Weird Harold
Opinionated Old Fart
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2000
- Posts
- 23,768
Bump for MorningGirl5 and Ishmael
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
medjay said:When I was a freshman in college I was amazed to see how many people in English 101 could not put together a simple research paper.
Me, from an earlier post in this thread:
I do think I created more confusion than necessary by choosing the word "Literate" for this discussion, but I still can't think of a word that covers the aspects of "educated" that I wanted to include.
"Educated" carries implications of "higher education" to many people, and that's well above the ignorant/not ignorant line I'm looking for.
"Ignorant" in turn skews things towards discussions of "common sense" and how uncommon it is.
"Functional" includes skills and aptitudes that can't be taught or quantified, so that doesn't quite work either.
"Graduate" covers too much and not enough. I've known droputs who were "literate" (in the inaccurate sense I've been using the word) and known "graduates" who were both ignorant and uneducated.
Weird Harold said:
But were they "literate" in the sense of being able to function in society?
The freshman you cite are not prepared for college, but if you met them on the street would you tag them as "ignorant" or "illiterate" or otherwise recognise their literary failings?
medjay said:
I'm sure they are quite able to function. I remember reading somewhere that the average American reads at a sixth grade level (correct me if I'm wrong on this). No it doesn't make them illiterate and if I did meet them on the street I would have no way to judge that.
It's just that encountering it at an institute of "higher learning" came as a shock to the system for me because reading and writing skills were stressed so seriously as I was growing up. I never imagined that people all over the country weren't receiving the same quality of education I was.
You know, the funny part of this whole discussion is that everything that is pointed out here as a potential improvement can be solved very simply. Give parents the choice as to where to educate their children. Give them school vouchers and make the public school system compete in a free marketplace and you'll se dramatic improvements in education gained from all sources, public and private.Originally posted by Problem Child
Ally and Harold are obviously very well educated, or at least naturally smart as hell.
My question is, why is this so tough?
What is so hard about coming up with basic minimum standards for learning and then writing a fair test to evaluate a students level of knowledge? . . .
I don't think the things people really need to know in order to have a basic understanding of how the world works really changes all that much. The only thing getting in the way of kids learning is the politics of teaching.
You're citing a case that is hardly the norm. These kinds of things occur but even if you take the phenomenal stretch and say it's 10%, that still doesn't explain the remaining 90%.Originally posted by Mischka
I'm afraid it isn't that simple, PC. I volunteered at an elementary school for a year, teaching math to two fifth graders. . .
Funding is hardly the issue. Get rid of the layers of administration imposed by all the Federal bureaucracy and return to an efficient administrative system and your budget problem is non-existent.Originally posted by Mischka
Do you propose increasing the budget along with this suggestion? . . .
Basic math skills involve arithmetic to the extent of multiplying and dividing multidigit numbers, being able to make change without a register or calculator and perform most aritmetic without a calculator. This includes know the precedence of operators in complex arithmetic problems involving add/subtract/multiply/divide combinations. Perhaps even some introductory algebra. I'd even consider including the ability to derive a square root with paper and pencil.Originally posted by Weird Harold
Are Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, and Logorithms, "basic math skills" or are they "advanced mathematics". Do we stop at the equivalent of a four function calculator, or is there more to "basic math skills" than Arithmetic?
The basis of learning at the outset is learning facts. In order to increase one's knowledge, however, it is imperative that one learn to think. If you teach someone how to think rationally and objectively in an organized manner, to apply reason, then you have adequately equipped them to learn.Originally posted by Weird Harold
Is teaching "how to learn" as important as teaching mere facts? Can "how to learn" even be assessed quantitatively? Does it need to be?
I'd give vocabulary a bit of an edge here. If you know the meaning of the words, you can perhaps glean the meaning from the context if you've learned to think coherently. If you don't know what the words mean, you can't learn anything from all the reading in the world.Originally posted by Weird Harold
Which is more basic to reading: Vocabulary or sentence structure?
