How Long Will The War Last?

How Long Will The War Last?

  • 1-60 days

    Votes: 7 43.8%
  • 60-120 days

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • 120-180 days

    Votes: 3 18.8%
  • Other

    Votes: 5 31.3%

  • Total voters
    16

Lost Cause

It's a wrap!
Joined
Oct 7, 2001
Posts
30,949
Okay, let's assume the talking is done, the dung is flung into the fan, and it's go time. How long do you think the actual combat will take before the victory parade in Baghdad? Do you think Sodamn Insane will lead his troops, die in a bunker like that miserable corporal in Berlin, or run to a cave like that corpse Bin Laden?

Consider this before you answer:

(CBS) They're calling it "A-Day," A as in airstrikes so devastating they would leave Saddam's soldiers unable or unwilling to fight.

If the Pentagon sticks to its current war plan, one day in March the Air Force and Navy will launch between 300 and 400 cruise missiles at targets in Iraq. As CBS News Correspondent David Martin reports, this is more than number that were launched during the entire 40 days of the first Gulf War.

On the second day, the plan calls for launching another 300 to 400 cruise missiles.

"There will not be a safe place in Baghdad," said one Pentagon official who has been briefed on the plan.

"The sheer size of this has never been seen before, never been contemplated before," the official said.

The battle plan is based on a concept developed at the National Defense University. It's called "Shock and Awe" and it focuses on the psychological destruction of the enemy's will to fight rather than the physical destruction of his military forces.

"We want them to quit. We want them not to fight," says Harlan Ullman, one of the authors of the Shock and Awe concept which relies on large numbers of precision guided weapons.

"So that you have this simultaneous effect, rather like the nuclear weapons at Hiroshima, not taking days or weeks but in minutes," says Ullman.

In the first Gulf War, 10 percent of the weapons were precision guided. In this war 80 percent will be precision guided.

The Air Force has stockpiled 6,000 of these guidance kits in the Persian Gulf to convert ordinary dumb bombs into satellite-guided bombs, a weapon that didn't exist in the first war.

"You're sitting in Baghdad and all of a sudden you're the general and 30 of your division headquarters have been wiped out. You also take the city down. By that I mean you get rid of their power, water. In 2,3,4,5 days they are physically, emotionally and psychologically exhausted," Ullman tells Martin.

Last time, an armored armada swept into Kuwait and destroyed Saddam's elite republican guard divisions in the largest tank battle since the World War II. This time, the target is not the Iraqi army but the Iraqi leadership, and the battle plan is designed to bypass Iraqi divisions whenever possible.

If Shock and Awe works, there won't be a ground war.

*Peace through superior firepower. :D
 
You're one of those guys who wore a "Ayatollah Ass-a-hollah" T-Shirts, arent you?
 
Nope...

All I got is a handful of military ribbons, and dusty uniforms. You obviously don't have a thought about the thread, so you divert with personal attack. I'm not disappointed, just amused.
 
That looks like a nice plan, if the enemy is just going to sit there and wait for the bombs. Somehow, I think it isn't likely to be so easy, come to that.
 
I don't have a link, but today Bush was quoted saying that more time will be given for UN inspector's.
 
Re: Nope...

Lost Cause said:
All I got is a handful of military ribbons, and dusty uniforms. You obviously don't have a thought about the thread, so you divert with personal attack.

I guess you thought less of those shirts than some.
 
I only have biker related t-shirts. I do remember everyone wearing those things in the eighties, like the phony flag flyers today. They are about as stupid as those, "No war in Iraq," or "No blood for oil" signs.

Anyway, I think the actual war will be quick and decisive, about 1 week to contain Baghdad, and about 10 days for it's capitulation. I heard today that Iraq is issuing atrophine to their troops for effects of chemical/biological weapons it say's it doesn't have. Sodamn Insane will run like the leader he is, while putting civilians in front of him to be killed. His kids are gonna run too, once the shootin' starts, and the generals will try to fight, but will order a general stand down as soon as the secret police are killed. I'm concerned about buried munitions in the oilfields, I would have SF troops in place before "A" hour to diffuse them before they blow the wells.
 
I voted other. The war itself might only last a month or so but the peacekeeping afterwards will last years.

It will be even worse if we try to do it ourselves. The US has historicaly been very bad at peacekeeping/nationbuilding. The UN has a bit better of a record.
 
Let me be more specific, lest someone accuse me of being a 'peacenik'.


"There will not be a safe place in Baghdad," said one Pentagon official who has been briefed on the plan.
That means no safe place for noncombatants, including women, children, and the infirm and elderly. Iraq doesn't have an overwhelmingly massive army that would make such an attack reasonable. North Korea, maybe...the Israeli army could whoop Saddam and Co., if someone would mind the store for them for a few weeks.


"So that you have this simultaneous effect, rather like the nuclear weapons at Hiroshima, not taking days or weeks but in minutes," says Ullman.

Again, Japan was pretty tough. They had the capacity to inflict massive damage to American troops. We're not even overly concerned about Iraq being able to torch their oil fields, let alone mount a serious counterattack. Iraq is already weakened by 12 years of sanctions and bombings.

