How do you define literate?

Problem Child said:
What is so hard about coming up with basic minimum standards for learning and then writing a fair test to evaluate a students level of knowledge?

I think that Problem Child is offering a simplistic view in a way which is to be congratulated. The question is about authority. Someone has to decide - to take responsibility [in exactly the same we that we have discussed in other threads 'parental responsibility' for similar issues] - what constitutes a decent level of literacy. In turn, 'we' have to accept said decisions, and have to accept that the powers-that-be are capable of serving their public duties in an efficient and dedicated manner. Easier said than done, it seems - given the content of this thread! To both define and implement this a curriculum has to be put in place, and an agreed canon offered to students. This feeds into points made about 'cultural bias': the canon and curriculum are either attacked as homogenising students within a white ['eurocentric'] set of knowledges, or else they are applied liberally to suit the heterogeneous student body, and any idea of standardisation is hard to achieve:

"The case against cultural diversity in the curriculum argues for a central spine in society to counter the perceived threats to the existing social and moral order which are posed when diversity slips into relativism; the case for diversity argues that anything else is either ideologically or socially reproductive." Keith Morrison, "Education," A Dictionary of Cultural and Critical Theory, ed. Michael Payne (Oxford: Blackwell, 1998) 161. [159-162]

Essentially, this is an issue about 'power', as social groupings (or dominant and often self-appointed voices within social groupings) perceive a threat to their way of life. Thus offering the 'dominant' social grouping's definition of what is used to achieve literacy is read in some quarters as a political endeavour. Education is the key building block to what shape our societies will eventually take, so it's understandable that so many voices are competing with each other to be heard. Unfortunately this can jeopardise the initial learning process, and I am against any and all so called 'politically correct' interventions in [primary] education.

BubbaRednek said:
Problem Child said:
I don't think the things people really need to know in order to have a basic understanding of how the world works really changes all that much. The only thing getting in the way of kids learning is the politics of teaching.

Hmmm... worked on a new car lately? How about an older model? Any change? How about using the Internet for research vs digging through a card catalog at a library? The world is changing, faster and faster. Geometry hasn't changed much, but basic life skills certainly have.

It just isn't that simple.

It's as simple as we want to make it, and that's the whole point. I understand what you're trying to say BubbaRednek, but literacy begins from an early age of course. None of the specialised / specific knowledges you offer [taking your example of car mechanics, and assuming that you are hinting at other related life skills] are necessary components in the primary classroom, with the possible exception of the Internet / computers. These play an increasing part, but they don't take away from "basic life skills" such as reading, writing and arithmetic; in fact they compliment them - or ought to.

I'll say again: It's as simple as we want to make it, and that's the whole point. I'm reminded of a news feature, within the last year or two, where a child had been taught at home by her parents. The point Laurel makes about 'memorizing versus seeing patterns in systems' is very relevant here. Essentially, the family had decided that they could offer a better education than that offered by public schooling. From a very early age their child was taught by them way beyond what is expected of a young child in any school. This is comparable with the idea someone raised about kids being able to pick up new languages better than adults. This kid was taught a very deep and complicated 'language' more commonly known as maths. Not any run of the mill stuff either, but extremely complicated maths which she assimilated successfully from a very early age. The child (who was a young teenager when the programme was shown) came across as very socially isolated. She had access to a whole childhood filled with hard facts and figures, but had missed out on more 'innocent' childhood experiences. In her situation, I doubt very much that she was "the life of the party" when trying to interact with her peers who were some educational years behind her.

The issue of literacy, which must be addressed from an early age, overlooks the fact that young pupils are in fact doing no more than learning facts and figures. Anyone who studies English or Maths (or any other subject) is learning the history of English or Maths (or any other subject). Through group interaction at school, experiences at home, and exposure to learning (which pretty much covers every daily activity), interpersonal and physical skills can be improved. Literacy must begin with the basics, with a foundation of facts and figures. The rest hopefully falls into place through the features I've described.

It has been mentioned that everyone learns at different paces, and some are more gifted than others at particular subjects. The educative process should be flexible enough to address this, while being rigid enough to ensure that all are given an equal opportunity to learn fundamental skills. Not everyone will utilise such opportunities, or be capable of meeting criteria, but this doesn't mean that the system is inherently inadequate. Change for everyone can be more harmful than no change to suit what are considered to be the basics [these having been agreed upon in the first place!].

... and then comes the approach to adulthood; the need to be able to make increasingly adult and responsible decisions for oneself. At this stage literacy, based on a firm and concise primary education, ought to be enhanced and added to by the capability to actively formulate ideas, to appraise the ideas of others, to begin to have a fundamental grasp of issues behind the newspaper headlines (to use an example already given). I don't mean in a specific way which covers all possible forms of media representation, but teenagers ought to be able to read and interpret ['decode'] various cultural forms. By this I mean the ability to interrogate a book, or a news story, and the ability to speak and write about their findings. Obviously questions would be 'set', and such projects would be framed within a certain discourse; but to avoid nihilistic readings of the education process then all - for there are many - other possible alternatives for what can and should be read must be restricted to some extent. Again, we are faced with the argument that some will be predujiced against, but we have to choose between a standard level which has some transferable meaning and a convoluted level which assumes that the teaching profession does not know best. [Note: I may have to clarify this point later, as I can't quite get my mind to address this issue as well as I'd like right now]

There is room for personal projects by students no doubt, but providing a standard and formal education must leave out as much as it lets in [if not more]. Otherwise it loses any clarity. This isn't hampering education, nor is it a form of politically incorrect intellectual closure, it's just offering education in a defined and ordered way. Numeracy is less controversial (or should be!), and if some 'fail' or generally don't do well, then that's just a fact of life [assuming that their school is fulfilling its functions to the best of its abilities]. This doesn't mean that such students need be overlooked; and it is entirely possible to make amends in adult life - such is the fluidity and flexibility of the job market. Literacy allied with practical skills depends as much on the home as on the school. Do parents take the time to show the workings of a car, to explain social and cultural issues, to involve their children in tasks which increase their "all-roundedness"? Do they have the time? Time should certainly be made, because every waking moment is a potential learning opportunity, and you never know when you might have to change your tyre on the way to your next job interview ...

:)
 
Literate...
The ability to read the warning on a cleaning supply bottle and being able to comprehend the use of said product. Also being able to comprehend the dangers if said product is not used correctly.
The ability to read a prescription bottle. To comprehend the results of over/under medicating oneself.
The abilty to read a sign and comprehend what that sign stands for (i.e. "One Way street"= traffic going the wrong way could possibly result in an accident).
The ability to read ingredients on a food items. Ex: Diabetics must have some basic literary skills to be able to read a label and comprehend if there are dangerous sugar additives.