Grammar absolutely! Penmanship is to communication what paint is to making your automobile run. Penmanship can be cured by a typewriter (word processor), voice recognition software, etc. Grammar can't for the most part though some software does take a stab at it. The greatest difficulty there is that the English language permits such complexity of structure that to create a program to analyze it effectively is extremely difficult. I use MS Word '97 with the grammar and spell check enabled to evaluate as I type. Most of the spelling suggestions I accept; most of the gramamr suggestions I reject because they're not valid in the context of my writing.Originally posted by Weird Harold
What is more basic to writing: Penmanship or grammar?
To borrow a quote from an old Navy acquaintance, "We're talking about them, not to them. There's no necessity for them to respond."Originally posted by Siren
But isnt this an awful lot of words for some of the semi-literates to be able to read and grasp?
I mean it is about them that we are all talking about isnt it?
Carry on.........![]()

This is precisly why critical thinking skills are important. They can eliminate much of this "cultural bias" nonsense.Originally posted by Weird Harold
. . . If the "story" that frames the problem deals with planning a debutante ball, many people who aren't rich and/or well read will get lost in the unfamiliar terms and lose track of the math problem. . . .
Tests have an objective: screening for a particular result. The result is determined by the criteria set. Construct the best possible test to evaluate the requisite skills and/or knowledge of the applicants and ignore the idiot nitpickers who are not contributing to the solution but rather seek to be part of the problem they wish to perpetuate.Originally posted by Weird Harold
. . . . Nit-pickers who oppose testing for whatever reason pick at every straw they can dream up and apply every PC silliness they can manufacture to obstruct any rational standard. . . .
I ran into this idea of "teaching the test" in the Navy schools where I taught on two different tours. There were some instructors whose ability was such that they would literally teach "40 well known facts" to get their class to pass the test. Fortunately, these particular people were rare. Also they were not particularly well thought of nor did they serve their students well.Originally posted by rambling man
Standardized testing also reduces teacher creativity because of pressure to teach to the test. . .
ronde said:I graduated from high school in the mid 60's and "literate" was inferred by the minimum graduation requirements.
...
WH, this rant may be tangential to your original question, I felt most of the discussions were aimed at the public school systems when the question of literacy has a broader scope in today's world.
Unclebill said:The fact is, there are learning objectives which identify the knowledge factors to be taught. Guess what? The questions on the tests check the students' knowledge of these objectives! So if you teach to the objectives, you teach the test, albeit not literally "the test".
One of my students told me I taught in six weeks everything about basic electricity he had covered in his first semester of college.Originally posted by Weird Harold
All good thoughts UB. I would add one other comment about military tech schools -- They somehow seem to cram a whole year's worth of learning into a six-week course without any noticeable loss of long term learning.
I think the problem is too much time is wasted o the "social indoctrination" and "social engineering" crap and administration. Teachers' admin should be kept to a minimum. Taking attendance, grading tests and homework and assigning grades and supplemental evaluations if necessary should be the limits of what they are required administratively.Originally posted by Weird Harold
Could the latest "cure" being suggested -- longer school days and longer school years -- be an indication that administration and required repitition be wasting too much of a teacher's time?
KillerMuffin said:The minimum standard for education? I think we're all making this far too difficult.
A person ought to be able to read well enough in the predominant language to understand the content, if not all of the ramifications, in the newspaper.
A person ought to be able to do enough math that if their calculator broke when you're standing in their line at the cash register, you don't have to figure out your own change.
A person ought to know enough about society and government to recognize the importance of participating in that society and government as well recognizing that there is cultural differences.
A person ought to know enough about auto mechanics to pump their own gas, check their own oil, put on the spare tire, and recognize when the car should be maintained.
A person ought to know enough about science to realize that chemicals should be treated with respect, stuff falls when you drop it for a reason, and that when you're sick, you go to the doctor.
