EmilyMiller
Alysa Liu is my God
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2022
- Posts
- 15,680
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The clever point of that video is that we recognise each character. Perhaps we're all, at times, guilty of being insincere, boorish or cowardly?Which one is me, hun?
Em
Well I've got a thirty-two year old son, and I'm going to call bullshit on that.Boys are taught since birth and it continues to be pounded into our brains, that we are not allowed or permitted to show emotions.
Hurt, anger, sadness, etc.
A significant portion of women push this narrative too, so it can't all be placed on "father's, uncles, grandfather's, etc"
We are told that we are only permitted to work, pay taxes, sacrifice our welfare and lives for others, kill bugs, and die.
What she said aboveYup yup... I made a post earlier and deleted it because it sounded like I was having a pop at the OP, which I'm not.
"Guys should be able to express their emotions ...
The way some guys talk you'd think they had no choices: they consider themselves tough but can't handle the reaction of other men if they're seen crying?! wtf
- but some women won't fancy them ( does everything in life revolve around getting laid? )
- they might look gay ( homophobic much? )
- we were told to be this way as kids ( so how old are you know? )
- I'd look like a girly-man ( that's sexist - there are strong women )
Men can cry AND be strong, yet the comments here suggest the two are incompatible. If there are women who can't handle a few man-tears, then who has the problem? If men mock their emotional brothers but then complain they can't express their own, then those are problems they need to address and not beat their chests in frustration, blame other people or lash out with slurs.
Be the man to make a difference but start with yourself.
Mic drop @stickygirl ?Yup yup... I made a post earlier and deleted it because it sounded like I was having a pop at the OP, which I'm not.
"Guys should be able to express their emotions ...
The way some guys talk you'd think they had no choices: they consider themselves tough but can't handle the reaction of other men if they're seen crying?! wtf
- but some women won't fancy them ( does everything in life revolve around getting laid? )
- they might look gay ( homophobic much? )
- we were told to be this way as kids ( so how old are you know? )
- I'd look like a girly-man ( that's sexist - there are strong women )
Men can cry AND be strong, yet the comments here suggest the two are incompatible. If there are women who can't handle a few man-tears, then who has the problem? If men mock their emotional brothers but then complain they can't express their own, then those are problems they need to address and not beat their chests in frustration, blame other people or lash out with slurs.
Be the man to make a difference but start with yourself.
Like, "Who stole my Zimmer-frame oil?" and fighting over the best seat in the day lounge?It's a knack
Besides, people just rabbit on endlessly like it was an old folks home
Call whatever you want, still doesn't change the fact, that that is what is still being taught in today's society to the majority of males.Well I've got a thirty-two year old son, and I'm going to call bullshit on that.
You're on a different planet to me, that's for sure.
We clearly move in different societies. It wasn't true with me and my upbringing, and it's not true with my son and any of his peers.Call whatever you want, still doesn't change the fact, that that is what is still being taught in today's society to the majority of males.
I don't think it's a competition as to who has it worse. The original question was directed at men, and some of us shared our experiences. I don't have it worse than women, but I do have issues that I deal with. They aren't the same as what women go through, but they aren't any less valid because women go through more pervasive shit than I do.More like 'we have it worse than women' and women saying 'no, we have it worse' but with more elegant phrasing that lasts an entire page of total bollocks and smelling of rotten cabbage
You'll know I was just kidding around, but that doesn't dismiss the problems individuals face as being irrelevant. Looking through the thread there are a lot of contradictory claims being made by men, so they have become there own worst enemies.I don't think it's a competition as to who has it worse. The original question was directed at men, and some of us shared our experiences. I don't have it worse than women, but I do have issues that I deal with. They aren't the same as what women go through, but they aren't any less valid because women go through more pervasive shit than I do.
What a sheltered, myopic, self-centric view of the world you have. Because you didn't experience it, it doesn't exist? Because you didn't teach or treat your son that way, no one else did either? I think everyone understands (or should) that a thing like this is not global, encompassing everyone. But it does still encompass the majority of males, at least in this country. Boys are still told "don't be a baby" "you aren't hurt that bad", "quit crying" and "men don't cry".Well I've got a thirty-two year old son, and I'm going to call bullshit on that.
You're on a different planet to me, that's for sure.
This is entertaining. An acerbic post on this subject from a person who touts global inclusion. As far as your "funny" examples, you do realize that's a classic underhanded tactic to insult without appearing to, right? And I don't think anyone throughout this thread has expounded on any of the points you used. But let's examine them, shall we?Yup yup... I made a post earlier and deleted it because it sounded like I was having a pop at the OP, which I'm not.
"Guys should be able to express their emotions ...
