NC passes Admendment 1

First of all, if you understand Constitutional history, then you know that "pursuit of happiness" is a euphemism. The right it refers to is property, but if they said that, the North knew they could never end slavery.
Yes, I know some people make the argument that it means property (which had conflicting meanings in Jefferson's time).
Others feel it's more likely taken from John Locke's Concerning Human Understanding considering that Jefferson admired Locke and had very likely read it.
The necessity of pursuing happiness [is] the foundation of liberty.
 
ITS NOT A RIGHT!

It's a designation conferred by the government that carries certain benefits not available to all citizens. You are looking at this exactly backwards.

The government doesn't have to recognize ANY marriage (and shouldn't), but when they do, they can't discriminate as to who is eligible for the deal. Either everyone is allowed to marry and share in the government boondoggle, or nobody is.

The Libertarian case on the issue is that who marries who is a religious issue not a governmental one and the government should mind it's own business.

Very good Johnny, you're almost there.

First of all I agree with you that the government doesn't have any business being in the marriage business. But they are so that's the fact that has to be dealt with.

Now, it's called a 'marriage license.' When we bother to look up the word 'License' we find that it's a permission granted and like all licenses the granting of that license is conditional upon the meeting of certain qualifications. The implication being that the government can set any conditions that it chooses even if those conditions may seem arbitrary to certain individuals or groups.

If there is no bar to the sex of the individuals that apply for a marriage license then how can there be a bar to polygamy, polyandry, marriage to close relatives? Applying the very arguments you've presented so far no such bars can exist.

Ishmael
 
Define "pursuit of happiness."

I'll be back tomorrow.




Johnny, you may claim to be Libertarian, but you have fallen for the trick of the Left, letting them define the argument in terms of "fairness" and then assume the issue is settled and all that we have to do is come to a consensus decision on the meaning of the word "fair."

It's not "fair" that gays cannot be man and wife, therefore, the definition of marriage is unfair and if it's unfair it discriminates and if it discriminates, it is unconstitutional...

;) ;)
 
Interesting. I had a conversation along the same lines with a gay friend. He also agreed that militant activism has damaged this cause. Had they moved to civil unions first and then on to marriage later the issue and the fight may have been completely different.
I honestly don't care if it's "civil union" or "marriage" as long as civil union confers the same legal rights. The problem is that not a single civil union law carries all the same rights as marriage, particularly under federal law. Anyone who claims they all have the same rights is simply just wrong.
Letting same sex couples marry is the least expensive option, as opposed to changing all the laws, and especially forms, that refer to marriage.
 
Last edited:
If there is no bar to the sex of the individuals that apply for a marriage license then how can there be a bar to polygamy, polyandry, marriage to close relatives?
There shouldn't be a bar. I don't know how you define "close relatives" but in some states first cousins can marry. That's pretty close.
If you mean immediate family, I don't know. It all depends on the genetics of the issue and I don't know what the risks are these days.
Incest was certainly fine in the bible, if you take the bible literally.


Define "pursuit of happiness."
Why? As long as my pursuit of happiness doesn't take away from someone else what difference does it make how I define it?

Rather, explain why your pursuit of happiness (you're arguing people should be able to define their happiness by denying others something they themselves can do) should trump the happiness of someone else who's happiness has no effect on you, other than causing mental or emotional anguish.
In other words, explain why you should be able to deny someone else happiness for the sole reason that you don't approve of their method of attaining it.

It's funny really. The pro and anti groups are exactly opposite from what you would think.
The only real reason that anyone has ever given for wanting to prohibit same sex marriage is because it would cause them mental and/or emotional anguish (of course they never admit that, but that's the hidden meaning).
So here we have a majority of republicans opposed to it for that reason, yet they scream and holler about laws passed to make people "feel good".
And a majority of democrats who supposedly pass those feel good laws not caring about the emotional anguish of republicans if homosexuals are allowed to marry each other.
 
Last edited:
Social Democrat and Pseudo Constitionalist President Obama called...

...he said that he cannot be reelected by a majority of Americans if he comes out in full support of homosexual marriage before November 6.

