Phony diversity

Ishmael said:
Walter Williams

August 27, 2002

Phony diversity

You've written a tuition check, carted your son or daughter off to college, given those last minute admonitions and made those tearful good byes. For those thousands of dollars, the anguish of seeing your 17- or 18-year-old pack up and leave home for the first time, and entrusting him to some strangers, what are some of the things you
might expect? One thing for sure is that your youngster will encounter and be bombarded with diversity newspeak.

Diversity is a big buzzword on college and university campuses.

<SNIP>

So what does all this mean? It means your son or daughter will be taught that the Founders of United States were racists and sexists; capitalism is a tool used to oppress women and minorities; literature and philosophy written by "dead white men" is a tool of exploitation, one person's vision of reality is just as valid as another's, one set of cultural values (maybe the Taliban's) is just as good as another, poverty is caused by rich people, and America is destroying the planet.

Americans as taxpayers and donors have been far too generous, and carelessly so, with colleges and universities. It's high time we began to demand accountability, not only in the area of ideological diversity, but in academic honesty and excellence as well.

Evening Ishmael.

Am I correct in assuming that in America it is wrong, or politically incorrect, to teach students to think analytically and for themselves??

To objectively discuss ideas and government policies, especially those policies designed to put them into military uniform and make them face awesomely devastating weaponry?? In other words, to dare to question the God-given right of political manipulators to send the sons of poor people off as cannon fodder to a war that only the President wants??

Geez, Ishmael . . . education is about opening the mind and creating a better world, not propping up corrupt carpet-baggers and their greedy ideologies that see millions spent on educating students only to kill them on the battlefield.
 
Ishmael said:


It started in the seventies with the campus radicals of the Viet Nam era. Up until that time the universtities were fairly well balanced as to political beliefs. In the interest of diversity many of these radicals were brought into the universtiy system. As they gained tenure, instead of recruiting new professor's across the political spectrum, they recruited those of the same beliefs. In other words, the door was opened for them, but once they were inside they slammed the door behind them. There was an excellent article written on this very subject by no less than an old line liberal who was ashamed of the new breeds performance in regard to intellectual honesty.

J. Patrick Moynihan, who couldn't not be considered conservative by any stretch of the imagination, has commented in much the same vein.

Ishmael

So, do we need to institute affirmative action then? I'm sure the market will certainly eliminate this problem when the Universities realize all they are losing from their discrimanatory hiring practices.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: Phony diversity

HighSchoolJock said:



hey dumbass maybe its because democrats usually base their platform on spending more money on education (ie giving teachers raises) while republicans usually base their platforms on cutting back on education spending (ie cutting salaries or assigning teachers to larger classrooms) how dumb are you if you dont realize this and youre a teacher? are you such a dicktwat youre too dumb to vote yourself a raise?

Hmmmmmmmmm, another intellectual giant heard from. Sooooo, if you have an employee that is NOT doing his or her work at an acceptable level, you propose that giving them more money is the answer. Regardless of whether thev've earned it or not?

And giving a teacher a raise is not spending more money on education. It's giving the teacher a raise and hasn't done a damn thing to improve the education of the child.

Go back to your playbook HSJ, Bobby might want you to inflate the football or something.

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Phony diversity

Never said:
Ishmael:
"For the bulk of universities and colleges, diversity means race quotas, sex quotas and programs to insure that representative forms of sexual deviancy become an accepted norm."


Sexual deviancy? :rolleyes:
Am I the only one that gets tired of people trying to pass bigotry off as conservative politics?

Well said, Never!! :D :D
 
Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

That's what I've been interpreting from the posts deriding the President. The President was a Air Force Reserve supersonic fighter pilot, so those in the service flying are not intellectually capable!?? Not one shred of truth/facts can be offered to disprove the President's intelligence. You all sound like a bunch of gossiping crones. A fucking professor is an example of those that can't...teach!
By the way, I got a low grade from a avowed Socialist teacher in English, when I submitted a project paper demonstrating the reason for the 2nd Amendment, backed up with documentation. The fucker smirked when he gave it back to me with the low grade. (the paper was perfect in composition like all my others)

:D
 
Re: Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

Lost Cause said:

