mercury14
Pragmatic Metaphysician
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2009
- Posts
- 22,158
Very good Johnny, you're almost there.
First of all I agree with you that the government doesn't have any business being in the marriage business. But they are so that's the fact that has to be dealt with.
Now, it's called a 'marriage license.' When we bother to look up the word 'License' we find that it's a permission granted and like all licenses the granting of that license is conditional upon the meeting of certain qualifications. The implication being that the government can set any conditions that it chooses even if those conditions may seem arbitrary to certain individuals or groups.
If there is no bar to the sex of the individuals that apply for a marriage license then how can there be a bar to polygamy, polyandry, marriage to close relatives? Applying the very arguments you've presented so far no such bars can exist.
Ishmael
Your argument doesn't make sense though. People are gay that can't be changed and it's part of their being. People who want to marry two people or their mom aren't doing so because that's how their human existence works, they're doing so because of behavior or making a choice. These are two totally different things here.
That being said, I find your idea interesting... where the government recognizes a civil contract between two people regardless of who they are and then the term 'marriage' is granted by some other body such as a church, minister, or a nonreligious person qualified to do that sort of thing.