Basic math is taught to our children early in life. Give a child a dollar, teach them what they can buy with that dollar. But, basic math skills need to be continuously re-enforced all through school. Ask a child in High School to figure out how much tax is on a CD, without the use of a calculator, and what the end cost will be. Basic math skills, multiplication and addition.

My granddaughter was denied entrance to Kindergarten this year, State tests stated she was ADD. Why? Because she didn't have the basic skills to "compete" with children the same age as her. She lacked the knowledge a child is taught through hearing and learning childrens songs and stories, her mother never sang to her or read her stories. The person giving these tests didn't feel she was capable of forming a grammatically correct sentence, making what she wanted to get across clear enough. The clincher to the whole terrible episode was when the testor told her mother she was ADD because she refused to listen to the instructor on how to hold the pencil correctly. It didn't matter that she knew when her birthday was, where she lived, her telephone number. It didn't matter that she could count to 100, she knew her colors, she could tie her shoes.

Unfortunately, my granddaughter has to wait another year before she can start Kindergarten. Her mother had her tested by a child psychiatrist, she is NOT ADD. It was also discovered, she had a difficult time "focusing" on things because she needed glasses. Eyestrain was causing headaches which made her concentration level low.

Sorry I transgressed there for a moment. I guess what I am trying to say is, sometimes the tests they give classify children as to "slow" learners or "advanced" learners. What is right for one child is not necessarily what is right for another child. Everyone learns at a different pace. But if each child is taught how to read, comprehend, add, subtract, multiply and divide then they have the basic skills of being a literate person.
 
What is the correct way to hold a pencil?

I too was punished and made an example of in kindergarten because I had trouble concentrating. I was also accused of having accidents, such as tripping over things, bumping into desks and other people, for attention.
I was lucky, very. My parents refused to keep me in that classroom, instead having me moved to another one, where the behaviour was the same. Looking back I think I probably would have been diagnosed ADD except we didn't have that particular intially disease back then. I would get so frustrated when the teacher wouldn't let me answer, or when I had to sit and do what I thought was boring.
After a couple visits to the Doctor for routine shots and things, it was discovered, by a nurse, that I was blind in my right eye. At the age of three I had corrective surgery for lazy eye and in the process the surgeon had nicked the optic nerve. It had eventually died off leaving the right eye dead in the socket, well you wiouldn't know it to look at me, it moves and does all that. Thus I have no depth perception and cannot tell how far away things are I so bumped into things alot, still do. My attention sucked beause, when they decided to test further, I was already reading at a 3rd grade level and doing the math of a 2nd grader.
Wasn't I smart? No, but the only way I could know what my older brothers and sisters were up too was to learn quicker so they couldn't hide things from me. Survival tactics.
Anyways. I was lucky it was discovered so early, though I still mentallly smart from being told I was lazy and stupid in front of the other students. Remember this was a long, long time ago.

No, I am not knocking down ADD. It is a real and tough disease, affecting millions. But I do feel it is overdiagnosed. Slapped on when a child is simply acting like a child.
 
The public school system needs to return to its roots in a way if it can become effective again. Our schools originated as small intimate places where teacher and student could establish working relationships. Now, like so many other things, they are big, impersonal, and driven by how efficiently they can use their money. We need to return to smaller schools with smaller class sizes. These schools have smaller cracks for students to slide through.

Literacy is situational. A teacher should know where Nepal, Luxemburg, and Botswana are but not a career gas jockey. Mathematical literacy for an average person does not need to extend beyond arithmetic.

In college, I feel that a liberal arts student needs no math beyond arithmetic but math and science need history, English, and philosophy because those subjects give perspective and teach future scientists of ethics and the consequences of their actions.


I am living up to my handle in this post so I will quit
 
rambling man said:
The public school system needs to return to its roots in a way if it can become effective again. Our schools originated as small intimate places where teacher and student could establish working relationships.
First, welcome to the Boards, Rambling Man. Second, exactly how far back are you thinking? Our educational system started out as intimate settings because it was a privilege in most places, and only a select few were even allowed to attend. Even if you are thinking back to the beginning of mandatory school for all children, since then we have experienced a population explosion that dwarfs those early days. I doubt it is economically feasible to return to that teacher student ratio, given the persistent teacher shortage and continued population growth. I agree that a closer ratio is preferable and a more effective way of teaching, but we've moved too far to rely on the models from the beginning.
 
I was thinking more about the small country schools in West Virginia, where I live now. It used to be high schools only had about 200 people in them at the most because of isolation. I think we need to get back to high schools of about 3-600 students and elementary schools with about 200 kids. That's what I mean when I say going back. Private schools did not cross my mind at all.

Also standardized tests are a joke. Too many children have too many problems with the testing situation alone. Also it is biased not only against minorities but also poor whites as well. We need to lose them before we lose more potentially great minds.
 
I'm in my twenties, so high school is not that faded a memory yet. My graduating class had close to a thousand students, and I believe I received an excellent education. I even graduated with 18 hours of college credit. My classes averaged 30-40 students, depending on the subject. So I believe that size doesn't matter as much as how the school appropriates its resources.
 
If you are a good student and you want to learn you will do well almost anywhere. But there are many kids of average ability who fade away in classes that large. I am in my 20s too and I did just that in my math class, kept my head down, said nothing, learned nothing. I didn't want to keep holding the class up with my foolish questions (thats how I felt then) so I just stayed quiet and took my Ds. Many more kids fall through the cracks in larger schools who could learn more if they felt the teacher had time for them or cared. My county (where I live now, not where I went to school)consolidated several schools into two andthe dropout rate skyrocketed.

Also with large schools, kids have less chance to play sports. Sports keeps a lot of young men and women off the streets and away from trouble and also teaches valuable lessons. With big schools they have much less opportunity
 
Good points, rambling man. I was quite the ultra-involved uber-nerd in high school, and I didn't take into account the average student's needs.
 
That's cool. One other thing I got from a smaller school was that cliques were less hardened. You had athletes on the academic team, so-called "nerds" on the football team and so on. People did clump together in groups but most peoplewere social with each other. I think that cut down on the harassment and bullying you see in so many of these big suburban high schools now because everyone had real personal contact with each other.
 
I think you're getting a little excited with the whole cultural thing. Example time!

I have a sister-in-law, I have had her for 12 years now. She reads harelequin romances as her reading activity, and somewhat rarely. We have conversations that are frustrating. We have to have a translator because I use words she doesn't understand and phrases or references that are beyond her. Now here's the thing. We are from the same culture. Exact same culture. In fact, she had a better head start in life because her family life was less dysfunctional than mine.

Like I said, cultural bias is a cop out. Facility with English is not a WASP thing. Facility with English is an American thing. That is the language of the country and you ought to speak it. Not Eubonics, not Chinese, not Spanish. Immigrants exempted.

