Native Americans

Ishmael said:


Pretty much crap. Thanksgiving has nothing to do with theft.

True, we have Columbus Day to celebrate the theft.

Notice, I didn't smile.
 
Starblayde said:


Biggest killer in the Crimean War was disease... doesn't stop it being a war. But i do see your point. Mine was mostly there for semi-comedic value



Ha ha? Very 'semi-comedic value'. Did you hear the one about the Jew at Dachau?



Before everyone gets all misty eyed at the plight of the 'Native' Americans. Read your history.
 
A little suggestion here... If you get a chance to visit a reservation and if the reservation has a welcome center or something along those lines go. One of the most enlightening moments of my child hood was visiting the Cherokee Reservation in North Carolina located about 30 minutes from the Tennessee border. I learned a lot from those visits and plan on visiting again if I ever get a chance.
 
reason why there are so few natives left....

I'm only part native Canadian (yes I didn't say american cause my great great grandmother was born in canada :p)

that's why, the population is slowy breading out into other cultures. but there is still a tribe in my city. as is an anchiant burial grown over at the river.
 
markb,

I have spent much of my time on western N.C. reservations. And while I enjoy our Pow Wows, ritual dances, and celebrations- spending time with my Elders, on any regular day continues to bring me enlightenment.
I don't live on a reservation but my spirit does. I am thankful that I've been able to keep ahold of my people.
Please visit again. Maybe you will see me there. :)
 
Starblayde said:
And the Americans celebrate genocide and theft of tribal homelands every year by calling it thanksgiving

And i thought Britain was bad.... :D
I suppose it might appear so to one who does not know the "modern" history of the North American continent, but the original celebration was unified, and predates the admittedly genocidal policies of the government which ultimately formed in the USA. The celebration was of the optimism the colonists had regarding surviving the winter on the heels of a bountiful harvest, based significantly on having learned things from the native population.

None of which is meant to derail the observation the thread started with about how utterly the early white folks here decimated the people they encountered. It's a tragic, ill-informed era in modern history, but the celebration of Thanksgiving should not be construed to be a result of something it pre-dates.
 
Hawthorne said:
If you consider Australian only has 17 million people and America has, christ, how many people are there in America? Shitloads. The ratio of indigenous to migrant natives is still pretty shocking.
The US has about 270-280 million people IIRC, so that would make the percentage of aboriginals at about 0.7% vs. almost 3% for Australia. But that is not a fair comparison as it only tells you how far the non-aborignal population has grown, not how much the aboriginal population has decreased. For that, you would have to look at how many were here in the first place, and how many are here now, and you would have to do the same for Australia.
 
Confused over this one

Part of the thread says that the native american population was reduced mainly through disease , intermarriages with other cultures etc - a natural reduction

A few are saying that there was some sort of ethnic cleansing where indiginious natives were wiped out by the original settlers and there offspring.

Is it a mixture of the two or what. ? What is the generaly accepted viewpoint.
 
A combination of many things, Gord.
Also, there's the sad fact that many, like my Grandfather, that left the reservation and attempted to pass as another race.

I'm bothered by people presented as numbers and facts. I understand the points and need for clarification. I admit that I am overly sensitive when it comes to this subject.
 
Re: Confused over this one

Gord said:
Part of the thread says that the native american population was reduced mainly through disease , intermarriages with other cultures etc - a natural reduction

A few are saying that there was some sort of ethnic cleansing where indiginious natives were wiped out by the original settlers and there offspring.

Is it a mixture of the two or what. ? What is the generaly accepted viewpoint.

There's not much natural about supplying blankets knowingly infested with smallpox, or forced pregnancy from rape.

Some Native American tribes were warlike and had no respect for boundaries. This led the US Gov't to the belief that all Native Americans should be conquered.

The Indian Wars reached their peak just after the US Civil War, so it was quite some time after the original settlers arrived.
 
Re: Confused over this one

Gord said:
Is it a mixture of the two or what. ? What is the generaly accepted viewpoint.
It is a mixture, and it is hard to sort out how much of it was genocide because there were "wars", but there were documented cases of slaughters of innocents, and of forced marches where innocents died from hunger, exhaustion and disease (Trail of Tears, 1838-1839, exposure and disease killed 4000 Cherokees on a forced march to Oklahoma). The numbers were relatively small though when compared to other causes of death (hunger and disease outside of wars and marches). Some documented cases:

Puritans killed 500-600 Pequi Indians at Mystic Fort in 1637
The French killed about 1000 Nanchez Indians.

The Sand Creek massacre (1864) involved somewhere between 70 and 600 Indians (two-thirds of them women and children) - 130 being the most likely number according to historians. This was indeed a massacre as the Indians were trying to surrender, but they were killed, scalped and mutilated. There was a scandal about this, but no one was punished beyond the Colonel Chivington resigning his commission.

Bear River massacre 1863, 250 Shoshoni killed - began as a battle, but degnerated into a massacre.
Washita 1868, 103 Cheyennes killed.
Piegan Village 1870, 173 Indians killed.
Wounded Knee 1890 146 Sioux killed.

These were some of the largest known and documented massacres, but historians agree that there were numerous other small ones not documented. According to my documentation ("Death by Government"), between 1789 and 1898, in army-Indian battles and massacres probably no more than 3000 Indians were killed, and civilians probably killed nor more than 1000, and it is thought that the numbers were actually quite a bit less.

