NC passes Admendment 1

Show me what "rights" are being violated.
"...certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

In every state Mark and Ann have the liberty to marry each other and pursue happiness together.
In some states Bob and Bill and Mary and Sue are actively prohibited from doing that.
In those states Bob, Bill, Mary and Sue have had supposedly unalienable rights taken away from them.

If you want to say that there is a right to be married, then how do you enforce that for every single person who shows us and says where's my rightful mate.
And the purpose of this red herring is....?

If the majority of Americans are all in favor of this why have the initiatives that have gone before the voter all supported the notion that marriage is between a man and a woman been passed by 60%+ margins?
Seems you really need to work on your math (or reading) skills.
 
Last edited:
:confused::confused: You mean medicare? Yea, I'm forced to buy medicare during my working life, then get forced into government run healthcare when I hit 65. It's terrible. :rolleyes:

Why do married people get to own property as Tenants by the Entirety? That's really not fair. How come they get to file tax returns as a group instead of as individuals?

Married people suck.

With the filing of a few simple legal forms at the county court any number of people can join to own property jointly or file taxes in the same manner. Although with the current tax code why anyone would want to file under the 'married' status is beyond me.

Ishmael
 
:confused::confused: You mean medicare? Yea, I'm forced to buy medicare during my working life, then get forced into government run healthcare when I hit 65. It's terrible. :rolleyes:

Why do married people get to own property as Tenants by the Entirety? That's really not fair. How come they get to file tax returns as a group instead of as individuals?

Married people suck.

But, if those are the complaints, then the homosexuals problem is not with the rite of marriage, but with the tax code.

Now, why should they attack the customs of a larger society merely because they have a tax problem?

The rest of the problem is simply a matter of drawing up the right legal documents.

Wait until they force you to lose those love handles in order to reduce the cost of mandatory health insurance.

They're coming for the Communists and the Catholics, but why would you care? you're a Proddy Socialist...

;) ;)
 
With the filing of a few simple legal forms at the county court any number of people can join to own property jointly or file taxes in the same manner. Although with the current tax code why anyone would want to file under the 'married' status is beyond me.

Ishmael

Maybe you don't understand basic property law, and that's ok. Tenants by the Entirety is a form of ownership where each owner owns 100% of the property. So when one owner dies, there is no effect on the other owner as the other owner already owned '100%' of the property.

That form of ownership is reserved, by law and definition, to married people.

There are lots of advantages to file as married rather than each file individually. But even if there weren't, the point is the government should treat everyone as an individual. If the government chooses to bestow different treatment upon one group, then can't then refuse to treat all groups the same way.
 
"...certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

In every state Mark and Ann have the liberty to marry each other and pursue happiness together.
In some states Bob and Bill and Mary and Sue are actively prohibited from doing that.
In those states Bob, Bill, Mary and Sue have had supposedly unalienable rights taken away from them.

Really? Do you understand the unalienable right?

First of all, if you understand Constitutional history, then you know that "pursuit of happiness" is a euphemism. The right it refers to is property, but if they said that, the North knew they could never end slavery.

Denying a rite to anyone is not a government-sponsored theft of Life, Liberty or Property.

(But forcing them to buy health insurance IS!!!!! :mad: )

Progressive tax codes designed to favor groups, such as married couples, may actually do that which is why I am a huge proponent of the FairTax.org.
 
But, if those are the complaints, then the homosexuals problem is not with the rite of marriage, but with the tax code.

Now, why should they attack the customs of a larger society merely because they have a tax problem?

The rest of the problem is simply a matter of drawing up the right legal documents.

Wait until they force you to lose those love handles in order to reduce the cost of mandatory health insurance.

They're coming for the Communists and the Catholics, but why would you care? you're a Proddy Socialist...

;) ;)

What you are saying, essentially, is that the black folk have their own swimming pools and don't need to use 'ours'

Do you see the correlation there?