My sister-in-law is literate enough to live happily as she is. She can read to pass the driving test, she can understand the content of USA Today. She may not get everything she reads, but she can read an article on Bush's trip to Japan and get the gist of it. For her, it's enough. I think she happily exemplifies the minimum standard. In some respects she's far more educated than I am. She can rebuild a vehicle without needing to ask what to do. I seriously doubt most of us in the country know when they're supposed to have their transmission fluid changed right off the top of their head.

Ignorance is not a cultural bias. Ignorance is a failing in the education of the ignorant. There are certain questions that should never be on a standardized test. Like what's the signifigance of Yom Kippur. Unless of course the essay one had to read prior to the question clearly states it. When you read a piece about something you don't already know, we call it learning. I don't not read stuff outside of my culture because it's culturally biased away from me. My sister-in-law didn't read Amy Tan not because she didn't comprehend the culture, but because the level of the language frustrates her. She said so herself. She's one of the smartest people I know, and I used to pity her for her lack of education. Until I figured out that she is perfectly happy just as she is. Amazing how stupid I was.
 
A few years ago it was decided by some group/panel that it would be required for all students to take and pass a Regents exam(s) in order to graduate. I know everyone is not familiar with what the Regents stands for as these tests are now only given in NY and CA. And a Regents diploma is only good in that state.

They are trying to force all children to think at the same intelligence level, giving them all the same chance to use their brains. But take a child who has a slightly slower learning rate, who gets frustrated easily. What my be the outcome for this? The child may drop out of school, due to the pressures of the tougher testing. Instead of focusing on what abilities these children have they are forcing them to more pressures, possibly giving them lower self-esteem because they won't be able to live up to expectations of school administrators and stupid tests.

Take a child who learnes more quickly, if they lower the guidelines for these tests so everyone has a fair chance to pass them, this child may become bored and then use less of their motivation to excel. It's a no win situation, in my opinion.
 
Standardized testing also reduces teacher creativity because of pressure to teach to the test. Teaching is more of an art than a science, in an optimal situation the teacher can tailor his or her approach to each student. In addition to what I said earlier about smaller schools and class sizes, teachers need to be treated like real professionals. Pay them a lot more but also require a masters degree in their field of teaching in addition to their bacheloprs in education.
 
WARNING! Several posts rolled into one!

Ally C said:
...'we' have to accept said decisions, and have to accept that the powers-that-be are capable of serving their public duties in an efficient and dedicated manner. Easier said than done, it seems - given the content of this thread! To both define and implement this a curriculum has to be put in place, and an agreed canon offered to students. This feeds into points made about 'cultural bias': the canon and curriculum are either attacked as homogenising students within a white ['eurocentric'] set of knowledges, or else they are applied liberally to suit the heterogeneous student body, ...

I think part of the problem in defining "literate" (which includes numerate in this context,) and "educated" is that we have lost trust in "the powers-that-be." We seem to see the PTB as being the pawns of all the interest groups we disagree with. "They" have vested interests in the status quo and might actually have to do what they're paid to do if standards are formulated enforced.

I don't particularly share the perception that professional educators are incapable of defining and evaluating literacy impartially and have to "teach the test" if standardized testing is imposed. I do however, believe that many school boards are composed of parochial bigots who are afraid of standardized testing because they know they could pass the simplest test. Over the years, I have seen numerous sound bites from local school board members to the effect of, "It don't make no matter whut them people in (pick a region) thinks they's young'uns need to larn, We knows what we's chillen needs ta larn."

Ally C said:
It's as simple as we want to make it, and that's the whole point. I understand what you're trying to say BubbaRednek, but literacy begins from an early age of course. None of the specialised / specific knowledges you offer ... are necessary components in the primary classroom, with the possible exception of the Internet / computers. These play an increasing part, but they don't take away from "basic life skills" such as reading, writing and arithmetic; in fact they compliment them - or ought to.

Ally C said:
... and then comes the approach to adulthood; the need to be able to make increasingly adult and responsible decisions for oneself. At this stage literacy, based on a firm and concise primary education, ought to be enhanced and added to by the capability to actively formulate ideas, to appraise the ideas of others, to begin to have a fundamental grasp of issues behind the newspaper headlines (to use an example already given).

...

Again, we are faced with the argument that some will be predujiced against, but we have to choose between a standard level which has some transferable meaning and a convoluted level which assumes that the teaching profession does not know best.


This raised the question for me of "graduated literacy."

Would it be better to establish a minimum knowledge level for graduation from Highschool, or define progressive tiers of literacy? Does it really matter if a student learned everything needed to graduate the week before the test, or should progress through the system be dependent on learning certain things at certain ages?"

I am adamantly opposed to "peer promotion" and feel that promotion from first to second grade (and every promotion thereafter,) should be earned by demonstrating that the curriculim for that level has been mastered.

Ally C said:
The child (who was a young teenager when the programme was shown) came across as very socially isolated. She had access to a whole childhood filled with hard facts and figures, but had missed out on more 'innocent' childhood experiences. In her situation, I doubt very much that she was "the life of the party" when trying to interact with her peers who were some educational years behind her.

The issue of literacy, which must be addressed from an early age, overlooks the fact that young pupils are in fact doing no more than learning facts and figures.

Is this really a question of "literacy" or does it stray into defining "a well rounded education?" I don't think it can be argued that the young lady in question wasn't "literate" but she clearly lacked a "well rounded" education. Social skills are important for survival in "the real world" but I don't think they can be considered as "literacy."

Ally C said:
Literacy allied with practical skills depends as much on the home as on the school. Do parents take the time to show the workings of a car, to explain social and cultural issues, to involve their children in tasks which increase their "all-roundedness"? Do they have the time? Time should certainly be made, because every waking moment is a potential learning opportunity, and you never know when you might have to change your tyre on the way to your next job interview ...

How do we "standardize and test" parental involvement and practical skills. Both of my daughters can change a tire, but only one will ever need to do so, because the younger doesn't drive. She can drive, but declined to take the test for her license because she doesn't think fast enough to be a good driver. She was wise enough to recognise that driving is not where hers skills lie and choose not to endanger others with her failings. (Her explanantion, not mine BTW)

Talent, ability, inclination, physical advantages/limitations, and millions of other factors make every person unique. Any national or international standard of literacy has to account and allow for differences in ability. If the bar is set too high when defining minimums, then "optimum" is out of reach for too many people.

Ksss said:
Literate...
The ability to read the warning on a cleaning supply bottle and being able to comprehend the use of said product. Also being able to comprehend the dangers if said product is not used correctly.
The ability to read a prescription bottle. To comprehend the results of over/under medicating oneself.

Comprehension is a slippery subject in this context. Comprehending specific warnings like "do not mix this product with ammonia" is different from comprhending that if Chlorine Bleach and Ammonia are mixed, it releases Chlorine gas which is poisonous" from that same warning.

