IQ matters

Jordan Peterson is really shaking the foundations of the empiricist and skeptics- who have been dominating in this post-modern age.

I believe we have just now started to evolve out of the post-modern problem, instead of continuing to revolve in this post-modern problem.

I hesitate to say "I hope I get to see it". I fear post-modernism may have pushed too hard, and that the corrective ways of the world will have to push-back... the question is how extreme does that push-back need to be?

Pretty hard, I would say. We can't even get concurrence that there are differences between individual humans in intelligence, much less the fact that those obvious differences are measurable in an objective way.

Every time some members of the wrong group of people fail at something that they are incapable of accomplishing the standard for what is an accomplishment is lowered. it matters not at all that individual members of those selfsame groups are in fact capable of meeting the prior standards.
 
Jordan Peterson is really shaking the foundations of the empiricist and skeptics- who have been dominating in this post-modern age.

I believe we have just now started to evolve out of the post-modern problem, instead of continuing to revolve in this post-modern problem.

I hesitate to say "I hope I get to see it". I fear post-modernism may have pushed too hard, and that the corrective ways of the world will have to push-back... the question is how extreme does that push-back need to be?

"extreme" simply covers the need to peel back the damage enough to discover how marred the actual foundation has become. Once enough grasp the "extreme" nerve to fully face that initial must, they'll then fully, finally realize the original foundation has been long "lost", too, to the extent that its very best components still inalienably survive, but not within the statist framework they were originally constituted among.

"New" has meaning...
 
"extreme" simply covers the need to peel back the damage enough to discover how marred the actual foundation has become. Once enough grasp the "extreme" nerve to fully face that initial must, they'll then fully, finally realize the original foundation has been long "lost", too, to the extent that its very best components still inalienably survive, but not within the statist framework they were originally constituted among.

"New" has meaning...

It's all necessary for Foundation Revival. Out with the old and in with the new.

I wonder what the next era will be named. Neo-classical? Oops, that one is taken. Neo-modern? Modern classical?
 
Pretty hard, I would say. We can't even get concurrence that there are differences between individual humans in intelligence, much less the fact that those obvious differences are measurable in an objective way.

Every time some members of the wrong group of people fail at something that they are incapable of accomplishing the standard for what is an accomplishment is lowered. it matters not at all that individual members of those selfsame groups are in fact capable of meeting the prior standards.

Their IQ beliefs don't cohere with some of their other biological beliefs.
 
It's all necessary for Foundation Revival. Out with the old and in with the new.

I wonder what the next era will be named. Neo-classical? Oops, that one is taken. Neo-modern? Modern classical?

"Revival"? That reads expectingly optimistic. Always a great chance what comes next will be called "even worse".
 
When there exists enough who MAINTAIN that human life ≠ human life...

...then there's really not much chance of ever holding any significantly successful kind of any other REALITY discussion(s).
 
When there exists enough who MAINTAIN that human life ≠ human life...

...then there's really not much chance of ever holding any significantly successful kind of any other REALITY discussion(s).

harsh.

im thinking...
 
Intelligence is neither biological nor inheritable. If it were, dummies would have been weeded from the genepool long ago and we'd all be fucking geniuses now, building interstellar colonies instead of lame excuses for intolerance.

IQ is not a single measure of anything. I vaguely recall the batteries of enlistment tests I took long ago, and the results. Army scores were in various areas for specific capabilities which were then factored together for a G.I. (general Intelligence) score, equivalent to IQ. Folks with high G.I. and verbal scores but low mechanical and visualization scores probably wouldn't do well as grease monkeys or gun bunnies.

Are specific capabilities inheritable? Did the Bach and Shankar families produce generations of musicians because of genes, or lifelong practice? Ask that of any trade.
 
When there exists enough who MAINTAIN that human life ≠ human life...

...then there's really not much chance of ever holding any significantly successful kind of any other REALITY discussion(s).

What are your beliefs on the concept of separation of church and state?
Should the state legislate morality?
What do you think about free will?



"Revival"? That reads expectingly optimistic. Always a great chance what comes next will be called "even worse".

I'm not a fatalist!
 
What are your beliefs on the concept of separation of church and state?

"the concept", meaning Jefferson's "concept" as explained in his letter "To messers. Nehemiah Dodge, Ephraim Robbins, & Stephen S. Nelson, a committee of the Danbury Baptist association in the state of Connecticut"?

Should the state legislate morality?

As far as America goes, "the state" can't constitutionally "legislate morality". Should the federal Congress, or state Legislatures, or local Councils "legislate morality"?

Define "morality".

What do you think about free will?

Immediately, I "think" it is as natural, God-endowed and as inalienable as breathing.

I'm not a fatalist!