Separate but equal!

;):eek::)
 
Maybe you don't understand basic property law, and that's ok. Tenants by the Entirety is a form of ownership where each owner owns 100% of the property. So when one owner dies, there is no effect on the other owner as the other owner already owned '100%' of the property.

That form of ownership is reserved, by law and definition, to married people.

There are lots of advantages to file as married rather than each file individually. But even if there weren't, the point is the government should treat everyone as an individual. If the government chooses to bestow different treatment upon one group, then can't then refuse to treat all groups the same way.

That still is not a violation of their right to property.

They just need a better will.

Then they need to get outraged over the TAX CODE!
 
That still is not a violation of their right to property.

They just need a better will.

Then they need to get outraged over the TAX CODE!

You are looking at the trees, which are blocking your view of the Forrest, 4est.

haha! I slay me.

Why can't the government just treat everyone the same? Is that such a radical idea?
 
What you are saying, essentially, is that the black folk have their own swimming pools and don't need to use 'ours'

Do you see the correlation there?

Separate but equal!

;):eek::)

Then you are making the case that Johnny can join the Girl Scouts.

Tell me, again, like I asked the other person, where does a lonely single guy apply to to be issued his "rightful" wife?

A right means you cannot be denied it.

You have to be given all your civil rights even if you don't ask for them...

Ask the cop reading you Miranda even if you're an anarchist trying to blow up a bridge.
 
Maybe you don't understand basic property law, and that's ok. Tenants by the Entirety is a form of ownership where each owner owns 100% of the property. So when one owner dies, there is no effect on the other owner as the other owner already owned '100%' of the property.

That form of ownership is reserved, by law and definition, to married people.

There are lots of advantages to file as married rather than each file individually. But even if there weren't, the point is the government should treat everyone as an individual. If the government chooses to bestow different treatment upon one group, then can't then refuse to treat all groups the same way.

Maybe I understand a lot more than you think. The filing of a Quit Claim with as many owners as you want with 'survivors rights' achieves exactly the same purpose. No will or probate required. I've used that twice to good effect already.

Ishmael
 
You are looking at the trees, which are blocking your view of the Forrest, 4est.

haha! I slay me.

Why can't the government just treat everyone the same? Is that such a radical idea?

It's a great idea.

Do we apologize to the Mormons and say, hey, we're now going to treat you the same and do we tell the rich person, hey, we're eliminating the progressive tax, do we tell everyone, hey! come get your food stamps, do we tell the insane, yeah, go ahead and get married, even if it's your sister, I mean, after all if she's your pursuit of happiness, we're going to treat you the same, and yes Mr. rich guy, you can marry your daughter to avoid the inheritance tax...

;) ;)

Let's put the blindfold back on government and go to some magic theoretical place that's never existed (recognize your own argument against Libertarianism?) and all pretend that everyone is going to be completely equal before the law.
 
The Amendment was/is irrelevant.
Not entirely, as it now prohibits heterosexual civil unions.

For those in denial about homosexuals in NC having rights taken away, either by the current law or the amendment, here's another tidbit:

North Carolina Marriage Laws and Common Law Marriages

Common law marriages or marriages by consent that arise in our state are not recognized by North Carolina marriage law as valid legal marriages. There is one instance where North Carolina will recognize a common law marriage: if a couple entered into a common law marriage in another state which does recognize common law marriages, and if that couple latter moves to North Carolina, our state will recognize their common law marriage as a valid legal marriage.

North Carolina Marriage Laws and Same-Sex Marriage

North Carolina marriage laws do not recognize the marriage between individuals of the same gender as valid or legal. It does not matter if the individuals entered into their same-sex marriage in another state that recognizes same-sex marriages and later move to North Carolina.
http://www.montylaw.com/north-carolina-family-laws/marriage-laws.aspx

I wonder if members of the military can refuse a transfer to NC (without detriment to their record) if it will result in the nullification of their marriage.
 