Minimum literacy should certainly include the ability to understand and follow warnings. However, I know many nominally literate people who don't understand WHY those warnings are there, and WHAT the consequences of ignoring them would be.

Ksss said:
My granddaughter was denied entrance to Kindergarten this year, State tests stated she was ADD. Why? Because she didn't have the basic skills to "compete" with children the same age as her. She lacked the knowledge a child is taught through hearing and learning childrens songs and stories, her mother never sang to her or read her stories.

Ksss said:
Unfortunately, my granddaughter has to wait another year before she can start Kindergarten. Her mother had her tested by a child psychiatrist, she is NOT ADD. It was also discovered, she had a difficult time "focusing" on things because she needed glasses. Eyestrain was causing headaches which made her concentration level low.

This certainly sounds as if your granddaughter encountered a bureaucrat instead of an educator.

Your story highlights just one of the problems with trying to quantify literacy, whether through testing or some other means of evaluation. In addition to defining "literate" or "educated" an acceptable method of determining when the definition has been met has to be agreed upon -- every bit as thorny a discussion as getting a basic definition.

Ksss said:
What is right for one child is not necessarily what is right for another child. Everyone learns at a different pace. But if each child is taught how to read, comprehend, add, subtract, multiply and divide then they have the basic skills of being a literate person.

rambling man said:
Literacy is situational. A teacher should know where Nepal, Luxemburg, and Botswana are but not a career gas jockey. Mathematical literacy for an average person does not need to extend beyond arithmetic.

Ksss and Rambling Man,

At what age/educational level would you expect the majority of people to transform from "semi-literate student" into a "literate person?" Is there a ratio of knowledge to age that defines "literate" rather than a fixed level of absolute knowledge that defines literate?

For example, A seven-year-old who is considered bright and ahead of hispeers in reading and math skills could be considered a "literate child." If that same child learns nothing new until he turns 21 would be considered "illiterate and stupid" by most.

rambling man said:
If you are a good student and you want to learn you will do well almost anywhere. But there are many kids of average ability who fade away in classes that large. ... Many more kids fall through the cracks in larger schools who could learn more if they felt the teacher had time for them or cared.

School and class size is a bit of a digression from the main topic of defining WHAT to teach without regard to HOW to teach.

As the product of a school system in a small town that had fewer students thanmy daughter's senior class, and fewer citizens than her highschool had students, I can definitely understand your fondness for small schools and classes.

However, ...

My senior year, I was one of four students in the first physics class offered in over ten years in my high school. The teacher was a first year math teacher. We had next to nothing in the way of lab equipment, save what we built for ourselves. The small faculty size did not allow enough diversity in teacher qualifications to offer a really useful physics class, and other subjects suffered as well.

All of the science classes suffered from the cost of equipment, both in absolute dollar amounts and as a proportion of the total school budget. Classes with less requirements for physical equipment still suffered shortages of supplies from books to films because of the proportion of the school budget that could be alotted to them.

Small classes are good, but small schools are not. It would be wonderful if the atmosphere and comaradery of a small school could be coupled with the physical and materiel resources of a large school. Maybe a system of several small schools sharing the facilities of one large campus could be made to work.

rambling man said:
Standardized testing also reduces teacher creativity because of pressure to teach to the test. Teaching is more of an art than a science, in an optimal situation the teacher can tailor his or her approach to each student. In addition to what I said earlier about smaller schools and class sizes, teachers need to be treated like real professionals. Pay them a lot more but also require a masters degree in their field of teaching in addition to their bachelors in education.

Standardized testing reduces teacher creativity only because they allow it to. Pressure to teach the test comes from people who don't understand the nature and purpose of standardized tests in the context of testing for minimum standards as opposed to testing for a ranking. (See my comments later to KM and Ksss for more on the nature of testing.)

As I illustrated with the example of my physics class, in a small school, the limitation of faculty size would necessarily require teachers in a small school to have multiple masters degrees in order to support the curriculim.

Just three exapmles from my High school:

My Physics teacher was hired to teach freshman math (Algebra and Remedial Math.) He also tought the physics class, Phys. Ed. And was an assistant Baseball coach.

My advanced Math teacher also taught English Lit, Creative Writing, Chemistry, and coached the Track team.

My Earth Sciences teacher also taught General Science (I and II), Typing I, Metal Shop, and was the Head Baseball coach, and assistant Football coach.

In a larger school, each of those teachers could concentrate on one subject and thereby teach it better than spreading their efforts over such a broad spectrum.


KillerMuffin said:
Like I said, cultural bias is a cop out. Facility with English is not a WASP thing. Facility with English is an American thing. That is the language of the country and you ought to speak it. Not Eubonics, not Chinese, not Spanish. Immigrants exempted.

In standardized testing, it is a cop-out.

I think there is some justification for complaining about classes taught only in English as being culturally biased against those who grew up speaking another language. Math and Science are the same no matter what language they are taught and tested in. (although I have my doubts about Ebonics being suitable for teaching those subjects.)

There is also a difference in English Fluency and thinking in English. Except for whatever requirement is established for English language proficiency, Tests available in other languages for the other subjects would not compromise the validity of the tests.


KillerMuffin said:
Ignorance is not a cultural bias. Ignorance is a failing in the education of the ignorant. There are certain questions that should never be on a standardized test. Like what's the signifigance of Yom Kippur. Unless of course the essay one had to read prior to the question clearly states it. When you read a piece about something you don't already know, we call it learning. ... My sister-in-law didn't read Amy Tan not because she didn't comprehend the culture, but because the level of the language frustrates her. She said so herself. She's one of the smartest people I know, and I used to pity her for her lack of education. Until I figured out that she is perfectly happy just as she is. Amazing how stupid I was.

A good point about the nature of ignorance and the relationship of education to happiness.

One thing that seems to be misunderstood (not just by you, but by everyone,) is that standardized tests designed to determine if a minimum level of knowledge has been reached should be able to be aced by anyone who has met that minimum level. Tests of this nature are different from the ASVAB, SAT, and other tests intended to rank and rate levels of knowledge. They are not, or at least should not, be difficult enough that no one can ace them, so top performers can be rated as well as minimum performers.

Ksss said:
A few years ago it was decided by some group/panel that it would be required for all students to take and pass a Regents exam(s) in order to graduate.
...
They are trying to force all children to think at the same intelligence level, .... Instead of focusing on what abilities these children have they are forcing them to more pressures, possibly giving them lower self-esteem because they won't be able to live up to expectations of school administrators and stupid tests.

Ksss said:
Take a child who learnes more quickly, if they lower the guidelines for these tests so everyone has a fair chance to pass them, this child may become bored and then use less of their motivation to excel. It's a no win situation, in my opinion.

