NC passes Admendment 1

Very good Johnny, you're almost there.

First of all I agree with you that the government doesn't have any business being in the marriage business. But they are so that's the fact that has to be dealt with.

Now, it's called a 'marriage license.' When we bother to look up the word 'License' we find that it's a permission granted and like all licenses the granting of that license is conditional upon the meeting of certain qualifications. The implication being that the government can set any conditions that it chooses even if those conditions may seem arbitrary to certain individuals or groups.

If there is no bar to the sex of the individuals that apply for a marriage license then how can there be a bar to polygamy, polyandry, marriage to close relatives? Applying the very arguments you've presented so far no such bars can exist.

Ishmael


Your argument doesn't make sense though. People are gay that can't be changed and it's part of their being. People who want to marry two people or their mom aren't doing so because that's how their human existence works, they're doing so because of behavior or making a choice. These are two totally different things here.

That being said, I find your idea interesting... where the government recognizes a civil contract between two people regardless of who they are and then the term 'marriage' is granted by some other body such as a church, minister, or a nonreligious person qualified to do that sort of thing.
 
A right means you cannot be denied it.
Really? I'm quite certain there are at least 2.3 million people in the US who would beg to differ. But at least they were denied their rights by (mostly) due process, rather than a minority of people deciding that a specific group should be denied the right to marry.

In NY, Same Sex marriage is legal. And guess what, the world's not ended! And...my marriage of 26+ years hasn't been effected AT ALL!!!
Imagine that! LOL
But just think of off the heterosexuals suffering mental anguish because of it. Don't you feel sympathy for them?
 
Last edited:
Really? I'm quite certain there are at least 2.3 million people in the US who would beg to differ. But at least they were denied their rights by (mostly) due process.

Imagine that! LOL
But just think of off the heterosexuals suffering mental anguish because of it. Don't you feel sympathy for them?[/QUOTE]

Yes, those Right Wing, narrow-minded Conservatives who want government OUT of people's lives, but want it in their bedrooms and vaginas.
 
Then you cannot apply equal rights under the law.

Social laws discriminate, that's why they are written.

The government should mind its own business. The homosexual community should not try to redefine that which they do not like.

But at least we agree, they have no right to marriage.

When the government gets powerful enough to fight over, the people will fight over it, and to the victors go the spoils, thus setting up the next fight.
A_J, the Stupid


AJ the fake libertarian stands up for big government that opposes its own people's freedom. And he wonders how we all know he's just a boring old Republican. :rolleyes:
 
The vote was the vote of the people, by the people, and ostensibly for the people...that is the most people. Apparently the people there have determined that family values are best promoted and maintained by real families. The left however cannot accept the democratic process when it goes against them so expect them to appeal to an activist judge.

SO what constitutes a "real" family? A mother and a father? So do families in which the biologicals are divorced aren't a family! I get it, you're one of THOSE people
 
The vote was the vote of the people, by the people, and ostensibly for the people...that is the most people. Apparently the people there have determined that family values are best promoted and maintained by real families. The left however cannot accept the democratic process when it goes against them so expect them to appeal to an activist judge.

"We should not be putting civil rights issues to a vote, to be the subject of the sentiments and passions of the day. No minority should have their rights subject to the will of the majority"

-Newark Mayor Cory Booker

He said it better then I could
 
I have five words for what sanctity of heterosexual marriage means:

Donald Trump AND Newt Gingrich
 
In practice, there are very few people who will tell you "I'm OK with civil unions and gay couples having the rights of married couples--just please don't call it 'marriage.'" Generally speaking, people voting to ban gay marriage do not believe in any sort of official recognition of same-sex relationships.

Exactly, and when questioned as to their reasoning, few of them answer with anything but circular logic.
 
I have five words for what sanctity of heterosexual marriage means:

Donald Trump AND Newt Gingrich

Being old, white, male and rich means never having to say you're sorry for being straight but unable to hold down your first (and second and third) marriage under the laws of God. :D
 
"We should not be putting civil rights issues to a vote, to be the subject of the sentiments and passions of the day. No minority should have their rights subject to the will of the majority"

-Newark Mayor Cory Booker

He said it better then I could

Especially at a primary election where republicans are fighting for two vulnerable seats.

I guess this bill was so critical to the safety of the Family in North Carolina that it couldn't wait until the November general election and face the state's full electorate.
 
The vote was the vote of the people, by the people, and ostensibly for the people...that is the most people. Apparently the people there have determined that family values are best promoted and maintained by real families. The left however cannot accept the democratic process when it goes against them so expect them to appeal to an activist judge.

Like in California?

Then, if the state supreme court validates the amendment the Left can judge shop it forever.
 
I wonder what Obama's answer to that question might be.

Is it still "evolving" or do we have to elect him to give him more "flexibility?"

So far, it seems, he's sending other people out to take his arrows for him on the campaign now known as the "Trail of Tears."

Find out what the good Rev. Wrights answer to that is and we may be more than halfway home.

Ishmael

He'll tell Holder to file suit.

How stupid do you jerk offs feel now? Oh right, you cant possibly feel more stupid.
 
...he said that he cannot be reelected by a majority of Americans if he comes out in full support of homosexual marriage before November 6.

But, he crosses his heart and hopes to die, if you stay-hard supporters of gay marriage retain him for #2, he'll come out of his politically correct closet on November 7.

Till then...

...please don't ask him so he doesn't have to tell everybody this truth.

You must be feeling extra stupid, huh?
 