Many Indians died from mistreatment and conditions on reservations (in the 20th century many have died from alcoholism). The California Yuki Indians originally had a population of around 3500, but in 30 years their numbers decreased to 400 through "kidnapping, epidemics, starvation, vigilante justice, and state sacntioned mass killing".

Overall, estimation is that by 1900, it is estimated that between 10,000 and 25,000 Indians were killed by the above causes.

Original population of Indians ranges anywhere from 8 million to 110 million, with numbers as high as 145 million being quoted. I really doubt the higher numbers, and the book I mentioned states a "moderate" estimate as about 55 million. The reason given for the decrease in numbers from 55 million to the current 2 million was disease inadvertantly brought to the US by Europeans. In Mexico the population dropped from 23 million to under 2 million, in Central and S. America 60 to 80 million Indians died from similar causes (no numbers for original population, but the ratio is probably about the same).

The book gives some facts for Australia:

Tasmania, 1832, 700 of an original population of 1000 killed.
The population in 1788 was estimated at 300,000, and it was further estimated that during the 18th and 19th centuries 20,00 were killed.
 
Re: Re: Confused over this one

phrodeau said:


There's not much natural about supplying blankets knowingly infested with smallpox,
As I recall, this was a tactic of the British (General Amherst) in the 1760s, not the US government.
 
raindancer said:
markb,

I have spent much of my time on western N.C. reservations. And while I enjoy our Pow Wows, ritual dances, and celebrations- spending time with my Elders, on any regular day continues to bring me enlightenment.
I don't live on a reservation but my spirit does. I am thankful that I've been able to keep ahold of my people.
Please visit again. Maybe you will see me there. :)

raindancer,

I hope to visit again one of these days. The last time I was there was well over 13 years ago. Of course it was easier at the time since I lived in TN. I have a lot of trips planned for the future and that is one of them.
 
Still... doesn't any one find it a little disturbing that the only Native American/American Indian at Literotica is Raindancer? (Or so it seems)
 
Hawthorne said:
Still... doesn't any one find it a little disturbing that the only Native American/American Indian at Literotica is Raindancer? (Or so it seems)

Well, given that LIT has 2 to 300 registered users at any point during the evening, 1 person is about right.


I have native ancestery about 240 years back. Basically, the longer an ethnic group has been in the United States, the less ethnically pure they are. The Amish have done well with their ethnic purity, & not so well with their birth defects.

I think you are more likely to find ethnic purity in closed communities, but ones on the WWW aren't so closed anymore, are they?
 
I'm part American Indian, not a lot but a sliver.

I think almost everybody in the United States has an Indian in their family tree somewhere.

Most probably don't know it.
 
Purple Haze said:
I think almost everybody in the United States has an Indian in their family tree somewhere.

Most probably don't know it.
I seriously doubt this. You aren't taking into account the millions of people who immigrated into this country and married with those who also immigrated, not only from Europe, but from Asia and all the other continents, most of whom arrived since the latter part of the 1800's. There wasn't all that much intermingling between the native population and whites before then.

Besides, back in the 70's it was the "in" thing to claim that one's great-great (-great...depending on how much blood they wanted to claim) grandmother was a "Cherokee (<insert most attractive tribe here>) princess"...bunch of bullshit "claiming to belong" kneejerk crap that was in response to everything happening in this country during the Vietnam War and the people's reaction to the actions by the U.S. government.
 
I used to live in Tahlequah, Oklahoma. That's the capital of the Cherokee nation. My brother and mother were born there. I still don't know shit about my heritage. I'm hoping that will change though... My dad always gets on me because I'm more white than I am native american, and I don't really claim my white side. I have a permanant tan, what can I say? We have an old cowtown here, and they want me to play an indian captive. I was wondering why I can't massacre the cowboys instead of going quietly. *L* Have you noticed that the "indians" in movies are getting whiter and whiter? Either that, or they're puerto ricans or something. It's sad what's happening. I remember I used to be really pissed at my mom for marrying a white man, but then I wouldn't exist, huh?
 
hubby was Native America (Delaware and Osage) mixed with Irish. From Oklahoma. What a temper!! I had no idea Indians could be that way, or is that the Irish? :confused:
 
dre wrote: I used to live in Tahlequah, Oklahoma

Hubby was from Nowata. :) He left and never wanted to go back, not even for a visit.:( Felt white men (like me) had no place at a real pow wow so we never went to any here in CA. So I got no piece of Indian culture even being married to one.
 
Hey, maybe you coulda painted yourself red. They used to do that in the old movies, paint white men red to play the indian parts. Hehehe, why not? You missed out on a lot when it comes to the pow wows. I remember when I was little, they were so loud, they made me cry and I had to leave. Very colorful and graceful.
 
LOL red is not my best colour. I envied his tan every summer though. I was lucky if I made a dent on my wrist watched wrist, while he was a toasty brown. And yes I always wanted to see a Pow Wow but nooooooooooooooo! He took me to baseball games though. How American! :rolleyes:
 
Yeah, the tan definately has to be the best part. I always make my friends jealous. They're so... white. *L* Man, I love native american men. Have you ever seen the dudes off Squanto or Crazy Horse? Yowww. I got a thing about long hair though, it bugs me when they wear it short.
 
Not sure what guys you mean, dre. Mine kept his hair short. In fact, hair cuts were his obsession. (no reference to scalping) ;-)He even liked my hair short. He did have that beer gut look I notice on some tribesmen. But at least he was tall (6'2"). Why do the Indians on the bodice rippers show these not so dark, lean hotties, rather than the actual look of the Indians of the 1880s? So white looking, you know?
 
Back
Top