If the tests are properly constructed to verify minimums, and not to rank testees, then there are no pressures to "think at the same level", merely pressure to think "at or above the minimum."

I don't understand the mindset that asserts that because minimum standards exist nothing more than the minimum needs to be taught. It baffles me the same way that people who drive at 45 mph on a highway that has a maximum speed limit of 75 mph and a minimum speed limit of 45mph do.

Minimum literacy standards and standardized tests are, or should be, like the open highways of Nevada and Montana used to be. There was no Maximum speed limit, there was only a Minimum speed limit in some areas. As long as you dorve safely, and were above the minimum speed, you could go as far and as fast as you wanted. The educational system should be the same way -- meet the minimum, and exceed it by as much as your heart desires and your budget can support.
 
lavender said:
I think if we place more focus on our children at such a young age, if we give them the appropriate tools and building blocks, the rest is merely allowing them to continue to add onto a well-developed base.

As to what is literacy? I think it would be the ability for someone to be able to read, comprehend and then restate an article they read in an average newspaper, like the LA Times. I suppose this is too simplistic.

I take it that you are more in favor of a graduated definition of literacy then? Something that insures that the basics of reading, writing and 'rithmetic are taken care of by third grade or so?
 
First of all, I want to thank you, WH, for this thread. Very thought provoking, and you've done a masterful job of steering the discussion.

Weird Harold said:
So, Just how to we define a "good education?"
What level of reading speed and comprehension qualifies as literate?

What level of mathematical or arithmetic ability is required to be considered literate?

What level of Geography, Literature, Rhetoric, Computer Skills, Music, History, Chemistry, Physics, General Science, Logic, Etc, is required to be considered an "educated person?"


Last, but not least, how do we determine when a student has met the minimum requirements to be considered "educated?"

The above is from the original message. I don't know if we're any closer to answering those questions, but the detours sure have been fun to read.

But I'm a little confused. The way I read the above, you're asking about standards for an "educated person". For me, that phrase means someone that's well above the average high school graduate. Yet the topic seems to have drifted toward defining minimum acceptable standards for those graduates.

If we're trying to define suitable minimum graduation requirements, then I think it would be interesting to look at how the military handles evaluating new recruits. You and KM seem to have a handle on that, and her usual no-nonsense-cut-through-the-bs approach makes a lot of sense. Could the public school system benefit from the military's experience here?
 
I've been reading this topic with interest since I am currently working on my Master's Capstone Exhibition in Education. My focus throughout my program has been on literacy and I have read volumes of research on the subject. Everyone has made some valid points, but I think the conversation has focused way too high when discussing literacy and what the standards are for a literate person. I currently teach Pre-K, moving up to K next year and ALL my students will be expected to read before they move to first. Pushing down the curriculum? Certainly. A challenge? Certainly. Can I accomplish it? I'll damn well try, but to a great extent it depends on where my students are when they arrive the first day of school. Research on literacy shows that the three best predictors of reading success have nothing to do with a child's experiences in learning to read, i.e. it's not what the teacher does in K or 1st, what is important is what occurs before the kids get to school. (In case you're wondering, they are: 1. Knowledge of the alphabet 2. Phonemic awareness -- hearing sounds as separate units and being able to segment and blend the sounds in words 3. BEING READ TO DAILY) All those things that "aren't educational" that parents used to do-- singing nursery rhymes, reading stories and telling fairy tales, making up silly songs and words -- those are the building blocks of literacy and without them, the kids are already behind when they reach school. And with an average of 25 Kindergartners, finding time to provide the individual attention these kids that are behind need, is a Herculean task.

I'm sure from what I've seen here so far, that most parents here are very concerned about their children and take their education seriously. Unfortunately, I see far too many kids whose only interactions outside my classroom are with the TV. One reason this really hit home today is my conference with a parent. She has twins who have been in our program for about two months. Her boys are seriously behind... they are functioning cognitively on the level of a 2 year old... these kids don't even recognize colors, they can only count to 4, they have no idea what their name looks like or how to spell it. They constantly lash out at classmates and refuse to cooperate with teacher's directions. We had the conference because the little boy in my room hit three classmates, kicked me when I stopped him from hitting another, and spit on my teacher's aide. When I laid all this on the table, Mom responded that if I couldn't control one child, I needed a new career. My response was that I have 20 students and 19 of them are achieving far above the state "expectations" for Pre-K children and I cannot re-teach what they already know in hopes that her son will catch up. I've suggested tutoring, activities she can use at home, and even sent home extra practice for these boys (one twin is in my room, the other isn't), but it's MY job to teach them and she doesn't have time to do any of this.

With parental attitudes like this, is it any wonder that kids are leaving third, fourth, and even eleventh grade not being able to read??? Parents are truly a child's first and most important teacher, and until we find some way to ensure that ALL parents take this role seriously, there will be kids who start school at a tremendous deficit. And research has shown that despite all the intervention programs we have, students that start school behind their peers do not catch up, instead they fall further and further behind.
 
BubbaRednek said:
First of all, I want to thank you, WH, for this thread. Very thought provoking, and you've done a masterful job of steering the discussion.

Thank you. I still haven't really found the answer(s) I started out looking for, so I have to keep steering it back towards my main point, which you so kindly qouted below.

Weird Harold said:
So, Just how to we define a "good education?"
What level of reading speed and comprehension qualifies as literate?

What level of mathematical or arithmetic ability is required to be considered literate?

What level of Geography, Literature, Rhetoric, Computer Skills, Music, History, Chemistry, Physics, General Science, Logic, Etc, is required to be considered an "educated person?"


Last, but not least, how do we determine when a student has met the minimum requirements to be considered "educated?"

BubbaRednek said:
... I'm a little confused. The way I read the above, you're asking about standards for an "educated person". For me, that phrase means someone that's well above the average high school graduate. Yet the topic seems to have drifted toward defining minimum acceptable standards for those graduates. [/QUOTE

It is phrased a bit awkwardly. The basic idea, is that everyone has their own personal image of what a literate or "educated person" is -- or more precisely, something that makes them consider a person "ignorant" or "illiterate." Any one who doesn't fit your image of ignorant or illiterate, is by default, "literate" or "educated".

I keep mixing the terms, because literate means "able to read" while educated encompasses the results all kinds of formal education. Yet each person's personal definition of ignorant incudes some of both.

morninggirl5 said:
My focus throughout my program has been on literacy and I have read volumes of research on the subject. Everyone has made some valid points, but I think the conversation has focused way too high when discussing literacy and what the standards are for a literate person.
...
it's not what the teacher does in K or 1st, what is important is what occurs before the kids get to school. (In case you're wondering, they are: 1. Knowledge of the alphabet 2. Phonemic awareness -- hearing sounds as separate units and being able to segment and blend the sounds in words 3. BEING READ TO DAILY) All those things that "aren't educational" that parents used to do-- singing nursery rhymes, reading stories and telling fairy tales, making up silly songs and words -- those are the building blocks of literacy and without them, the kids are already behind when they reach school.