But, he crosses his heart and hopes to die, if you stay-hard supporters of gay marriage retain him for #2, he'll come out of his politically correct closet on November 7.

Till then...

...please don't ask him so he doesn't have to tell everybody this truth.
 
NC's gays should just exercise their economic right to move to a state that fully supports their lifestyle.
 
...he said that he cannot be reelected by a majority of Americans if he comes out in full support of homosexual marriage before November 6.

But, he crosses his heart and hopes to die, if you stay-hard supporters of gay marriage retain him for #2, he'll come out of his politically correct closet on November 7.

Till then...

...please don't ask him so he doesn't have to tell everybody this truth.

And I'm sure you were shocked that a politician doesn't want to alienate voters during an election season:rolleyes:
 
Maybe you don't understand basic property law, and that's ok. Tenants by the Entirety is a form of ownership where each owner owns 100% of the property. So when one owner dies, there is no effect on the other owner as the other owner already owned '100%' of the property.

That form of ownership is reserved, by law and definition, to married people.

There are lots of advantages to file as married rather than each file individually. But even if there weren't, the point is the government should treat everyone as an individual. If the government chooses to bestow different treatment upon one group, then can't then refuse to treat all groups the same way.

The federal government doesn't treat everyone as an individual, equal or fair.

If it did, programs ranging from "The GI Bill", "Affirmative Action" to "No Child Left Behind" (and countless others) would not have existed. Moreover, the federal government has no legal obligation to treat everyone the same.

Any way the point is, what defines marriage has been accepted by the federal judiciary system to be a "state rights" issue. That where the concept of "Homo marriage" is vetted and, if eventually put to ballot, soundly defeated...:)
 
Then you cannot apply equal rights under the law.

Social laws discriminate, that's why they are written.

The government should mind its own business. The homosexual community should not try to redefine that which they do not like.

But at least we agree, they have no right to marriage.

When the government gets powerful enough to fight over, the people will fight over it, and to the victors go the spoils, thus setting up the next fight.
A_J, the Stupid

Actually, marriage is a fundamental right. It's ripe for both equal protection and due process analysis.

The jurisprudential battle that is being waged is whether same-sex relationships are enough like opposite sex relationships to be require that they be treated the same way under the law.

The leading decision of this Court on the right to marry is Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967).In that case, an interracial couple who had been convicted of violating Virginia's miscegenation laws challenged the statutory scheme on both equal protection and due process grounds. The Court's opinion could have rested solely on the ground that the statutes discriminated on the basis of race in violation of the Equal Protection Clause. Id., at 11-12. But the Court went on to hold that the laws arbitrarily deprived the couple of a fundamental liberty protected by the Due Process Clause, the freedom to marry. The Court's language on the latter point bears repeating:

"The freedom to marry has long been recognized as one of the vital personal rights essential to the orderly pursuit of happiness by free men.

"Marriage is one of the 'basic civil rights of man,' fundamental to our very existence and survival." Id., at 12, quoting Skinner v. Oklahoma ex rel. Williamson, 316 U.S. 535, 541 (1942).​

Although Loving arose in the context of racial discrimination, prior and subsequent decisions of this Court confirm that the right to marry is of fundamental importance for all individuals. Long ago, in Maynard v. Hill, 125 U.S. 190 (1888), the Court characterized marriage as "the most important relation in life," id., at 205, and as "the foundation of the family and of society, without which there would be neither civilization nor progress," id., at 211. In Meyer v. Nebraska, 262 U.S. 390 (1923), the Court recognized that the right "to marry, establish a home and bring up children" is a central part of the liberty protected by the Due Process Clause, id., at 399, and in Skinner v. Oklahoma ex rel. Williamson, supra, marriage was described as "fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race," 316 U.S., at 541.

More recent decisions have established that the right to marry is part of the fundamental "right of privacy" implicit in the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. In Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965), the Court observed

"We deal with a right of privacy older than the Bill of Rights -- older than our political parties, older than our school system. Marriage is a coming together for better or for worse, hopefully enduring, and intimate to the degree of being sacred. It is an association that promotes a way of life, not causes; a harmony in living, not political faiths; a bilateral loyalty, not commercial or social projects. Yet it is an association for as noble a purpose as any involved in our prior decisions." Id., at 486.​

See also id., at 495 (Goldberg, J., concurring); id., at 502-503 (WHITE, J., concurring in judgment).

