Problem Child said:What is so hard about coming up with basic minimum standards for learning and then writing a fair test to evaluate a students level of knowledge?
I think that Problem Child is offering a simplistic view in a way which is to be congratulated. The question is about authority. Someone has to decide - to take responsibility [in exactly the same we that we have discussed in other threads 'parental responsibility' for similar issues] - what constitutes a decent level of literacy. In turn, 'we' have to accept said decisions, and have to accept that the powers-that-be are capable of serving their public duties in an efficient and dedicated manner. Easier said than done, it seems - given the content of this thread! To both define and implement this a curriculum has to be put in place, and an agreed canon offered to students. This feeds into points made about 'cultural bias': the canon and curriculum are either attacked as homogenising students within a white ['eurocentric'] set of knowledges, or else they are applied liberally to suit the heterogeneous student body, and any idea of standardisation is hard to achieve:
"The case against cultural diversity in the curriculum argues for a central spine in society to counter the perceived threats to the existing social and moral order which are posed when diversity slips into relativism; the case for diversity argues that anything else is either ideologically or socially reproductive." Keith Morrison, "Education," A Dictionary of Cultural and Critical Theory, ed. Michael Payne (Oxford: Blackwell, 1998) 161. [159-162]
Essentially, this is an issue about 'power', as social groupings (or dominant and often self-appointed voices within social groupings) perceive a threat to their way of life. Thus offering the 'dominant' social grouping's definition of what is used to achieve literacy is read in some quarters as a political endeavour. Education is the key building block to what shape our societies will eventually take, so it's understandable that so many voices are competing with each other to be heard. Unfortunately this can jeopardise the initial learning process, and I am against any and all so called 'politically correct' interventions in [primary] education.
BubbaRednek said:Problem Child said:I don't think the things people really need to know in order to have a basic understanding of how the world works really changes all that much. The only thing getting in the way of kids learning is the politics of teaching.
Hmmm... worked on a new car lately? How about an older model? Any change? How about using the Internet for research vs digging through a card catalog at a library? The world is changing, faster and faster. Geometry hasn't changed much, but basic life skills certainly have.
It just isn't that simple.
It's as simple as we want to make it, and that's the whole point. I understand what you're trying to say BubbaRednek, but literacy begins from an early age of course. None of the specialised / specific knowledges you offer [taking your example of car mechanics, and assuming that you are hinting at other related life skills] are necessary components in the primary classroom, with the possible exception of the Internet / computers. These play an increasing part, but they don't take away from "basic life skills" such as reading, writing and arithmetic; in fact they compliment them - or ought to.
I'll say again: It's as simple as we want to make it, and that's the whole point. I'm reminded of a news feature, within the last year or two, where a child had been taught at home by her parents. The point Laurel makes about 'memorizing versus seeing patterns in systems' is very relevant here. Essentially, the family had decided that they could offer a better education than that offered by public schooling. From a very early age their child was taught by them way beyond what is expected of a young child in any school. This is comparable with the idea someone raised about kids being able to pick up new languages better than adults. This kid was taught a very deep and complicated 'language' more commonly known as maths. Not any run of the mill stuff either, but extremely complicated maths which she assimilated successfully from a very early age. The child (who was a young teenager when the programme was shown) came across as very socially isolated. She had access to a whole childhood filled with hard facts and figures, but had missed out on more 'innocent' childhood experiences. In her situation, I doubt very much that she was "the life of the party" when trying to interact with her peers who were some educational years behind her.
The issue of literacy, which must be addressed from an early age, overlooks the fact that young pupils are in fact doing no more than learning facts and figures. Anyone who studies English or Maths (or any other subject) is learning the history of English or Maths (or any other subject). Through group interaction at school, experiences at home, and exposure to learning (which pretty much covers every daily activity), interpersonal and physical skills can be improved. Literacy must begin with the basics, with a foundation of facts and figures. The rest hopefully falls into place through the features I've described.
It has been mentioned that everyone learns at different paces, and some are more gifted than others at particular subjects. The educative process should be flexible enough to address this, while being rigid enough to ensure that all are given an equal opportunity to learn fundamental skills. Not everyone will utilise such opportunities, or be capable of meeting criteria, but this doesn't mean that the system is inherently inadequate. Change for everyone can be more harmful than no change to suit what are considered to be the basics [these having been agreed upon in the first place!].
... and then comes the approach to adulthood; the need to be able to make increasingly adult and responsible decisions for oneself. At this stage literacy, based on a firm and concise primary education, ought to be enhanced and added to by the capability to actively formulate ideas, to appraise the ideas of others, to begin to have a fundamental grasp of issues behind the newspaper headlines (to use an example already given). I don't mean in a specific way which covers all possible forms of media representation, but teenagers ought to be able to read and interpret ['decode'] various cultural forms. By this I mean the ability to interrogate a book, or a news story, and the ability to speak and write about their findings. Obviously questions would be 'set', and such projects would be framed within a certain discourse; but to avoid nihilistic readings of the education process then all - for there are many - other possible alternatives for what can and should be read must be restricted to some extent. Again, we are faced with the argument that some will be predujiced against, but we have to choose between a standard level which has some transferable meaning and a convoluted level which assumes that the teaching profession does not know best. [Note: I may have to clarify this point later, as I can't quite get my mind to address this issue as well as I'd like right now]
There is room for personal projects by students no doubt, but providing a standard and formal education must leave out as much as it lets in [if not more]. Otherwise it loses any clarity. This isn't hampering education, nor is it a form of politically incorrect intellectual closure, it's just offering education in a defined and ordered way. Numeracy is less controversial (or should be!), and if some 'fail' or generally don't do well, then that's just a fact of life [assuming that their school is fulfilling its functions to the best of its abilities]. This doesn't mean that such students need be overlooked; and it is entirely possible to make amends in adult life - such is the fluidity and flexibility of the job market. Literacy allied with practical skills depends as much on the home as on the school. Do parents take the time to show the workings of a car, to explain social and cultural issues, to involve their children in tasks which increase their "all-roundedness"? Do they have the time? Time should certainly be made, because every waking moment is a potential learning opportunity, and you never know when you might have to change your tyre on the way to your next job interview ...
