Laurel
Kitty Mama
- Joined
- Aug 27, 1999
- Posts
- 20,709
Weird Harold said:Is teaching "how to learn" as important as teaching mere facts?
It's not just as important - it's vastly more important. It should be the goal of our education system, because that's what makes a person truly intelligent. I've dealt with more than my share of highly degreed clods who can spout textbook facts at you all day long, but can't handle a crisis with a client or can't think through a technical problem to save their lives.
Public education should prepare kids to succeed in the real world. In the real world, a head full of facts and numbers may make you the life of the party, but it's not extremely helpful in day-to-day life. What IS helpful is being able to understand systems. An example...I saw a woman learn to use Photoshop in less than an hour. She was able to see the program as a whole entity, to see that if selecting a tool and holding down shift does one thing, then selecting another tool and holding shift would do something as well. She never needed a manual - she learned new features by trying different keys and making logical connections. And because most photo manipulation products out today are modeled on Photoshop, she could then work with any of them because she understood the principle behind the software. Another man I know spent months on the program and STILL couldn't do anything that he hadn't read about in the manual. Instead of seeing the program as a rational system, he saw Photoshop as a series of unrelated and mystifying key commands.
People who don't truly know how to learn go through life memorizing every new set of tasks, rather than seeing patterns in systems. Rather than saying, "In this other situation, I did A and got B, so in this very similar situation I can also do A and get B." No matter what profession a person chooses, it is a huge asset to be able to learn rather than memorize.
Can "how to learn" even be assessed quantitatively? Does it need to be?
Yes and Yes. In my elementary school G.A.T.E. class, we were broken into groups, given a little word problem of some sort and asked to find solutions to these scenarios - to come up with as many as we could, then weight them all by how effective each would be. We then discussed our answers. The teacher would lead us in exploring why each solution was good or bad. She'd also give us plastic cube puzzles to solve. You'd have to figure out how the puzzle worked - how the pieces came apart - then take them apart in the correct order to get to the center and remove the "goodie". You'd then have to put it all back together again. The first team to do so got to go to recess a little early.
I think these skills can be tested, though I'm not sure you could a A-F scale. Possibly more of a pass/fail situation. Either a kid can learn or they can't.