BR thinks I'm aiming higher than I intended, and MG5 thinks I'm aiming too high, and they're both right. What I set out looking for is some idea of what factors determine how they decide the ignorant/educated line.

From the answers so far, I've come to the conclusion that there is some sort of ratio involving age, educational level, and ability that determines where people draw the line. For some, it's a pass/fail judgement when they test for a diploma; for others, it's having the basic building blocks of arithmetic and some reading comprehension profiency; Yet others draw the line at some level of social skills being combined with reading and reasoning skills.

MG5 is certainly correct that without certain minimal preparation by parents, children will always be "less literate" than their peers who got that parental jump-start. I personally don't think it makes them illiterate when they start school or keeps them from achieving minimum proficiency later in life.

Another thing I wanted to find out with this thread, is what we expect from our educational system, and since most literacy complaints focus on high school gradutaes and college freshmen, that is pretty much the level I was unconsciously aiming at.

As I said at the beginning, we've had a lot of discussion on HOW the system is failing and WHY it is failing, but nothing specific on WHAT it is failing to do. That's what I set out in search of -- the WHAT, rather than the HOW or WHY.

In troubleshooting a problem, I've learned that until you can exactly define the symptoms, you can't define the problem. On something this complex, neither the symptoms nor the problem are easy to define.

BubbaRednek said:
If we're trying to define suitable minimum graduation requirements, then I think it would be interesting to look at how the military handles evaluating new recruits. You and KM seem to have a handle on that, and her usual no-nonsense-cut-through-the-bs approach makes a lot of sense. Could the public school system benefit from the military's experience here?

Yes and NO. Much of the way the military trains and evaluates people could well make the public school system better. However, the evaluation and training practices of the military are based on the basic assumptions that A) They don't have to accept anyone, and B) They have absolute control over the recruits.

The ASVAB and AFAQT tests that I've mentioned before are "Aptitude assessment" tests rather than tests of knowledge or profiency. They are tests specifically designed for the military by education specialists to assess both educational level and for specific aptitudes. While these are excellent tests for their designed purpose, they wouldn't be suitable as standardized testing for educational standards, or even for college entrance qualifications.

The key difference in military training and evaluation, is that there is always a fixed pass/fail point on every test and until that test is passed, the training continues or the student is "washed out" and sent for some other training. Private schools can afford to be similarly ruthless, but public schools can't.

Public schools could however, be more demanding and ruthless than they are -- even without standardized testing.

I'm not sure what the correct term is, but I'll call them "goals". I graduated from High School in 1968, and there were a set of goals established by the state of Oregon for what had to be learned to get a high school diploma. Those goals were expressed as "credits" required to graduate, and as of 1998, the school district here in Nevada used a similar method of defining requirements to graduate.

The difference between then and now, was that Every accredited class in any Oregon school had a set of goals for what would be learned in that class, and unless those goals were met, the class did not count. In later years I encountered the same principle in a formalized checklist of things that had to be learned to a certain level before a trainee could be certified and/or promoted.

In the military version of the process, the subject to be taught was divided into "sub-tasks." These were further divided into Mandatory, Recommended, and "Job Specific." When a trainee was entered into training, he was taken through the list item by item and shown which items had to be certified for the particular job he was being trained in. When every item was checked off, then traing was finished. When one item was left to master to the required level, training continued.

In terms of public schooling, a similar checklist would follow a child from K through college. As each school year started, the appropriate items would be ticked off as requaired to complete that grade level, and when all of those items were completed, they would move on to the next grade level.

Tasks on the checklist would vary from "pass a standard reading test for this grade level" to "writes legibly." The first would require a score of 70% on a specific test, and the second would require a teacher's certification that the writing was legible.

A reasonable definition of "high scool educated" could then be easily defined as having a certain percentage of specified tasks certified as complete.

It's a system that would work, but will never be implemented because "it puts too much performance pressure on the students."
 
I would be vastly interested to have a cross-section of literoticans take the Defense Language Aptitude Battery, which measure fluency. It's culturally biased, but then language is culture. The scale of grading reads like this:

0 = No language.
0+ = Can repeat a few words or phrases, but doesn't understand usage.
1 = Can make simple comments requests, ie, thank you, where is the bathroom? I can't speak your language.
1+ = Can add descriptors and carry simple conversation.
2 = Can survive in culture without using native language, carry on conversation and offer opinions without reasoning.
2+ = Can offer simple opinions and reasoning.
3 = Can offer opinions and explain why.
3+ = Can offer opinions persuasively.
4 = Can make persuavive arguments and debate.
4+ = Can debate with with higher reasoning.
5 = Total fluency.

Or something like that. Estimates state that the average American hovers in the 3+ range in their writing and listening skills and the 3 range in their speaking skills for their own native language of English. That's the national average guesstimate. There hasn't been any direct research.

On this board, some of us are 4s and 4+s. The only 5, in my opinion, would be Felix. The DLPT is one of the best standards for literacy, since it is an extremely lengthy test covering the listening, writing, and speaking areas in a variety of manners that include different cultures and dialects in that language.

I have no idea why I would think this is relevant.
 
KillerMuffin said:
0 = No language.
0+ = Can repeat a few words or phrases, but doesn't understand usage.
1 = Can make simple comments requests, ie, thank you, where is the bathroom? I can't speak your language.
1+ = Can add descriptors and carry simple conversation.
2 = Can survive in culture without using native language, carry on conversation and offer opinions without reasoning.
2+ = Can offer simple opinions and reasoning.
3 = Can offer opinions and explain why.
3+ = Can offer opinions persuasively.
4 = Can make persuavive arguments and debate.
4+ = Can debate with with higher reasoning.
5 = Total fluency.

Or something like that. Estimates state that the average American hovers in the 3+ range in their writing and listening skills and the 3 range in their speaking skills for their own native language of English. That's the national average guesstimate. There hasn't been any direct research.

...
I have no idea why I would think this is relevant.

I think it' is highly relevant! It is a quantitative way of expressing the "literacy" level I'm looking for. I think a score of two in reading and writing would be the minimum acceptable to be considered "Literate."

Now all we need is some way of certifying when students have reached level two that doesn't require one-on-one testing and six hours of testing. :p
 
:) I still miss Felix.

Maybe the DLPT wouldn't be such a bad thing. Only the speaking part is one on one testing, the rest was done in a large room all at the same time. Interview portions only lasted about an hour, if that long.

The prospect of having to pass the test and gain the minimum of 2s straight across in order to get a high school diploma might either make students pay more attention to the language, or drop out. Getting a 2 in your native language is generally easily accomplished.