I will never understand people who work to stand in the way of same sex marriage. Their union has no impact on me whatsoever, so why would I stick my nose in and demand they not be allowed to marry?
 
Then you are making the case that Johnny can join the Girl Scouts.

Tell me, again, like I asked the other person, where does a lonely single guy apply to to be issued his "rightful" wife?

A right means you cannot be denied it.

You have to be given all your civil rights even if you don't ask for them...

Ask the cop reading you Miranda even if you're an anarchist trying to blow up a bridge.

The government isn't controlling membership in the Girl Scouts.

Your argument about the lonely guy was a straw man. Nobody said you have a right to marry, the argument is that if the government is involved in marriage, then it has to treat all participants equally.

A right means you cannot be denied it? Really? Ok... I deny you your right to walk down my street. What are you going to do about it? Rights are denied all the time, so I'm really not sure where you are going with this point.

Or the next one... Civil rights were demanded and paid for by blood. Ancient history though, right? The government would never, ever deny someone their civil rights. It's a benevolent governmental, ours is.

You lost me on the last point as well. Is the cop the judge, jury and executioner in your hypo that the accused need not worry about his rights? The thing has been decided, comrade, off to the gulag with you!
 
It's a great idea.

Do we apologize to the Mormons and say, hey, we're now going to treat you the same and do we tell the rich person, hey, we're eliminating the progressive tax, do we tell everyone, hey! come get your food stamps, do we tell the insane, yeah, go ahead and get married, even if it's your sister, I mean, after all if she's your pursuit of happiness, we're going to treat you the same, and yes Mr. rich guy, you can marry your daughter to avoid the inheritance tax...

;) ;)

Let's put the blindfold back on government and go to some magic theoretical place that's never existed (recognize your own argument against Libertarianism?) and all pretend that everyone is going to be completely equal before the law.

With respect to your first paragraph - who is this "we" you are talking about? I don't want big brother/big government dictating how I live my life. If I'm not hurting you, leave me alone. Seen that show, "Sister Wives"? That guy is 'married' to several women, but not married in the legal sense. I think it's pretty stupid (one women is one too many), but it's his life not mine. What consenting adults do is not of my business, and it's certainly none of the government's business.

Lady Justice is wearing a blindfold ;)

I AM a libertarian! lol That's the funniest thing, you saying I'm arguing against libertarianism. Of course even someone like you who wants the government dictating how people live their lives can call themselves a libertarian. Like how the big spenders can call themselves conservatives.

A rose by any other name...
 
A right means you cannot be denied it.

You have to be given all your civil rights even if you don't ask for them...

Ask the cop reading you Miranda even if you're an anarchist trying to blow up a bridge.
People are denied civil rights all the time.
 
I will never understand people who work to stand in the way of same sex marriage. Their union has no impact on me whatsoever, so why would I stick my nose in and demand they not be allowed to marry?

It's the word 'marriage' that's the sticking point, and will continue to be so for years to come. Where there once existed the possibility of 'domestic partnerships' or some other legal form that conferred the same legal status on same sex unions that possibility was squandered by the militant gay community who have insisted that it be called 'marriage.' This more or less proved that the issue was not equality of access to certain legal benefits but an 'in your face' move. And that in turn has provoked a backlash by those that just don't feel like being the Mae Clark to James Cagney.

I, like you, don't have a dog in the fight. To me this is nothing more than an exercise in politics. But I fully understand the feelings of those that believe that the word 'marriage' has a specific gender relationship meaning and I feel free to express my frustration, for lack of a better word, at the single minded lunacy of the militant gay community in their picking a fight over a word when they could have had all they wanted by an alternative route.

Ishmael
 
I will never understand people who work to stand in the way of same sex marriage. Their union has no impact on me whatsoever, so why would I stick my nose in and demand they not be allowed to marry?
People who aren't scared of "them" wouldn't, that's probably why you don't.
 