:D Whatever you need to do to assuage the inevitable, worm food.

Factually, reality doesn't really care how any of us view it.
 
Then you think knowledge is innate?
Depends on defining 'knowledge'. Our genes and instincts store aeons' worth of survival knowledge for certain contexts. But "fight or flight" doesn't always apply in subtle situations. So we learn a few things here and there, and maybe record it somewhere. Meanwhile, some learn by reading. Some learn by listening. And some gotta piss on the electric fence to see if it's not.

Innate knowledge: Prey creatures that aren't skittish don't survive to breed.
Gained knowledge: Learn some charm and you might be chosen to breed.

It really is all about reproduction. If your parents didn't have kids, you probably won't either.
 
"the concept", meaning Jefferson's "concept" as explained in his letter "To messers. Nehemiah Dodge, Ephraim Robbins, & Stephen S. Nelson, a committee of the Danbury Baptist association in the state of Connecticut"?

I know you know what I'm talking about. Yes, that concept. Separation of church and state, religious freedom, give unto caesar what is caesars and to God what is God's.

Define "morality".

I'll rephrase, should the state define morality?

Immediately, I "think" it is as natural, God-endowed and as inalienable as breathing.

I agree. It is not endowed by man or any system flawed man creates.
 
Depends on defining 'knowledge'. Our genes and instincts store aeons' worth of survival knowledge for certain contexts. But "fight or flight" doesn't always apply in subtle situations. So we learn a few things here and there, and maybe record it somewhere. Meanwhile, some learn by reading. Some learn by listening. And some gotta piss on the electric fence to see if it's not.

So you think knowledge is gained by the senses, from the things we observe in the external world, through empirical means; but you don't think we can test how much empirical knowledge one has gained.

I don't think that follows.
 
So you think knowledge is gained by the senses, from the things we observe in the external world, through empirical means; but you don't think we can test how much empirical knowledge one has gained.

I don't think that follows.
I said nothing of the sort. We test what we think we know constantly. Every step you take tests your knowledge of gravity -- which isn't much, since nobody has a good theory, but our empirical take is enough to survive. My cat test gravity constantly, pushing objects off edges.

And we learn from instruments as well as senses. I'd rather stick a thermometer into the meat loaf to see if it's done, than poke my thumb and judge by blisters.
 
I said nothing of the sort. We test what we think we know constantly. Every step you take tests your knowledge of gravity -- which isn't much, since nobody has a good theory, but our empirical take is enough to survive. My cat test gravity constantly, pushing objects off edges.

And we learn from instruments as well as senses. I'd rather stick a thermometer into the meat loaf to see if it's done, than poke my thumb and judge by blisters.

Yes, that's exactly what you said, I just rephrased it, and then you rephrased it again in this post. Think about what you are saying. Also, humans aren't cats, we have cognitive abilities that allow for abstract thought- like gravity or zero.

Also, observing a thermometer and feeling temperature with you finger are both empirical knowledge gains through the senses. One is more accurate than the other, and less painful. Would you say the person who used an advanced tool to judge the temperature of the meatloaf is smarter or dumber than the person who used their finger? Why would you rather use the tool?
 
I know you know what I'm talking about. Yes, that concept. Separation of church and state, religious freedom, give unto caesar what is caesars and to God what is God's.

Are you sure?

The State Becomes the Church: Jefferson and Madison

It is no exaggeration to say that on Sundays in Washington during the administrations of Thomas Jefferson (1801-1809) and of James Madison (1809-1817) the state became the church. Within a year of his inauguration, Jefferson began attending church services in the House of Representatives. Madison followed Jefferson's example, although unlike Jefferson, who rode on horseback to church in the Capitol, Madison came in a coach and four. Worship services in the House--a practice that continued until after the Civil War--were acceptable to Jefferson because they were nondiscriminatory and voluntary. Preachers of every Protestant denomination appeared. (Catholic priests began officiating in 1826.) As early as January 1806 a female evangelist, Dorothy Ripley, delivered a camp meeting-style exhortation in the House to Jefferson, Vice President Aaron Burr, and a "crowded audience." Throughout his administration Jefferson permitted church services in executive branch buildings. The Gospel was also preached in the Supreme Court chambers.

Jefferson's actions may seem surprising because his attitude toward the relation between religion and government is usually thought to have been embodied in his recommendation that there exist "a wall of separation between church and state." In that statement, Jefferson was apparently declaring his opposition, as Madison had done in introducing the Bill of Rights, to a "national" religion. In attending church services on public property, Jefferson and Madison consciously and deliberately were offering symbolic support to religion as a prop for republican government.

More here:

https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/religion/rel06-2.html

Are you sure your perception of Jefferson's concept identically match Jefferson's, because as it is popularly, Orwellian doublethink applied as statist religion today, "separation of church and state" clearly doesn't represent what its creator insisted and demonstrated.