[Edited by KillerMuffin on 05-17-2001 at 09:57 PM]
 
This thread has proven to be very thought provoking; as I read one post I formulated some responses only for these to be addressed in the following post. Now that I'm replying we have a scale of grading provided which is a timely point for me to join in again.

Weird Harold said:
So, Just how to we define a "good education?"
What level of reading speed and comprehension qualifies as literate?

What level of mathematical or arithmetic ability is required to be considered literate?

What level of Geography, Literature, Rhetoric, Computer Skills, Music, History, Chemistry, Physics, General Science, Logic, Etc, is required to be considered an "educated person?"


Last, but not least, how do we determine when a student has met the minimum requirements to be considered "educated?"

I'm starting to reach a conclusion which might end (or begin with) the words "It's all relative". As the vast majority of this thread deals with the American educational experience I've found myself having to divine meaning on occasion, and essentially 'translate' American scenarios into a more general idea which suits my train of thought. The scale of grading which KillerMuffin offers is a handy reference point. Being literate isn't necessarily a value-free situation. By this I mean that the ability to read and write, while a desirable asset, isn't an indicator of how 'educated' one is in certain cases. I'm aware that I'm shifting from the original questions again, but I'll try to explain myself.

We seem to have reached a point where one possible minimum definition of literacy has been 'measured'. The way 'we' give meaning to ourselves is on the basis of such measurements. That is to say that people with similar literacy levels group together on social and / or psychological levels. The psychological aspect is perhaps more fundamental to the original questions.

Weird Harold said:
The basic idea, is that everyone has their own personal image of what a literate or "educated person" is -- or more precisely, something that makes them consider a person "ignorant" or "illiterate." Any one who doesn't fit your image of ignorant or illiterate, is by default, "literate" or "educated".

I keep mixing the terms, because literate means "able to read" while educated encompasses the results all kinds of formal education. Yet each person's personal definition of ignorant incudes some of both.

When we encounter literature in any format which we find 'boring' or 'irrelevant' most of us switch off. I'm not too sure how to describe this moment, but I think that it is a key point in whether or not someone can go beyond the 'average' or 'minimum' grade of literacy; although 'specialization of knowledge' is a factor in the equation which I'll mention later (I'm thinking of Laurel's description of the "degreed" people who are very literate but who lack so many other skills). It's certainly a confusing situation if we look at and try to define literacy in isolation: one could spend their whole life studying the English language in great depth. They would measure a '5' on the scale offered, but would effectively have "no language" regarding many other social practices - all of which require a level of literacy. This is an extreme example, but I think that 'literacy' does pretty much have a common meaning and the scale provided is a good one.

The next question which has already been asked is how to apply it? Is it possible to gauge literacy in a way "that doesn't require one-on-one testing and six hours of testing"? The point someone made about students 'falling between the cracks' at school does seem to be a feature which occurs at so many levels in adult life. Can school ever be an ideal - given all of the issues which have been raised so far? What would that ideal look like? I think that this thread is conclusive evidence (certainly so far) that while a common definition of minimum literacy can be given, the core components which form the foundation of being literate (as in the level WeirdHarold is aiming at - see below) are in fact arbitrary. In this thread there have been examples of state-specific qualifications, military versus public versus private forms of education, child education compared to 'adult' education, social and cultural factors, etc. All of these come into play when deciding "the ignorant/educated line". I don't think this line is as fixed as we might think, as it pretty much depends on context. In affluent societies many people can no doubt afford to be "ignorant" while most of the population can afford to be "educated". Some can afford to be both at once!

Weird Harold said:
Another thing I wanted to find out with this thread, is what we expect from our educational system, and since most literacy complaints focus on high school gradutaes and college freshmen, that is pretty much the level I was unconsciously aiming at.

As I said at the beginning, we've had a lot of discussion on HOW the system is failing and WHY it is failing, but nothing specific on WHAT it is failing to do. That's what I set out in search of -- the WHAT, rather than the HOW or WHY.

In troubleshooting a problem, I've learned that until you can exactly define the symptoms, you can't define the problem. On something this complex, neither the symptoms nor the problem are easy to define.

You said it! Like I've said: it's all relative. As soon as tests are introduced then, because of the complexity and all of the variables involved, any and all tests can never be ideally suited to all student abilities. Having said that, the idea of students being 'under pressure' needn't be looked on as a bad thing. A lot of pressure when facing exams is 'self-inflicted', as I think it would be fair to say that many students don't dedicate themselves as wholeheartedly as possible. I'm not commenting on this specifically, as I think this is just an understandable feature of young adult life. Most of us don't like exam situations, and the fear of failure can be very powerful to the point that our true abilities aren't represented. For those who want to go on to well-paid jobs the ability to prioritise and deal with such pressure situations is essential. As has been pointed out, failing (or 'just passing') isn't the end of the world as life can and does go on.

Back to the focus that "most literacy complaints focus on high school gradutaes and college freshmen". I've mentioned earlier that the way knowledge is compartmentalised is an important factor here. Perhaps literacy is increasingly under threat from competing disciplines within colleges and universities? Not that each respective discipline is actively promoting 'illiteracy', of course! Rather that the amount of disciplines and courses means that students can hope to be the Master of one [linguistic / literary] trade, but very few can ever hope to be the Master of more than one. There was a time when a few people (usually men) possessed a working knowledge of the sciences, philosophies, mechanics and engineering and the like to an extent that would now be considered as 'genius'. The fact is that society has developed to the point that a lot more people are literate, but technological (and social it must be added) advancements mean that any 'elite' are now far more specialized. It's hard to dovetail ideas of 'literacy' with associated ideas of 'ignorance' in the modern world. After all, if our car breaks down we can call out a mechanic, if we don't like the news on TV we can change channels, if we don't know how to cook we can eat out or order pizza.

:)

Just a final thought re the scale KillerMuffin provides. I wonder how well we'd all score each other? While most of us would no doubt score each other above the average (I hope!) how would factors such as length of post, clarity, brevity, etc, etc, influence our final decisions? Does anyone have a fixed idea of how to begin? Being literate must then be relative after all; it won't matter what we are able to write, it will matter how others read it. ;)
 
Ally C said:
I'm starting to reach a conclusion which might end (or begin with) the words "It's all relative". As the vast majority of this thread deals with the American educational experience I've found myself having to divine meaning on occasion, and essentially 'translate' American scenarios into a more general idea which suits my train of thought. The scale of grading which KillerMuffin offers is a handy reference point. Being literate isn't necessarily a value-free situation. By this I mean that the ability to read and write, while a desirable asset, isn't an indicator of how 'educated' one is in certain cases. I'm aware that I'm shifting from the original questions again, but I'll try to explain myself.