Cases subsequent to Griswold and Loving have routinely categorized the decision to marry as among the personal decisions protected by the right of privacy. See generally Whalen v. Roe, 429 U.S. 589, 598-600, and nn. 23-26 (1977). For example, last Term in Carey v. Population Services International, 431 U.S. 678 (1977), we declared: S

"While the outer limits of [the right of personal privacy] have not been marked by the Court, it is clear that among the decisions that an individual may make without unjustified government interference are personal decisions 'relating to marriage, Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1, 12 (1967); procreation, Skinner v. Oklahoma ex rel. Williamson, 316 U.S. 535, 541-542 (1942); contraception, Eisenstadt v. Baird, 405 U.S., at 453-454; id., at 460, 463-465 (WHITE, J., concurring in result); family relationships, Prince v. Massachusetts, 321 U.S. 158, 166 (1944); and child rearing and education, Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510, 535 (1925); Meyer v. Nebraska, [262 U.S. 390, 399 (1923)].'" Id., at 684-685, quoting Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113, 152-153 (1973).I

See also Cleveland Board of Education v. LaFleur, 414 U.S. 632, 639-640 (1974) ("This Court has long recognized that freedom of personal choice in matters of marriage and family life is one of the liberties protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment."); Smith v. Organization of Foster Families, 431 U.S. 816, 842-844 (1977); Moore v. East Cleveland, 431 U.S. 494, 499 (1977); [**681] Paul v. Davis, 424 U.S. 693, 713 (1976). 10

Zablocki v. Redhail, 434 U.S. 374 (U.S. 1978)
 
Last edited:
insofar as marriage being an unalienable right is concerned, you are correct.

"...certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

In every state Mark and Ann have the liberty to marry each other and pursue happiness together.
In some states Bob and Bill and Mary and Sue are actively prohibited from doing that.
In those states Bob, Bill, Mary and Sue have had supposedly unalienable rights taken away from them.

And the purpose of this red herring is....?

Seems you really need to work on your math (or reading) skills.

and by limiting your understanding of unalienable rights so, you are wrong.

Really? Do you understand the unalienable right?

First of all, if you understand Constitutional history, then you know that "pursuit of happiness" is a euphemism. The right it refers to is property, but if they said that, the North knew they could never end slavery.

Denying a rite to anyone is not a government-sponsored theft of Life, Liberty or Property.

(But forcing them to buy health insurance IS!!!!! :mad: )

Progressive tax codes designed to favor groups, such as married couples, may actually do that which is why I am a huge proponent of the FairTax.org.
 
Last edited:
The intent of the court decisions mentioned all support the concept of hetrosexual marriage. I can guarantee you that judicial opinion in all these cases never considered the possibility of a homosexual union. It would be absurd given the times, places and moral standards followed then to suggest otherwise.
 
The intent of the court decisions mentioned all support the concept of hetrosexual marriage. I can guarantee you that judicial opinion in all these cases never considered the possibility of a homosexual union. It would be absurd given the times, places and moral standards followed then to suggest otherwise.

so?

the same observation can be made about laws prohibiting interracial marriage and opinions upholding those laws.

judges decide only the issue in front of them. they do not give advisory opinions. regardless, marriage is a fundamental right.
 
NC's gays should just exercise their economic right to move to a state that fully supports their lifestyle.

Generally speaking, when homogenous groups form enclaves/ghettos individuals within the group fare worse than in the general society.
 
so?

the same observation can be made about laws prohibiting interracial marriage and opinions upholding those laws.

judges decide only the issue in front of them. they do not give advisory opinions. regardless, marriage is a fundamental right.

You are talking to a Cade. You know his position on that.

Dummy.
 
I was ashamed to wake up in my state this morning...
 