The way some guys talk you'd think they had no choices: they consider themselves tough but can't handle the reaction of other men if they're seen crying?! wtf
- but some women won't fancy them ( does everything in life revolve around getting laid? )
- they might look gay ( homophobic much? )
- we were told to be this way as kids ( so how old are you know? )
- I'd look like a girly-man ( that's sexist - there are strong women )
Men can cry AND be strong, yet the comments here suggest the two are incompatible. If there are women who can't handle a few man-tears, then who has the problem? If men mock their emotional brothers but then complain they can't express their own, then those are problems they need to address and not beat their chests in frustration, blame other people or lash out with slurs.
Be the man to make a difference but start with yourself.
For an average heterosexual male, yes it does, especially in the teen years. And since heterosexual males are the majority, then the majority are consumed by sex. So you are closer to the truth than you realize.
- but some women won't fancy them ( does everything in life revolve around getting laid? )
See the first example. If you are a heterosexual male rife with male hormones, you NEVER want to appear homosexual. It would be difficult to attract a female that way. So it isn't so much about being "homophobic" as it is not wanting to appear to be anything other than heterosexual and being as attractive to as many females as possible.
- they might look gay ( homophobic much? )
Not just "told". Most males are immersed in it, infused with it, from every corner of their lives. So a simplistic "we were told" is deceptive and misdirection.
- we were told to be this way as kids ( so how old are you know? )
Women are strong. I can attest to how strong some of them are, stronger than I am in some instances. But women have little problem crying in public. Men do, for a variety of reasons. So the term "girly-man" doesn't have anything to do with how strong one is, but how they express their emotions.
- I'd look like a girly-man ( that's sexist - there are strong women )
Want a hug?What a sheltered, myopic, self-centric view of the world you have. Because you didn't experience it, it doesn't exist? Because you didn't teach or treat your son that way, no one else did either? I think everyone understands (or should) that a thing like this is not global, encompassing everyone. But it does still encompass the majority of males, at least in this country. Boys are still told "don't be a baby" "you aren't hurt that bad", "quit crying" and "men don't cry".
Good or bad, I'm not judging it either way. All I'm saying is that it still exists, is still the way the majority of boys are raised. You can believe anything you want. however, it doesn't matter what you believe, it only matters what is.
This is entertaining. An acerbic post on this subject from a person who touts global inclusion. As far as your "funny" examples, you do realize that's a classic underhanded tactic to insult without appearing to, right? And I don't think anyone throughout this thread has expounded on any of the points you used. But let's examine them, shall we?
For an average heterosexual male, yes it does, especially in the teen years. And since heterosexual males are the majority, then the majority are consumed by sex. So you are closer to the truth than you realize.
See the first example. If you are a heterosexual male rife with male hormones, you NEVER want to appear homosexual. It would be difficult to attract a female that way. So it isn't so much about being "homophobic" as it is not wanting to appear to be anything other than heterosexual and being as attractive to as many females as possible.
Not just "told". Most males are immersed in it, infused with it, from every corner of their lives. So a simplistic "we were told" is deceptive and misdirection.
Women are strong. I can attest to how strong some of them are, stronger than I am in some instances. But women have little problem crying in public. Men do, for a variety of reasons. So the term "girly-man" doesn't have anything to do with how strong one is, but how they express their emotions.
As far as your assertion that the subject of men being strong and crying is incompatible, I invite you to go back and read my post and some of the others. You will find the two aren't. You will also find that most of us don't do it in front of anyone for a variety of reasons which are explained.
I find it fascinating that you and EM who both want to be accepted for who you are, refuse to allow that in this instance on this subject.
and while I'm at it I'm going to take up the subject of the "cis" gender bullshit. Why is it that those who would insist on detailing which pronouns are to be used to address them, also insist on demanding that I use "cis"? A classic double standard. I'll say this, which I say a lot over on the PB, you should give what you demand from others. If I demand to be called by a certain pronoun, I should also allow ANYONE else the same freedom.
'nuff said,
Comshaw
I was pretty with you for much of this. It is difficult to change cultural conditioning, and it is conditioning from an entire culture, not just being told things by dad 40 years ago.What a sheltered, myopic, self-centric view of the world you have. Because you didn't experience it, it doesn't exist? Because you didn't teach or treat your son that way, no one else did either? I think everyone understands (or should) that a thing like this is not global, encompassing everyone. But it does still encompass the majority of males, at least in this country. Boys are still told "don't be a baby" "you aren't hurt that bad", "quit crying" and "men don't cry".
Good or bad, I'm not judging it either way. All I'm saying is that it still exists, is still the way the majority of boys are raised. You can believe anything you want. however, it doesn't matter what you believe, it only matters what is.