And I'm sure you were shocked that a politician doesn't want to alienate voters during an election season:rolleyes:

Well, it looks like the Statist-in-Chief was told he may very well end-up losing a bunch of folks who voted for him last time if he doesn't sh!t or get off the pot now concerning homosexual marriage...

...so Obama chooses ABC exclusively today to spew that, indeed, he supports homosexual marriage.

Now, til November, it'll be all about building the story how he's always supported homosexual marriage "personally".

Obama Supports Same-Sex Marriage

WASHINGTON—President Barack Obama said Wednesday he supports gay marriage, reversing his position on a controversial social issue just six months before the November election and adopting a stance fraught with political implications.

- read all about it @

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304070304577394332545729926.html

So...

...that now establishes Obama as personally endorsing homosexual marriage ( reversing his 2008 campaign stance, btw), while Milt the Wilt Romney has reiterated today his continued, personal opposition to homosexual marriage.

Ron Paul, naturally, stays on the Constitutional path and avers that homosexual marriage - like all power not enumerated to the federal government - is an issue for each state to decide, regardless of any President's "personal" feelings.
 
It's the word 'marriage' that's the sticking point, and will continue to be so for years to come. Where there once existed the possibility of 'domestic partnerships' or some other legal form that conferred the same legal status on same sex unions that possibility was squandered by the militant gay community who have insisted that it be called 'marriage.' This more or less proved that the issue was not equality of access to certain legal benefits but an 'in your face' move. And that in turn has provoked a backlash by those that just don't feel like being the Mae Clark to James Cagney.

I, like you, don't have a dog in the fight. To me this is nothing more than an exercise in politics. But I fully understand the feelings of those that believe that the word 'marriage' has a specific gender relationship meaning and I feel free to express my frustration, for lack of a better word, at the single minded lunacy of the militant gay community in their picking a fight over a word when they could have had all they wanted by an alternative route.

Ishmael

The problem is that the same legal status was not conferred. A "domestic partnership" was a second class marriage.
 
...that now establishes Obama as personally endorsing homosexual marriage ( reversing his 2008 campaign stance, btw), while Milt the Wilt Romney has reiterated today his continued, personal opposition to homosexual marriage.

I used to be against gay marriage too. People's views evolve.
 
You must be feeling extra stupid, huh?

Hardly, sugarbritches...

...it's called a flip-flop.

The Pro was literally right in the middle of one as I posted his documented position on the issue this morning...

...with his 2nd term in the balance, it's hardly surprising that his advisers are assuring him he cannot afford to lose any more votes that went his way in 2008.

His boy Biden floated the homosexual marriage balloon just days ago...

...I would've been more surprised had he stuck with his pathetic fence-sitting position, because it's never made any sense to me, and I have never understood how his base can tolerate his politically correct squat on the matter (again: up to this morning, that is, literally when I was posting).

What this does, of course, is make this Presidential election a national referendum on homosexual marriage...

...the folks in NC voiced their views yesterday; we'll see how pertinent it actually is to American voters in November.

Personally...

...I don't care if Maggie marries Beth or Bill marries Mike; heck, I don't even care if Maggie, Beth, Bill, and Mike invite Mr. Ed into their union. I also don't care if Mark marries Sue, or Sally weds Mac and then makes him use her maiden name like a good little cuckold.

I can joyfully live the rest of my life without knowing anything about who you marry, or without telling you anything about my personal life. If the folks of one state decide homosexual marriage is cool with them, I still don't care. If another state decides homosexual marriage isn't cool with them, guess what? Yep - I still don't care.

I'm now far past what other folks and especially folks in any government think of any of my personal business. If folks truly wanted to be independent from the natural prying noses, fast fingers, and ruling hands of others and especially government, they have the free option of choosing not to play that statist game...

...but the great majority of folks just as naturally possess the insecure, dire need to have their personal issues acknowledged and accepted by the rest of the collective. Government loves those sheep because statists in both Parties realize that while this election the candidate who favors homosexual marriage might lose and next election the candidate who wants to outlaw abortion might win, it really doesn't matter.

...because the only thing that matters is that sheep continue to choose to play the game government rules.

It's the game, stupid.
 
Last edited:
Really? Do you understand the unalienable right?

First of all, if you understand Constitutional history, then you know that "pursuit of happiness" is a euphemism. The right it refers to is property, but if they said that, the North knew they could never end slavery.

Denying a rite to anyone is not a government-sponsored theft of Life, Liberty or Property.

(But forcing them to buy health insurance IS!!!!! :mad: )

Progressive tax codes designed to favor groups, such as married couples, may actually do that which is why I am a huge proponent of the FairTax.org.

"Pursuit of happiness" is a euphamism?

Good ole "living document" AJ to the rescue.

If they meant "pursuit of property", why didn't they leave it "pursuit of property"?

I mean, the founding father were all knowing and omnipresent, weren't they?

How could they have made such a huge mistake?
 
The vote was the vote of the people, by the people, and ostensibly for the people...that is the most people. Apparently the people there have determined that family values are best promoted and maintained by real families. The left however cannot accept the democratic process when it goes against them so expect them to appeal to an activist judge.


So you think it's a load of crap that deep south states which opposed civil rights legislation were forced to desegregate? Same principle.
 
Last edited:
I don't feel stupid at all. The President was forced into action by Biden, not by his very predictable anti-gay marriage convictions. I'll bet you feel stupid though, having been fooled by it all.


You don't think the timing of Biden's announcement was scripted?


Fox News host Shepherd Smith saying that the GOP is clearly on the wrong side of history on this issue:

http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/cutline/obama-supports-gay-marriage-shep-smith-warns-gop-203159510.html
 
Last edited:
Back
Top