It's the word 'marriage' that's the sticking point, and will continue to be so for years to come. Where there once existed the possibility of 'domestic partnerships' or some other legal form that conferred the same legal status on same sex unions that possibility was squandered by the militant gay community who have insisted that it be called 'marriage.' This more or less proved that the issue was not equality of access to certain legal benefits but an 'in your face' move. And that in turn has provoked a backlash by those that just don't feel like being the Mae Clark to James Cagney.

I, like you, don't have a dog in the fight. To me this is nothing more than an exercise in politics. But I fully understand the feelings of those that believe that the word 'marriage' has a specific gender relationship meaning and I feel free to express my frustration, for lack of a better word, at the single minded lunacy of the militant gay community in their picking a fight over a word when they could have had all they wanted by an alternative route.

Ishmael
Interesting. I had a conversation along the same lines with a gay friend. He also agreed that militant activism has damaged this cause. Had they moved to civil unions first and then on to marriage later the issue and the fight may have been completely different.
 
Love it.

Homosexuals shouldn't be allowed to marry because if they just know how to work the system they can figure out how to get all the same benefits of a marriage anyway:rolleyes:
 
Johnny.



Make the Libertarian case for me for marriage being a right.

If you can do that, then I will acquiesce happily to equal protection.

;) ;)
 
Interesting. I had a conversation along the same lines with a gay friend. He also agreed that militant activism has damaged this cause. Had they moved to civil unions first and then on to marriage later the issue and the fight may have been completely different.

Precisely. I had a debate with Rhys (Rhys was actually bi with strong same sex leanings. He was also extraordinarily bright and literate, unlike many that post on the subject.) years ago. The debate covered several pages here on the GB. Rhys was militant in his support of 'gay rights' but honest enough to concede that all of my points were valid and that it was ALL about the word 'marriage.' In that respect he at least exhibited and intellectual honesty that is, for the most part, singularly lacking in these discussions.

Ishmael
 
Johnny.



Make the Libertarian case for me for marriage being a right.

If you can do that, then I will acquiesce happily to equal protection.

;) ;)

ITS NOT A RIGHT!

It's a designation conferred by the government that carries certain benefits not available to all citizens. You are looking at this exactly backwards.

The government doesn't have to recognize ANY marriage (and shouldn't), but when they do, they can't discriminate as to who is eligible for the deal. Either everyone is allowed to marry and share in the government boondoggle, or nobody is.

The Libertarian case on the issue is that who marries who is a religious issue not a governmental one and the government should mind it's own business.
 
ITS NOT A RIGHT!

It's a designation conferred by the government that carries certain benefits not available to all citizens. You are looking at this exactly backwards.

The government doesn't have to recognize ANY marriage (and shouldn't), but when they do, they can't discriminate as to who is eligible for the deal. Either everyone is allowed to marry and share in the government boondoggle, or nobody is.

The Libertarian case on the issue is that who marries who is a religious issue not a governmental one and the government should mind it's own business.

Then you cannot apply equal rights under the law.

Social laws discriminate, that's why they are written.

The government should mind its own business. The homosexual community should not try to redefine that which they do not like.

But at least we agree, they have no right to marriage.

When the government gets powerful enough to fight over, the people will fight over it, and to the victors go the spoils, thus setting up the next fight.
A_J, the Stupid
 
Precisely. I had a debate with Rhys (Rhys was actually bi with strong same sex leanings. He was also extraordinarily bright and literate, unlike many that post on the subject.) years ago. The debate covered several pages here on the GB. Rhys was militant in his support of 'gay rights' but honest enough to concede that all of my points were valid and that it was ALL about the word 'marriage.' In that respect he at least exhibited and intellectual honesty that is, for the most part, singularly lacking in these discussions.

Ishmael

You should go over to the education thread and see Radatits "understanding" of economics.



;) ;)
 
Back
Top