By the way, I got a low grade from a avowed Socialist teacher in English, when I submitted a project paper demonstrating the reason for the 2nd Amendment, backed up with documentation. The fucker smirked when he gave it back to me with the low grade. (the paper was perfect in composition like all my others)

:D

Funny you should mention that. My son went through the same thing with one of his professors. According to her the Bill of Rights was a work of genius, except for the 2nd ammendment at which point the founders had a collective brain fart. :rolleyes:

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

Ishmael said:


Funny you should mention that. My son went through the same thing with one of his professors. According to her the Bill of Rights was a work of genius, except for the 2nd ammendment at which point the founders had a collective brain fart. :rolleyes:

Ishmael

It's too bad it didn't accomplish what it was set out to do.
 
Re: Re: Re: Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

Sillyman said:


It's too bad it didn't accomplish what it was set out to do.

And what was that?

Ishmael
 
Both sides worry far too much about the influence of the right and the left. It seems to me that conservative thought and practice are quite strong in the U.S.
It could be argued that the the past 20 years has seen a strong move to the right in american politics. Even Mr. Clinton was no traditional liberal. For all the rants about college campuses being too liberal it would seem to have had little impact in the country. I think what happens is that those graduates from the top universitys begin to make very substantial incomes and suddenly all the ideals they held so close in college that now might cost them money( in the form of taxes) become secondary.
 
Re: Re: Phony diversity

Don K Dyck said:


Evening Ishmael.

Am I correct in assuming that in America it is wrong, or politically incorrect, to teach students to think analytically and for themselves??

To objectively discuss ideas and government policies, especially those policies designed to put them into military uniform and make them face awesomely devastating weaponry?? In other words, to dare to question the God-given right of political manipulators to send the sons of poor people off as cannon fodder to a war that only the President wants??

Geez, Ishmael . . . education is about opening the mind and creating a better world, not propping up corrupt carpet-baggers and their greedy ideologies that see millions spent on educating students only to kill them on the battlefield.

That would be perfect if that was what was happening. Students should be taught to think analytically and for themselves. There should be an objective discussion of ideas and government policies. There should be a free competition of a diverse range of ideas -- that is what going to a university should be about.

That is the direct opposite of the direction that American education has been moving in. There is no real debate -- if you disagree with the current belief system that is in power you are penalized in your grades, you are never hired as an instructor or professor, and if you are hired, you will never make tenure. A real debate and analytical thinking is not about just questioning government policies. It is about being able agree or disagree, freely, and to be graded not on your conclusions but on how your arguments are expressed.

No student should have to learn not to say things agreeing with half the country (politically speaking), in order to get good grades, or to later have a chance to get hired by a university.

Never said she was never penalized for speaking her mind, even though she went to a very liberal college. My question is, what would have happened if she had argued for a stronger defense, for the 2nd Amendment and against the Roe versus Wade decision? I suspect there are some areas you are allowed to disagree in, and others you are not.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

Ishmael said:


And what was that?

Ishmael

To avoid having a large standing army.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Air Force pilots must be idiots then...

Sillyman said:


To avoid having a large standing army.

If you read the Federalist Papers and other writings of the times you'll find that that was less than half of what the 2nd Ammendment was about.

Ishmael
 
Sillyman said:
But it was a factor, and it did fail on that point.

Not really. If you consider that until recently we've been continuously at war since WWII. (The Cold War may not have produced great battles, but it was a war none the less.)

The draw down in forces since the end of the Cold War is a typical American pattern.

Ishmael
 
Hiya, Ish.:)

You really need to change the title of this thread. Everytime I see the word Phony..I think it's a thread about Phone...and therefore about sex. I need to revamp my thinking..but political and social conscience issue threads won't do that. I'm hopeless. lol

JL:kiss:
 
Last edited:
juicylips said:
Hiya, Ish.:)

You really need to change the title of this thread. Everytime I see the word Phony..I think it's a thread about Phone...and therefore about sex. I need to revamp my thinking..but political and social conscience issues won't do that.

JL:kiss:

That has so made me laugh, JL
 
Conclusive Argument . . .

juicylips said:
Hiya, Ish.:)

You really need to change the title of this thread. Everytime I see the word Phony..I think it's a thread about Phone...and therefore about sex. I need to revamp my thinking..but political and social conscience issue threads won't do that. I'm hopeless. lol JL:kiss:

Finally a logical argument to agree with. Well done, Juicy!! :D :D
 
Re: Conclusive Argument . . .