I'll rephrase, should the state define morality?

:D Actually, I was asking for your definition of morality, since without first agreeing on its definition, how can we possibly, practically discuss it further? Surely you know today that "morality", just like "human life =", is totally up for subjectively individual perception, right?

To me a moral person is an imperfect individual whose mind natively understands the difference between right and wrong, and whose heart inherently longs to do right. Alas, even with two people agreeing to that general premise, they can still totally disagree on what is then right or wrong. :D

And, since no "state" can exist without individuals first enabling it, it seems imperative that those individuals first define their own interpretations of "morality" before their state can be held accountable for defining its. Because, in fact, every state most definitely does COLLECTIVELY define itself morally (pro or con) by its dominant politics/constitution.

Our microwave culture isn't conducive at all to such patient contemplation, is it? Good thing America's founders/framers didn't have to suffer that, eh?
 
Are you sure?


More here:

https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/religion/rel06-2.html

Are you sure your perception of Jefferson's concept identically match Jefferson's, because as it is popularly, Orwellian doublethink applied as statist religion today, "separation of church and state" clearly doesn't represent what its creator insisted and demonstrated.

I am sure I am talking about the divine concept, not the flawed man's actions.



:D Actually, I was asking for your definition of morality, since without first agreeing on its definition, how can we possibly, practically discuss it further? Surely you know today that "morality", just like "human life =", is totally up for subjectively individual perception, right?

To me a moral person is an imperfect individual whose mind natively understands the difference between right and wrong, and whose heart inherently longs to do right. Alas, even with two people agreeing to that general premise, they can still totally disagree on what is then right or wrong. :D

And, since no "state" can exist without individuals first enabling it, it seems imperative that those individuals first define their own interpretations of "morality" before their state can be held accountable for defining its. Because, in fact, every state most definitely does COLLECTIVELY define itself morally (pro or con) by its dominant politics/constitution.

Our microwave culture isn't conducive at all to such patient contemplation, is it? Good thing America's founders/framers didn't have to suffer that, eh?

I believe that everyone's moral judgement is not universal, and that is the beauty of it. We keep each other in check. So, I do not believe that government should legislate universal morality decisions. That's between me and God.
 
Hypoxia inspired me to create a question.

If genes aren't inherited. Then how come a white couple can't make a black baby?
 
I believe that everyone's moral judgement is not universal, and that is the beauty of it. We keep each other in check. So, I do not believe that government should legislate universal morality decisions. That's between me and God.

So, government shouldn't legislate that murder is wrong/against the law?
 
Hypoxia inspired me to create a question.

If genes aren't inherited. Then how come a white couple can't make a black baby?

Tough question to answer but here's my best shot. It certainly seems possible for two white people to have a black baby even if the baby's grandparents appear white as well. Even though the genetics behind all of this are really poorly understood, there are lots of stories where white parents have black babies.

http://genetics.thetech.org/ask/ask9

SKIN Trailer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbj691Z1Z1E
 
Intelligence is neither biological nor inheritable. If it were, dummies would have been weeded from the genepool long ago and we'd all be fucking geniuses now, building interstellar colonies instead of lame excuses for intolerance.

IQ is not a single measure of anything. I vaguely recall the batteries of enlistment tests I took long ago, and the results. Army scores were in various areas for specific capabilities which were then factored together for a G.I. (general Intelligence) score, equivalent to IQ. Folks with high G.I. and verbal scores but low mechanical and visualization scores probably wouldn't do well as grease monkeys or gun bunnies.

Are specific capabilities inheritable? Did the Bach and Shankar families produce generations of musicians because of genes, or lifelong practice? Ask that of any trade.

Too bad your theory here fails when it comes to hair, looks, tits, legs and ass that most certainly keep dummies in the breeding pool. And in any family, in any generation the genes might be there, but have been suppressed by the sheer necessity of surviving in a world where life was short, nasty and brutish.
 
Last edited:
Good point.

I'm thinking... this one is going to take a bit more time, I think.

What's between you and God is wholly spiritual, eternal.

What's between you and government is wholly political, worldly.

That's the separation between God and state, your reference to Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's; and to God the things that are God's.

Jefferson's "separation" referred to the political entities of "church and state", both of which still vie for individual dominance on the world scale. In Jefferson's younger days, the "church", whichever denomination, was as politically powerful as any colony's government, and in many instances, more so.

Jefferson's "separation", then, had nothing to do with God per se, but everything to do with denouncing"church and state" dominance over YOUR natural, God-endowed, inalienable individual right to freely manage your own relationship with God without any outside political interference at all.
 
Back
Top