We call them MINIMUM standards for a reason. Some people DO NOT care to be educated. They'd rather subsist down at the bottom of the socio-economic food chain. Someone has to manage McDonalds and swab the deck.
None of the minimum standards to get by in today's society should have anything to do with cultural bias. How can you culturally bias math and basic reading? English is English. Addition and subtraction is addition and subtraction. When it comes to MINIMUM standards of education for a person to subsist in this world, you're talking about a cultural bias already. These people are from all cultures and share one thing in common, poverty.
If you want to raise the standards, to give them a stronger education and a better future, then you can get into cultural biases. This is where things like history and creativity come into play. Face it, the minimum standard does not equate with the ideal minimum standard.
Hamletmaschine said:First of all, "literacy" is the state or quality of being literate--i.e., having the ability to read and write. Consequently, knowledge of math, science, geography, and so forth are, strictly speaking, irrelevant to the question of literacy.
At any rate, I believe that the goal of public education back in the 18th and 19th centuries was to help foster the Jeffersonian ideal of an informed citizenry. ...
How necessary is it, really, for an "informed citizen" to be able to read the newspaper? ... Why? Newspapers are mainly outlets for advertising, not news or information--a simple content analysis will show you that. ...
knowledge and skills we'll need to live--not in a literate world, but in a post-literate world.
Weird Harold said:. . . Personally, I hope we never reach your "post-literate" ideal. It strikes me as being a world rules by con-men, shysters, and advertising flacks instead of informed citizens. We're far to close to that vision alrady unless education -- AKA literacy -- improves.
Weird Harold said:
Not really tangental at all. As a graduate from high school in 1968, I agree with almost everything you say.
This discussion was started as a way to narrow the discussion of "our schools have gone to hell" down to some specific points that need to be addressed. As such, it cna't help but be an indictment of "public schools" which are the largest percentage of "our educational system." Not all private and parochial schools can escape censure, but they do, in general, represent the top end of the educational system.
Sandia said:Ok, I've finally caught up. And thank you WH for starting this conversation.
Literacy/education/minimum standards...
I'd argue there's three levels of "literacy."
Reading, writing, and arithmetic, which ought to be learned in grade school; basic civic knowlege, which ought to be learned no later than Jr. High, and logic.
...
"Logic" has to do with how to think, not what to think.
It's the difference between a teacher who says: "here's what's going to be on the test: memorize it," and one who encourages students to find answers themselves; to debate those answers, and to think of education as a continuing process, not an end result.
...
To be a good worker is not the same as to be educated. In fact it may often be the two are in conflict.
Ally C said:That's the last time I'll be reading a whole thread from start to finish. My coffee's gone cold ...

KillerMuffin[/i][b] A person ought to know enough about science to realize that chemicals should be treated with respect said:
Math tests are easy to bias culturally as well. Any good math assessment test includes "story problems." If the "story" that frames the problem deals with planning a debutante ball, many people who aren't rich and/or well read will get lost in the unfamiliar terms and lose track of the math problem. By the same token, a problem dealing with how many Keys of Coke are required to make a batch of crack, is going to distract those who had no trouble with planning a ball.
pagancowgirl said:Originally posted by Weird Harold
Math tests are easy to bias culturally as well. Any good math assessment test includes "story problems." ...By the same token, a problem dealing with how many Keys of Coke are required to make a batch of crack, is going to distract those who had no trouble with planning a ball.
Wouldn't the fact that they were so caught up in the details show that they were, in fact, lacking in problem solving skills? Any word problem is only a math problem. If you lack the ability to pick out the pertinent information, and apply it in the manner required to solve the problem, then that shows a lack of 'literacy'. Doesn't it?
Sandia said:
Also: managing a McDonald's is no easy thing, and my understanding is a manager can make a decent living doing what he does. About as good as teachers I believe. And you know, don't you, that Bill Gates was a college drop-out?