Don K Dyck said:


Finally a logical argument to agree with. Well done, Juicy!! :D :D

How ya doing, Don?

I haven't been around to see what you been up to lately. Hope you've been having fun. Loads and loads of it.;)

JL:kiss:
 
Re: Re: Conclusive Argument . . .

juicylips said:


How ya doing, Don?

I haven't been around to see what you been up to lately. Hope you've been having fun. Loads and loads of it.;) JL:kiss:

Doin' fine, Juicy . . . my av is still lusting after your av . . . maybe we should let them ease the tension some time . . . heheheh :p :devil: :p

Don :kiss:
 
Re: Re: Re: Conclusive Argument . . .

Don K Dyck said:


Doin' fine, Juicy . . . my av is still lusting after your av . . . maybe we should let them ease the tension some time . . . heheheh :p :devil: :p

Don :kiss:

Yea.. my mask just seems to do it for some men.:D

JL:kiss:
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Conclusive Argument . . .

juicylips said:


Yea.. my mask just seems to do it for some men.:D

JL:kiss:

Well, actually . . . it was a little more than that . . . :kiss:
 
Originally posted by Ishmael

Why should a professor of mathmatics, or physics, or anthropology be questioned concerning his/her political leanings in a [j]ob interview? That is exactly what is occurring today.

I've been involved in dozens of academic job interviews, as both interviewee and interviewer. Never once have I asked to see or been asked to show a voter registration card. Never once was I asked about or heard anyone else asked about 'political leanings.'

I suppose such things have occurred and still do occur, but your assertion might lead one to infer that this occurs routinely in all academic interviews in all academic fields. That simply is not true.

This "tenured radicals" idea which has received a lot of popular press since the late-80s and has become part of our doxa is rather silly--like those urban legends about giant albino alligators in sewers and Snapple being owned by the KKK. It asks us to believe that "The Sixties" turned a bunch of middle-class white kids into fire-breathing Reds, in spite of the fact that their teachers were not.

Somehow, though, (the legend implies) when those "radicals" took over the halls of academe, they were able to neutralize or innoculate the students of my generation from the influence of "The Eighties"--which by the logic of this myth ought to have turned me and most of my colleagues into fire-breathing Conservatives.

And here's a news bulletin for you kids: those "tenured radicals" from the '60s? They're retired--or getting ready to retire--and they're more concerned about their 401K plans than they are about turning your kids into Commies.
 
alltherage said:
Both sides worry far too much about the influence of the right and the left. It seems to me that conservative thought and practice are quite strong in the U.S.
It could be argued that the the past 20 years has seen a strong move to the right in american politics. Even Mr. Clinton was no traditional liberal. For all the rants about college campuses being too liberal it would seem to have had little impact in the country. I think what happens is that those graduates from the top universitys begin to make very substantial incomes and suddenly all the ideals they held so close in college that now might cost them money( in the form of taxes) become secondary.

I just think this needs to be shown again.

Bavisimo, atr!
 
70/30 said:
To answer Shy Tall Guy, Thomas Jefferson is, by far the most leftist president this country has seen, so left(Henry David Thoreau) he almost becomes ultraright.

<snip>

Articles like that aren't intellectual pieces, professors study history and they usually understand it.
And your point is?

Is your point that since a particular group of conservatives wrote that piece, which was slanted for their purposes, that a history prof that is a conservative should not be allowed to teach history, the danger being he/she be as biased as the group that wrote and published that webpage/site?

And the Left never rewrites history to their advantage? The Left never interprets facts in their own way such that the whole story isn't heard?

Everyone hears history profs talk about how the terrible facists under Hitler massacred 6 million Jews (and 14 million other people), and the Left often associate the Right with facism - spitting it out like a curse word - "FACIST!".

But how often do you hear any of these same history profs talk about the 40 million that Stalin murdered? If it is mentioned, then it is quickly followed with the excuse that Stalin was a disturbed paranoid (of course, Lenin had no such excuse for the 4 million he murdered), and then in the same breath they say that this wasn't really socialism. No mention at all of the 37.8 million killed under Mao Tse-tung.
 
Back
Top