would fail such a reading test, but many Americans would fail miserably because all of those words mean something different to us than they do to the Brits.

Math tests are easy to bias culturally as well. Any good math assessment test includes "story problems." If the "story" that frames the problem deals with planning a debutante ball, many people who aren't rich and/or well read will get lost in the unfamiliar terms and lose track of the math problem. By the same token, a problem dealing with how many Keys of Coke are required to make a batch of crack, is going to distract those who had no trouble with planning a ball.


If you want to raise the standards, to give them a stronger education and a better future, ...Face it, the minimum standard does not equate with the ideal minimum standard.

I guess I'm asking about the "ideal minimum" rather than the defacto current minimum. If you were setting the standards all North American students had to meet to be considered educated, would your answers still be the same?
 
Wow, I go to work for one DAY and look what I come back to.

Thank you Harold for proving that intelligent discussion is not dead at Literotica, no matter who leaves, and no matter how big a fucking deal they make out of leaving. (Killer, I know you left but you came back, thanks again).

I was going to post here again, but it's mostly already been said. I think KM's standards for literacy are very common-sense.

:)
 
A lot of very good insights in this thread. I think perhaps I'll contribute by quoting from Robert Heinlein - who should be REQUIRED reading, in my opinion - this is Heinlein speaking through his character Lazarus Long in the novel Time Enough For Love:

"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects."
 
Dilly

That is so cool.

I like the parts about planning invasions and dying gallantly. But then again I am a goddamn warmonger.

:)
 
The word problems I'm familiar with usually involve a man getting on a train going one way at 35 miles and hour and another man getting on a train going the other way at 45 miles an hour. If they leave at exactly the same time, how long will it take them to meet?

I'm missing the cultural bias here. I've never seen a word problem involving debutants.

As far as the reading goes, there is common ground. Dr. Suess managed to bypass the cultural bias. You do not have to read Mark Twain, Maya Angelou, or Amy Tan to take a standarized reading test. You can read about how Joe decided on which flavor of ice cream to eat. Or you can read an instruction manual. Oddly enough, the people who had problems with the reading portion of the ASVAB that I personally knew didn't have problems with the cultural bias, they had problems with the fact that they had learning disabilities that precluded them from doing the test in the allotted time. As you know, the military is a mix of cultures. Minimal standards aren't that hard to set without cultural bias.
 
KillerMuffin said:
The word problems I'm familiar with usually involve a man getting on a train going one way at 35 miles and hour and another man getting on a train going the other way at 45 miles an hour. If they leave at exactly the same time, how long will it take them to meet?

I'm missing the cultural bias here. I've never seen a word problem involving debutants.

I never have either, nor have I seen one about crack production. Still, despite my intentionally outrageous examples, cultural bias can be put into a math test.

In fact, although your example of two trains is a classic example of a story problem, it has been acused of cultural bias! Supposedly, it's biased, because it mentions trains, and many people have no direct knowledge of trains, and there are certain assumptions about trains that affect the way people solve the problem!

Note, I don't say that there is any cultutal bias, only that it has been acused of such.

[/b]Oddly enough, the people who had problems with the reading portion of the ASVAB that I personally knew didn't have problems with the cultural bias, they had problems with the fact that they had learning disabilities that precluded them from doing the test in the allotted time. As you know, the military is a mix of cultures. Minimal standards aren't that hard to set without cultural bias. [/B]

I think I took the ASVAB and AFAQT before you were born. (June 1968) At that time, both were culturally biased and stayed that way until the mid-70's when they were revised. It was not just the reading portions that were biased, but (nearly) the whole test. The only part I know for sure wasn't culturally biased, was the box folding section to test spacial realtionships.

I agree that minimum standards should be simple to apply without cultural bias, but the key word is should. Tests however, are designed by humans Something as simple, and seemingly innocuous, as the order the answers are lettered has been accused of being a bias against certain cultural assumptions.

I'm of the opinion that any bias towards the dominant culture is a good thing if the purpose of the test is to determine knowledge of that dominant culture. It may make the test more difficult for members of another culture, but it isn't testing other cultures, it's testing minimum standards of the dominant culture.
 