"...You also take the city down. By that I mean you get rid of their power, water. In 2,3,4,5 days they are physically, emotionally and psychologically exhausted," Ullman tells Martin.

Again, that also targets civilians, which is a clear violation of international law, and any moral decency.

Last time, an armored armada swept into Kuwait and destroyed Saddam's elite republican guard divisions in the largest tank battle since the World War II. This time, the target is not the Iraqi army but the Iraqi leadership, and the battle plan is designed to bypass Iraqi divisions whenever possible.

If Shock and Awe works, there won't be a ground war.

This just strikes me as cowardly, quite frankly. We KNOW we can beat Iraq in a ground war, it would be a piece of cake. Ask any of the troops on the ground...they are ready to fight. Unfortunately, the politicians are cowards, and are afraid of the backlash of American casualties. The military trains to fight, and should be allowed to do so. This 'Playstation war' lacks honor, and in my opinion is a slap in the face to all those who died with honor in wartime.
But that's just my opinion. If I hadn't shattered my ankle, I would likely be on my way to Iraq, and my opinion would be the same.
 
The final proof that Bush's America is...

turning into a bunch of genocidal murderers.

The sickening thing is, the writer of the article is boasting about America's plans...

Cunts the lot of them...

ppman
 
I agree with all of your points exept for the last one.

Urban combat in Baghdad would be horrible. I don't even want to look at what the casulity projections would be if we had to fight for Baghdad block by block.

Cut off power and water to the major cities at about the same time you destroy anything even remotely capably of fighting back outside the cities and then wait.

Hit any hard targets in Baghdad or other cities with the same JDAM bombs and then hope enough units surrender that you don't have to fight block by block for the cities.

I don't know what the difference in causlity statistics were for WWII when comparing urban combat to normal combat but I am sure they were extreme.

The US has had urban combat experience in the past, Somalia being the most recent one I think, but we have done nothing on this type of scale since WWII.
 
Azwed said:
I agree with all of your points exept for the last one.

Urban combat in Baghdad would be horrible. I don't even want to look at what the casulity projections would be if we had to fight for Baghdad block by block.

Cut off power and water to the major cities at about the same time you destroy anything even remotely capably of fighting back outside the cities and then wait.

Hit any hard targets in Baghdad or other cities with the same JDAM bombs and then hope enough units surrender that you don't have to fight block by block for the cities.

I don't know what the difference in causlity statistics were for WWII when comparing urban combat to normal combat but I am sure they were extreme.

The US has had urban combat experience in the past, Somalia being the most recent one I think, but we have done nothing on this type of scale since WWII.


I understand that casualties will be higher than what we would like them to be...but that is what the military is for! Yes, absolutely minimize their losses by any and all means short of mass-murder...but don't place their safety against the lives of children.
 
As long as it takes too kill Sadamn. Then on to Iran or North Korea.

All the while Europe is cleaning the muslim fuckups and gleening info until all Al-Quedia is dead and buried in pig fat.
 
clit_licker30 said:
As long as it takes too kill Sadamn. Then on to Iran or North Korea.

All the while Europe is cleaning the muslim fuckups and gleening info until all Al-Quedia is dead and buried in pig fat.

You have a pig fat fetish or something?
 
I think if we do "Invade" Iraq....it will be the biggest mistake this countries leaders have ever made in this countries history.

I hope they have plenty of bodybags for our guys over there, and all of us over here.
 
Plus, I'll love seeing everyone start flying thier USA flags, and having a flag flying from the windows of thier cars like we did when 911 happened.

Where are thier flags now?

I fly a flag at my home on the porch 365 days a year....but if we invade Iraq....I am taking it down.

I might even package it up and send it to the Whie House......They can have it....I wont need it anymore.
 
Lost Cause said:
The battle plan is based on a concept developed at the National Defense University. It's called "Shock and Awe" and it focuses on the psychological destruction of the enemy's will to fight rather than the physical destruction of his military forces.
...
If Shock and Awe works, there won't be a ground war.

Shock and Awe won't work.

It didn't work in WWI when the Zepelins Bombed London; It didn't work in WWII for either the Germans or Allies -- the Atomic Bomb was an exclamtion point, not an opening; it didn't work in Korea, Vietnam, Kosova or Desert Storm.

Every time some backroom intellectual has proposed that bombers alone can win a war, it hasn't worked. In every case, it has been troops on the ground that decided things.
 
Re: Re: How Long Will The War Last?

Weird Harold said:
Shock and Awe won't work.

It didn't work in WWI when the Zepelins Bombed London; It didn't work in WWII for either the Germans or Allies -- the Atomic Bomb was an exclamtion point, not an opening; it didn't work in Korea, Vietnam, Kosova or Desert Storm.

Every time some backroom intellectual has proposed that bombers alone can win a war, it hasn't worked. In every case, it has been troops on the ground that decided things.

I am pretty sure Kosovo was won pretty much soley with air power but no other conflict ever has been.

There have to be troops on the ground to hold territory and to round up any hold outs.
 
Back
Top