This is entertaining. An acerbic post on this subject from a person who touts global inclusion. As far as your "funny" examples, you do realize that's a classic underhanded tactic to insult without appearing to, right? And I don't think anyone throughout this thread has expounded on any of the points you used. But let's examine them, shall we?
For an average heterosexual male, yes it does, especially in the teen years. And since heterosexual males are the majority, then the majority are consumed by sex. So you are closer to the truth than you realize.
See the first example. If you are a heterosexual male rife with male hormones, you NEVER want to appear homosexual. It would be difficult to attract a female that way. So it isn't so much about being "homophobic" as it is not wanting to appear to be anything other than heterosexual and being as attractive to as many females as possible.
Not just "told". Most males are immersed in it, infused with it, from every corner of their lives. So a simplistic "we were told" is deceptive and misdirection.
Women are strong. I can attest to how strong some of them are, stronger than I am in some instances. But women have little problem crying in public. Men do, for a variety of reasons. So the term "girly-man" doesn't have anything to do with how strong one is, but how they express their emotions.
As far as your assertion that the subject of men being strong and crying is incompatible, I invite you to go back and read my post and some of the others. You will find the two aren't. You will also find that most of us don't do it in front of anyone for a variety of reasons which are explained.
I find it fascinating that you and EM who both want to be accepted for who you are, refuse to allow that in this instance on this subject.
and while I'm at it I'm going to take up the subject of the "cis" gender bullshit. Why is it that those who would insist on detailing which pronouns are to be used to address them, also insist on demanding that I use "cis"? A classic double standard. I'll say this, which I say a lot over on the PB, you should give what you demand from others. If I demand to be called by a certain pronoun, I should also allow ANYONE else the same freedom.
'nuff said,
Comshaw
You've lived your own experience and who am I to judge? I'm sorry if my bullet list caused wounds but I will give your points some thought. TYWhat a sheltered, myopic, self-centric view of the world you have. Because you didn't experience it, it doesn't exist? Because you didn't teach or treat your son that way, no one else did either? I think everyone understands (or should) that a thing like this is not global, encompassing everyone. But it does still encompass the majority of males, at least in this country. Boys are still told "don't be a baby" "you aren't hurt that bad", "quit crying" and "men don't cry".
Good or bad, I'm not judging it either way. All I'm saying is that it still exists, is still the way the majority of boys are raised. You can believe anything you want. however, it doesn't matter what you believe, it only matters what is.
This is entertaining. An acerbic post on this subject from a person who touts global inclusion. As far as your "funny" examples, you do realize that's a classic underhanded tactic to insult without appearing to, right? And I don't think anyone throughout this thread has expounded on any of the points you used. But let's examine them, shall we?
For an average heterosexual male, yes it does, especially in the teen years. And since heterosexual males are the majority, then the majority are consumed by sex. So you are closer to the truth than you realize.
See the first example. If you are a heterosexual male rife with male hormones, you NEVER want to appear homosexual. It would be difficult to attract a female that way. So it isn't so much about being "homophobic" as it is not wanting to appear to be anything other than heterosexual and being as attractive to as many females as possible.
Not just "told". Most males are immersed in it, infused with it, from every corner of their lives. So a simplistic "we were told" is deceptive and misdirection.
Women are strong. I can attest to how strong some of them are, stronger than I am in some instances. But women have little problem crying in public. Men do, for a variety of reasons. So the term "girly-man" doesn't have anything to do with how strong one is, but how they express their emotions.
As far as your assertion that the subject of men being strong and crying is incompatible, I invite you to go back and read my post and some of the others. You will find the two aren't. You will also find that most of us don't do it in front of anyone for a variety of reasons which are explained.
I find it fascinating that you and EM who both want to be accepted for who you are, refuse to allow that in this instance on this subject.
and while I'm at it I'm going to take up the subject of the "cis" gender bullshit. Why is it that those who would insist on detailing which pronouns are to be used to address them, also insist on demanding that I use "cis"? A classic double standard. I'll say this, which I say a lot over on the PB, you should give what you demand from others. If I demand to be called by a certain pronoun, I should also allow ANYONE else the same freedom.
'nuff said,
Comshaw
The guy said it as an absolute - "boys are taught." If he had written, "some boys in my country are taught", I wouldn't have even responded. You've perpetuated his absolutism by slamming me calling it out as bullshit. But at least you offered the caveat. You can both have your country, but don't assume it's the world.What a sheltered, myopic, self-centric view of the world you have. Because you didn't experience it, it doesn't exist? Because you didn't teach or treat your son that way, no one else did either? I think everyone understands (or should) that a thing like this is not global, encompassing everyone. But it does still encompass the majority of males, at least in this country. Boys are still told "don't be a baby" "you aren't hurt that bad", "quit crying" and "men don't cry".
and while I'm at it I'm going to take up the subject of the "cis" gender bullshit. Why is it that those who would insist on detailing which pronouns are to be used to address them, also insist on demanding that I use "cis"? A classic double standard. I'll say this, which I say a lot over on the PB, you should give what you demand from others. If I demand to be called by a certain pronoun, I should also allow ANYONE else the same freedom.