The cultural bias of a train may exist in the back jungles of the amazon, but I sincerely doubt you'll find a person in the country who doesn't know what a train is. If they don't, then they're going to have difficulties with the test if it's written. Trains are prevelant in childrens books, mass media, errata. Miles per hour would be an even harder concept. This isn't cultural bias for a standardized test in the nation. All cultures in the US have access to facts of trains and miles per hour. The people who do not have access to those aren't going to be taking the test anyway because they won't have seen the interior of a school. It's not their culture preventing them from understanding what a train is in the problem

Cultural bias is a cop out for ignorance in minimalist standards. I am not a Jew, nor do I know much about them. I don't have to know much to understand that trains going separate speeds are going to meet as some funky time.
 
Harold, (or anyone else):

Design a word problem or any other test question and post it. I'll make it totally neutral- completely without cultural bias. I'm pretty damn sure it ain't that hard.



[Edited by Problem Child on 05-16-2001 at 10:20 PM]
 
KillerMuffin said:
Cultural bias is a cop out for ignorance in minimalist standards. I am not a Jew, nor do I know much about them. I don't have to know much to understand that trains going separate speeds are going to meet as some funky time.

Well said.
 
Laurel said:
KillerMuffin said:
Cultural bias is a cop out for ignorance in minimalist standards. I am not a Jew, nor do I know much about them. I don't have to know much to understand that trains going separate speeds are going to meet as some funky time.

Well said.



I agree.

I never claimed that the accusation of trains being a cultural bias was rational or logical, only that the accusation had been made.

Part of one of my management courses in the USAF included a short chapter on avoiding cultural bias in building a test. The example of trains was one used to show how subtle cultural biases can be, and how fanatic those who seek to eliminate cultural bias can be.

PC, I don't doubt that you could remove any cultural bias in anything I came up with to demonstrate cultural bias.

I must confess I've been playing devil's advocate on this issue to demonstrate how difficult the issue of standardized testing is. Nit-pickers who oppose testing for whatever reason pick at every straw they can dream up and apply every PC silliness they can manufacture to obstruct any rational standard.

I think this thread has demonstrated just how difficult it can be to define a minimum literacy standard everyone can agree to. Just pinning people down to presenting a definition of what minimum literacy is difficult. Issues like "how much is this going to cost?", "People will just teach the test," and several other issues beyond the mere definition were immediately raised.

Unless the people making the decisions on standards and testing can focus on the basics better than we Literoticans can, I'm afraid we're in for a long period of patchwork fixes that only plaster over the warts in our educational system.
 
Weird Harold said:
I must confess I've been playing devil's advocate on this issue to demonstrate how difficult the issue of standardized testing is.

Dammit Harold, I had a feeling you were... :)


Nit-pickers who oppose testing for whatever reason pick at every straw they can dream up and apply every PC silliness they can manufacture to obstruct any rational standard.

That's what I get upset at. People complain about the public school system, but no one will just get down to business and construct simple, basic standardized testing on a national basis, or even for most states. Why not start off small...math, english, science, and try it for a few years to see how it progresses? The testing can always be modified later. Just get going on it!

 
Problem Child said:
Weird Harold said:
I must confess I've been playing devil's advocate on this issue to demonstrate how difficult the issue of standardized testing is.

Dammit Harold, I had a feeling you were... :)

Just on the testing issue. I really am trying to find some sort of consensus on what Literoticans consider minimum literacy.

Why not start off small...math, english, science, and try it for a few years to see how it progresses? The testing can always be modified later. Just get going on it!

Oh No! <Some omniscient, all-powerful entity> forbid you should add SCIENCE to testing standards! The Flat-Earthers, Creationists, Luddites, and possibly even one or two really extremist groups will band together just to lynch you.
 
This in reply to Dillingers post

R.A.H. was NOT a common man. His standards were so far above todays mass education standards(?)that even he admited that he made that list tongue in cheak.

My High school Physics teacher defined EDUCATED as Not what you know but what you know how to find. Data base skills.

Yes, those who teach primary grades DO have the power to shape the students ability to learn. The ones who stifel inquirys as "That is not part of the course." will pass on students that have blunted curiosity.



[Edited by The_old_man on 05-17-2001 at 01:13 AM]
 
Back
Top