I've pretty much reached the same conclusion about relative literacy. Of course, I kind of leaned towards that opinion when I started this thread.

Your point about the preponderance of American scenarios requiring translation for other nationalities is a good one. I only have a very minimal understanding of "A-levels" and other facets of the English school system and no knowledge of other country's school systems.

I do think I created more confusion than necessary by choosing the word "Literate" for this discussion, but I still can't think of a word that covers the aspects of "educated" that I wanted to include.

"Educated" carries implications of "higher education" to many people, and that's well above the ignorant/not ignorant line I'm looking for.

"Ignorant" in turn skews things towards discussions of "common sense" and how uncommon it is.

"Functional" includes skills and aptitudes that can't be taught or quantified, so that doesn't quite work either.

"Graduate" covers too much and not enough. I've known droputs who were "literate" (in the inaccurate sense I've been using the word) and known "graduates" who were both ignorant and uneducated.

The scale KM cited was specifically related to language skills. Reading, Writing, listening and speaking. A similar scale probably exists for Math/Arithmetic skills, and others for general scientific, Historical, geographical knowledge.

I think it is interesting to note that in scoring a test for "language skills" that reasoning and debating are required for the higher levels of proficiency. Reasoning and debating are based on logic which is primarily taught as a mathematical discipline. Expressing logic verbally is dependent on vocabulary an is therefore a legitimate method of sorting out the level of profiency, but it does bias the test in favor of people with a math skill.

It's certainly a confusing situation if we look at and try to define literacy in isolation: one could spend their whole life studying the English language in great depth. They would measure a '5' on the scale offered, but would effectively have "no language" regarding many other social practices - all of which require a level of literacy. This is an extreme example, but I think that 'literacy' does pretty much have a common meaning and the scale provided is a good one.

I think that it is impossible to assess 'literacy,' in it's literal sense of being able to read and write, in a vacuum. Having sufficient vocabulary to reason and debate does not give one the ability to use that vocabulary to reason and debate. Even more important, a large vocabulary and a love of words can actually hamper communication -- which is, after all, the whole purpose of gaining language skills. I know this from painful personal experience. :p

I think that this thread is conclusive evidence (certainly so far) that while a common definition of minimum literacy can be given, the core components which form the foundation of being literate ... are in fact arbitrary. In this thread there have been examples of state-specific qualifications, military versus public versus private forms of education, child education compared to 'adult' education, social and cultural factors, etc. All of these come into play when deciding "the ignorant/educated line". I don't think this line is as fixed as we might think, as it pretty much depends on context.

I think "subjective" is closer than "arbitrary." Literacy, in the broader sense, is definitely dependent on context. In America, the UK, or other English speaking country, I am am very literate (he says modestly.) In France, Germany, Russia, China, Thailand, or any other country where I don't speak the language, I'm functionally illiterate. On the Serengeti, Gobi, or Sahara, I'm totally illiterate because what I know won't keep me alive.

... Having said that, the idea of students being 'under pressure' needn't be looked on as a bad thing. ... Most of us don't like exam situations, and the fear of failure can be very powerful to the point that our true abilities aren't represented. For those who want to go on to well-paid jobs the ability to prioritise and deal with such pressure situations is essential.

I agree completely. I mentioned the "students under presure" because that is one of the biggest arguments against testing and ranked grading. I happen to believe that it is one of the root causes of the perceived failures in the American schools -- but that is a subject for another debate on the WHY and HOW schools are failing the students.

Back to the focus that "most literacy complaints focus on high school gradutaes and college freshmen". I've mentioned earlier that the way knowledge is compartmentalised is an important factor here. Perhaps literacy is increasingly under threat from competing disciplines within colleges and universities? Not that each respective discipline is actively promoting 'illiteracy', of course! Rather that the amount of disciplines and courses means that students can hope to be the Master of one [linguistic / literary] trade, but very few can ever hope to be the Master of more than one.

Every year, I see new banner headlines to the effect of "Colleges report incoming freshmen are dumber than last year" and "Johnny still can't read!" decrying the lack of basic mastery of the tools needed to learn what the colleges have to offer.

It isn't pressure from competing disciplines, the diversity of knowledge, or specialization that is perceived as a problem. Rather, it is a breakdown in the basic skills that all of the higer, specialized disiplines have in common.

There was a time when a few people (usually men) possessed a working knowledge of the sciences, philosophies, mechanics and engineering and the like to an extent that would now be considered as 'genius'. The fact is that society has developed to the point that a lot more people are literate, but technological (and social it must be added) advancements mean that any 'elite' are now far more specialized. It's hard to dovetail ideas of 'literacy' with associated ideas of 'ignorance' in the modern world.

I'm not quite sure that I agree with the assertion that "literacy" was a phonomenon of the Elite. Certainly, History makes much of the "Great Thinkers" but the common man -- the farmer in the fields, and the housewife slaving away at the stove -- were far more 'literate' in relative terms than today's common man -- The assembly line worker and fast-food cook.

Partly, that is because in earlier, less specialized times, everyone had to be able to make-do without calling in a specialist for every stopped drain or sagging barn roof. Since the only entertainment that wasn't self-made, books and newspapers, required literacy more importance was placed on the ability to read. While not everyone could read, those who could were accorded much more respect because they could.

Basic necessities were dependent on each individual's ability to do what was needed, and so practical physics, mathematics, engineering, medicine, mechanics, et al, were survival skills. They are still very useful in everyday life, even if they don't place much importance on learning them.

The faceless they above being the people who decide what goes or stays on the curriculim.

Between the Civil War and WWI, the average level of formal education was seventh grade. Hoever, a seventh grader of that time period was capable of reading and understanding anything from War and Peace to Stresses in Box-truss Bridges. I'm not sure that is the case with today's seventh graders anywhere in the world.

The Wright brothers weren't college educated, but they taught themselves aeronautics and accomplished what many college educated people tried and failed to do -- build an airplane.

They had the foundation of literacy, so they were able to educate themselves beyond what colleges of the time could teach them. Granted, they were exceeptional men, even by today's standards, but they were also typical of of their time educationally.

Just a final thought re the scale KillerMuffin provides. I wonder how well we'd all score each other? While most of us would no doubt score each other above the average (I hope!) how would factors such as length of post, clarity, brevity, etc, etc, influence our final decisions?

Those who have participated in this thread are 4+ to 5- on KM's scale. I think that's partly because of the problem I mentioned above with vocabulary interfering with communication. :( (I've toyed with the idea of rephrasing the question in words of two syllables to see if the response is different.)

I think time is more of a factor than literacy when it comes to long posts. This is not a subject which lends itself to brevity, but online time is precious when your last-read counter resets because you waded through eight or ten long posts. Only those who would rate above average on KM's scale and are interested in literacy would take the time to follow this thread.
 
Back
Top