I have to agree with you, I couldn't have written the things I'm writing now as little as 10 years ago. I think when life starts hitting me over the head with a mallet, the things I took for granted have become more importantI think as I get older rather than becoming more bitter and closed off, the things that I love I LOVE even more, so much so I find it hard to rein in.
Considering I've actually lived or spent significant time in NA, SA, Europe, Asia and Africa(military family), that is absolutely taught to males all over the world.The guy said it as an absolute - "boys are taught." If he had written, "some boys in my country are taught", I wouldn't have even responded. You've perpetuated his absolutism by slamming me calling it out as bullshit. But at least you offered the caveat. You can both have your country, but don't assume it's the world.
Appreciate the acknowledgement - I am indeed fortunate to be "ahead of the game" - we move in different circles, I guessConsidering I've actually lived or spent significant time in NA, SA, Europe, Asia and Africa(military family), that is absolutely taught to males all over the world.
I also said that society is trending away from things like that, but it's definitely going at a pace that is far too slow.
It took me a long time and an incredible therapist, for me to understand that it's OK for me to cry and allow myself to have those feelings.
I'm personally happy that you taught your son different.
Anyway, I hope you have a great weekend.
Guys can cry, some don't care about hiding how they feel. Guys can sometimes be passive or not take charge, or be aware of particular fashion details of a woman's attire. But all of the above? Not usually a guy's M.O.I often get told that I write girlie-men. Men who cry. Men who don’t immediately take charge. Men who might be a bit lost or even broken. Oh and men who notice the dress cut, fabric, coloration and fastenings of the FMCs attire. Mustn’t forget that.
I got a comment the other day saying that suppressing emotions is a major factor in men having mental health challenges. They were challenging multiple people who had said something along the lines of the above in comments. That made me think.
I get annoyed when women get treated as a homogenous whole. Just look at the female authors on AH, lots of diffeent personality types.
So I don’t want to make the same mistake about men. But, in general, is it good for guys to be in touch with their emotions?
Em

Love this. I'd reinforce what you've said by underlining that men are not a monolith any more than women. The problem with threads like this is that our anecdotes lead us into unrealistic, one-sided statements. Such topics deserves books not blogs.Guys can cry, some don't care about hiding how they feel. Guys can sometimes be passive or not take charge, or be aware of particular fashion details of a woman's attire. But all of the above? Not usually a guy's M.O.
Crying is usually a sign of vulnerability and weakness for a guy to do. Not saying it's right or wrong that it's that way, it's just how it is.
Most guys, even the emotional ones, go between two modes, normal mode where we're just going with it, and "solve shit" mode, where we're trying to solve something or deal with it and set aside whatever emotional distress or feelings we're going through to solve or handle something. Suppressing emotion is a skill a lot of us guys rely on, and emotional support isn't something we usually count on. A good amount of us don't even have it, period. It's part of the reason why a lot of us are just terrible listeners.
And when it comes to problems, most of us tend to be problem-solvers first, and emotion-focused second. Learning how to handle and just move on from things like rejection, failure, and dwelling on hardship is usually just a part of our lives and our learning experience, especially with failure and rejection. While different guys have different ways of dealing with it, getting emotional and showing vulnerability isn't normally a guy's go-to for handling it. Getting emotional and expressing vulnerability over something beating us down usually worked out of us even if some of us are otherwise emotional naturally.
Taking conflict, distress, and failure by the chin and just walking through it is usually a skill most guys learn if they aren't that way already. Stoicism is often preferred. Not to say all guys are this way a lot of the time, but a lot of us employ this to make life easier for us. Being emotional and vulnerable isn't something that men are rewarded for usually. Mockery, pity, or just creating awkwardness is not uncommon for a guy who does break down and cry especially in public or even if with friends or a girlfriend. Oftentimes it's just not worth it for us even if we're emotionally in a bad place and feel unsure of where to go next. And crying usually leaves us feeling more awkward or weak, and most guys don't like feeling weak, timid, and helpless. If we can't deal with it, we try to move on.
Same thing with being passive or indecisive. This one, most guys just feel more comfortable more often than not to take charge or some kind of initiative of a situation. Most of us feel way more comfortable being competent or assertive rather than passive or indecisive. Staying passive is awkward for us usually. Passive men that just cry without a care in the world the moment things get hard and are comfortable and happy not feeling strong and masculine might exist, but it's not common.