It's the word 'marriage' that's the sticking point, and will continue to be so for years to come. Where there once existed the possibility of 'domestic partnerships' or some other legal form that conferred the same legal status on same sex unions that possibility was squandered by the militant gay community who have insisted that it be called 'marriage.' This more or less proved that the issue was not equality of access to certain legal benefits but an 'in your face' move. And that in turn has provoked a backlash by those that just don't feel like being the Mae Clark to James Cagney.

I, like you, don't have a dog in the fight. To me this is nothing more than an exercise in politics. But I fully understand the feelings of those that believe that the word 'marriage' has a specific gender relationship meaning and I feel free to express my frustration, for lack of a better word, at the single minded lunacy of the militant gay community in their picking a fight over a word when they could have had all they wanted by an alternative route.

Ishmael

Interesting. I had a conversation along the same lines with a gay friend. He also agreed that militant activism has damaged this cause. Had they moved to civil unions first and then on to marriage later the issue and the fight may have been completely different.


Just FYI, but the new law in North Carolina outlawed any legal recognition of a domestic partnership that's not a heterosexual marriage. Gay marriage was already banned in North Carolina, and failure to pass this amendment would not have changed that status, so this vote was more about precluding the sort of compromise you're talking about here.

In practice, there are very few people who will tell you "I'm OK with civil unions and gay couples having the rights of married couples--just please don't call it 'marriage.'" Generally speaking, people voting to ban gay marriage do not believe in any sort of official recognition of same-sex relationships.
 
Just FYI, but the new law in North Carolina outlawed any legal recognition of a domestic partnership that's not a heterosexual marriage. Gay marriage was already banned in North Carolina, and failure to pass this amendment would not have changed that status, so this vote was more about precluding the sort of compromise you're talking about here.

In practice, there are very few people who will tell you "I'm OK with civil unions and gay couples having the rights of married couples--just please don't call it 'marriage.'" Generally speaking, people voting to ban gay marriage do not believe in any sort of official recognition of same-sex relationships.

For once, I agree with you on something.
 
I see where the problem with people lies. There are TWO marriages: Legal and Religious. Most confuse the two because, well, they listen to the Bible's interpretation of God's words. Um, in the same book that decries against "man should not lay with man," there are also many rules against eating pork and shellfish. So those who say Same sex marriage is against Bible teachings must also NOT have a bacon cheeseburger, or you're going against Bible teachings.

In NY, Same Sex marriage is legal. And guess what, the world's not ended! And...my marriage of 26+ years hasn't been effected AT ALL!!!
 
I see where the problem with people lies. There are TWO marriages: Legal and Religious. Most confuse the two because, well, they listen to the Bible's interpretation of God's words. Um, in the same book that decries against "man should not lay with man," there are also many rules against eating pork and shellfish. So those who say Same sex marriage is against Bible teachings must also NOT have a bacon cheeseburger, or you're going against Bible teachings.

In NY, Same Sex marriage is legal. And guess what, the world's not ended! And...my marriage of 26+ years hasn't been effected AT ALL!!!

Neither of my past marriages were affected by it, either. That could have been a nice line of BS to feed the opposing counsel, though.

"My client feels that his marital infidelity wasn't his fault. His ability to be faithful was distorted by all of the gays getting married." ;)

Don't worry about me. Neither of my divorces resulted in alimony. Maybe because my exes were thankfully not housewives while married to me. They were royal shrews at times, but they did me that favor of not being too poor when we divorced. For which I'm eternally grateful. :devil:
 
Neither of my past marriages were affected by it, either. That could have been a nice line of BS to feed the opposing counsel, though.

"My client feels that his marital infidelity wasn't his fault. His ability to be faithful was distorted by all of the gays getting married." ;)

Don't worry about me. Neither of my divorces resulted in alimony. Maybe because my exes were thankfully not housewives while married to me. They were royal shrews at times, but they did me that favor of not being too poor when we divorced. For which I'm eternally grateful. :devil:

Doesn't Infidelity and Abuse be more affects against heterosexual marriage than Same Sex couples? I wish someone from NC would 'splain that to me. <Scratching head at the obvious>
 
Back
Top